Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my MIL to take a back seat & allow her son to be happy

68 replies

1011y · 28/05/2024 22:47

In short, my fiancé came here 7 years ago to work with the short term plan of working and then returning back to his home country of Norway. He met me 2 years in to his work placement and decided to stay here in the UK to be with me.

In the early days and since I have tried to make an effort with his family in various ways, such as learning the language and other forms. This has always been rejected by his family as they feel they don’t know me and that I am a stranger who has forced their way into the family. They see me as the barrier in him going back home to Norway.

He is struggling with being homesick and missing his home country. We don’t have the option to move there, or visit more due to his work being so demanding. They also won’t visit here and have refused to support his choices. This causes him a huge amount of pain but what’s worse is whenever they speak to my fiancé they play on his emotions and say things like “we would all be so happier if you came home” “you are such a different person now” “don’t forget your Norwegian roots” “don’t forget who you are” .. and so many others which chip away at his mental health. This of course hurts him no end and is making it incredibly difficult to settle and be happy here, understandably. No matter what I do to try and make him feel happier here he still feels such a huge void as they are so unsupportive and cause problems for us. If he goes a length of time without speaking to them his mood lifts, he is happier, settled and enjoying life with our little baby.

We have a little boy who is 4 months old and this worsened matters as they have now started chipping away regards to him and how he is not being raised “Norwegian” in a Norwegian culture.

His father is poorly and more recently my MIL is bringing him into it too with things like “your dad misses you he get so upset that you don’t live here and we’re not closer” (his dad is not able to voice his own feelings due to illness)

Am I doomed here for a separated family?, what can I do, I have tried my dammed hardest to create a happy home but every time the phone rings and she starts with the comments his mood drops a mile and the “homesickness” starts all over again.

I have tried to ask him to talk to her regards this and ask her to stop but Norwegian culture simply doesn’t do conflict and is very open speaking. So he tells me this isn’t a Norwegian way of addressing things. He isn’t mentally resilient enough to have a blowup or consider cutting them out.

I have tried everything and anything to make him feel happier and feel more in touch with his culture. Overall and without her interference he is happy and content however we’re living in a vicious circle I can’t seem to get out of.

AIBU by wanting my MIL to stop with the narrative in his ear to let him just live the life he’s chosen for himself?

OP posts:
twinmummystarz · 01/06/2024 08:07

I empathise with your situation but I also don’t understand why is this your responsibility to solve? He is as an adult: his feelings and life choices are not your responsibility.

twinmummystarz · 01/06/2024 08:06

I don’t understand why this is your responsibility to solve: he’s an adult. Let him figure it out. You are not responsible for his feelings or his life choices.

SeatonCarew · 31/05/2024 20:48

Aquamarine1029 · 31/05/2024 20:44

Don't give up lightly, deal with it together

But that's the problem. The op's partner refuses to deal with it.

Your relationship is in very big trouble unless your partner grows a pair and puts up some serious boundaries with his mother. You simply can't compete against that type of emotional terrorism. Unless your partner takes control and puts you first, it's already over.

Then that needs to change, and that can be a process in these cases. Ultimately you do need to sort it together, but I repeat, don't give up lightly. There are a lot of responses on here from people who've never been in this situation. I have, so I offered my advice based on my experience.

Aquamarine1029 · 31/05/2024 20:44

Don't give up lightly, deal with it together

But that's the problem. The op's partner refuses to deal with it.

Your relationship is in very big trouble unless your partner grows a pair and puts up some serious boundaries with his mother. You simply can't compete against that type of emotional terrorism. Unless your partner takes control and puts you first, it's already over.

SeatonCarew · 31/05/2024 20:38

You're getting a lot of negative responses here OP.

I got some serious resistance from my German PILs when DH moved to the UK. I'd been flavour of the month up till then, key to the house and everything.

As a parent myself, I can understand a pang if the kids move away, but it was hardly the end of the world he'd moved to. Their attitude caused a lot of unnecessary problems, but they were troubled people with a difficult history.

