Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Ridiculous" to expect cutlery and crockery to be clean

39 replies

SisMichael · 14/05/2024 11:35

Hi Forum,

Newbie here (2nd thread ever). Sorry to post something that might be trivial!

MumsNet is a broad church so I think I the answer to this one will put me right one way or the other.

I am not the tidiest person but I insist on clean (I know many will say these 2 go together and I can't disagree).

Mum lives with me and I care for her - she has a few medical conditions which means clean is actually critical for us.

Family member has just called me ridiculous for insisting on cutlery, crockery and pans being truly clean after dishwashing - sadly, we don't have a dishwasher due to space.

He says this because I spend time re-washing pans with dried on carrot and broccoli, cutlery with small specks of food dried on, dishes still smelling of salmon, teaspoons with the remnants of the tea or coffee they have been used to stir (there are other examples) all after he has washed them and they have dried.

I don't go looking for these things - I find them when putting away dry dishes/pots/cutlery because he does not do it (perhaps he might do it once in a week).

The implication in his words is that I am somehow abnormal for insisting on what I consider to be a basic level of clean. I am certainly not perfect, far from it in fact, but I thought this sort of thing was something all normal adults expect?

I am beginning to wonder if I am actually nuts!

Please tell me - AIBU???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
parakeet · 17/05/2024 19:40

I think a dishwasher will help you as things usually come out pretty clean. Yes, you have to scrape your plate very thoroughly beforehand but we don't actually rinse plates unless they're covered in thick sauce, and we generally don't have problems. If anyone starts getting too lazy and putting in plates with chunks of food on them, the dishwasher gets blocked up, which is a massive pain in the arse to sort out, so there's a big incentive not to let that happen.

In the meantime, have you tried offering him some food with a plate, knife and fork that have visible bits of old food stuck to them, to test if he really does think it doesn't matter?

IncompleteSenten · 17/05/2024 19:34

Keep a couple of dirty plates and serve his dinner off them then hand him a dirty fork.

It's ok after all. Isn't it? So how can he mind?

SisMichael · 17/05/2024 19:28

CoffeeBeansGalore - I have just spent this entire afternoon doing exactly that - consulting with various kitchen brands and their in-house designers to have a chat about what can be achieved. 1 or 2 showed promise so fingers crossed!

Abbyant - the bacteria/mould aspect is the bit that actually worries me most, especially because mum is on a medication that causes her to be immunosuppressed (she has Rheumatoid Arthritis). I have actually told him as plainly as that that this is what makes me re-wash things. He still thinks I am being over the top. If the kids are not old enough to make sure things are OK if I ever get ill like this, lord help me if it falls to my sibs 😐

Stormyweathr - good point, but I was hoping I could use the opportunity of the appliance being new to tell him (and perhaps show him in the product literature) that things should be rinsed before putting them in to the dishwasher. Might have a better chance getting the moon on a stick though....

TonTonMacoute - The first time I explained it to him (after watching him do it some 5 times or so), I suspect I had a look of 'are you crazy?' on my face as, like you, I thought this was a feature of being a normal well-adjusted adult even without the medical bits and bobs. But, no no, I am ridiculous for expecting dishes/cutlery/pots with absolutely zero evidence of food on them!

DecoratingDiva - What is even worse is that he has previously suggested that his friends and colleagues think I am a little much for expecting this apparently super-human standard of cleanliness. Not sure I believe him tbh.

OP posts:
DecoratingDiva · 17/05/2024 15:58

Is this for real? Who would consider pots & cutlery with bits of dried food on them clean?

Of course they are not clean

TonTonMacoute · 17/05/2024 13:12

Good grief, he sounds an utter slob! How disgusting. Even without the medical issue, anyone can get ill from food scraps left on plates and pans.

There are only two of us in our household and to be honest we rarely generate enough washing up to make a dishwasher viable. It's easy enough to wash up as you go along - and to do it properly.

Stormyweathr · 17/05/2024 12:58

SisMichael · 15/05/2024 17:48

CoffeeBeansGalore - You have no idea about the mental gymnastics I have been doing trying to wedge a slimline dishwasher in somewhere, even if it has to go on the sodding roof. I think you're right, he just does not care.

toomuchfaff - That is exactly how I see it. When I explain that a spoon that does not have any visible dried food on it might not actually be clean (in terms of bacteria etc) but that a spoon where there is actually visible dried food on it is DEFINITELY not clean, I am met with a blank look. Mindboggling.

