Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's smelly house

223 replies

failedthepsychopathtest · 14/05/2024 21:46

Over the last year or so I've become friendly with a woman who's doing the same college course as me. We're the only mature students and we hit it off as soon as we met. She has a great sense of humour and she and I have sparked some good work off each other. I know she smokes roll-ups, but at college and when she's visited me in my home she's smoked outside and it hasn't been an issue.

A couple of weeks ago she needed a lift home and asked me in for a cup of tea. The house was pretty stinky. The cat litter tray in the kitchen was overflowing and ponged, but the worst bit is that she and her partner both smoke heavily in the house. I found it really difficult to bear. I'm not someone who is keen on cleaning and my own home wouldn't bear close examination but hers is on a completely different level. I watched one of the cats walking around the work surfaces. The mug of tea she gave me was a bit crusty, IYKWIM.

They've invited me round for a meal in a couple of weeks' time and I'm really not sure I can face it. I think the smoke puts me off just as much as the lack of cleanliness. I'm not a princess: I don't need things to be dettoled and pristine. But this was beyond my comfort zone.

AIBU? Anyone else know what I'm talking about? What do I do? I've already suggested that if the weather's nice we go for dinner at a nice tapas place nearby, but she said she can do better tapas at home.

OP posts:
RoseUnder · 15/05/2024 11:10

Abitlosttoday · 14/05/2024 21:52

Grim. I'm an ex-smoker and I couldn't cope with that. Tell her kindly that the smoke makes you wheezy, and you don't want to ask her and her partner to change their behaviour at home on your behalf, so you'd prefer to go out. Spares her feelings a bit. Although, be aware that some smokers like to socialise at home to save the inconvenience of constantly popping outside a restaurant for a tab.

This - it's fair and respectfully worded, but honest - important and kind to be truthful about the smoke.

I'd be feel the same, I couldn't bear to spend a minute breathing in the smoke smell (and I'm an ex smoker as well)

shearwater2 · 15/05/2024 11:08

I would say the smoke smell had triggered my asthma- not that far fetched as the smell of smoke on people's clothes has made me cough!

Okaaaay · 15/05/2024 11:05

Yuk no - I have a very low tolerance for dirty and smells and would go with the cat allergy.

GracefulGrandma · 15/05/2024 11:03

It would put me off. We once went to pick up a bed frame from FB marketplace place and the stench in the house of the seller was indescribable and so overpowering. We left the bed frame and went and bought one from IKEA instead 🤣

the80sweregreat · 15/05/2024 10:51

I'd go down the allergy route myself as advised on here ( I do actually have one to cats and any kind of smoke, it a fairly common allergy to have )

PrincessHoneysuckle · 15/05/2024 10:47

"Hi Susan I need to be honest with you.Im allergic to cats.I thought I'd be ok when we nipped in at urs but I really suffered with symptoms afterwards" Can we meet up elsewhere?

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 15/05/2024 10:39

Wimpeyspread · 15/05/2024 10:05

You may find he goes outside more when he gets more settled - my newest cat took about 6 months to feel safe toileting outside

I hope so! He’s utterly charming but a right little stinker (don’t worry OP, we clean the trays immediately he goes).

Offcom · 15/05/2024 10:37

It's really hard! Could you say you didn't want to mention it before, but other members of your household (if there are any) commented on your smoky smell when you got home?

Otherwise a recent friend/relative's lung disease diagnosis has made you anxious?

YesMam1 · 15/05/2024 10:33

Cat allergy is the only way 😂

The problem with blaming the smoke is she can easily say they'll just smoke outside that day and then you'll be really stuck! "Oh and errm, er I also have a cat allergy...." She'll see right through you and know somethings up.

With the cat allergy make a point that some cats seem to affect you more than others. That way if you are around cats together in the future you're covered.

Peppermintytea · 15/05/2024 10:28

Or worse... they'll spray air freshner from a can over the top of the smoke and cat poo.

Peppermintytea · 15/05/2024 10:28

Cat allergy is the way forward. If you mention the smoke they'll just say 'Oh we'll wipe everything down and smoke outside the day before' or something like that because they don't understand that it's in every pore of their house.

CaribouCarafe · 15/05/2024 10:26

I think you can just be honest about the smell of smoke being an issue for you, most smokers understand that. And then offer to host her instead and you can cook together?

It's a tricky one, but I do think if you're hosting guests then it's your responsibility to ensure that they can be comfortable in your home...and that does include minimum standards of cleanliness.

Cyanobacterium · 15/05/2024 10:22

That's way too wordy, gives itself away as a lie immediately.

No that's not how that works. How she explains just needs to fit in with how she usually talks.

pontipinemum · 15/05/2024 10:22

PanicAttax · 15/05/2024 10:07

Ah OK, I miss read you response, sorry.

OP just say you have an allergy to smoke and cats.

Double whammy on the stink-o-meter!

I prob didn't word it very well. So easy for meaning to get lost in text.

babyproblems · 15/05/2024 10:14

Agree a cat allergy is a good idea! You could go out for lunch or dinner instead… YANBU. My next door neighbours house is like this. I even posted a thread on it a year ago or so and everyone said maybe she was smoking weed!! But no it’s cat litter and poor hygiene standards.

PanicAttax · 15/05/2024 10:07

pontipinemum · 15/05/2024 10:03

I'm saying they do go nose blind. My DH cannot smell smoke off himself at all. If I say it he is surprised or thinks I am making it up to nag him. Genuinely I don't think he can smell it off himself.

Ah OK, I miss read you response, sorry.

OP just say you have an allergy to smoke and cats.