We've been married for thirty odd years and it works very well indeed. Don't give up lightly, deal with it together. x

Itsonlymashadow · 31/05/2024 20:27

I think the main problem is that he home sick. He probably isn’t shutting her down because that’s how he feels.

I think, even if she did stop you may find that not much changed or he still goes back. He stayed because he was in love, which is understandable. But now real normal life has set in, it seems living outside his home country isn’t for him.

That’s the issue.

DreamTheMoors · 31/05/2024 20:22

It was a little different for me — my husband and I always lived apart from his family in the U.S., but they always traveled to see us, no matter where we were.
It was exhausting for me — cleaning & shopping for a full house for one week then cleaning & shopping for another week & so on.
But his family got to see a great deal of the country and they were delightful. We always had fun and they were generous.

What’s stopping your husband’s family from coming to visit you@1011y?

pizzaHeart · 31/05/2024 20:17

Is he the only child?

Emmz1510 · 31/05/2024 20:12

You need to have an honest discussion about what he actually wants. He either wants to continue to build a life here with you and his child and to do it wholeheartedly or he would rather return to Norway.
If it’s the former than he needs to set boundaries with his family. If they can’t cut it out with the emotional blackmail then he will lessen the contact or even go no contact and he can’t be leaving you with these feelings of him being torn. It’s focus on the life he has and be firm with his parents or the relationship has no real future
Or, he tells you his heart still lies in Norway in which case you discuss whether the three of you can make a life there.
Would things improve if between you two and the in laws you made a plan for visits? Like you visit one year, they visit the next, or whatever works?

Noseybookworm · 31/05/2024 20:05

He does seem very passive in all this. He really needs to tell his family how much they upset him and that they need to support his choices or he will reduce contact with them. He's a father and a partner first. I do understand feeling homesick but he has to embrace life here otherwise what's the point? Are you near a city? Could he find a Norwegian Social group nearby or start one? Can he plan a holiday so he can visit home? He needs to take the initiative and help himself.

Viewfrommyhouse · 31/05/2024 17:30

You don't have a MIL problem, you have a fiancé problem. What's he doing about it all?

Alwaysalwayscold · 31/05/2024 17:26

You seem to be placing all the blame on your MIL, I think the issue is with your DH.

Findinganewme · 31/05/2024 17:06

Wow, some of these messages are really one sided.

As a parent myself (of a 12 and 5 year old) I imagine it must be so very hard to be away from the children, where there are long periods of not being able to see , touch, hug them. When we have raised our children with a culture and identity, to see that change all of a sudden, must be very hard. I accept that different cultures operate differently; some western cultures are very open to their children making their own family and own life and not seeing their parents very much. Not all cultures are like that, and your partners culture is one of those. Maybe this is something To consider, for the long term.

why won’t his parents visit him?

SiobhanSharpe · 29/05/2024 13:00

Does your DP go back at all to visit for a week or so?
He must get some holiday time from work, during which could you all go so his family could meet and then perhaps regularly see your DS. Is there a reason why you can't? (eg the inlaws are still horrible to you)
Apologies if you already do/have done this.
Good luck, I hope you can work something out.

YouveGotAFastCar · 29/05/2024 12:53

Trust me, as someone with similarly overbearing in-laws. Your marriage is doomed if your husband can't stand up for you. It is the only thing that will stop the behaviour, and save his mental health.

It took mine a while - longer than I'd have liked - but once he'd done it, the weight lifted off him. It was honestly unbelievable. He seems them infrequently now, two or three times a year, they don't talk much, but he isn't living in that state of stress and dreading the phone ringing, and neither am I.

If he wants to go home, you both need to create a realistic plan to make that happen, whether it's a two year plan or a ten year plan. You need to bear in mind your son, that any childcare will feel like it ties him to here, and the relationship your in-laws have with you, alongside all the other practicalities. If moving there is never an option, you need to both accept that, and your husband might need to talk to someone to process it and put it to bed.

