Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the consensus is on saturated fat?

31 replies

IntertwiningLeaves · 27/05/2024 11:13

I tend to agree with science and our health authorities when it comes to dietary info, but over the years have noticed a lot of push back against the stigmatisation of saturated fat - typically animal fats.

There's a lot of divisive noise out there concerning food health, especially on sites like youtube, with all sorts of conflicting theories backed up by 'medical professionals'. Well, they can't all be correct!!

Personally, I prefer the less troublesome concept of a balanced diet, without excluding entire groups, being mindful to take factors such as allergies and gut issues into consideration.
I also realise that a balanced diet just isn't as sexy, nor will it sell so many books or rate highly on algorithms.

I tried to find some solid agreement out there regarding sat fats, but apart from the British Heart Foundation and other official bodies, it's one heck of a confusing mess. I would have imagined by now that there would be an established declaration from NHS etc if the link between sat fat and cholesterol had been debunked.

On one side, many people now think that such health issues are caused by agriculture/grain and genetics, whilst the governing bodies still insist a link to animal fats/obesity. Is there any reliable new science on this?

I did notice that a lot of the documentaries/adherents to the pro sat fat group also had some tentative links to anti vax, full carnivore diet, and getting women back into the kitchen...sorta thing. A sensible and measured bunch of data would be great but I can't seem to locate any. However, I do know that our knowledge of health is shifting all the time, so is there anywhere where these two opposing theories meet?
Hoping there are people much more knowledgeable than myself here who have some idea?

OP posts:
mossylog · 27/05/2024 12:12

Look up "blue zone" diets. The places in the world where people live the longest have very low amounts of animal fat— like vegetarian Seventh Day Adventists, or remote mountaintop villagers who eat some meat and dairy but more as supplementary or celebratory food. Diet isn't the only factor here, but it does seem like the big meat eaters in the world suffer for it (Mongolians eat loads of meat and no one holds them up as paragons of health).

These meat evangelists are being faddish, but they are right that a lot of processed grains are bad for us.

IntertwiningLeaves · 27/05/2024 12:08

Yeh, I like a balance, so just try to stay aware of doing anything too much or too little.

I think in the video I referenced, the guy was trying to prove that eating a high sat fat 'junk food' diet made him loose body fat and lowered his cholesterol. it was sufficiently smug.

It would seem we can engineer any outcome (or bias) we like with the right, er, conditions and data.

OP posts:
Ineffable23 · 27/05/2024 12:03

I think the way I feel is that I am sure a diet consisting of lentils/vegetables and maybe some chicken breast and fish would be the healthiest option.

But I am not actually going to live like that.

And I would rather eat butter than margarine. Probably would be better using olive oil than butter and if it's suitable I do.

I'd rather have some cheese than end up eating UPFs. I'm sure I should be a better person and eat neither but I am not that person so for me it's about the "least bad" options.

dudsville · 27/05/2024 11:58

I think the high sat fat trend is going to resul in a lot of heart and gallbladder issues!

It's not cool or trendy, but the only weight loss scheme that works for me is low fat and especially low sat fat.

IntertwiningLeaves · 27/05/2024 11:54

One particular video called 'fat head' did seem to have a fairly nasty anti-vegetarian slant, which is off putting even though I'm not a veggie. It just smacks of culture wars rather than true data.

The cholesterol stuff confuses me a little, since I'm not an expert in these things. One 'doctor' in the documentary claimed that post menopausal women NEED higher cholesterol and that trying to reduce it would cause osteoporosis.

Some pretty wild and dangerous claims if untrue Shock
I also wonder if the 'experts' in the videos are trying to get their own books noticed...

OP posts:
emeraldtablet · 27/05/2024 11:29

Only nutbags advocate a diet high in saturated fat and animal fats nowadays. HTH.