Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Widows vs Single mums and divorcees

234 replies

IfIGoTiAnotherWedding · 16/05/2024 19:32

I am a divorced mother of 3. My ex husband was financially abusive and emotionally absent: when we split my sons were 4, 2.5 and 4 months respectively. He moved back to his home country U.S,A and has never seen the children since or sent a penny. Obviously it was hard. And still is.

I know a few widows. Some were friends of mine before they lost their husbands, some are new friends as we move in the same circles and have things in common, mainly solo parenting obviously. Like them, I have my children 24-7-365. In fact some of them have better family support (from two sides of their family), all happen to be in a better financial situation (whereas my ex left me with significant debts), but obviously they have gone through trauma and the death of their loved one, where I have not. I give them full credit for keeping going. It’s very lonely.

They never planned to be alone.
They never chose it.
I have utmost sympathy for both my widowed acquaintances, and for their children.

My AIBU is is it ok that there is SUCH a difference in how society approaches us. I have never received any offers of help or money. Obviously. My own parents are talking about offering a young widow who lives locally a few hours childcare once a week so that she can go to the cinema and have a break.

This was not something offered to me. I am listening to this thinking eh? They hardly know this person. I also am not sure if this widow would want such charity. She certainly wouldn’t if she knew that the sympathy is very much dependent on the term widowhood and not single mum.

Friend in question has already a rota of helpers.

Fundraisers, paid holidays - I don’t want them, I don’t begrudge my friends this.

I am just struck by the contrast between the “worthy” solo mums (widows) and the rest of us (unworthy) - Ditto for the children. This is not internalised stigma, the net difference is impossible to ignore.

My widowed friends are lovely people, they are devastated about losing their husbands and have no idea that there is this disparity in treatment.

The disparity feels like a throwback to more religious times and is akin to worthy poor versus unworthy poor. Anyway it sucks to be in the second category.

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 16/05/2024 20:15

I agree OP (I’m nether widowed nor divorced, or married for that matter) but I can see that society judges single mothers very harshly for some reason.

Londonscallingme · 16/05/2024 20:11

OceanStorm · 16/05/2024 19:47

Although a sad situation, you chose to marry and have kids with your partner. The widows didn't choose for their husbands to die

But neither of them chose to end up alone - presumably OP married and had kids expecting it to last, not expecting it to end I. Abuse and for him to skip the country without offering any financial support.

Tellmeifimwrong · 16/05/2024 20:11

I don't know any widows, and I imagine that is very hard. But I'm a single parent divorced from an absent, abusive man, and I agree that nobody seems to want to support me, even my own family who offer support to seemingly everyone else. My parents don't want me to rely on them, despite them having no evidence or past indicator that this might ever happen.

IfIGoTiAnotherWedding · 16/05/2024 20:10

Thank you for the replies. Food for thought. There are nuances, there are many factors at play about what makes parenting hard, or we should accept that there are nuances. It so happens that I feel the divide keenly, it’s undeniable, echoed by the divide on here with the responses. It’s not a race to the bottom, just my observations.
I actually don’t want anyone to step in and make my kids lives better. I just happened to think they are as worthy of acceptance and support from their community as any other child.

OP posts:
Londonscallingme · 16/05/2024 20:09

Ereyraa · 16/05/2024 19:48

Because there’s a DF still alive who should be in the picture helping out.

But he’s not!

Quiteavibe · 16/05/2024 20:08

Are your parents local to you? Have they supported you?

Sometimes people are weird and nicer to non-family members, I have experienced this.

Muffin101 · 16/05/2024 20:07

I think it’s a very unfortunate stance to take, comparing divorcees with widows, like it’s a ‘who has it worse’ competition. It’s not reasonable to make such sweeping comparisons, particularly when you’re attempting to compare such different scenarios. Apples and oranges, if you will.

Willowkins · 16/05/2024 20:07

I'm a widow but prefer to describe myself as a single mum. I'd rather not have all the wailing and if that means some people think I've had an exciting life so be it.
One thing I will say, I never knew how grindingly hard it would be to be responsible for absolutely everything and the sheer frustration of having be in two places at once. RegardIess of how it happened, I don't think single mums get the respect they deserve.

dastardlyglobetrotter · 16/05/2024 20:06

OP, I agree. It’s like comparing apples and oranges but the pain and the outcome for you has been the same.

im sorry other posters have not been kind.

your parents attitude really shocks me. What woman wouldn’t not help their daughter after she was brave enough to leave an abusive marriage.

God forgive me but your abusive husband has every chance of reappearing and destroying your life again. Something that cannot be easy to live with either.

im sure you’ve done a wonderful job of raising your 3.

MugsGames · 16/05/2024 20:06

I'd also add that if you want help, ask for it. Helping a widow is very normal, helping a divorcee less so (as you say yourself) and it may be that your friends just haven't thought of offering or don't want to cause offence by implying that you are struggling. Just ask!

Quiteavibe · 16/05/2024 20:05

A "who has it worst" debate is bizarre couldn't agree more, being a lone parent without a dad or other parent around for whatever reason is very very hard.

RedBananas12 · 16/05/2024 20:05

I find this a truly horrible post. It's not a competition in who has it worse. It reads as if you are envious of widows.

MugsGames · 16/05/2024 20:04

There really is no comparison between being widowed and divorced. A widow isn't just dealing with solo parenting- she is also dealing with the grief of bereavement and the difficulty of parenting bereaved children.

I don't think it's anything to do with judging divorcees or whether divorce is a choice. My friends who have been widowed would give anything to have their husbands alive, even if they were apart, and for their children to still have a hope of seeing their father again. It is not the same.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 16/05/2024 20:03

I don't see it as widows v single parents v divorcees etc. At all.

Everyone has their own shit to deal with including married people and single people. Everyone. It's all relatively, but everyone's biggest problem is their biggest challenge - even though all challenges aren't equal.

A "who has it worst" debate is bizarre.

dastardlyglobetrotter · 16/05/2024 20:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

well you’re a delight aren’t you?

some folk on here are just the worst - like you @missmollygreen

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 16/05/2024 20:02

Chaney · 16/05/2024 19:57

Choosing to have three children in quick succession with a man you consider to be finally abusive and emotionally unavailable is a choice you made. Having a husband who dies isn’t a choice.

They’re not comparable.

Oh my goodness, you are proving the OP right, no one chooses to be in an abusive relationship and pregnancy is a known risk factor when abuse begins, they have you trapped.

DancingNotDrowning · 16/05/2024 20:02

@OceanStorm

you chose to marry and have kids with your partner. The widows didn't choose for their husbands to die

This isn’t an equally comparison.

if you want to compare like for like the OP didn’t choose for her husband to be abusive and disappear.

I can well believe that single mums are seen as less worthy of support than widows, despite their positions often being no fault of their own

Ereyraa · 16/05/2024 20:00

IfIGoTiAnotherWedding · 16/05/2024 19:56

Yes to the issue of how to deal with kids who could in theory see their dad, except he chooses not to.

Agree that I chose to marry a loser. I could say the problems started once the kids came along - one might contest that but ok. Sadly it happens.

Finally, there are also widows whose husbands were terrible partners too and they were on the cusp of breaking up. The categories don’t make sense, but my experience is that they exist.

to the first reply - I said it sucked to be in the unworthy category - unworthy of any help or support or empathy. Not that it sucked to be in the category of being divorced. Also it was not my decision.

But you’re fundamentally looking for others to step in to make you and your DC’s life better, due to the lacking of their father.

People are far more willing to step in for a dead man, than a deadbeat.

OhmygodDont · 16/05/2024 20:00

I guess because there is no hope of a dead man springing back to life and deciding to support his children or be a decent a man.

While a relationship ending is sad it’s seen as one of those things. Losing your partner / father to death is seen as a tragic event.

mitogoshi · 16/05/2024 19:59

Aside from your question, why don't you seek child maintenance from him, the American courts take child support seriously (assuming he's earning or has assets)

Trickabrick · 16/05/2024 19:58

Chaney · 16/05/2024 19:57

Choosing to have three children in quick succession with a man you consider to be finally abusive and emotionally unavailable is a choice you made. Having a husband who dies isn’t a choice.

They’re not comparable.

I kinda agree with this, although it sucks if you feel your parents somehow feel a widow is more deserving of support than you are.

sparkellie · 16/05/2024 19:57

I think you're just thinking the grass is greener.

I'm divorced from my kids dad and my partner passed away in Sept of last year. Absolutely I know there was a while lot more sympathy and help from people for the first 3 months or so. But it doesn't last. Talk to any widow and they will tell you how quickly the offers of help dry up, or commitments aren't kept to. People mean well, but honestly the sympathy and extra help doesn't last long before the expectation is that you get on with it. Yes, comments might be more sympathetic but that doesn't mean anything in terms of actual support. People forget. And quickly. And then you are alone with bereaved children, who can often take a while to process the whole situation.

In some ways being widowed (though I wasn't married to my partner) is simpler, as you don't have to deal with a dickhead of an ex, but you are dealing with a whole heap of shit more. It's not preferable, trust me.

Chaney · 16/05/2024 19:57

Choosing to have three children in quick succession with a man you consider to be finally abusive and emotionally unavailable is a choice you made. Having a husband who dies isn’t a choice.

They’re not comparable.

IfIGoTiAnotherWedding · 16/05/2024 19:56

Yes to the issue of how to deal with kids who could in theory see their dad, except he chooses not to.

Agree that I chose to marry a loser. I could say the problems started once the kids came along - one might contest that but ok. Sadly it happens.

Finally, there are also widows whose husbands were terrible partners too and they were on the cusp of breaking up. The categories don’t make sense, but my experience is that they exist.

to the first reply - I said it sucked to be in the unworthy category - unworthy of any help or support or empathy. Not that it sucked to be in the category of being divorced. Also it was not my decision.

OP posts:
Quiteavibe · 16/05/2024 19:55

I also think it's strange if your parents offer to help a widow out and not you when you need a lot of help with three little ones. Perhaps that's a location thing? I haven't had anyone offer to take my children lately except blood relatives and I wouldn't expect random people to babysit them so I could go out.