Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that conspiracy theorists are everywhere

118 replies

CobbldyCook · 15/05/2024 23:55

I recently acquired a dog and so now make small talk with lots of people I probably wouldn’t have spoken with before. Not because I would avoid them or anything, just because I wouldn’t run into them. Conversation usually starts normally enough but there seems to be about a 1 in 3 chance that the chat suddenly takes a turn for “mRNA experiments”, “turbocancers”, “contrails”, “chip totality”… you name it! It’s particularly prevalent in men it seems. I never had these kinds of conversations before. What changed? Is this all because of lockdown and/or people spending so much time on the internet/social media? Aren’t there enough real issues in the world to be interested in/worried about without making stuff up? Why are people so credulous?! How should I counter it?!?

OP posts:
CJsGoldfish · 16/05/2024 14:43

The term "conspiracy theorist" was put into circulation to discourage chatter after JFKs assassination by the US security services, as I recall
That in itself is a conspiracy theory. Awkward 😂

It is now used to shut down and ridicule anyone trying to challenge injustice or highlight bad actors in authority
This is what conspiracy theorists tell themselves and each other 🤷‍♀️

fuckssaaaaake · 16/05/2024 14:23

@catchthebeat ok I'll pipe down

catchthebeat · 16/05/2024 14:22

fuckssaaaaake · 16/05/2024 14:15

@catchthebeat not the heart problem I have. The ones I've read about are not the same

It's perfectly reasonable to assume there are other side effects that haven't been officially documented yet. This happens quite often when new medicines are administered on a global scale, even following trials. It doesn't have to be conspiracy theory, just because it concerns vaccines. We're in a strange situation now where people are so scared to be called anti-vaxxers, any critical thinking or natural curiosity around new vaccines and drugs is instantly dismissed as a conspiracy theory. We don't approach other areas of science with this absolute certainty that we already know all there is to know. If you've noticed a strong correlation between a drug and a peculiar side effect, it doesn't make you a conspiracy theorist to assume there may be some causation.

FOJN · 16/05/2024 14:19

Superlambaanana · 16/05/2024 07:55

I'd be very interested in a study to compare conspiracy theorists' jobs with non-conspiracy theorists.

I have a theory (perhaps it is a conspiracy theory?! 🤔🤣) that people who believe in conspiracies are generally quite junior (in their jobs/ careers). It's easier to imagine a cabal 'above' you who are controlling everything.

I have found (anecdotally at least) that the further people climb up the career ladder, the less likely they are to believe anyone is competent and organised enough to plan and perpetrate evil deeds on a mass scale.

Humans just aren't that great at delivering major projects and most of these conspiracy theories would involve a huge amount of planning, organisation, expertise, technical knowhow and discipline on behalf of a huge number of people, and all at once.

There is a recognised phenomena of intelligent people having stronger ideological biases than less intelligent people. The theory is that people who are good at reasoning are also good at rationalising so are able to persuade themselves they are right about things which clearly make no sense.

catchthebeat · 16/05/2024 14:16

catchthebeat · 16/05/2024 14:14

I'm no conspiracy theorist. I had all the Covid jabs willingly.

But why are you saying that this is a conspiracy theory? The link between certain covid vaccines and heart problems was very well documented in the mainstream media and has been confirmed by the medical community. It's the fact that they continued administering those specific vaccines after finding this out that was shocking.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-57781637.amp

A person receives the Moderna vaccine against Covid-19 in the device launched by Acciona in Madrid, on July 5, 2021

Heart inflammation link to Pfizer and Moderna jabs

But European regulators say the benefits of Covid vaccines continue to far outweigh the risks.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-57781637.amp

fuckssaaaaake · 16/05/2024 14:15

@catchthebeat not the heart problem I have. The ones I've read about are not the same

catchthebeat · 16/05/2024 14:14

fuckssaaaaake · 16/05/2024 07:30

I've found myself being a bit of a conspiracy twat this week. I've been having problems with my heart and I'm only 35, in addition, I've also heard about 4 different people all locally with the same thing! One person said to me, do you think it's the vaccine and all of a sudden I started to think it must be.
I know it's silly, I know it's not, but my head has been turned a bit

I'm no conspiracy theorist. I had all the Covid jabs willingly.

But why are you saying that this is a conspiracy theory? The link between certain covid vaccines and heart problems was very well documented in the mainstream media and has been confirmed by the medical community. It's the fact that they continued administering those specific vaccines after finding this out that was shocking.

OriginalUsername2 · 16/05/2024 14:08

I hate the phrase “conspiracy theory”. Such an easy way to poo-poo any information that doesn’t fit the script!