Double whammy on the stink-o-meter!

Wimpeyspread · 15/05/2024 10:05

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 15/05/2024 10:00

Our previous cat never ever used a litter tray - even in a foot of snow she would toilet outside although we always had two trays in the house. We lost her to lymphoma this year and recently adopted a wee ginger guy from Cats Protection. Even though he can and does go out, he prefers to use the litter tray. I think some cats feel safer because they are vulnerable when toileting. I hate it but thankfully he tends to poo during the night so it can be cleaned first thing.

I’m an ex smoker - although always went out, never in the house - and I think it is now considered so anti-social that someone saying they are bothered by smoke indoors wouldn’t be unusual.

You may find he goes outside more when he gets more settled - my newest cat took about 6 months to feel safe toileting outside

Noshowlomo · 15/05/2024 10:03

Cat allergies definitely!

pontipinemum · 15/05/2024 10:03

PanicAttax · 15/05/2024 09:57

That is exactly my point though? Smokers don't go nose blind to smoke. I have met people with cats who stink to high heaven but can't smell it at all.

I'm saying they do go nose blind. My DH cannot smell smoke off himself at all. If I say it he is surprised or thinks I am making it up to nag him. Genuinely I don't think he can smell it off himself.

OvalLemon · 15/05/2024 10:02

This! Definitely this. If she asks why you weren’t allergic last time saw you took a bucket load of antihistamine but they knocked you out so you can’t do that anymore. Definitely don’t eat there surrounded my cat litter, you could get seriously sick. Or play the smoke/hayfever/asthma card… say you had an asthma attack or something when you got home.

AntiHop · 15/05/2024 10:00

I had a similar situation and I stepped away from the friendship. Our daughters were friendly. They invited us round. The house was disgustingly dirty. I couldn't face ever going there again, it was that bad. So I stopped pursuing the friendship.

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 15/05/2024 10:00

Our previous cat never ever used a litter tray - even in a foot of snow she would toilet outside although we always had two trays in the house. We lost her to lymphoma this year and recently adopted a wee ginger guy from Cats Protection. Even though he can and does go out, he prefers to use the litter tray. I think some cats feel safer because they are vulnerable when toileting. I hate it but thankfully he tends to poo during the night so it can be cleaned first thing.

I’m an ex smoker - although always went out, never in the house - and I think it is now considered so anti-social that someone saying they are bothered by smoke indoors wouldn’t be unusual.

TheNoonBell · 15/05/2024 09:59

I have a friend who is similar, cat poo just lying around on the lounge carpet, piles of rubbish everywhere and a crunchy kitchen floor etc. The place reeks. She just refuses to clean anything, just sits on the PC smoking weed all day. I really feel sorry for those in the neighbouring flats.

I visit to check she is still alive/in good health every so often but always take my own prepack sandwiches and a can of drink. Never accept a cuppa, glass, food or use the disgusting toilet.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 15/05/2024 09:57

Anotherview · 15/05/2024 06:58

Just be honest with her and tell her that your friendship with her is based on what her house looks/smells like - rather than the quality of person she is. I mean I'm SURE she will understand - Especially if you show her this thread where you talk about her home and habits with strangers on the internet - like if she cant see what a great friend you are from that? then is she really worth being friends with in the first place?
Like really!!! how RUDE of her to live her OWN life in her OWN home and not consider YOU in that equation!!!!! I mean really when she met you she should have started smoking outside and got rid of her beloved pet cat just to accommodate YOUR standards!! - if she didn't? then can you really call her a friend at all???
How inconsiderate of her to extend a welcome into her home to you! To feel so comfortable with you that she let you into her world - then NOT change her entire homelife to suit you!!
Maybe you could stage an intervention to explain how her home standards dont meet yours and how this hurts you so badly - then she might give up smoking or possibly even redecorate her entire house to suit your needs?

YES this whole post is sarcasm - why? because this post to me is absolutely ridiculous - Ok - so when she comes to your house - do you allow her to smoke inside? of course not - and I would guess that she doesn't try to.
She doesn't smoke in your home because its your home and she accepts how you live - it probably doesn't make her feel comfortable because its not what she does at home - its not what SHES used to - but she accepts its YOUR home right?
So why do you want her to change how she lives for you? that's HER home, where SHE should feel comfortable and you should accept how she lives - just like she does in your home by NOT smoking.

Another thing to consider is - do you have ANY idea how many of us mums out here DONT HAVE A FRIEND AT ALL????
Some of us are single mums or have disabled kids or difficult situations or might just be overwhelmed with their life and don't get to meet and people and would LOVE to have a friend. ANY friend!!! Regardless of what their house smells like - as long as they're a good friend - does it matter?
How bout you accept her for who she is - consider the quality of her friendship rather than the quality of her housework and stop trying to change her - then just be her friend? - providing of course she still WANTS to be your friend - I'm not so sure I would want to be if I were her.

I'm sorry you don't have any friends, I don't either. Maybe your house stinks.

Whether you agree or not, people don't want to spend time in unpleasant environments, and don't have the capacity to hold their breath indefinitely.

You sound hopelessly naïve if you really think that cleanliness should be overlooked in the name of being "nice".

PanicAttax · 15/05/2024 09:57

pontipinemum · 15/05/2024 09:53

You'd be surprised. I haven't smoked for years and we never smoked in our house only outside. But I never really smelt smoke from me/ DH. Now I can smell if he's had one an hour before coming home.

But most smokers are very open to being told people don't like the smell of smoke and don't get offended by it.

That is exactly my point though? Smokers don't go nose blind to smoke. I have met people with cats who stink to high heaven but can't smell it at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread