Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent taking teenage boy into women's changing room

268 replies

JohnnyLuLus · 12/05/2024 23:26

I need to preface this with this is not about transwomen. This is about parents.

I was swimming with my children today at a leisure club. The gym overlooks the pool.and my teens noticed a boy who looked about their age (13) in the gym. They asked if they could use the gym, but the rules are no under-16s. I explained that the boy was probably older than he looked. All fine. (I was somewhat disgusted by the fact he took off his top to run on the treadmill, but I recognise that's probably my issue).

Anyway, after our.swim my teen boys went off to get changed in the men's changing room, whilst my 11 year old daughter and I went into the ladies.

It's an open-plan changing room - no private space and who should walk in, but the teenage boy and his mother. She kind of ushered him nto the corner and he sat on a bench. I got my daughter to cover up and hurried her along, but she's 11 and autistic so some executive functioning issues, so inevitably was exposed - I stood between her and the boy's line of sight. As I was trying to get her to finish up, the mother came over and said , "is it okay if my little boy walks through". I said "no not really is it, and he shouldn't be in here, he's no little either".
She then said in a defensive voice "Well he's autistic, what am I supposed to do?" and then hurried him.out to the pool.

2/3 of my children are autistic, I get it's hard. But that shouldn't mean a teenage boy is in the open-plan women's changing area. The local leisure centres have family changing.

Being the weekend, the only staff on reception were young weekend staff, but I've left a message for the manager to get back to me tomorrow.

Aibu unreasonable for leaving a message saying we will revoke our membership if they don't make it very clear what their rules are around age limits to the opposite sex changing room?

OP posts:
JohnnyLuLus · 13/05/2024 20:19

YouJustDoYou · 13/05/2024 09:41

The right for a young girl to be able to get undressed/dressed in privacy away from older males shouldn't be trumped by said older males. If the teenager has additional needs, his needs should never trump the rights of a young girl to her privacy. The mother of the teenager needs to figure out a different way for him to get changed.

Also it is a leisure club with quite a few elderly members. I think they could find it quite distressing too.

OP posts:
PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 20:18

Prinnny · 13/05/2024 20:04

It was part of a discussion with a previous poster who was explaining her own autistic child’s cognitive ability as to why he wouldn’t be suitable to be left unattended but agreed that cognitive ability is irrelevant in regards to a male being in a female space…but thanks for your very helpful and thought provoking interjection 😃

Right, so she was pointing out (as she has repeatedly) that autism is a wide ranging syndrome that affects people differently, and that it is possible for the boy to be able to use a treadmill but not to change alone (as is the case for one of her sons)

… and your response was that he must be able to change alone because he can use a treadmill. And you think that was helpful and thought provoking?

JohnnyLuLus · 13/05/2024 20:12

CharlotteBog · 13/05/2024 09:37

There should always be a manager available when the facility is open.

There is a hotel manager, but not a leisure club manager on Sunday afternoons apparently. Also at this point my own autistic daughter was getting agitated and we needed to leave.

OP posts:
Prinnny · 13/05/2024 20:04

PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 19:45

It doesn’t give us any idea at all about his cognitive abilities.

his cognitive ability is irrelevant

Then why did you bring it up and make an uninformed sweeping statement about it?

It was part of a discussion with a previous poster who was explaining her own autistic child’s cognitive ability as to why he wouldn’t be suitable to be left unattended but agreed that cognitive ability is irrelevant in regards to a male being in a female space…but thanks for your very helpful and thought provoking interjection 😃

Swampsnake · 13/05/2024 20:02

My new neighbour insists on parking two of his vehicles (one a car and the other a truck he uses for his business) in the turning point in our cul de sac. Surely he can't be allowed to do this? We have to do 7 or 9 point turn before we can park our car, unless we reverse all the way down the street to get back out! 😡

Mouk · 13/05/2024 19:52

*avoid the dreaded hand dryers

FaeryRing · 13/05/2024 19:50

YANBU, autism doesn’t trump everything.

PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 19:45

Prinnny · 13/05/2024 19:29

Given that the OP states she saw him working out on the treadmill I think that gives us a pretty good idea but his cognitive ability is irrelevant he still doesn’t belong in the female changing rooms.

It doesn’t give us any idea at all about his cognitive abilities.

his cognitive ability is irrelevant

Then why did you bring it up and make an uninformed sweeping statement about it?

Mouk · 13/05/2024 19:42

sleepyscientist · 13/05/2024 19:26

Ask if you can use the disabled toilet to change? I would say your son's medical need for supervision trumps anyone not liking a young boy in the changing room. DS is 10 I still take him in the woman's toilet if I have any doubts about where we are. It's not about men being in a space it's about it being an enclosed space away from supervision regardless of gender.