Rec0veringAcademic - It is actually a brother I am referring to, well picked up. Tried to keep it vague in case he ever happens upon this thread and recognizes the situation and the way I write but, hey, it might actually help matters if he did. I have wondered if there is an element of guilt here but there needn't be because he actually does help out with her care in other ways that matters to mum and me (and I have told him before on more than one occasion how much I do value his input). The annoying thing is that, tiring though it may be, I actually don't mind re-washing things if it means they are actually clean and mum is kept safe (and away from the NHS at a time of NHS collapse) - what really gets on my wick is the comments suggesting that I am odd for not tolerating a bit of dried food on washed items!

KnitnNatterAuntie - What a gorgeous comment - thank you! You do what you have to for your folks I suppose and mum has been an absolutely gorgeous mum to us all our lives, we really were very lucky as we had a difficult childhood otherwise. Interestingly, mum is slightly immunosuppressed through medication she takes for one of her medical conditions which is why I keep an eagle eye on the cleanliness thing - I totally get your paranoia when your parents were on chemo (mum's situation is not quite as serious).

Encouraging responses, MumsNet, thank you!

Be wary you do still need to rinse things before putting them into a dishwasher otherwise you will have the same scenario

Abbyant · 17/05/2024 12:56

Not unreasonable it’s dried food which means it will harbour bacteria and mold if left uncleaned and given that it’s stuff that goes into our mouths or contains the food that will go into our mouths it’s certainly not unreasonable to expect them to be clean.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 15/05/2024 18:37

@SisMichael Is there anywhere near you that offers kitchen design?
I think years ago B&Q used to do it free of charge if you were looking at one of their kitchens. Someone who does it all the time may be able to come up with a solution.

SisMichael · 15/05/2024 17:48

CoffeeBeansGalore - You have no idea about the mental gymnastics I have been doing trying to wedge a slimline dishwasher in somewhere, even if it has to go on the sodding roof. I think you're right, he just does not care.

toomuchfaff - That is exactly how I see it. When I explain that a spoon that does not have any visible dried food on it might not actually be clean (in terms of bacteria etc) but that a spoon where there is actually visible dried food on it is DEFINITELY not clean, I am met with a blank look. Mindboggling.

Rec0veringAcademic - It is actually a brother I am referring to, well picked up. Tried to keep it vague in case he ever happens upon this thread and recognizes the situation and the way I write but, hey, it might actually help matters if he did. I have wondered if there is an element of guilt here but there needn't be because he actually does help out with her care in other ways that matters to mum and me (and I have told him before on more than one occasion how much I do value his input). The annoying thing is that, tiring though it may be, I actually don't mind re-washing things if it means they are actually clean and mum is kept safe (and away from the NHS at a time of NHS collapse) - what really gets on my wick is the comments suggesting that I am odd for not tolerating a bit of dried food on washed items!

KnitnNatterAuntie - What a gorgeous comment - thank you! You do what you have to for your folks I suppose and mum has been an absolutely gorgeous mum to us all our lives, we really were very lucky as we had a difficult childhood otherwise. Interestingly, mum is slightly immunosuppressed through medication she takes for one of her medical conditions which is why I keep an eagle eye on the cleanliness thing - I totally get your paranoia when your parents were on chemo (mum's situation is not quite as serious).

Encouraging responses, MumsNet, thank you!

OP posts:
KnitnNatterAuntie · 15/05/2024 06:44

You are not being unreasonable at all. When my parents were going through chemotherapy I was fairly paranoid about the washing up, work surfaces, light switches . . . anything that they might touch really!

Even in normal times I would expect the washing up to be done properly ~ we didn't have a dishwasher but it's quite normal, obviously, to return anything to the washing up bowl which has visible food on it.

If I was given dirty tableware and/or cutlery in a restaurant I would return it ~ why wouldn't we have the same standards at home?

Best wishes, OP ~ sounds like you are doing a fantastic job looking after your DM in difficult circumstances 💐

Rec0veringAcademic · 14/05/2024 18:29

You are not wrong, OP. Just a guess, but is this a brother or an uncle of yours, feeling a tad guilty about you doing all the caring? Their anger over your "perfectionism" may be projection.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 14/05/2024 18:25

Juggle the new kitchen & get a dishwasher. He just doesn't care.

WhenWillTheSunShineIWonder · 14/05/2024 18:13

He’s in the very small minority of the population I would think.

toomuchfaff · 14/05/2024 18:12

Next time he eats out, question whether he would be happy to receive a dirty plate, a dirty fork that had been in someone else's mouth. He may double down and say he wouldn't but that'd be a lie.

