Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Messy people always get their way

131 replies

Wellthatsit · 26/05/2024 23:45

If you're a tidy person living with messy people, you never get to live in the environment you want, because the messy people always mess it up.

AIBU to feel this is unfair?

OP posts:
LondonLass61 · 28/05/2024 12:52

curlywurlymum · 26/05/2024 23:48

It is unfair, but they’re under 8 and I can hardly kick them out! 😄

🤣

Dartwarbler · 28/05/2024 12:45

Dartwarbler · 28/05/2024 12:35

You should see my utility room…I am full on 5s 🤣🤣🤣🤣 look it up if you don’t know.
I blame my employer who installed these principles into employers ( manufacturing sector)

the reason manufacturers are keen on 5s is the sheer amount of non value add time ( lost capacity and money) spent by operators, engineers etc looking for tools, materials etc they can’t find. You do maths of each minute wasted, over sum of workforce, over 24/7 shifts and you’re talking days

its not unreasonable to feel pissed when others waste your time.

And cos I’m really really sad well that it I’ll share images of shadow boards (5s technique) that are game changer for putting stuff down randomly, just cos images make me happy 😉😱🙄🤦‍♀️

and yes, I’ve done it in my utility 🤣🤣🤣

Messy people always get their way
Messy people always get their way
Baaliali · 28/05/2024 12:41

I grew up in a house of extreme, overwhelming and exhausting perfection.

Me too.

Interestingly there was competitive tidying going on between my relatives that my cousins were recently speaking about. Their Mom’s found my mother’s perfectionism very intimidating. But actually the perfectionism hid a lot of the crimes that were going on under the surface very well.

I like living in clean and a small bit messy but like actual humans live in the building.

Dartwarbler · 28/05/2024 12:35

Wellthatsit · 28/05/2024 07:47

One of my big bugbears is things not having a place so are always misplaced. I started buying my own version of things eg tools or stationery or cash or gym equipment. Guess what happens? They constantly use my stuff because it's easy to find and always there!

And don't bring up how often my keys go missing cause someone else has taken them.

It doesn't matter how cross I get or how often I remind people not to borrow my stuff, it still happens, and I end up looking petty, when all I'm doing is trying to keep my own life free of unnecessary stress.

This argument isn't about stifling tidiness versus total chaos, it is about where the line of compromise should be drawn. And I think when you've made the effort to get your own shit under control and to stay fairly disciplined about cleaning up, it is miserable when other people blithely trash it then act like it's no big deal. I don't

You should see my utility room…I am full on 5s 🤣🤣🤣🤣 look it up if you don’t know.
I blame my employer who installed these principles into employers ( manufacturing sector)

the reason manufacturers are keen on 5s is the sheer amount of non value add time ( lost capacity and money) spent by operators, engineers etc looking for tools, materials etc they can’t find. You do maths of each minute wasted, over sum of workforce, over 24/7 shifts and you’re talking days

its not unreasonable to feel pissed when others waste your time.

Dartwarbler · 28/05/2024 12:29

Theothername · 28/05/2024 08:31

I think there are essentially two types of people - those who take out a scissors, cut something and put the scissors away; and those who put the scissors down.

I’m the latter. My brain has already moved on to the next stage of whatever I’m doing and I can’t do those little back track loops. But as an adult I have trained myself to build in a 5 minute tidy up at the end of a project, and several 5 minute whirlwind tidy ups throughout a day to find all the displaced items. I can’t see them until I actively try looking for them.

That’s motivated by consideration for others. And I suppose therein is the other distinction. I know some extreme tidiers who lack consideration.

I agree with this…but I think mine is more specific as I’m on the “ tidy” end of spectrum

i remember a very specific point in my early teens when I dropped something on floor in my own bedroom. The day before I’d have left it. That day a very clear internal “ voice” said pick it up. I did. That internal voice of conscientiousness has been stalking me ever since (. 45 plus years). It is frankly a bloody pain. I’d love to be someone laid back about mess. But I’m not…that little internal check goes on and on

so there we go…it may be there’s a split between the move on people you say…but I think there’s also the internal dialogue factors that come into play

onlyconnect · 28/05/2024 12:26

I haven't read the whole thread so someone may have already said this but also people who are alway late get their way too.

Dartwarbler · 28/05/2024 12:21

Wellthatsit · 27/05/2024 01:46

I can see that living with someone super tidy or with OCD could be oppressive. But I'm talking about normal levels of tidiness and order.

