Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how to communicate with foster carer?

223 replies

UndertheCedartree · 16/05/2024 19:28

I wasn't sure if there was somewhere more specific I could put this but couldn't find anything.

My DNephew is in foster care. This isn't about the reasons for that.

I look after him twice a week. He is brought to mine via transport. My only way of contacting the FC is through a communication book. Last summer I bought him a lot of clothes which went to the FC as he has been there since September. I would like to know if any still fit him so I know what he needs before I get him summer clothes this year.

I have asked in the book 3 times now over 5 weeks and she hasn't replied. I'm not sure if I'm doing something wrong here. The last time I said if it was easier for her she could send the clothes to me so I could check the size for myself. But still no reply. I don't really want to get the SW involved as I know she is busy and surely this is something we should be able to sort ourselves?

The foster carer in general shares very, very little which makes me sad as I want to be part of his life.

YABU - foster carer doesn't have to give any information, there should be no expectation of working together
YANBU - it would be nice if we could work together and if FC could engage in that

OP posts:
IvyGrippedtheSteps · 17/05/2024 11:17

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 11:06

But in what way have I micromanaged his care with her?

And why does she think it's ok to micromanage my care of DN?

Honestly, OP, I can’t help feeling the clothes and packed lunches situation is the tip of an understandably complex iceberg of feelings here. You almost don’t mention your sister, probably for good reasons, but I can’t help wondering whether some of this frustration with the FC is displaced feelings about your sister, and whatever situation has meant she’s been unable to care for her own child, or guilt that your own circumstances meant you couldn’t care for him FT yourself (or any other family member for that matter). The clothes in particular seem as if you’re very set on them as signals that this child is loved, this child has a caring, involved birth family, this child isn’t just another child in care, who’s sent out in mismatching cheap clothes and cheap food as some kind of signals of institutionalisation.

I absolutely sympathise with what sounds like a difficult and complex situation, but it sounds to me as if it would be useful to talk your own feelings through with a therapist, because there’s a lot more going on here than a wrangle about non-fitting summer outfits.

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 11:11

IvyGrippedtheSteps · 17/05/2024 11:08

I thought that the placing local authority shared PR with the parent in certain situations, like a child placed under a care order.

No, not in all cases.

OP posts:
IvyGrippedtheSteps · 17/05/2024 11:08

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:58

But the FC doesn't have PR either, only his mum does.

But yes, it's certainly complex.

I thought that the placing local authority shared PR with the parent in certain situations, like a child placed under a care order.

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 11:06

Doingmybest12 · 17/05/2024 10:46

You might have to be the bigger person here I'm afraid as you don't want his placement to breakdown I assume and you don't want to disrupt the plans for 50/50. You can't micro manage his care with her. Hope it all goes ok with the 50/50.

But in what way have I micromanaged his care with her?

And why does she think it's ok to micromanage my care of DN?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 11:04

AGlinnerOfHope · 17/05/2024 10:46

Yes, but no, but…

I fed my kids well but culturally it’s not standard.
My friends did too.
But me and my friends and you aren’t the majority.

If you look at what’s sold in massive quantities in supermarkets, a hell of a lot of people are feeding kids chicken fridge raiders and snack attacks.

I would like to agree that NHS standards should be followed at all times.

Pragmatism suggests that we have to accept it’s not happening.

If care was ideal, we wouldn’t work so hard to keep our kids out of it.
If being a foster carer was easy, there would be more of them.

It’s not ideal. It is what it is. You do what you can, both as foster carer and relative.

Oh, yes, fridge raiders is another favourite of hers! 😂

I guess we surround ourselves with like minded people so healthy eating seems 'normal'.

But no, I completely take your point. Of course FC isn't going to be perfect. Of course I'm not perfect. I don't expect that. I bite my tongue about the food she sends. I just say it's not needed. I wish she could realise I don't micromanage her so why does she feel the need to micromanage me?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:58

IvyGrippedtheSteps · 17/05/2024 09:51

I think this is fair. It’s also possible that the fact the OP isn’t the child’s mother, and doesn’t have PR, though she will be sharing his care with FC 50/50, is complicating relationships. I mean, the birth family/FC relationship can be complex at best.