Mimilamore · 14/05/2024 17:06

I'd be exactly the same as you, if the job's worth doing, it's worth doing properly or just leave it. Hate half hearted washing up...

Midge75 · 14/05/2024 17:01

You could be me, writing about my husband. It drives me mad. I do all the cooking, and our agreement has always been that whoever cooks doesn't wash up. That means that with the pattern we've slipped into, he always washes up. But I have to re-wash at least half of it - and he also thinks I'm nit picking. I reckon his dishwashing habits are similar to your husband (?) - he fills the sink with hot water and washing up liquid and the sponge definitely touches everything but I'm not sure how much pressure he uses - and he very rarely rinses, which I never realised until recently, as I don't stand over him as he does it. It's infuriating when you go to the drawer and have to throw most of the cutlery back in the sink, or you're about to wash up, take the dishes out of the cupboard, only to find you have to wash them all again. I've run out of different ways to broach the subject without sounding like a nag. But I am going to have to, and it's going to have to be gently, but seriously - to make him realise this really means something to me and it makes me feel like he doesn't care. (Not to mention puts me off him!). Sounds like you've tried several times to explain too, so I'm not sure I have any words of wisdom, but certainly lots of support from me and you are definitely not being unreasonable.

PickAChew · 14/05/2024 14:57

Sounds like he went to the same school of washing up as my DH, @SisMichael . The dried on food and generally not smelling fresh is grim. If I'm really lucky, he hasn't rinsed the soap off, either 😖

SisMichael · 14/05/2024 14:48

WarshipRocinante - I have seen him washing things before and he does actually use the sponge and washing up liquid - he just doesn't really pay attention as he washes up. I think he thinks that if he's got some sort of washing up liquid on it and a sponge has touched the spoon or whatever, the job is done. He doesn't look at the spoon (or whatever) after he rinses to check that it is actually clean.

For instance, when he washes cutlery, he holds the stem of the spoon, washes the head, runs it under water, then puts it on the dish drainer. The idea that the stem of the spoon may also need washing does not occur to him.

When washing one of our stainless steel pots, he'll wash the inside (I have a photo of food bits still stuck on the inside after he washed a pot recently) but it does not occur to him that the outside might also need scrubbing, especially if the pan boiled over during cooking.

It really does blow my mind.

Everyone is correct - if I dare broach the subject (which I try to avoid because I don't get an adult response) he gets immediately defensive and flips it on me, telling me that I am actually the one in the wrong for getting upset about a little bit of food left on something - YUCK.

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 14/05/2024 14:39

@SisMichael You are absolutely right to be so careful.
Bacteria will thrive in old scraps left on stuff.

He’s gross and an appalling washer - upper

Stuff needs rinsing thoroughly after washing, too to wash the detergent off.

👍

SisMichael · 14/05/2024 14:36

Thanks for such speedy responses!

Honestly, I am at the point where I had begun to question whether it really was me as I have been made to feel as if my standards are ridiculously high. As an example of the sort of thing I mean, please see the pot lid I have uploaded below.

PercyJackson - I am not sure whether or not to be flattered by you thinking that I can mimic AI! Hilarious because I am not that great with tech at the best of times.....😆

Good idea about whether or not it's his eyesight - except for the fact that I am pretty sure he has better eyesight than me! He's pretty absent-minded, I just don't think he notices things he just doesn't think are important.

When I am then spotted re-washing things that are not clean, I am accused of micromanaging and undermining.

I can't seem to win either way. We are about to have the kitchen renovated and I have been trying really hard to work out a way to afford replumbing and reorganising the space just so I can wedge a slimline dishwasher in - am I fooling myself in thinking this would solve the problem (given some of the insightful posts above)?

Thanks all, it's such a relief to know I am not going mad. Have felt a bit gas-lit to be honest.

"Ridiculous" to expect cutlery and crockery to be clean
OP posts:
skyeisthelimit · 14/05/2024 14:17

YANBU. We have a small dishwasher, and if anything comes out dirty, it goes back in again. DD often puts dirty stuff in the drawer when putting away because she just doesn't notice it, and it really annoys me

Silvers11 · 14/05/2024 14:11

I presume this is your husband if it's in your home. As someone else said, possibly weaponised incompetence. Or just complete laziness, so the dishes don't get properly washed

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/05/2024 14:06

I'm never going to win Housekeeper of the Year but whoever they are, they're wrong. Any cutlery I see that's not washed properly goes around again in the washing up.

wintersgold · 14/05/2024 14:04

How horrible. You are completely justified here

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 14/05/2024 12:50

Oh yuk yuk yuk !