Always look into things yourself.

Just watching documentaries on mainstream channels has opened my eyes to the amount of corruption in every area of power.

scalt · 16/05/2024 14:02

Also, "conspiracy theorists" is nothing new, it's happened with many technological advances before, although they might have been named under a different insult. When television was a novelty, people would say:
"It gives you square eyes."
"It's bad for children, it fries their brains."
"It gives people bad ideas."
And, quite probably, some people feared that it could be used by the government to "brainwash" the public, and that's without George Orwell's idea of telescreens that would spy on you in your own home as well.

RoseUnder · 16/05/2024 13:41

I agree with this!

@Jumpingthruhoops I think the main issue these days is that everything is explored, examined, considered in absolute terms. Good, bad, left, right. When I suspect the actual truth is somewhere in the middle. But no one gives each other the time of day enough to work that out.

Social media has made everyone much more binary, polarised, one side or the other. Right or left. Wrong or right. And self-rightious, tending towards information sources which affirm their hunch, rather than challenge it. OP I have also come across this on dog-walks!

Generally, people seem less tolerant of having their ideas and theories challenged (in a respectful way). Is this due to the whole social media push to be kind, respect others etc etc?

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/05/2024 13:26

YaMuvva · 16/05/2024 03:52

This is MN. You could ask for advice about your sick hamster and eventually someone will post “transwomen are men”

🤣

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/05/2024 13:14

CobbldyCook · 16/05/2024 10:03

Thank you for all your replies. I think that one of the problems I have with these interactions is that they tend to stay with me afterwards. There are often gaping holes in their logic, their understanding of science (my area of special interest, professionally), their knowledge of history, and their lack of knowledge of languages other than English (so they never read things from anywhere other than the UK or US media, EN language accounts on social media etc.), but I don’t feel comfortable pointing any of these things out, because they seem like nice people fundamentally. Essentially I don’t want to have a confrontation with them, because when I’ve attempted to engage (in a friendly way), they tend to get irritated. But afterwards I’m left with a bad feeling. Several posters here have said that it’s not worth engaging with people that espouse these views because they won’t listen—I’m prepared to believe it, but it makes me feel rather sad.

Why don't you try them? They may indeed be ill informed. Or YOU might be ill informed. There's really only one way to find out - but it would involve having a measured, respectful conversation.

Strip it right back... You say there are 'gaps in their knowledge'. What are they referring to that makes you say that? Why does what they say 'stay with you' if you 'know the truth'?

I think the main issue these days is that everything is explored, examined, considered in absolute terms. Good, bad, left, right. When I suspect the actual truth is somewhere in the middle. But no one gives each other the time of day enough to work that out.

Jumpingthruhoops · 16/05/2024 13:03

notanothernana · 16/05/2024 07:36

😳 OP you're right, they are everywhere.

What, critical thinkers? You're right, we are!

Conspiracy theorist is just a dickhead term for people whose opinion you don't agree with - largely because you haven't made even a vague attempt to look into anything they're saying yet still think you know it all.

All I heard throughout the pandemic, for instance, was: 'They just want to be proved right'. On the contrary, they desperately want to be proved WRONG. Now, as PPs have said upthread, lots of these 'theories' have come to fruition. Whether you choose to believe them is, at this point, neither here nor there.

My advice would be, before you write people off as 'conspiracy theorists', ask yourself this: why would somebody go out of their way to make themselves unpopular?

fantasmasgoria1 · 16/05/2024 10:05

There are many things that were considered to be conspiracy theories, mk ultra being one of them . Many of the conspiracies have been declassified by the CIA in recent times. So if some of the conspiracies of yesteryear are true it stands to reason that some conspiracy theories of today are true.

CobbldyCook · 16/05/2024 10:03

Thank you for all your replies. I think that one of the problems I have with these interactions is that they tend to stay with me afterwards. There are often gaping holes in their logic, their understanding of science (my area of special interest, professionally), their knowledge of history, and their lack of knowledge of languages other than English (so they never read things from anywhere other than the UK or US media, EN language accounts on social media etc.), but I don’t feel comfortable pointing any of these things out, because they seem like nice people fundamentally. Essentially I don’t want to have a confrontation with them, because when I’ve attempted to engage (in a friendly way), they tend to get irritated. But afterwards I’m left with a bad feeling. Several posters here have said that it’s not worth engaging with people that espouse these views because they won’t listen—I’m prepared to believe it, but it makes me feel rather sad.

OP posts:
SavetheNHS · 16/05/2024 09:56

The problem is that governments and corporations and billionaires lie ALL THE TIME in order to keep hold of power and wealth.

It's very hard for us to know what is real and what is not.

Common sense can be useful.
A CT that the rich manipulate us so we vote a certain way and they get away with tax avoidance - highly likely

The royal family are lizards - highly unlikely.

I try to think who would benefit, is there a strong evidence base and is it likely according to common sense?

scalt · 16/05/2024 09:54

Northernnature · 16/05/2024 08:57

I think all this started around 2016. The people voted for Brexit and I just assumed those in power would work to put it into effect. But no, they spent 3 years wasting time and trying to stop it. Then Covid. We have had many pandemics in the past including in 1957 and 68 but life just went on as normal and govt tried to keep calm and carry on. This time they did the opposite, controlled us in the extreme and actually lied about things like whether the vaccines stop transmission and efficacy of masks. So now people are extremely sceptical about anything they say (I tend to think they do and say the opposite of what's in my interests)

Exactly this. I still remember when Hancock et al said with great authority “masks are ineffective “, then there was a massive u-turn. So now, I take the view that if the government really presses and emphasises something, it is likely to be false. It will be years or decades before I can believe, respect or trust any government again.

SavetheNHS · 16/05/2024 09:49

@fuckssaaaaake yes vaccines can cause heart complications but it's rare.

What is quite common though is heart complications following a Covid infection. Even asymptomatic covid can cause long covid. Some of the most common symptoms of LC are fatigue, brain fog and heart palpitations. Can also cause a racing heart at random times.

More people have long term effects of Covid than we realise and the effects include cognitive decline. The long term consequence is that even more people may end up believing in conspiracy theories.

(LC isn't a CT by the way, it's backed up by tonnes of evidence published in the top medical and scientific journals)

BeethovenNinth · 16/05/2024 09:38

My husband and I are both healthily sceptic. We don’t think the royal family are lizards. We don’t think there is an aim for global control by higher powers

we are both professionals in higher earning jobs. You would never guess from speaking to us that we lean towards some so called conspiracy theories

from the start we believed Covid was a (accidental) lab leak. We declined the vaccines. We laughed at the statements that they stopped transmission. JFK was shot by the US Security service. Weapons of mass destruction and dodgy reports? I could go on. I’m not even sure the US landed on the moon to be honest but I don’t care hugely.

what is the difference between conspiracy theory and fact? Perhaps a decade?

I am always amazed people are so trusting. You just need to look at the catalogue of shit to realise experts often have ulterior motives. Asbestos, smoking, bloody mesh, blood contamination, the trans debacle.

Beefcurtains79 · 16/05/2024 09:12

sunnydaysanddaydreams · 16/05/2024 07:35

In what way were they speaking about concentration camps? The German use of them? Don't think any one reasonable has doubted their existence after 1945.

People and soldiers were disbelieved during the war when they spoke about camps being built that people were worked to death and killed in.
Obviously not since 1945, as they were clearly fact by then.

Bobskeleton · 16/05/2024 09:04

There is so much information accessable via internet/social media these days that people can delve into what they want.

I'm not into conspiracies as such but think the very lightheaded ones are fun to read or research so I can see why people get caught up in it. It's a bit of escapism from the "real news" which in my opinion is truly terrifying.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 16/05/2024 09:01

And don't worry.

The army has the 77th brigade to monitor "disinformation" and carry out psy-ops to counter it.

Not a conspiracy theory.

Northernnature · 16/05/2024 08:57

I think all this started around 2016. The people voted for Brexit and I just assumed those in power would work to put it into effect. But no, they spent 3 years wasting time and trying to stop it. Then Covid. We have had many pandemics in the past including in 1957 and 68 but life just went on as normal and govt tried to keep calm and carry on. This time they did the opposite, controlled us in the extreme and actually lied about things like whether the vaccines stop transmission and efficacy of masks. So now people are extremely sceptical about anything they say (I tend to think they do and say the opposite of what's in my interests)

AlisonDonut · 16/05/2024 08:48

I think if you think that people AREN'T conspiring for their own good in some way or other, then just enjoy life. Enjoy the dog walking, pop some headphones on so people think you are listening to your own conspiracy theory podcasts and don't overthink it.

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/05/2024 08:46

YANBU . I know a few people who I always thought were intelligent and sane by they believe all sorts of nonsense, especially surrounding covid and vaccines. You can tell them that the majority of the world's scientists are saying the opposite of them and then they tell you that they have done their research ....... how incredibly thick they are to think that at few hours of googling is going to wield better information than a degree in a relevant subject and years of experience.

I think as PP have said it of because people are stressed and anxious. Plus Trump has validated these people .