Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ASD DD struggle with transition from home to school

63 replies

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 08:26

My DD is in Y7. She started at the school in November. We are having ongoing problems with her separating from me. She won't want me to go and will cling to me. I take her into reception and an LSA comes down for her. We did try taking her to the student entrance but we were blocking it. School are finding it difficult with her having meltdowns in reception too. This doesn't happen every day maybe 2-3/5.

They have phoned me this morning to say if she won't go in within 5 minutes then I'll have to 'take her away and come back later.' Her brother has taken her recently a few times and she has gone in not too bad (although one day she did cling to him.) But they could be more luck that those were mainly good days. The school are keen for her to bring her in more. But he is doing his exams (he's 17 in Y12.) so I don't really think this is fair. I don't really think this is going to solve the problem. She has been referred to the Ed Psych to see if they can help.

Any ideas or suggestions much appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 23/05/2024 01:26

whatsagoodusername · 22/05/2024 14:20

My ASD DS struggles with transitions as well, although not the separation anxiety your DD has. We found that if he went into school early and went to the canteen, he could have a hot chocolate and settle into being at school without the stress of immediately getting into the school day. He's then able to go on with his day quite calmly.

Now there's stress if he's running late because he Must Have Hot Chocolate, but that's another issue! 🤣

The solve one thing create a new issue is always a fun one. I've also got the something that helps one of my Autistic DC is bad for another one issue. My DD used to absolutely meltdown if we were running late and wouldn't be at school 10 minutes early, of course the meltdowns actually made us late. Now she likes to arrive just before the bell but her little brother is freaking out about being late and if she rolled her eyes any harder over it you'd hear them. She's telling him we're not going to be late as long as he starts getting stuff done and then gets annoyed he's still melting down about it and he's behaving the exact way she used to which ironically annoys her no end.

I just remembered pocket hugs if she ever needs a tiny teddy for comfort OP.They're on a little card and really small and easy to keep hidden.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 23/05/2024 01:16

Riversideandrelax · 22/05/2024 14:13

Just to say we had a really good morning today. Wednesdays aren't usually too bad anyway but using some new strategies had a really positive impact. Hopefully they can help with Mondays a bit!

Good mornings are nice. My DS had a similar thing except in kindy where other 5 year olds were making fun of him for wearing a chewy sensory necklace. He wont use anything at all at school now that might help him regulate. My DD got told a broken lolly snake was Autistic at a party, like it means you're broken, its shit that this behaviour still goes on. The kid saying it didn't know she is Autistic, she choses who she tells. Good luck for Monday.

Theothername · 22/05/2024 16:14

Glad you had a good day.

whatsagoodusername · 22/05/2024 14:20

My ASD DS struggles with transitions as well, although not the separation anxiety your DD has. We found that if he went into school early and went to the canteen, he could have a hot chocolate and settle into being at school without the stress of immediately getting into the school day. He's then able to go on with his day quite calmly.

Now there's stress if he's running late because he Must Have Hot Chocolate, but that's another issue! 🤣

Riversideandrelax · 22/05/2024 14:13

Just to say we had a really good morning today. Wednesdays aren't usually too bad anyway but using some new strategies had a really positive impact. Hopefully they can help with Mondays a bit!

OP posts:
Riversideandrelax · 22/05/2024 14:02

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 22/05/2024 00:32

Just for missing me and transition away from me at various times she's had a matching necklace to mine, a drawing of a heart on both our hands, a photo of us together in her bag, an angel pin, taking special teddy, locket with photo. We've also done going in just till start of lunchtime. It can be used as a strategy for separation anxiety specifically because they know they'll see you sooner. The idea is to have a gentle calm transition to school then build on the time they're there. Might not be appropriate for your DD, just wanted to say it can still be helpful when school's not the issue.

Interesting people saying not to reward when all the professionals we've worked with say to do so. We've worked with 3 psychologists and did a group program for kids with anxiety. She loved group program. They all recommended immediate (that bits important) rewards for kids when they did the current step on their challenge ladders (CBT). Kids can't really work off future reward their brain's need something immediate. DD loves drawing so she got s single pen/pencil from a big pack of pretty colours I bought. One kid got a story, another got lots of cheers and congratulations from the parents, another got stamps, another stickers. If there's something she likes you could give it to the school and the person who comes to get her could give her her reward.

