Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not have realised how abusive and horrible men were until I joined MN

495 replies

geoger · 15/05/2024 20:04

Been on MN a while now and I must admit that it has really opened my eyes to how abusive and horrible some men are. I’m not ignorant, I know that men can be violent, controlling, abusive etc - I read loads, watch the news and documentaries but I just didn’t realise the depths of depravity some men reach. Every day there are threads where women are physically, emotionally, financially and sexually abused by their so called ‘d’ h/p that I find really worrying and distressing.
Some of these threads still play on my mind and I worry for the women who posted them.
I feel so stupid and naive and trusting. MN has really opened my eyes. Has anybody else experienced this worry for other women on here or am I just living in a bubble?
I know this is AIBU but please no bashing

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
MsLuxLisbon · 17/05/2024 11:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Crikeyalmighty · 17/05/2024 11:13

There are awful men and some pretty horrible women too - but as this is mumsnet it's more likely you will see threads about male behaviour. If you want to look at threads where men are bashing women then pop over to Reddit- plenty of such posts on the 'dead bedrooms' reddit - although 'some 'are such mysogonistic egocentric pricks that I have a chronic urge to reply 'and you wonder why your wife isn't interested'? Some people have a chronic lack of self awareness.

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 11:11

skyfairy · 17/05/2024 11:06

Most women on this thread haven’t spoken about being abused.

Given that at least 1 in 5 women experience sexual assault - for starters - at the hands of a man, you don't really need every woman on the thread to lay out her experiences.

Sexual abuse, violence, domestic violence, emotional and mental and psychological abuse, are quite common. Victim blaming is abhorrent.

Edited

Every single woman I know well enough to have spoken about this topic has experienced some form of abuse from a man. My mother, grandmother, aunts, MIL, friends, past work colleagues. And me.

BlackPanther75 · 17/05/2024 11:09

5128gap · 17/05/2024 10:39

But some women on this thread have disclosed they have been abused. So lets focus on them. So I ask you again, do you stand by your claim that 'most' women who are domestically abused are reciprocal abusers? Because if you do, you are saying that 'most' of the women on the thread who have disclosed abuse are abusers. Do you intend to double down on that, wriggle out of it with by arguing about something else, or retract it for the offensive nonsense it is?

I don’t know what has happened with women posting on this that who are saying they have been abused, and neither do you. This is an Internet forum not a therapy session or a court of law. And even in those settings people get things wrong.

The evidence on reciprocal abuse in relationships is as long standing as it is unpalatable. this doesn’t mean that i am saying that people who report abuse on this thread are involved in reciprocally abusive relationships. It would be clearly as dishonest for me to say i knew that, as much as it would be dishonest for you to say you knew that it wasn’t

but we do know that it does happen and it sadly that it appears to be the norm

skyfairy · 17/05/2024 11:06

Most women on this thread haven’t spoken about being abused.

Given that at least 1 in 5 women experience sexual assault - for starters - at the hands of a man, you don't really need every woman on the thread to lay out her experiences.

Sexual abuse, violence, domestic violence, emotional and mental and psychological abuse, are quite common. Victim blaming is abhorrent.

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 11:02

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 17/05/2024 10:50

Start your own thread then, because this one is about male behaviour.

Oh they have! Bashing women.

Maybe they’ll get the fuck if this one then.

I’m sure their thread is ‘interesting’. 🤣

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 17/05/2024 10:50

Start your own thread then, because this one is about male behaviour.

Oh they have! Bashing women.

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 10:49

MsLuxLisbon · 17/05/2024 10:22

Hear hear. There are a large number of toxic women, both on this site and IRL. Women aren't saints. Far fucking from it.

Start your own thread then, because this one is about male behaviour.

5128gap · 17/05/2024 10:39

BlackPanther75 · 17/05/2024 10:29

Most women on this thread haven’t spoken about being abused.

The OP wasn’t ‘all my life ive experienced men being abusive shits’, it was ‘all my life i didn’t think men were all massive bastards, but now I've found mumsnet i realise they are’.

its nonsense

nobody here is saying that you dont get abusive men who do horrible things. And nobody is saying that we shouldnt do everything we can to stop it

but also women can be horrible and loads of them are. Does that mean i go around saying ‘ive just realised that women are emotional abusers..’ ? No, because it would be wrong. But loads if women i know do abusive things and i have plenty of friends in abusive relationships

you just have to look at female only friendship groups or female work environments to see the emotional bullying that goes on.

pretty much every teacher i know, and mum who has girls will say girls are horrible the way they treat eachother. Boys tend to be more violent and hit eachother more quickly, but girls psychologically bully and abuse eachother. That’s not a research based comment of mine, that’s what I’m told in parents evenings and conversations with other parents. I have a son and a daughter and i see gender differences there

and yeah there’s plenty of published research over the last 50yrs on the reciprocity of violence in relationships

But some women on this thread have disclosed they have been abused. So lets focus on them. So I ask you again, do you stand by your claim that 'most' women who are domestically abused are reciprocal abusers? Because if you do, you are saying that 'most' of the women on the thread who have disclosed abuse are abusers. Do you intend to double down on that, wriggle out of it with by arguing about something else, or retract it for the offensive nonsense it is?

