Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people living longer is making quality of life for everyone worse?

640 replies

Futurascope · 14/05/2024 22:04

Possibly controversial…,

https://www.itv.com/news/2024-05-14/one-in-three-councils-not-confident-they-can-provide-basic-adult-social-care

“The fears about meeting the legal requirements come despite eight out of 10 councils forecasting having to cut spending on other community services such as parks, libraries and leisure centres to try to protect funding”.

So - libraries, leisure centres, parks, all vital for young children, families and others - being closed because the elderly desperately need social care.

As awful as it is for us all individually to lose somebody that we love….. is curing every disease, and having us all live to 100 really a good thing if it is at the expense of quality of life for the rest of society?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
TonTonMacoute · 16/05/2024 18:03

YourPithyLilacSheep · 16/05/2024 17:59

I pretty sure @Pedallleur knows exactly that. I suspect that was her point. And I agree with her.

The Nazi "Final Solution" was to kill all the Jews - a way of controlling events by applying a hateful criterion. Using age is pretty similar - an arbitrary criterion for getting rid of human beings who you regard as in the way - in this case, old people who are in the way of @Futurascope 's DD being able to buy a house.

It's chilling.

The Nazis also killed disabled people, homosexuals, gipsies and many other groups of people they regarded as being undesirable in some way.

YourPithyLilacSheep · 16/05/2024 18:02

vivainsomnia · 16/05/2024 08:25

we get people at 75 or 80 making the kinds of decisions that people at 20 might make
Or the decisions that those 20 years old will likely make for themselves when they reach 75.

When we are young, we can't picture ourselves getting to our 50s let alone our 70s and 80s.

We assume that by then, just like our body and brain slow down, so do our feelings and emotions.

Well a lesson for the youngsters: they don't! You feel just as strongly as you do when you are young. Your wish to live and keep going, your fear of dying and death and wanting to avoid it as much as possible, it's all there.

I think a lot of posters might think back about what they wrote here when they reach that age and feel very ashamed of their 'younger times' views.

Absolutely!

They have a lot to learn, as I did when I was 25.

YourPithyLilacSheep · 16/05/2024 17:59

Rosscameasdoody · 16/05/2024 17:43

You do know that Final Solution is Nazi language don’t you ?

I pretty sure @Pedallleur knows exactly that. I suspect that was her point. And I agree with her.

The Nazi "Final Solution" was to kill all the Jews - a way of controlling events by applying a hateful criterion. Using age is pretty similar - an arbitrary criterion for getting rid of human beings who you regard as in the way - in this case, old people who are in the way of @Futurascope 's DD being able to buy a house.

It's chilling.

TonTonMacoute · 16/05/2024 17:59

The elderly are not the only 'drain on resources'. There are a lot of people in society that are economically inactive and need looking after, as well as the elderly. It's a major problem for a modern developed society.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/05/2024 17:48

vivainsomnia · 16/05/2024 08:25

we get people at 75 or 80 making the kinds of decisions that people at 20 might make
Or the decisions that those 20 years old will likely make for themselves when they reach 75.

When we are young, we can't picture ourselves getting to our 50s let alone our 70s and 80s.

We assume that by then, just like our body and brain slow down, so do our feelings and emotions.

Well a lesson for the youngsters: they don't! You feel just as strongly as you do when you are young. Your wish to live and keep going, your fear of dying and death and wanting to avoid it as much as possible, it's all there.

I think a lot of posters might think back about what they wrote here when they reach that age and feel very ashamed of their 'younger times' views.

This. One hundred percent. Well said.

ShyPoet · 16/05/2024 17:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/05/2024 17:43

Pedallleur · 16/05/2024 14:28

perhaps we just need a 'Final Solution'? There is a template for it but for those who want to try it I'll suggest you and all your family can be the test subjects

You do know that Final Solution is Nazi language don’t you ?

dandelionseverywhere · 16/05/2024 15:39

Rosscameasdoody · 15/05/2024 21:01

In practice I don’t think this happens very often given the number of people I know who have a DNR placed on their hospital notes by medical staff, because of multiple co morbidities and the fact that resuscitation will result in little or no quality of life.

Edited

This happens all the time and one of the things I objected to when I was nursing. Sometimes they'd return from hospital with a DNAR, but often they didn't and the cycle would continue.

YourPithyLilacSheep · 16/05/2024 14:34

Pedallleur · 16/05/2024 14:28

perhaps we just need a 'Final Solution'? There is a template for it but for those who want to try it I'll suggest you and all your family can be the test subjects

Indeed.