If you have the money a good psychologist who has experience working with Autistic girl could be helpful. Just seen you're post saying about going back to therapy, I think that's a good idea. All the other things we've tried were temporary fixes and like with your DD the issue kept coming back after she's had time away.

I would get an EHCP sorted even if you don't need it, it's good to have the supports documented if you need to change schools, for going to high school, college, university if she chooses. Im getting my DDs supports documented now for the transition to high school.

She actually finds teddies very comforting and used to take one every day at Primary. But she took once once to her school now and some older girls laughed which obviously put her off.

I think 'rewards' is a funny one. I think it really depends how it is done. But if you had supervision from a professional to do it then great. I've probably done what you suggest in different situations but I never really saw it as a reward as such. But it's definitely worth thinking about.

I'll speak to the SENCO about the EHCP. My DD is already at high school.

OP posts:
Lilacdew · 22/05/2024 13:46

@usernamebore - I do wish there were more small schools that are less overstimulating. Calm, familiar. I think even neurotypical kids get overwhelmed by the vastness of secondary. I hated secondary school. I went from loving primary and being studious to bunking off because it was so overwhelming and bullies ruled. I think no school should be bigger than about 500 pupils. It would make a world of difference.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 22/05/2024 00:32

Just for missing me and transition away from me at various times she's had a matching necklace to mine, a drawing of a heart on both our hands, a photo of us together in her bag, an angel pin, taking special teddy, locket with photo. We've also done going in just till start of lunchtime. It can be used as a strategy for separation anxiety specifically because they know they'll see you sooner. The idea is to have a gentle calm transition to school then build on the time they're there. Might not be appropriate for your DD, just wanted to say it can still be helpful when school's not the issue.

Interesting people saying not to reward when all the professionals we've worked with say to do so. We've worked with 3 psychologists and did a group program for kids with anxiety. She loved group program. They all recommended immediate (that bits important) rewards for kids when they did the current step on their challenge ladders (CBT). Kids can't really work off future reward their brain's need something immediate. DD loves drawing so she got s single pen/pencil from a big pack of pretty colours I bought. One kid got a story, another got lots of cheers and congratulations from the parents, another got stamps, another stickers. If there's something she likes you could give it to the school and the person who comes to get her could give her her reward.

If you have the money a good psychologist who has experience working with Autistic girl could be helpful. Just seen you're post saying about going back to therapy, I think that's a good idea. All the other things we've tried were temporary fixes and like with your DD the issue kept coming back after she's had time away.

I would get an EHCP sorted even if you don't need it, it's good to have the supports documented if you need to change schools, for going to high school, college, university if she chooses. Im getting my DDs supports documented now for the transition to high school.

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 22:50

ShittyGlitter · 21/05/2024 22:45

Place marking as I have a DD that sounds exactly like yours OP and want to read more of these replies.

We have never managed to help her with the transition part, but we have managed to help her process and understand the anxiety which helps in other situations too. Therapy was really the most helpful coupled with supportive staff at her school.

I think we need to go down the therapy route. It helped so much at Primary. She is on the waiting list for the therapist at school but if necessary I'll look privately.

OP posts:
Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 22:48

usernamebore · 21/05/2024 22:28

@Riversideandrelax thanks OP, and sorry for teaching you to suck eggs 😂You are way ahead of us, and it is great to hear how well your kids are doing generally. Yes the crisis in Year 7 came as a complete shock to us, and he only got his diagnosis in the summer after the year was done as both the school and his (rubbish) therapist kept insisting he was not autistic.
re transitions: for us the distraction approach often helps. He loves reading so if I have him a bit of time to get settled into a book, he would have calmed down enough that it was easier to leave. Same with playing a game on his phone or something to bridge that short period.
it is so hard, I wish you and your family the best and good luck

Oh no, don't be silly! All advice, ideas, anything is much appreciated! ☺️ And thank you so much.

OP posts:
ShittyGlitter · 21/05/2024 22:45

Place marking as I have a DD that sounds exactly like yours OP and want to read more of these replies.