BlackPanther75 · 17/05/2024 10:29

5128gap · 17/05/2024 07:28

So the women on this thread who have spoken of being abused, in your opinion, are 'mostly' also abusers, who have committed violence against and terrorised their male partners in equal measure? That 'most' woman raped, hospitalised or murdered in their homes commit the same acts to their male partner? And that 'most' of them have chosen an abusive partner either subconsciously or deliberately because they want to be in an abusive relationship so they can hurt men? Because, that's quite a bold statement you've made there. Are you sure you don't want to have a little think about it...?

Most women on this thread haven’t spoken about being abused.

The OP wasn’t ‘all my life ive experienced men being abusive shits’, it was ‘all my life i didn’t think men were all massive bastards, but now I've found mumsnet i realise they are’.

its nonsense

nobody here is saying that you dont get abusive men who do horrible things. And nobody is saying that we shouldnt do everything we can to stop it

but also women can be horrible and loads of them are. Does that mean i go around saying ‘ive just realised that women are emotional abusers..’ ? No, because it would be wrong. But loads if women i know do abusive things and i have plenty of friends in abusive relationships

you just have to look at female only friendship groups or female work environments to see the emotional bullying that goes on.

pretty much every teacher i know, and mum who has girls will say girls are horrible the way they treat eachother. Boys tend to be more violent and hit eachother more quickly, but girls psychologically bully and abuse eachother. That’s not a research based comment of mine, that’s what I’m told in parents evenings and conversations with other parents. I have a son and a daughter and i see gender differences there

and yeah there’s plenty of published research over the last 50yrs on the reciprocity of violence in relationships

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 10:28

MsLuxLisbon · 17/05/2024 10:22

Hear hear. There are a large number of toxic women, both on this site and IRL. Women aren't saints. Far fucking from it.

Indeed.

A lot of the posters on here struggle to understand it's not all about them. It's about providing the statistics and a balanced picture of the reality so people can make an informed decision.

MsLuxLisbon · 17/05/2024 10:22

BlackPanther75 · 16/05/2024 23:01

That’s because your talking to women so your perspective is skewed.

These mums net threads are classic echo chambers of lots of Internet people saying hugely over the top things. It’s crazy behaviour.

i bet none of these women talk about times they have undermined their partners, been emotionally abusive etc etc. But plenty of them will have. Plenty of us have seen our mums be abusive towards our dads, our friends mums, or our siblings and their mates do it. I know men who are in abusive relationships and I know women who are. I also know that sometimes people can be abusive in their relationship, but you wouldn’t call it an abusive relationship as such

It’s just really extreme what you are saying and quite simply sexist. you should be ashamed of yourself.

Edited

Hear hear. There are a large number of toxic women, both on this site and IRL. Women aren't saints. Far fucking from it.

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 10:21

IdgieThreadgoodeIsMyHeroine · 17/05/2024 10:16

I wish they wouldn't announce their departure in the first place, as if they're a bloody train.

I wish they didn’t arrive in the first place. 😂 Why don’t they realise when they’re making a dick of themselves?

IdgieThreadgoodeIsMyHeroine · 17/05/2024 10:16

KitchenSinkLlama · 17/05/2024 09:55

Don't you wish when someone says they are going to leave a thread, they would fucking leave a thread.

I wish they wouldn't announce their departure in the first place, as if they're a bloody train.

KitchenSinkLlama · 17/05/2024 09:55

Don't you wish when someone says they are going to leave a thread, they would fucking leave a thread.

Magnastorm · 17/05/2024 09:46

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 09:00

OK, I admit it. I stole a random person's driving license. Hmm

I'll ask again -> what do you think your astonishingly lacking in self-awareness posts are achieving here, other than making yourself look really, really silly?

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 09:29

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 09:00

OK, I admit it. I stole a random person's driving license. Hmm

My family are not random people. I could easily post ‘evidence’ of 4 degrees, of which only 2 would be mine. I could also post ‘proof’ that I’m 44, 43, 28, 20 or 15 depending on which family members birth certificate I posted a photo of. Etc, etc.