WearyAuldWumman · 16/05/2024 14:31

MrTiddlesTheCat · 16/05/2024 11:38

Some younger people don't seem to realise that when they are older they will still be the same person inside. Your body may be failing but the essence of who you are remains the same.

I still want to ride the rollercoasters at Alton Towers even if my body screams in terror at the thought of the 4 hour car journey to get there let alone the whiplash from the ride. I still want to be picked to be Mary in the nativity play. I still want my mum to bring me chicken soup and luncheon meat sandwiches when I 'm sick. And I still haven't decided what I want to be when I grow up.

Edited

That about covers it!

Againname · 16/05/2024 14:29

They’re not a skint cohort. Some might be - but less than other groups by a long way.

I really need to get on with work and also don't want to take over this thread, so just one more thing.

Within any group (age, or whatever other unhelpful and unfair generalisation) the ones with less do matter, and need and deserve empathy and support.

Their needs shouldn't be ignored just because others in their designated group (age or whatever) might not have those needs.

One of the reasons why pensioner poverty is a growing problem is precisely because of the lumping together of people by age, who are in varied social and financial circumstances. Limited help or concern for them, because 'lots are ok'. So the ones who aren't ok are ignored and forgotten.

Pedallleur · 16/05/2024 14:28

perhaps we just need a 'Final Solution'? There is a template for it but for those who want to try it I'll suggest you and all your family can be the test subjects

ShyPoet · 16/05/2024 14:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ShyPoet · 16/05/2024 14:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MooseBreath · 16/05/2024 14:19

I have two elderly relatives (89+) who aren't in the best of health, but aren't dying either. Their spouses have passed, their friends have all passed, and they spend every day in their care homes. They have both signed DNRs and have stated explicitly that they are ready to go.

As much as I love them and want them to be around forever, I wish there was a way to help them pass peacefully on their own terms, without waiting to die sick, in pain, or without their precious memories.

Againname · 16/05/2024 14:11

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 13:09

90% of pensioners own their home outright with no mortgage. They’re not a skint cohort. Some might be - but less than other groups by a long way.

I understand it's 80%, not 90%, and owning a home doesn't mean no poverty. Many need to sell to downsize and move away to free up cash See below

People aged 60-64 now have the highest relative poverty rate at 25%.

The report also details that the average annual income of the poorest 20% of retired individuals is below the minimum amount needed to live on.

This means that the country’s poorest retirees, including those solely reliant on the state pension, have an annual income estimated to leave just £41 for a weekly food shop and insufficient funds to run their own car or service their boiler.

The other thing is those who move away are mainly younger pensioners and people nearing retirement. There's growing poverty and more private renters in these groups. See below.

More than 4.6 million people 50 and older still having to pay off mortgages. No guarantee they'll eventually own outright. Life events like divorce, job loss, of illness, then can't afford mortgage payments...at an age when soon the only income will be a pension

The highest number of older people in rented accommodation ever (almost 2 million aged 50 and older).

More than one in three (37%) pensioners who rent homes privately are in poverty.

YourPithyLilacSheep · 16/05/2024 13:49

MrTiddlesTheCat · 16/05/2024 11:38

Some younger people don't seem to realise that when they are older they will still be the same person inside. Your body may be failing but the essence of who you are remains the same.

I still want to ride the rollercoasters at Alton Towers even if my body screams in terror at the thought of the 4 hour car journey to get there let alone the whiplash from the ride. I still want to be picked to be Mary in the nativity play. I still want my mum to bring me chicken soup and luncheon meat sandwiches when I 'm sick. And I still haven't decided what I want to be when I grow up.

Edited

Best & truest post in this horrible thread. Thanks @MrTiddlesTheCat for giving the younger posters some sense of the ageing process.

I can remember about 30 years ago, when I was in my early 30s, my grandmother (83) telling me that inside she was still 33 - it was when her beloved husband was still alive (he was shot down in WW2) and they lived a charmed life with great love. She didn't feel 83.

I'm coming to learn to understand what she meant - in my mid-60s I still feel I have much to accomplish. The other day I climbed a rope in the gym to the top. And there's still more to do.

We dismiss people because of how they look on the outside at our peril and to our detriment.

tillytoodles1 · 16/05/2024 13:26

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 13:10

No they don’t - they threw the people off a cliff as a human sacrifice which happened once every 100 years (or something)

It's not. People have to throw themselves off the cliff when they're 75 so they don't become a burden on Society. The sacrifice is at the end of the film.

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 13:10

tillytoodles1 · 16/05/2024 12:29

Has anyone seem Midsommar? When people reach 75 they have to throw themselves off a cliff.

No they don’t - they threw the people off a cliff as a human sacrifice which happened once every 100 years (or something)

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 13:09

Againname · 16/05/2024 12:54

I was on another thread where some posters wanted affordable housing in big cities like London to be only for keyworkers and people who 'need to be there'.

I imagine older people from those cities feel unwelcome and pressured to move away. Especially as (I think?) there's even an official scheme in London to 'relocate' retired social housing tenants to rural areas.

My previous posts on this thread point out many pensioners are in poverty, and many don't own their home.

A significant minority of older people are private renting especially in big cities. Moving away could be their only chance to buy, or to simply continue affording the rent when on a state pension.

Most older people who move away from cities don't buy big houses. Lots, probably most, downsize. They sometimes opt for somewhere less urban, because the more affordable housing in urban areas tends to be tiny flats not designed for older people especially those with mobility needs.

There's been funding cuts to public services across the country. Sometimes support in cities is worse than rural areas, as support schemes there often focus on the young.

Also in cities, many older people's kids have had to move away (due to unaffordable housing). So the issue you mention, of lack of social contact, care including help getting to doctors, and isolation is a problem in big cities too.

Sometimes it's worse, especially as there's less informal community support in large cities because of more transient populations.

90% of pensioners own their home outright with no mortgage. They’re not a skint cohort. Some might be - but less than other groups by a long way.

Againname · 16/05/2024 12:54

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 11:55

The elderly culture in this country really doesn’t help either. People seem to want to retire in large rural homes - their right of course, but it means they increasingly struggle with their house/stairs/garden and live ages away from doctors, shops and useful services. They end up sort of retreating into their homes, living in a couple of rooms watching TV all day. Then the lack of social contact and movement means their health declines.

I was on another thread where some posters wanted affordable housing in big cities like London to be only for keyworkers and people who 'need to be there'.

I imagine older people from those cities feel unwelcome and pressured to move away. Especially as (I think?) there's even an official scheme in London to 'relocate' retired social housing tenants to rural areas.

My previous posts on this thread point out many pensioners are in poverty, and many don't own their home.

A significant minority of older people are private renting especially in big cities. Moving away could be their only chance to buy, or to simply continue affording the rent when on a state pension.

Most older people who move away from cities don't buy big houses. Lots, probably most, downsize. They sometimes opt for somewhere less urban, because the more affordable housing in urban areas tends to be tiny flats not designed for older people especially those with mobility needs.

There's been funding cuts to public services across the country. Sometimes support in cities is worse than rural areas, as support schemes there often focus on the young.

Also in cities, many older people's kids have had to move away (due to unaffordable housing). So the issue you mention, of lack of social contact, care including help getting to doctors, and isolation is a problem in big cities too.

Sometimes it's worse, especially as there's less informal community support in large cities because of more transient populations.

tillytoodles1 · 16/05/2024 12:29

Has anyone seem Midsommar? When people reach 75 they have to throw themselves off a cliff.

TorturedPoetsDepartmentAnthology · 16/05/2024 12:19

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 11:55

The elderly culture in this country really doesn’t help either. People seem to want to retire in large rural homes - their right of course, but it means they increasingly struggle with their house/stairs/garden and live ages away from doctors, shops and useful services. They end up sort of retreating into their homes, living in a couple of rooms watching TV all day. Then the lack of social contact and movement means their health declines.

Non rural areas have as much social care pressure as rural areas, so it’s not people flocking to large rural homes.

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 11:55

The elderly culture in this country really doesn’t help either. People seem to want to retire in large rural homes - their right of course, but it means they increasingly struggle with their house/stairs/garden and live ages away from doctors, shops and useful services. They end up sort of retreating into their homes, living in a couple of rooms watching TV all day. Then the lack of social contact and movement means their health declines.

FaeryRing · 16/05/2024 11:41

MrTiddlesTheCat · 16/05/2024 11:38

Some younger people don't seem to realise that when they are older they will still be the same person inside. Your body may be failing but the essence of who you are remains the same.

I still want to ride the rollercoasters at Alton Towers even if my body screams in terror at the thought of the 4 hour car journey to get there let alone the whiplash from the ride. I still want to be picked to be Mary in the nativity play. I still want my mum to bring me chicken soup and luncheon meat sandwiches when I 'm sick. And I still haven't decided what I want to be when I grow up.

Edited

?

Swipe left for the next trending thread