When no one notices or enjoys it, and is happy to undo it immediately without a second thought it is so depressing (and stressful - as there's no way to control it).

Entropy …unfortunately the natural order of the universe 🤷🏼‍♀️

Seriously Op, the ONLY way to deal with this is to get a cleaner. If you can afford it even once a month it will save your sanity and budding resentment

I tried to cope with it for 12 years with kids. A promotion resulted in me giving husband ultimatum of that’s what my pay rise is going on and you can stick it

i live on my own now, retired, kids left home. Cleaning is the perk. Once per month blitz. My mess only and not much of it. 🥳🥳

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 28/05/2024 12:15

SoEmbarrassed2024 · 27/05/2024 00:31

Maybe untidy people should make better choices who they live with. Tidy people aren't going to change either.

True, but untidy people don't tend to have an issue with tidy people, it's usually the other way round

I'm untidy in the sense that I often leave things 'out' to remind me and if someone puts that away in a drawer or something it can mean that bill doesn't get paid or I don't have sun cream with me that day etc - so I can find it annoying!

PuttingDownRoots · 28/05/2024 09:50

iamnotgroot0 · 28/05/2024 09:07

What a weird response. As I said we do but my view is you don’t have to tidy every toy away the second it’s put down or line all the cushions back up if you leave the sofa. As an example I left my AirPods on the hall table the other day because I was going for a run later, in the meantime they ended up in in a kitchen draw. They don’t go there (they go on my desk) and I’d specifically said why I’d left them out. It’s excessive.

That's not tidying... thats putting stuff out of sight. Its creating work.

iamnotgroot0 · 28/05/2024 09:07

grinandslothit · 27/05/2024 23:37

If you and the kids were cleaning up after yourselves, there wouldn't be an issue.

What a weird response. As I said we do but my view is you don’t have to tidy every toy away the second it’s put down or line all the cushions back up if you leave the sofa. As an example I left my AirPods on the hall table the other day because I was going for a run later, in the meantime they ended up in in a kitchen draw. They don’t go there (they go on my desk) and I’d specifically said why I’d left them out. It’s excessive.

EmpressSoleil · 28/05/2024 08:59

This is why I live alone. I can have my exact level of tidy/messy. I would place myself around the middle of that spectrum. Too far either way isn't good imo.

I grew up in a "show home". We were only allowed in the living room to sit still and watch TV. Not allowed in the kitchen except to eat. Never any messy play or baking or whatever. I had to share a room with my sister and, if it wasn't nice enough to play out, it was like being in prison! We had bunks, a tiny room, no space to do anything. We actually had a lovely large "spare" room that no one ever stayed in! So it wasn't lack of space.

I couldn't live with anyone really messy but likewise I also couldn't live with someone that expected everything tidied the moment you'd used it. That would also be stressful to me.

K0OLA1D · 28/05/2024 08:56

WingBingo · 28/05/2024 08:55

Tidy up after yourself and you don’t need to tidy up.

seems simple to me but no one else in my home gets this.

It doesn't register in my home.. it seems so simple! I am sure the dc don't enjoy me calling them back downstairs to move the crisp packets, shoes, dirty dishes etc. Yet I do every time and they never learn!

fieldsofbutterflies · 28/05/2024 08:56

SoEmbarrassed2024 · 27/05/2024 00:31

Maybe untidy people should make better choices who they live with. Tidy people aren't going to change either.

True, but untidy people don't tend to have an issue with tidy people, it's usually the other way round

That's definitely not the case, lol.

K0OLA1D · 28/05/2024 08:55

arethereanyleftatall · 28/05/2024 08:52

To all those wondering why people do things like leave cupboard doors open - I watch my dd do it all the time, it's because her brain has already moved on to the next thing. Because I love her unconditionally, I watch her fascinated rather than bitter. She isn't doing it deliberately to irritate me, nor weaponised incompetence, she has simply already moved on. She is, waiting, to be assessed for adhd. I am trying to teach her to slow down, look around the room before she leaves it etc, but it is

My DP and both DSs are like this. I can laugh about it with them sometimes, but as a disabled person, it does get very tiring picking up and following them around!

WingBingo · 28/05/2024 08:55

Tidy up after yourself and you don’t need to tidy up.

seems simple to me but no one else in my home gets this.

arethereanyleftatall · 28/05/2024 08:52

To all those wondering why people do things like leave cupboard doors open - I watch my dd do it all the time, it's because her brain has already moved on to the next thing. Because I love her unconditionally, I watch her fascinated rather than bitter. She isn't doing it deliberately to irritate me, nor weaponised incompetence, she has simply already moved on. She is, waiting, to be assessed for adhd. I am trying to teach her to slow down, look around the room before she leaves it etc, but it is

RampantIvy · 28/05/2024 08:48

I think you might be right @arethereanyleftatall.

DH gets so frustrated at his inability to find stuff, which is why I remind him to look on the most logical place.

We both did an online ADHD test and he scored 94, I scored 26, and we both think that he has ADHD tendencies.

soupfiend · 28/05/2024 08:46

Emmerald · 27/05/2024 09:09

I can clean the kitchen, walk away and come back in 10 minutes later and I find cupboard doors open, a drawer left open and a folder of recipes left open on the worktop. He also takes sauces back to the fridge and leaves them by the fridge. I often find the sink with a couple of inches of used washing up water left in. 🤦🏻‍♀️😱.

It really does my head in!

I particularly like things being taken near to the bin and left on the worktop next to the bin.

WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!

soupfiend · 28/05/2024 08:43

SoEmbarrassed2024 · 27/05/2024 00:31

Maybe untidy people should make better choices who they live with. Tidy people aren't going to change either.

True, but untidy people don't tend to have an issue with tidy people, it's usually the other way round

I beg to differ actually, OH is almost a hoarder, he would be if I didnt stay on top of him, he calls this 'controlling'.

He is offended and upset at things being tidied, cleaned, moved around, put their homes (drawers and cupboards) and most upset at things being thrown out when they're broken or no longer used.

I have zero tolerance here, I am not going to live in a shithole.

arethereanyleftatall · 28/05/2024 08:43

Is this an ADHD brain/non-ADHD brain thing for the initial behaviour? Followed up by a more conscious decision to be considerate of others or not. Neither wrong nor right, but definitely compatible/not compatible.

RampantIvy · 28/05/2024 08:38

DH is the put the scissors down type. He also leaves lights on, leaves cupboards and drawers open, puts the front door key in his pocket when returning to the house instead of in the door, leaves the washing up water in when he has finished washing up and a myriad other things in a similar vein.

Then spends hours (and I literally mean hours) looking for stuff. It drives me round the bend.

He works from home and his desk is chaos. The floor of his office is scattered with files and bits of paper as well.

I also WFH and have commandeered a spare bedroom. My desk has a laptop, 2 wide-screen monitors, mouse, keyboard, pen and notebook and that is it.

SheepAndSword · 28/05/2024 08:35

I see what you mean - the bins didn't even get done when I was in hospital recently! Loads of other things like disinfecting surfaces, leaving ready meal packaging out, splattering toothpaste all over the sink and not cleaning up. Makes me feel like a nag.

oObyeOo · 28/05/2024 08:31

Luio · 27/05/2024 05:28

I remember when I was younger there were certain people’s houses we all avoided because they had a super tidy parent and it was extremely stressful to go there. You had to walk on egg shells the whole time and it was horrible. There were unfamiliar systems that had to be adhered to otherwise the Mum or Dad would get angry. I don’t think very tidy or very messy is a good thing.

I met a parent friend like this at a toddler group. I went round to her house for a play date when my ds was 3.

She told him off for being a conservatory toy in to the living room!… We never went round again.

Theothername · 28/05/2024 08:31

I think there are essentially two types of people - those who take out a scissors, cut something and put the scissors away; and those who put the scissors down.

I’m the latter. My brain has already moved on to the next stage of whatever I’m doing and I can’t do those little back track loops. But as an adult I have trained myself to build in a 5 minute tidy up at the end of a project, and several 5 minute whirlwind tidy ups throughout a day to find all the displaced items. I can’t see them until I actively try looking for them.

That’s motivated by consideration for others. And I suppose therein is the other distinction. I know some extreme tidiers who lack consideration.

usernother · 28/05/2024 08:27

I'm a naturally messy, untidy person. I don't even notice mess. But my husband isn't, he's very tidy. I have made a real effort to be tidier around the house and it's worked. I recognise that it makes my life easier. However, whenever he is away for work I revert to my natural self but tidy it all up before he gets back.