But the FC doesn't have PR either, only his mum does.

But yes, it's certainly complex.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:50

AGlinnerOfHope · 17/05/2024 09:26

It’s really tricky because you are supposed to treat the child like your own in most ways, but not in others.

The DC doesn’t know which family they feel part of- the one they are with, or the one they are born to. It would happen that strangers would assume I was mummy. DC wanted to call me mummy. I wasn’t supposed to let them, as they have a mummy. I didn’t let them and regret that hugely.

Can you see it as being a bit like divorced parents? You each have different expectations and just have to accept that the other doesn’t share them?

Yes, I understand it is a fine line. But surely it must depend on what family the DC has and what contact they have, what they can provide.

I know I keep going on about clothes but we have no need for anyone else to buy his clothes. We need someone to look after him some of the time, yes and are very grateful of course. I wish I could say for how long but I can't right now. Maybe that would make it easier?

I am divorced and have a great co-parenting relationship and I think communication is the key! But like I said I don't micromanage my ex and I don't micromanage FC. So yes, I do accept she does things differently. The other way round though, she tries to dictate everything! If my ex phoned me and said 'what summer clothes could X do with?' - I'd just tell him!

OP posts:
Doingmybest12 · 17/05/2024 10:46

You might have to be the bigger person here I'm afraid as you don't want his placement to breakdown I assume and you don't want to disrupt the plans for 50/50. You can't micro manage his care with her. Hope it all goes ok with the 50/50.

AGlinnerOfHope · 17/05/2024 10:46

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:27

No, just nursery and me. She isn't expected to write much in the nursery book and can leave a bag there if it is easier (My DC were at the same nursery.) I get writing in the book is an extra thing to do. But I do it. I make the effort and after all it is her job. He doesn't come to me straight from nursery.

She is welcome to a private home life. I'm not interested in going in to her house. I just think it would be nicer for DN rather than having to use transport for everything. (He goes to nursery in transport too.) She could drop him to me if she doesn't want me going to her house. But anyway, that's her decision at the end of the day. It just feels very cold and impersonal, I suppose.

Do you mean most people feed toddlers on UPF high in sugar and salt? Not in my experience. The NHS specifically advises against that. Out of interest is there no expectation on a FC to feed the DC healthily? I mean I assumed she would feed him healthy meals at her house but maybe not? The point is I can't dictate what she feeds him at hers. She wants to feed him rubbish, I can't stop her (not saying she does just feed him rubbish.) But when he is with me I provide him with the same healthy meals I feed my own DC and I don't need her sending a load of junk food with him.

I take your point we're all different with what we consider 'healthy' or 'junk' but surely basic health advise by the NHS is the minimum? Surely everyone knows you don't give peperami to toddlers??

Yes, but no, but…

I fed my kids well but culturally it’s not standard.
My friends did too.
But me and my friends and you aren’t the majority.

If you look at what’s sold in massive quantities in supermarkets, a hell of a lot of people are feeding kids chicken fridge raiders and snack attacks.

I would like to agree that NHS standards should be followed at all times.

Pragmatism suggests that we have to accept it’s not happening.

If care was ideal, we wouldn’t work so hard to keep our kids out of it.
If being a foster carer was easy, there would be more of them.

It’s not ideal. It is what it is. You do what you can, both as foster carer and relative.

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:42

Mummapenguin20 · 17/05/2024 08:49

Your nephew is so lucky as a child I was a lac and I had a foster carer who wanted to be my mum it was so confusing

Oh, bless you, I'm sorry.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:41

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 17/05/2024 08:45

I can't imagine how hard this is for you. Sorry for the explanations around things you're already well across and when you're already a great advocate for your DN needs. Its lovely he has you there. You sound like a fantastic Aunty. I'd be a lot less worried about my DC future if I knew they had someone like you to fight their corner if I couldn't care for them for a time.

Edited

That's really nice of you, thank you.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:39

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 17/05/2024 08:44

I think it might be sensible to direct some of your frustration at the situation and not the foster carer. It must be very difficult to have a stranger looking after a family member and doing things differently to how you or your sister would. This isn't the foster carer's fault. She has stepped into a situation that you wouldn't have chosen to be in. The longer the thread is going on, the more it seems to me that you need to be right and you need her to be in the wrong, which is beginning to seem counterproductive to me. You both have to care for your nephew and you need the relationship to work. I think you've had some good advice to speak to the social worker about it to see if communication can be improved. Focus on building that relationship now, not rubbishing her.

Oh, I do have so much frustration with the situation too.

And as I have said, I accept when he is with her she looks after him completely differently to how we do. I don't think I should micromanage. I have to believe DN is ok with her.

I have tried so, so hard to build a relationship. But I guess I'm tired of it now. I needed to vent, that's all. I'm exhausted. And I just wish she could just be a tiny bit less exhausting herself. Just have a tiny bit of compassion, maybe. But I'm probably expecting too much. I have spoken to the SW before about communication not being forthcoming and I will try again.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:32

Doingmybest12 · 17/05/2024 08:09

This is dangerously falling into 'he said, she said' territory and with 50/50 beginning next week ,just try to step back from all of this unless you have safeguarding concerns which you still should share. I hope it all settles down for the little ones sake, otherwise this plan could be disrupted. You've got the measure of how she works, stop banging your head against a brick wall and concentrate on your time with your nephew.

Yes, I know what you mean. I've kept it all bottled up for so long it's all coming out! I know I sound critical but I usually keep it all to myself. She is just exhausting. I dread the next thing I've done 'wrong.'

Yes, you're right I clearly am banging my head against a brick wall with trying to communicate. Maybe I should just communicate with her how she communicates with me? But then I'd not hear the end of it! If she asks me a question and I don't reply immediately she's straight onto the SW to complain!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:27

AGlinnerOfHope · 17/05/2024 08:07

Quick question- he’s going to nursery (communication book) and you (communication book ) anywhere else? All the bag packing and communicating can get a bit repetitive, even if it’s essential.

Is he coming to you straight from nursery?

It can get a bit full on, organisationally, all the bags and transport arrangements.

Also, she has a right to a semi private home life so may be in the habit of keeping relatives away from her house. I can’t think of anything worse than having a relative turn up ten minutes early and ask to use the loo (perfectly reasonable from their point of view) when I was trying to organise everyone and everything. When the SW came unexpectedly, for a home visit or similar, that was ok because they’d been many times before and would be understanding if they caught me on an off day where everything was going wrong! A relative, less so.

And while I totally agree with you about the food, it’s actually a bit snobby in practice. It’s perfectly normal to feed a child like that. I don’t. But know from other DCs lunch boxes that many if not most do.

My DC went to independent schools for various reasons. At the first, I was the slummy mummy sending ‘junk’ food while the others were on home made vegan stuff. At the next school, I was the health freak and everyone else was normal. Same food both times 🤣

No, just nursery and me. She isn't expected to write much in the nursery book and can leave a bag there if it is easier (My DC were at the same nursery.) I get writing in the book is an extra thing to do. But I do it. I make the effort and after all it is her job. He doesn't come to me straight from nursery.

She is welcome to a private home life. I'm not interested in going in to her house. I just think it would be nicer for DN rather than having to use transport for everything. (He goes to nursery in transport too.) She could drop him to me if she doesn't want me going to her house. But anyway, that's her decision at the end of the day. It just feels very cold and impersonal, I suppose.

Do you mean most people feed toddlers on UPF high in sugar and salt? Not in my experience. The NHS specifically advises against that. Out of interest is there no expectation on a FC to feed the DC healthily? I mean I assumed she would feed him healthy meals at her house but maybe not? The point is I can't dictate what she feeds him at hers. She wants to feed him rubbish, I can't stop her (not saying she does just feed him rubbish.) But when he is with me I provide him with the same healthy meals I feed my own DC and I don't need her sending a load of junk food with him.