We have never managed to help her with the transition part, but we have managed to help her process and understand the anxiety which helps in other situations too. Therapy was really the most helpful coupled with supportive staff at her school.

usernamebore · 21/05/2024 22:28

@Riversideandrelax thanks OP, and sorry for teaching you to suck eggs 😂You are way ahead of us, and it is great to hear how well your kids are doing generally. Yes the crisis in Year 7 came as a complete shock to us, and he only got his diagnosis in the summer after the year was done as both the school and his (rubbish) therapist kept insisting he was not autistic.
re transitions: for us the distraction approach often helps. He loves reading so if I have him a bit of time to get settled into a book, he would have calmed down enough that it was easier to leave. Same with playing a game on his phone or something to bridge that short period.
it is so hard, I wish you and your family the best and good luck

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 21:28

Nottherealslimshady · 21/05/2024 20:53

Based on what I do myself when transitioning from my car to a place. Csn you park up outside school. Set a ten/five minute timer and let her play on her/your phone or a game console or read a chapter of a book for a bit before you get out. Whatever she does to relax usually.

I don't know why but I always do that, like I need time to prepare for getting out the car like at the gym or supermarket or even at home. Au-DHD and anxiety here.

Edited

I don't drive to school we get the train. I think on a 'good' day it provides enough preparation to move from home to school. I think if we sit in the park and she doesn't want to play on the equipment/run around she could read/play on her phone if she'd like.

I always have to have strategies for myself for transitions too. I can't transition too quickly or I can't properly move from one thing to the other.

OP posts:
Nottherealslimshady · 21/05/2024 20:53

Based on what I do myself when transitioning from my car to a place. Csn you park up outside school. Set a ten/five minute timer and let her play on her/your phone or a game console or read a chapter of a book for a bit before you get out. Whatever she does to relax usually.

I don't know why but I always do that, like I need time to prepare for getting out the car like at the gym or supermarket or even at home. Au-DHD and anxiety here.

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 20:50

Icedlatteplease · 21/05/2024 16:47

Can I add that although I have offered advice on managing transition, I agree with everything that has been said about school being a deeply uncomfortable situation for ND children.

Having my time again I wouldn't considered a school environment. I absolutely would have home schooled for secondary onwards.

I home educated my eldest ASD DC the whole way through. However, DD is very different and school suits her. I did briefly home educate her while I was waiting for my appeal for this school to go through and she hated it. I did choose both her schools very carefully, though.

OP posts:
Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 20:46

usernamebore · 21/05/2024 16:07

I know this may not be what you want to hear, and it may be that your kids is totally different to ours so this does not apply, but I wanted to just drop a different perspective in here.
We had a very similar situation to you with our DS. We ended up forcing him in every day for the whole of year 7. Yes he would usually come out in a good mood, yes it was the transition in the morning that seemed to be the big challenge, and yes things did seem to be improving in many ways as the year went on. However we eventually found out, after getting the ASD diagnosis in the summer of year 7, that he had just been masking like crazy. That the reason for the meltdown at the start of the day, and the fear at leaving us, was because he knew it meant he had to face a whole day alone in an environment he found terrifying and overwhelming due to his unmet needs and, in particular, his sensory issues. He ended up being so traumatised by the year of being forced to cope that he started self-harming and was so anxious he became a shell of his former self.
In the end we realised that a big, noisy, bustling school was just never going to work for someone with a profile like his and have withdrawn him. We are now doing online schooling from home with Minerva and it is going fantastically.
I guess I would just advise being cautious as ASD kids are expert maskers and it can be hard to see exactly where the real problem is. Autistic burnout is real thing, and we know kids who ended up being hospitalised because of it. Resilience building is all very well and good, but for ASD kids it sometimes just doesnt work. Similarly, if I am scared of dogs exposure can help reduce that fear, but if everytime I see a dog it bites me, repeated exposure is actually just going to make things worse.
I guess my question would be - why is the transition so hard for her? What is she leaving when she goes away from you, or what is she transitioning into, which is so scary? If she was leaving you to do something she was excited or happy about, would there be an issue? For our DS it was leaving the safety and support he had from us (understanding his needs etc) and being alone and unsupported in an overwhelming and unpredictable school environment.

Edited

Yes, I understand where you are coming from. But it sounds like you weren't aware of your DS's unmet needs prior to the summer of Y7? It's different in our case because I am aware of her needs and ensure that they are met.

But that's wonderful that home ed is working for your DS. I did it with another of my ASD DC.

Transitions are often very difficult for people with ASD. It is just hard to move from one thing you are fully involved in to another, no matter how much you may like it. I mean obviously she is extremely attached to me. Home is her ultimate safety. But transitions can be difficult even if the thing we are moving to isn't scary. My DS for example would go berserk when we left friends houses to go home. Home wasn't scary - the transition was hard. And yes, the issue is there no matter how happy or excited she is about her day.

I'm sorry your DS didn't get the support he needed but as you say maybe a big school was never going to work and there isn't always a lot of choice. I was lucky in that I took it to appeal to get DD into a small Catholic school that due to the extra funding has excellent SEN support. I wish your DS well. My eldest who was home educated is doing T levels now at college.

OP posts:
Holesinmycheese · 21/05/2024 20:36

My DS (ASD) was also very unhappy going into school. Changing schools made all the difference, I’ve seen this with other children too.

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 20:32

Basically any day after a change of routine. So every Monday, doubly so if back after a holiday. If there has been a change in routine the night before so the day after parents evening for example.

I think the trouble with planning to be late every Monday and maybe Tuesday is it is probably just kicking the can down the road.

Hopefully the park should be ok for the rest of the term now. She is very reliant on routine so that is certainly a consideration. She will probably be ok for going in tomorrow but I want to get it in place ready for the extra tricky Monday back after half term.

Funnily enough I've just been having a joke with DD that when we get into school I'll start doing my 'mum dancing' and then she'll be so embarrassed she'll be happy to get away from me!

Yes, I definitely want to start the hug early. Because sadly sometimes I feel reluctant to hug her as it gives her the opportunity to take hold. I do still hug her but she can maybe feel a bit of reluctance. And that makes me sad.

I'm always the one walking away. Even on good days as it seems it is very much I have to leave before she can move on with her day. I always say 'have a good day, darling' even though sometimes I feel so cruel leaving her.

Yes, I know from my elder DC things are always going to evolve and change. But no matter how worn down I often get I will never stop advocating for my DD.

Thanks for thale advice - I appreciate it.

OP posts:
Icedlatteplease · 21/05/2024 16:47

Can I add that although I have offered advice on managing transition, I agree with everything that has been said about school being a deeply uncomfortable situation for ND children.

Having my time again I wouldn't considered a school environment. I absolutely would have home schooled for secondary onwards.

usernamebore · 21/05/2024 16:07

I know this may not be what you want to hear, and it may be that your kids is totally different to ours so this does not apply, but I wanted to just drop a different perspective in here.
We had a very similar situation to you with our DS. We ended up forcing him in every day for the whole of year 7. Yes he would usually come out in a good mood, yes it was the transition in the morning that seemed to be the big challenge, and yes things did seem to be improving in many ways as the year went on. However we eventually found out, after getting the ASD diagnosis in the summer of year 7, that he had just been masking like crazy. That the reason for the meltdown at the start of the day, and the fear at leaving us, was because he knew it meant he had to face a whole day alone in an environment he found terrifying and overwhelming due to his unmet needs and, in particular, his sensory issues. He ended up being so traumatised by the year of being forced to cope that he started self-harming and was so anxious he became a shell of his former self.
In the end we realised that a big, noisy, bustling school was just never going to work for someone with a profile like his and have withdrawn him. We are now doing online schooling from home with Minerva and it is going fantastically.
I guess I would just advise being cautious as ASD kids are expert maskers and it can be hard to see exactly where the real problem is. Autistic burnout is real thing, and we know kids who ended up being hospitalised because of it. Resilience building is all very well and good, but for ASD kids it sometimes just doesnt work. Similarly, if I am scared of dogs exposure can help reduce that fear, but if everytime I see a dog it bites me, repeated exposure is actually just going to make things worse.
I guess my question would be - why is the transition so hard for her? What is she leaving when she goes away from you, or what is she transitioning into, which is so scary? If she was leaving you to do something she was excited or happy about, would there be an issue? For our DS it was leaving the safety and support he had from us (understanding his needs etc) and being alone and unsupported in an overwhelming and unpredictable school environment.

Theothername · 21/05/2024 15:52

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 14:23

So, we go into reception and I let them know DD is here. Then we sit down and wait for someone to come. When they come I say goodbye to DD and give her a hug and try to leave. At this point on a difficult day she will cling on to me. Sometimes I can gently talk to her and get her to let go. Other times I can get a bit cross because she is hurting me and will then try and remove her hands.

A strategy that worked for a while was getting her to hold her lanyard with her fidgets on so she wouldn't grab hold of me. So then I could stay calm and encourage her/support her to go in. But that's not working anymore. We tried meeting an LSA at the student entrance to eliminate the sitting in reception but they felt it was distressing her more and then it was happening in front of all the students.