Of course I wouldn’t post any of them because I’m not desperate to prove anything, because I’m not trying to prove that I’m not here with questionable intentions. You’re failing in that by the way. It’s easy to see what you are.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 17/05/2024 09:28

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 08:07

Whoops, I used gender in place of sex. Waiting for somebody to call me a TRA now. 😂 I'm an angry transwoman trying to get my own back on the terfs. 🤣🤣🤣

Comprehension skills appear to be on par with the TRA's to be fair.

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 09:00

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 08:42

As has already been said, it proves nothing as it could be anyone’s, but your protesting too much and offering ‘proof‘ that proves nothing is a clear sign of being full of shite.

OK, I admit it. I stole a random person's driving license. Hmm

BlackPanther75 · 17/05/2024 09:00

SomersetBrie · 17/05/2024 08:40

I'd like to see a link to "most children under 1 are killed by their mother".
The awful thing about you writing stuff like this is that people might believe you.

The truly awful thing is that what I’m saying is true

child homicide perpetrators worldwide: a systemic review (Stockl et sl, BMJ, 2017)

Irisginger · 17/05/2024 08:57

This reflects physical, social and economic power differential and reinforced by social structures and prevailing culture, where for centuries women have not been afforded the same rights as men and have been treated as their husbands chattels. In the UK is is only in relatively recent modern history that is has become unlawful for a husband to beat his wife, unlawful for a husband to rape his wife, or for married women to have the right to enter in credit agreements independently of men. In other parts of the world women are still fighting for these rights. This history, and these differentials in physical, economic and social power affect who we all are and how we behave and live. They also affect the distribution, severity and impact of violence.

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 08:42

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 07:19

Here you go. Apology accepted lol.

As has already been said, it proves nothing as it could be anyone’s, but your protesting too much and offering ‘proof‘ that proves nothing is a clear sign of being full of shite.

SomersetBrie · 17/05/2024 08:40

BlackPanther75 · 17/05/2024 07:11

That’s the common narrative at the moment isn’t it.. husband kills a wife, the man is evil. Wife kills husband , the man is evil.

Most domestic violence is reciprocal and happens in abusive relationships i.e. violent abusive people seek eachother out for relationships and unsurprisingly violence occurs. it is genuinely tragic

It is interesting.. similar happens when mums kill their infants.. most children killed under 1 are killed by their mother. The narrative is currently that the mother is suffering mental health problems (so shes the victim). Father kills his child, he’s a monster.

And again similar with these female teachers who have sex with children. The women who do it are ‘under great stress’ or ‘acting out of character’ and its only classed as sexual abuse in the UK. A male teacher does it he’s a pervert and a paedophile and a rapist

plenty of men do shit things. Plenty of women do shit things. Some men are really nasty. Loads of women are really nasty too

Edited

I'd like to see a link to "most children under 1 are killed by their mother".
The awful thing about you writing stuff like this is that people might believe you.

ThinkingOfMe · 17/05/2024 08:39

5128gap · 17/05/2024 07:57

Well assuming you and the quoted poster are two different people, I wasnt talking to you. You're getting a lot of attention on here for sure, but just now and again we do speak to other people. Hope that's OK.

Yes, assuming they’re two different people. 🤔 I think someone is getting mixed up, it must be hard to keep track when you’re spouting crap from multiple accounts/usernames. No surprise there.

Irisginger · 17/05/2024 08:31

WalrusOfLove · 17/05/2024 07:30

Aside from the 1700 studies that in aggregate found that women perpetrate more DV.

Nobody is a winner here. I'm not rejoicing in glee at the prospect of my gender being significantly more violent than general opinion seems to believe. You just can't tackle a problem if you don't know the reality of it.

A small but very vocal cohort of women are pushing a narrative that the statistics seem to contradict and unfortunately (as with the trans lobby) it's been sucked up as truth, even if the majority of recent studies show that most women don't like this hateful agenda.

And more and more men/boys are deciding they've had enough and are turning to toxic role models like Andrew Tate, which is making things measurably worse for women. Sadly, it's not the women on here that take the brunt of it as many don't want to associate with men. It's younger women like myself that suffer for their actions.

Edited

No, you are struggling to connect with anyone here other than men here with you bizarre narrative, because you have run into reality. The near universal lived experience of women, which is a source of considerable solidarity between us, is that male aggression and sexual violence is widespread and pervasive and represents a very significant threat to our safety and wellbeing. If it is not us who has been beaten or raped it is our mother, our sister, our daughter, our best friend or the woman we sit opposite at work. Women are terrorised by men-it affects us all and many men are involved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread