Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Widows vs Single mums and divorcees

234 replies

IfIGoTiAnotherWedding · 16/05/2024 19:32

I am a divorced mother of 3. My ex husband was financially abusive and emotionally absent: when we split my sons were 4, 2.5 and 4 months respectively. He moved back to his home country U.S,A and has never seen the children since or sent a penny. Obviously it was hard. And still is.

I know a few widows. Some were friends of mine before they lost their husbands, some are new friends as we move in the same circles and have things in common, mainly solo parenting obviously. Like them, I have my children 24-7-365. In fact some of them have better family support (from two sides of their family), all happen to be in a better financial situation (whereas my ex left me with significant debts), but obviously they have gone through trauma and the death of their loved one, where I have not. I give them full credit for keeping going. It’s very lonely.

They never planned to be alone.
They never chose it.
I have utmost sympathy for both my widowed acquaintances, and for their children.

My AIBU is is it ok that there is SUCH a difference in how society approaches us. I have never received any offers of help or money. Obviously. My own parents are talking about offering a young widow who lives locally a few hours childcare once a week so that she can go to the cinema and have a break.

This was not something offered to me. I am listening to this thinking eh? They hardly know this person. I also am not sure if this widow would want such charity. She certainly wouldn’t if she knew that the sympathy is very much dependent on the term widowhood and not single mum.

Friend in question has already a rota of helpers.

Fundraisers, paid holidays - I don’t want them, I don’t begrudge my friends this.

I am just struck by the contrast between the “worthy” solo mums (widows) and the rest of us (unworthy) - Ditto for the children. This is not internalised stigma, the net difference is impossible to ignore.

My widowed friends are lovely people, they are devastated about losing their husbands and have no idea that there is this disparity in treatment.

The disparity feels like a throwback to more religious times and is akin to worthy poor versus unworthy poor. Anyway it sucks to be in the second category.

OP posts:
AlcoholSwab · 17/05/2024 05:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OceanStorm · 17/05/2024 04:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AlcoholSwab · 17/05/2024 04:39

IfIGoTiAnotherWedding · 16/05/2024 19:32

I am a divorced mother of 3. My ex husband was financially abusive and emotionally absent: when we split my sons were 4, 2.5 and 4 months respectively. He moved back to his home country U.S,A and has never seen the children since or sent a penny. Obviously it was hard. And still is.

I know a few widows. Some were friends of mine before they lost their husbands, some are new friends as we move in the same circles and have things in common, mainly solo parenting obviously. Like them, I have my children 24-7-365. In fact some of them have better family support (from two sides of their family), all happen to be in a better financial situation (whereas my ex left me with significant debts), but obviously they have gone through trauma and the death of their loved one, where I have not. I give them full credit for keeping going. It’s very lonely.

They never planned to be alone.
They never chose it.
I have utmost sympathy for both my widowed acquaintances, and for their children.

My AIBU is is it ok that there is SUCH a difference in how society approaches us. I have never received any offers of help or money. Obviously. My own parents are talking about offering a young widow who lives locally a few hours childcare once a week so that she can go to the cinema and have a break.

This was not something offered to me. I am listening to this thinking eh? They hardly know this person. I also am not sure if this widow would want such charity. She certainly wouldn’t if she knew that the sympathy is very much dependent on the term widowhood and not single mum.

Friend in question has already a rota of helpers.

Fundraisers, paid holidays - I don’t want them, I don’t begrudge my friends this.

I am just struck by the contrast between the “worthy” solo mums (widows) and the rest of us (unworthy) - Ditto for the children. This is not internalised stigma, the net difference is impossible to ignore.

My widowed friends are lovely people, they are devastated about losing their husbands and have no idea that there is this disparity in treatment.

The disparity feels like a throwback to more religious times and is akin to worthy poor versus unworthy poor. Anyway it sucks to be in the second category.

Widows are single mums through no fault of their own.

You chose with free will to procreate three times with an unsuitable man.

I bet those red flags were flying long before he fucked off back home.

There is clearly a big difference.

OceanStorm · 17/05/2024 04:28

@LieutOliviaBenson no the definitely shouldn't stay. But it would have helped to be more discerning before choosing to have children and marry someone

mondaytosunday · 17/05/2024 00:19

I'm a widow. My kids were four and six when my husband died unexpectedly. I've never been offered money, childcare, help of any kind from people outside my own family (and they lived abroad so no help there either).
I don't know any other widows so have nothing to compare with, and I also don't know any single mothers that do not have their ex partners taking responsibility and having their kids some of the time and paying maintenance.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/05/2024 00:11

elevens24 · 16/05/2024 21:04

There really is no comparison between being widowed and divorced. A widow isn't just dealing with solo parenting- she is also dealing with the grief of bereavement and the difficulty of parenting bereaved children.

I think this is really too simplistic. I know two families, one where the father died unexpectedly in an accident and the other where the dad just moved to the other end of the country for another woman. Both situations unexpected, both devastating, both women left having to parent solo. The majn difference is the children who are bereaved know they were utterly loved and cherished by their dad who wouldn't have left them given the choice. The other children are bereft that they've been abandoned.

The bereaved family were left with the dad's insurance policy and will be fine financially, and the mum has been able to reduce work hours.

I agree it's far too simplistic.

As awful as it is to say grief is possibly preferable compared with some of the horrific abuse women and children suffer at the hands of men. Some traumas last a lifetime.

Ludoole · 17/05/2024 00:10

I was widowed at 39. My boys were 12 and 15. I had NO help from family. Infact I was showering my dad who has alzheimers 6 hours after my husband died.... It might be that some get help but I didn't. I worked nights after his death, the only job I could get at the time, and had to leave my eldest in charge of my youngest. 8 and a half years on and we are doing great now, but my god it was bloody hard at the time.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/05/2024 00:06

OceanStorm · 16/05/2024 20:43

It's difficult to believe a bad character came out of the blue. There would have been signs beforehand

Well they do.

I was married for nearly 20 years before he tried to choke me.

They walk among us.

LieutOliviaBenson · 17/05/2024 00:04

OceanStorm · 16/05/2024 19:47

Although a sad situation, you chose to marry and have kids with your partner. The widows didn't choose for their husbands to die

I don't understand this post. Both women, ones whose partner left them (or they had to leave) and women whose husbands died chose to marry and have kids!

Are you saying women in abusive relationships should stay because they "chose" abusive men? 🤔

Tbry24 · 17/05/2024 00:02

I think it’s probably a you and your parents thing. One of my parents was very very similar towards me as I was not worthy of any help. I was a very young parent not married and had to go through a horrific court case due to domestic violence and sexual assault so became my baby’s only legal parent and the other person was not allowed to now our whereabouts etc. So definitely a lone parent with zero help.

But my parent would, and still does, have to list all these other single mothers widowed or divorced and how they feel so sorry for them, their life’s been so hard, etc,etc,etc.

One of the actual widows in question actually lived with my family for a time as a child as parent felt sorry for her then too, at the same point as me being kicked out of home and made homeless.

So it’s harsh parenting I’m afraid, I’m currently no contact with my family apart from speaking to my parents every few weeks. What was your childhood like?

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/05/2024 23:59

OceanStorm · 16/05/2024 19:47

Although a sad situation, you chose to marry and have kids with your partner. The widows didn't choose for their husbands to die

Women don't choose to be abused either.

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:47

EucalyptusIndigo · 16/05/2024 23:44

Oh well, if you’ve said it three times then it must be true 😂

I’m not the only person who has read it as intended; that I am a lone parent because of something that I did, how I behaved, something I said, blah blah blah. I, woman, am clearly to be blame for the failings of man. And so too is every woman at fault for not picking better, or nagging too much, or daring to not shift the baby weight et cetera et cetera.

I won’t be replying to you again.

Read it as you wish, I'm beyond giving a shit. Go scrap somewhere else.

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 16/05/2024 23:44

sixnearlyseven · 16/05/2024 23:42

I was widowed 3.5 years ago when my 8 children were between 19 and 9 months old. I haven't received any special treatment I don't think, apart from a trip to a theme park for my kids after COVID was over through Merlin's magic wand. It's the only time they have ever been .
Childcare wise, my parents are a bit older now so see the children once a week but I'm usually there too.
I'm on Universal Credit though hopefully starting a part time job soon. Every month , the money I get from my husband's pension is deducted in full from the UC. So I'm no better off and the government bereavement support payment now only lasts 18 months , rather than 16 years like it used to.

Please message me if you would like as through my volunteering work I know of a number of charities that help bereaved families if you would like it.

EucalyptusIndigo · 16/05/2024 23:44

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:32

You also didn’t mean that ‘quelle surprise’ comment the way you’re now claiming at all so you can fuck off with that. You’ve just realised what a bellend it made you sound.

No that's what I meant - I've clarified three times now.

There's only one bellend here....

Oh well, if you’ve said it three times then it must be true 😂

I’m not the only person who has read it as intended; that I am a lone parent because of something that I did, how I behaved, something I said, blah blah blah. I, woman, am clearly to be blame for the failings of man. And so too is every woman at fault for not picking better, or nagging too much, or daring to not shift the baby weight et cetera et cetera.

I won’t be replying to you again.

sixnearlyseven · 16/05/2024 23:42

I was widowed 3.5 years ago when my 8 children were between 19 and 9 months old. I haven't received any special treatment I don't think, apart from a trip to a theme park for my kids after COVID was over through Merlin's magic wand. It's the only time they have ever been .
Childcare wise, my parents are a bit older now so see the children once a week but I'm usually there too.
I'm on Universal Credit though hopefully starting a part time job soon. Every month , the money I get from my husband's pension is deducted in full from the UC. So I'm no better off and the government bereavement support payment now only lasts 18 months , rather than 16 years like it used to.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 16/05/2024 23:41

@OceanStorm Are you for reel. They all chose yo have kids with their husband/partner. The widow may not have chose their husband to die but at the same time single mums do not always choose to be single mums. Sometimes a relationship is great but years down the line it breaks down, perhaps the husband cheated, had a gambling addition, got into debt and disappeared, went off to start a new family. It does not mean just because he ain't dead she chose to be a single parent. Her own parents should offer her a break whilst watching their grandchildren before offering a stranger.

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 16/05/2024 23:40

AnonAnonmystery · 16/05/2024 23:19

My god are you sure you weren’t married to my ExH? I’m glad you got out x

So sorry you went through that too.

err I mean aren't we lucky let's count our blessings

It was out of the frying pan into the fire as ex then deliberately and knowingly risked DSs life when he was there just with his toddler sister (cafcass ignored police and medical reports and said he could have contact). It has left him deeply traumatised. But hey, I guess his dad only tried to kill him, his dad didnt die, so he's a lucky little chap really

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:32

You also didn’t mean that ‘quelle surprise’ comment the way you’re now claiming at all so you can fuck off with that. You’ve just realised what a bellend it made you sound.

No that's what I meant - I've clarified three times now.

There's only one bellend here....

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:31

Sugarcoatedalmonds · 16/05/2024 23:24

It wasn't meant to come across patronising at all. Its obviously an emotive and very difficult subject. I was trying to be kind.

Maybe people didn't help you because this is how you treated them?

You obviously need an emotional punching bag tonight but its not going to be me I'm afraid so I'm not going to respond to you again.

Eh? Who said I didn't get help? I got (and still get) los of help in terms of practical and emotional support...I did say I didn't bebefit for any fundraisers or free holidays (neither would I want them). You're making things up your suit your own agenda. I only reminded in kind to someone who was abusive to me.

EucalyptusIndigo · 16/05/2024 23:29

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:17

What aspersions have I cast upon you? I haven't made any assumptions about you or any single mothers at all. I haven't said one situation is worse than the other - I've said it's fucking nasty to assume that widows have some kind of easy ride and the original post sounds jealous. Read my posts again.

It was obvious that you were coming at it from the POV as a single parent and one with a massive chip on her shoulder.

And if were talking pleasant 'massive prick', 'bore off', 'fuck off' - I think that's rather rich, don't you?

There’s no chip on my shoulder about being a single mum. Our life is lovely, thanks. I’m angry that men get to live life as if their child doesn’t exist, but not at my situation. So, again, you’re wrong. You also didn’t mean that ‘quelle surprise’ comment the way you’re now claiming at all so you can fuck off with that. You’ve just realised what a bellend it made you sound.

And, to be clear, I’ve never claimed to be pleasant. Your posts are filled only with unkindness for anyone other than yourself. You don’t come across well here at all.

Sugarcoatedalmonds · 16/05/2024 23:24

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:21

Come on, it was patronising. I think you're a sanctimonious twat for what it's worth.

I didn't say 'quelle surprise' that their partner left, I said it because it's no surprise that's her angle.

It wasn't meant to come across patronising at all. Its obviously an emotive and very difficult subject. I was trying to be kind.

Maybe people didn't help you because this is how you treated them?

You obviously need an emotional punching bag tonight but its not going to be me I'm afraid so I'm not going to respond to you again.

TreesWelliesKnees · 16/05/2024 23:23

@StJulian2023 I think we made the same point really, at the same time.

We’re all just walking each other home. Let’s do it with a bit of grace.

I love how you put it.

I also agree that the even harder times come later, when you see that for your children there is no getting over this. It shapes them and you can't change it. I just wanted to send you some solidarity. I'm feeling that too.

Quiteavibe · 16/05/2024 23:21

@StJulian2023 I hear you. I haven't wanted to go into what my children saw on this thread either, but it was things adults struggled to witness, and it has deeply scarred them and both have struggled in different ways to come to terms with such horror at an early age, as have I. Unmumsnetty hugs to you and to all the single parents trudging forward.

PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/05/2024 23:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Come on, it was patronising. I think you're a sanctimonious twat for what it's worth.

I didn't say 'quelle surprise' that their partner left, I said it because it's no surprise that's her angle.

AnonAnonmystery · 16/05/2024 23:19

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 16/05/2024 21:33

This is my life. But actually that is incomparably better than when I was still married to him. That was the bit where I felt most alone. And of course he pretended to be the dream husband in public so noone knew I needed help. Even when I was so ill I was crawling around the house after our toddler while my ex's contribution was to sit on the sofa and scream and swear at me for being so useless.

My god are you sure you weren’t married to my ExH? I’m glad you got out x