I take your point we're all different with what we consider 'healthy' or 'junk' but surely basic health advise by the NHS is the minimum? Surely everyone knows you don't give peperami to toddlers??

OP posts:
Eggmoobean · 17/05/2024 10:09

Go through the social worker.

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 10:07

AGlinnerOfHope · 17/05/2024 06:28

I haven’t quite finished reading the thread, but from what I can see it’s just one of those things. You sound lovely, it’s quite unusual to have someone so committed and reliable in an FCs life. The relatives of mine were quite problematic for a variety of reasons.

For those thinking the longer term questions were irrelevant and nosy, they really weren’t If you are trying to understand someone’s behaviour it’s going to be affected by the situation!

I have known people who are excellent at looking after small DC who have really limited other skills. Maybe poor literacy, or poor communication skills. Makes them hard to work with, but no doubt the dc they look after is doing well. That’s not good in fostering- it’s a big, broad job- but if she’s the best they have available for a child with a specific set of needs then that’s it.

I have been in your position when my FCs move on and the next placement doesn’t want contact and seems to quietly rebel against it. It’s painful.
One day he’ll be home and she’ll be in your position. We were always encouraged to stay in touch but families were always keen to forget and move on!

Yes, obviously I understand FC are in short supply. She may be great at communicating with toddlers but not adults, perhaps!

That must be very painful when you have developed a bond.

I'd be quite happy to stay in touch if it makes it easier for DN. But I doubt she'd be bothered and it would just be very one sided. I may be wrong. I think from my experience dealing with SWs and in this case the FC is so hard, I can imagine just wanting to forget it and move on. It's very traumatic them going into FC in the first place. And then the FC wanting to shut out the family, it's very, very hard.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 09:59

Mummy3Plus1 · 17/05/2024 08:00

Ah I see, so this is another 'i want advice but only if you agree with me' post 😂

You asked for advice, I have been in your position and theirs and you can't make a distinction between your life and their job. As long as that remains you'll continue to have an issue. Enjoy!

I'm not asking for you to agree or disagree. I just asked how I can communicate with the SW as she ignores me. You said have meetings but she refuses. You said I shouldn't be told how difficult she is which would mean me getting more upset which hardly aids communication. What was your advice?

You can't make a distinction between your life and their job? What does that even mean?

And thanks, I do enjoy my time with DN.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 09:53

caringcarer · 17/05/2024 01:52

I'm a FC are I think it's odd that FC won't answer simple questions about if the clothes you bout him fit or not. Id just take him out and buy him a few T shirts and shorts if he gets hot. If he's average size I'd get 3-4 years. I'm assuming he had 2-3 last year. I'd buy him a few nice outfits to wear when he's with you and keep them at your house for him. Let his FC dress him when he's with her. I find it really weird that she packs food for him unless he's on a special diet. It's as if she doesn't think you feed him. I think it's quite rude of her. I would just throw it away and feed him what you want to. Also I wouldn't unpack the bags she sends then she can't complain you don't pack them properly. I suppose the main thing is his SW has told you she is taking good care of him until you can get him back with you full time.

He had a mix of sizes as to what fit. I think at this point she's not going to engage so I'll just go out and get his clothes and if some fit from last year then he'll just have extra. I do always keep some at mine but obviously things get mixed up where he is back and forth. I don't want to just let her but his clothes as I want him to be dressed with love like all the other DC. I'll get clothes that can be mixed and matched to make it easier for FC.

Yes it is weird as does she think I'll feed my DC dinner and just give him his 'packed lunch'. It's such a pain I have to 'hide it' from him. I think I'll just start throwing it away. I've asked her enough times not to send it.

The thing with the bags is there are some things he needs so I end up searching through all the bags looking for the item. All the while the toddler is pulling it all out looking for his lunchbox full of treats! 😂

And yes, I hold onto that.