Merryoldgoat · 29/05/2024 12:49

stayathomer · 29/05/2024 12:08

He’s not willing to put you and the family you’ve created first so yes - unless he sorts his shit out - the relationship is doomed.
eh he moved country- on what planet is this not putting his partner and child first?! Is it always that one has to concede in every single way?!

You know, allowing his family to exclude OP and their child, acting like he has no agency in the decision, generally allowing his family to mistreat OP without comment.

SleepingMermaid · 29/05/2024 12:39

I am Scandinavian myself and have lived in the UK a long time and raised my family here. I get desperately homesick sometimes, it's a yearning for the forest, lakes, air that I can't describe. Maybe that Scandi darkness or melancholy that is part of our heritage. BUT I have made my life in the UK and have made that clear to my family who have largely embraced it. The key here is your partner, not your MIL. Your partner needs to own his choices and make that clear to your inlaws.

And btw, we bought a little place of our own in Scandinavia, having a modest house back home has made me feel much better about living abroad. It csn be the best of two worlds

Genevieva · 29/05/2024 12:16

What sort of work does he do? And will they accept you once you are married? Where are you getting married and what sort of ceremony?

It is really important that you both learn to put your own family unit first and they your fiancé feels some (joint) ownership of that decision. The North Sea is always going to exist between you and one set of grandparents and (his work aside) moving there would be impossible for you if his family exclude you. It would help if he asked for his family to accept you: love you as the mother of their grandson, appreciate your efforts to learn their language and participate in their culture. He also needs to pull his socks up for his son and stop moping about. I’m sure moping isn’t very ‘Norwegian’.

Ponoka7 · 29/05/2024 12:13

How would they feel towards you if you were married? Are you the barrier to him returning? Does he honestly want to live in the UK permanently? I'd give Norway a go if possible tbh.

stayathomer · 29/05/2024 12:08

He’s not willing to put you and the family you’ve created first so yes - unless he sorts his shit out - the relationship is doomed.
eh he moved country- on what planet is this not putting his partner and child first?! Is it always that one has to concede in every single way?!

stayathomer · 29/05/2024 12:06

From the other side op, not the same thing Because we moved within Ireland but I live rurally and for years was so upset and homesick. Dh and in laws used to hate my family talking about getting me back to Dublin but it was because I’d ask about different things I was missing and saying if I won the lottery we’d be coming back. In the same way (but obviously a bigger scale) I have two friends abroad that say the same thing- if they could get back to Ireland they would but their other halfs can’t get jobs and they can’t afford houses. Your dh is homesick, your ils might be adding fuel to the fire but I think you need to discuss how strongly he feels. I’m still the same, I get a yearning when I go home. Lottery win I’d be gone and dh would be where I was/ am

5128gap · 29/05/2024 12:06

You seem to see your H as a bit of an empty vessel, passively being filled with emotion from either his family or yourself. They can't make him homesick if he is otherwise happy here, and you can't make him entirely happy here if he has a pull to his family and country of birth. He needs to take responsibility for his own feelings and choices, and you need to allow him to. You can't control how his mother speaks with him, and continuing to try is simply going to reinforce her view that you are pulling him away. He's a grown man who needs to balance this conflict within himself. All you can do is carry on as you are, offer sympathy and compromise if you feel its justified, and otherwise leave them to it.

Gioia1 · 29/05/2024 11:58

Frankly speaking your partner is choosing his parents over you and your son. This is doomed.

Floralnomad · 29/05/2024 11:52

Merryoldgoat · 29/05/2024 08:03

You were utterly mad for settling down with him when he shows you so little consideration regarding his family.

I don’t know if any relationship that works well when the in-laws so utterly reject the partner.

He’s not willing to put you and the family you’ve created first so yes - unless he sorts his shit out - the relationship is doomed.

I agree with this . Your partner needs to grow a backbone and tell his family that he has made his choices and is happy where he is so they can get on board with that or butt out . If he can’t / won’t do that then nothing will change and I personally wouldn’t carry on with that relationship because you will spend forever propping him up and when one or both of his parents die it will be all your fault that you separated him from them . You need to have a very difficult conversation and sort this out now .

Swipe left for the next trending thread