Thank you. I will inquire whether or not they have a disabled toilet or changing room. We are new to his leisure club so not familiar with it.

As I say, when he turns 8. We'll abide by the changing room rule and his Dad can tag along and bring him into the male changing room. For my sons dignity and the privacy of females using the room.

When out and about, I will more often than not bring him into disabled toilets, mostly to the dreaded hand dryers.

Prinnny · 13/05/2024 19:29

PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 19:13

You have no idea what the boys cognitive ability is, or whether he was working out independently.

Edited

Given that the OP states she saw him working out on the treadmill I think that gives us a pretty good idea but his cognitive ability is irrelevant he still doesn’t belong in the female changing rooms.

sleepyscientist · 13/05/2024 19:26

Mouk · 13/05/2024 17:13

YANBU - Austism or not, he was too old to be in the female changing room.

I have a 7 year old autistic son. I'm a single mum but their dad is very involved in their lives. I took the kids swimming recently and noted that once boys reach the age of 8 they are no longer allowed to change in the female changing room.

When we arrived home, I spoke with their dad and said that he'll have to come with us next year when my son is 8 and he'll have to help our son get changed in the mens changing room.

Ex doesnt swim, has a phobia but is willing to come along and help our son.

Ask if you can use the disabled toilet to change? I would say your son's medical need for supervision trumps anyone not liking a young boy in the changing room. DS is 10 I still take him in the woman's toilet if I have any doubts about where we are. It's not about men being in a space it's about it being an enclosed space away from supervision regardless of gender.

x2boys · 13/05/2024 19:26

Prinnny · 13/05/2024 19:02

Well regardless of your sons disabilities he’s still a teenage boy who shouldn’t be in women’s spaces.

Given that this boy was working out independently in the gym prior to invading the women’s changing room I doubly he’s cognitively a toddler.

Yes I know that I have repeatedly said I would never take him in a female changing room ,I'm just explaining why some autistic teenagers are not able to care for themselves.

TomeTome · 13/05/2024 19:20

I don’t take my adult dependent autistic son into female changing rooms or toilets. It’s limiting but the facilities we have on offer are what’s on offer we don’t invade. Finding facilities he can use is much easier than finding toilets I can use while keeping him safe. Luckily I have a bladder of steel.

PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 19:13

Prinnny · 13/05/2024 19:02

Well regardless of your sons disabilities he’s still a teenage boy who shouldn’t be in women’s spaces.

Given that this boy was working out independently in the gym prior to invading the women’s changing room I doubly he’s cognitively a toddler.

You have no idea what the boys cognitive ability is, or whether he was working out independently.

Prinnny · 13/05/2024 19:02

x2boys · 13/05/2024 12:29

The child had autism it it is a huge spectrum i wouldn't take my son into a female changing room
But I can't leave him because although he's 14 cognitively he's around 2/3 I don't think he's my " ickle prince"
He's severely disabled and incredibly vulnerable ,we have no way of knowing how this boys autism impacts him.

Well regardless of your sons disabilities he’s still a teenage boy who shouldn’t be in women’s spaces.

Given that this boy was working out independently in the gym prior to invading the women’s changing room I doubly he’s cognitively a toddler.

PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 18:40

HugePresha · 13/05/2024 18:30

The whole "mental age Vs actual age" thing is a moot point as the male has still gone through puberty.
My brother is 30, he's more like a 5/6 year old. Very young minded (don't want to say immature but I'm sure you get my point) gets on amazingly with my 6yo as they find the same things hilarious. 😂 Absolutely amazing young man and I love him dearly.
However, he is a man not a child however you slice it. He has urges and feelings that he is unable to fully understand. To be blunt, he will get erections and does masturbate like any 30 year old male as he has been through puberty. Luckily my mum is amazing and has woked hard with him and he now understands that this is absolutely fine but it is private and he must only do it in the privacy of his own room. However some adults with learning difficulties may not understand and shouldn't be placed in a position where they may see things that cause this in public (naked women in general, I'm not saying children's bodies).

This was really awkward to write, I know what I mean in my head but its hard to word, I hope it's not offensive.

Not offensive! This is the sort of thing I meant earlier when I said for the boys/man’s safety they need to not be put in situations they don’t understand or where they might be misunderstood.

HugePresha · 13/05/2024 18:30

The whole "mental age Vs actual age" thing is a moot point as the male has still gone through puberty.
My brother is 30, he's more like a 5/6 year old. Very young minded (don't want to say immature but I'm sure you get my point) gets on amazingly with my 6yo as they find the same things hilarious. 😂 Absolutely amazing young man and I love him dearly.
However, he is a man not a child however you slice it. He has urges and feelings that he is unable to fully understand. To be blunt, he will get erections and does masturbate like any 30 year old male as he has been through puberty. Luckily my mum is amazing and has woked hard with him and he now understands that this is absolutely fine but it is private and he must only do it in the privacy of his own room. However some adults with learning difficulties may not understand and shouldn't be placed in a position where they may see things that cause this in public (naked women in general, I'm not saying children's bodies).

This was really awkward to write, I know what I mean in my head but its hard to word, I hope it's not offensive.

cansu · 13/05/2024 18:23

Your gym should provide disabled changing. Do they?

SprigatitoYouAndIKnow · 13/05/2024 18:18

LordSnot · 13/05/2024 17:50

If the choice is a) not go or b) bring men or older boys into a female changing room, then a it has to be. We can then write and complain and campaign, but in the meantime it isn't okay to choose b.

I haven't said anywhere that it is. My post before this stated that I go to a different town instead of the local leisure centre now due to this issue. Just that there wouldn't have been an issue at all if there had been provision for disabled people. That is what we should be outraged about.

SpidersAreShitheads · 13/05/2024 18:10

CormorantStrikesBack · 13/05/2024 17:35

You’re quite right @SpidersAreShitheads and it’s great that you’re so thoughtful. The real answer is there needs to be better facilities. I know our local leisure centre is a family changing village with individual locking floor to ceiling cubicles. Which is good. Though in an ideal world there would be that and also a female only changing room.

You're absolutely right, yes. Facilities are almost universally dire.

I have autistic twin teens, aged 14 and I'm now facing new challenges as they start to get older. In some ways it's actually harder now because when they were young, we could use child facilities without any issues. DD and DS have quite different challenges but both need a hell of a lot of support, DS especially. Neither would be able to use any facilities on their own.

I don't think the wider public realise how dire provisions are for disabled teens/adults who fall into this category. It's not that people don't care, I think people just assume the help/facilities are there. Until you live with it every day, you just don't realise how lacking everything is. I didn't have a clue until I had my DC.

And honestly, it's a case of being on the hoof and trying to come up with solutions when you hit an unexpected problem. I could write a very long list of the barriers we've hit when trying to do the simplest and most basic activities that we thought would be accessible! And definitely there have been many times when I've got things wrong...

Startingagainandagain · 13/05/2024 18:01

Nope, sorry, no teenage boy should ever have access to the female changing rooms.

I am surprised there isn't a disabled space that they could have used instead or a unisex or family space.

I would have reported this to the manager on duty.

A female/ladies changing room is a place where I would never expect to see any teen boys or men to walk in.

Disability does not change that.

G123456789 · 13/05/2024 17:59

I'm male 55 and I am learning to swim. The council pool has a unisex changing room with individual cubicles including larger family ones. Thankfully I have never seen any females of any ages "bits". You have to take your shoes off in entering and a mother had her daughter aged about 7 with her the other day and made her take her tights off at the shoe changing bench, I have never turned around so fast in my life!

No way at 13 should that boy be in there...the woman is just weird.

CormorantStrikesBack · 13/05/2024 17:51

Yes, very good points about their dignity as well.

i always think when i see the 11/12 yo boys in the women’s changing rooms at the gym they must be embarrassed as well.

LordSnot · 13/05/2024 17:50

SprigatitoYouAndIKnow · 13/05/2024 16:06

@Ereyraa @Sirzy @Februaryfeels
Quotes from just the first two pages of this thread.

If this gym doesn't provide a disabled or family changing room then they need to go elsewhere.
Worst case scenario, they may have to find another pool.
His mum needs to take him somewhere with family changing rooms or similar.
If he was able enough to be in the gym, he is able enough to get dressed in the men's or wait outside surely?
They need to go elsewhere if the changing facilities don’t work for them at this place.

People are having a good rant, but not looking at the drivers. One need does not cancel out the other and everybody benefits if we improve. Women and girls get their changing spaces. Families where the care giver and disabled person are opposite genders get to have a dignified space for the disabled person to have equal access. Posters here are absolutely just saying that disabled people need to go elsewhere.

If the choice is a) not go or b) bring men or older boys into a female changing room, then a it has to be. We can then write and complain and campaign, but in the meantime it isn't okay to choose b.

PodCastingPodCasters · 13/05/2024 17:45

Sirzy · 13/05/2024 17:36

As well as being about protecting female only spaces being just that it’s surely also about dignity for the disabled young person?

they may not understand the situation but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be treated with dignity and be allowed to change in the wrong changing area for them. To me it’s a basic of dignity and respecting the young person to protect their privacy.

by enforcing the female only spaces it is also reinforcing (within the ability of the individual to understand) the importance of respecting the boundaries of women.

Not just the boys dignity but also safety- I wouldn’t want my ds in a space with changing women in case someone shouted at him/thought he was staring at them/flashing at them/accused him of something- his movements and gaze are completely erratic.

Its better all round if that situation isn’t created.

Swipe left for the next trending thread