OP posts:
IvyGrippedtheSteps · 17/05/2024 09:51

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 17/05/2024 08:44

I think it might be sensible to direct some of your frustration at the situation and not the foster carer. It must be very difficult to have a stranger looking after a family member and doing things differently to how you or your sister would. This isn't the foster carer's fault. She has stepped into a situation that you wouldn't have chosen to be in. The longer the thread is going on, the more it seems to me that you need to be right and you need her to be in the wrong, which is beginning to seem counterproductive to me. You both have to care for your nephew and you need the relationship to work. I think you've had some good advice to speak to the social worker about it to see if communication can be improved. Focus on building that relationship now, not rubbishing her.

I think this is fair. It’s also possible that the fact the OP isn’t the child’s mother, and doesn’t have PR, though she will be sharing his care with FC 50/50, is complicating relationships. I mean, the birth family/FC relationship can be complex at best.

AGlinnerOfHope · 17/05/2024 09:26

It’s really tricky because you are supposed to treat the child like your own in most ways, but not in others.

The DC doesn’t know which family they feel part of- the one they are with, or the one they are born to. It would happen that strangers would assume I was mummy. DC wanted to call me mummy. I wasn’t supposed to let them, as they have a mummy. I didn’t let them and regret that hugely.

Can you see it as being a bit like divorced parents? You each have different expectations and just have to accept that the other doesn’t share them?

Mummapenguin20 · 17/05/2024 08:49

Your nephew is so lucky as a child I was a lac and I had a foster carer who wanted to be my mum it was so confusing

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 17/05/2024 08:45

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 08:01

What you have to remember is I've looked after him his whole life. I am fully aware of his SEN much more than she is (I have DC with SEN too.)

Yes, DN has particular needs around clothes, food, naps. I have communicated this to the FC but she likes to do her own thing. I think she is very rigid. But as you say it's not a comment on her as a carer! And I'm sad about how unsettled he is with her compared to me. But I have to keep moving forward. Overnights starting next weekend.

I do think she is finding it overwhelming. There are a lot of things she can't cope with and some support with equipment has been slow to arrive for her. It's a shame because if she was having a difficult day I'd always try and help but she doesn't phone me. DN is pretty much non-verbal with her so it must be even harder than with me where he has some words and signs. I'm not downplaying what a hard job it is for her or how grateful I am for her looking after DN.

I can't imagine how hard this is for you. Sorry for the explanations around things you're already well across and when you're already a great advocate for your DN needs. Its lovely he has you there. You sound like a fantastic Aunty. I'd be a lot less worried about my DC future if I knew they had someone like you to fight their corner if I couldn't care for them for a time.

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 17/05/2024 08:44

I think it might be sensible to direct some of your frustration at the situation and not the foster carer. It must be very difficult to have a stranger looking after a family member and doing things differently to how you or your sister would. This isn't the foster carer's fault. She has stepped into a situation that you wouldn't have chosen to be in. The longer the thread is going on, the more it seems to me that you need to be right and you need her to be in the wrong, which is beginning to seem counterproductive to me. You both have to care for your nephew and you need the relationship to work. I think you've had some good advice to speak to the social worker about it to see if communication can be improved. Focus on building that relationship now, not rubbishing her.

UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 08:37

SullysBabyMama · 17/05/2024 07:28

I’m not a foster carer currently but I had children up until 2020 so fairly recent.

I would strongly suggest you drop this if he is coming to live with you. If it is a short term issue then pick your battles!

If this isn’t likely then his “home” is this families home and when he comes to visit you, then you are his auntie. You need to stop overstepping and remember you and not his mum but his auntie.

You mentioned that you have children of your own. If your child’s aunt said that it was not your job to buy your children clothes and it was HER job- would you agree?
It is literally legally and morally this ladies responsibility to cloth your nephew.
If you want to buy him nicer clothes that’s great and lovely, but your attitude towards it comes off controlling and like nothing she is doing for nephew is good enough.

We are all just guessing the foster carers reasons but asking 3 times in 5 weeks feels excessive to me, especially since where I am we have had two days of “shorts” weather so I haven’t even looked at the summer clothes for some DCs.
This would make me glad I hadn’t shared phone numbers with you as I would be worried you would ask even more if I did.