I'll ask her if she wants to try a timer.

I pack her bag for her and closely monitor homework so she has no worries about books or homework. If there are any issues I tell the LSA and they sort it. But I find that in that moment talking about her day just overwhelms her more.

Chatting about a SI sounds good. I'll definitely try that tomorrow.

I appreciate the ideas, thank you.

Have you any idea of what might make for a difficult day, op? If you have an inkling it’s going to be one of those mornings, then would doing something completely different and maybe going in a bit later be an option?

The park is also a good idea to try though it may not be viable in bad weather. Depends how reliant on routine she tends to be.

Sometimes a verbal rehearsal can be effective - you describe what is going to happen on the way there- and then follow the steps you’ve described. It can create a pull to complete the sequence.

With my ds, who is a bit oppositional and has a strong sense of humour, I’d describe something ludicrous that definitely won’t happen (…”and then you’ll start dancing with the LSA” ) but it still causes him to imagine the actual sequence.

I wondered if starting the hug sooner might be an option? So that you’re voluntarily giving her the nice long cuddle rather than her dragging it out of you.

Do you, or does she, have a phrase or gesture when she’s walking away? Or are you always the one walking away?

It’s brilliant that you’re getting so much support from the school. And it’s good that you’re confident in how well you know your dd - and what won’t work, even if you’ve not quite hit on what will yet.

Sometimes the solution isn’t going to be a one and done - just something for now.

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 15:31

RainbowZebraWarrior · 21/05/2024 15:21

Can she see the school nurse at her current school? They are brilliant. It's often something a lot of parents don't even realise is an option. I remember saying "I don't think the school has a nurse" when someone mentioned it to me. It's a local authority provision and the school nurses visit each school in turn, usually once a week.

DD has been seeing the school nurse for 3 years. At the height of her morning meltdowns, the school nurse managed to get to the bottom of it all, which was a fear of losing me. They gave her all sorts of coping mechanisms. To be honest, she doesn't remember most of them in the moment, but the weekly chat definitely helps. If nothing else, she feels heard and understood.

I'll look into it. She did have some input from the School nurse at her Primary too.

OP posts:
RainbowZebraWarrior · 21/05/2024 15:21

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 15:10

Yes, exactly the same for my DD.

My DD used to see a play therapist at her Primary school which helped lots.

Can she see the school nurse at her current school? They are brilliant. It's often something a lot of parents don't even realise is an option. I remember saying "I don't think the school has a nurse" when someone mentioned it to me. It's a local authority provision and the school nurses visit each school in turn, usually once a week.

DD has been seeing the school nurse for 3 years. At the height of her morning meltdowns, the school nurse managed to get to the bottom of it all, which was a fear of losing me. They gave her all sorts of coping mechanisms. To be honest, she doesn't remember most of them in the moment, but the weekly chat definitely helps. If nothing else, she feels heard and understood.

Riversideandrelax · 21/05/2024 15:10

RainbowZebraWarrior · 21/05/2024 15:03

This actually made my DD worse as it ramped up the stress of it all.

OP, hopefully the Ed Psych can help. In the meantime, you have my sympathy. DD went through this for about six months (also diagnosed ASD and Anxiety)

She wouldn't allow anyone else to take her in, so it's always fallen to me. School Nurse was very helpful and she has a weekly meeting with her just to chat through her fears and anxieties (usually while making something crafty)

Yes, exactly the same for my DD.

My DD used to see a play therapist at her Primary school which helped lots.

OP posts:
RainbowZebraWarrior · 21/05/2024 15:03

Singleandproud · 21/05/2024 14:50

What do you have on after dropping her off? If you are going home can you make up an appointment you need to get to and be very breezy about it, reminding her as you walk that you are going to the hairdresser's / optician / get home for the window cleaner and then when she tries to cling to you remind her that you need to go.

It might not make a difference particularly if you already have an engagement to get too (work) but it might do

This actually made my DD worse as it ramped up the stress of it all.

OP, hopefully the Ed Psych can help. In the meantime, you have my sympathy. DD went through this for about six months (also diagnosed ASD and Anxiety)

She wouldn't allow anyone else to take her in, so it's always fallen to me. School Nurse was very helpful and she has a weekly meeting with her just to chat through her fears and anxieties (usually while making something crafty)