I don’t chat casually with the birth families about our lives as it’s not safe, although I pray and hope they are able to reunite.
If asked what your nephew had been doing I would write a list like “Beach. Finger painting. Crabbing. Playing in the garden. Park.”
I wouldn’t be sharing details like “We went to Blackpool beach and DN had a lovely bubblegum ice cream, which he had 3 licks of and then declared the best food ever! He loved the teacups and got a new hat from the seaside shop with a fish on.”
It sounds like the “she is difficult” stuff is her actually sticking to the foster carer training! Except the style of clothing issue which is identity.
I am told to pack food as almost all children have come from food instability backgrounds.
I am told not to share any details about where DC could be such as “Blackpool Pleasure Beach”.
I am told to use the book to communicate about YOUR VISITS not his life at my home.

I had one foster family that bought their 3 children all under 5 matching outfits but only one set at a time. They would ask the social worker to pass on messages such as “Can the girls wear the pink dresses with Minnie Mouse on on Saturday please as we have a party?”
These dresses were bought 18 months before and would definitely not fit. I chose to hand down the dresses so two wore the dresses and the eldest wore something else- that I had hoped was their style. I tried so hard to make sure they were happy.
They complained to the social worker I didn’t match the girls. They complained if the dresses didn’t fit I could have at least sent the matching outfits for the younger two so they could swap them all to match at their house. I didn’t have matching outfits for the younger two as I don’t dress them identical. I cried as I had tried so hard to please them.

They also used to give me one days notice to launder all the clothes. I hated the clothes by the end of it.
They also didn’t send hats back that I needed for nursery the next day! Literally forgot something every single time!

He will be with me 50:50 with the FC. Yes, I'm his aunty and I get his clothes on behalf of his mum. Yes, I have DC. If I was unwell I'd ask my sister to get my DC's clothes. The FC is his carer not his mum!

As I have said I trip over myself to thank FC. I walk on eggshells so as not to upset her.

How is asking 3 times in 5 weeks excessive? It shouldn't take 5 weeks to get an answer. If she answered the first time I wouldn't need to ask again! And where we are we've had weeks of warm weather and DN runs hot so has needed me to change him into cooler clothes. I mean honestly, would it be so very difficult for you just to see what summer clothes your FC needs? It's something parents do up and down the country every season change. It's a normal part of looking after a child. And you'd be glad you hadn't shared your phone number because you may get asked to do this so difficult task??

I haven't asked her to chat casually with me about her life. Although I pose no risk to her. But to let me know what things DN is getting up to. Exactly like your list. I don't get that. Well no other foster carers must be sticking to their training then if she has a reputation for being difficult. Interesting how other FC on here wouldn't do things as she does. Is sticking to foster carer training mean you complain to the SW if the bags you send (despite requests not to send them all) are packed slightly differently to how you do it? Is it training to give 3 yos highly processed sugary and salty food? And is it training to barely communicate with the DC's family? I don't think it is atall.

There are no food insecurity issues or risks to me knowing where they may have gone at the weekend! Not that I'm asking for specifics, anyway! The book is meant to be 2 way not just about me giving the FC information. Why does she need information if I don't??

You're complaining about the girls not having clothes that fit, but also complaining that I'm checking if things fit! And I have cried many times as I try so hard to keep this woman happy, but it should be my DN's happiness who should be put first not hers!

Hats get forgotten sometimes! Parents know this so have more than 1! I've ensured DN has multiple things at FC so she doesn't have to get in a panic if something is left behind. I'm sorry but you sound ever so hard work too.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 17/05/2024 08:09

Doingmybest12 · 17/05/2024 01:23

It's great if carers and family members can get on well and are on the same page as each other. But really it can be a complicated relationship .There may be other reasons why she feels she needs to keep boundaries in place, maybe she's had a bad past experience with a birth family. Not saying she should be nit picking or obstructive but it's not as simple as everyone being one happy family. From what you describe of her dressing your dn , there is an implied criticism that her standards aren't good enough however carefully you approach it, but I totally get you feeling he doesn't look like himself. I hope talking to the sw will help.

It certainly is so complicated! I've realised that writing this.

OP posts: