Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the level of state involvement many posters expect is bonkers?

987 replies

FaeryRing · 11/05/2024 11:47

It seems like there is nothing the state shouldn’t be responsible for any more! Feeding your kids, getting them to school, hiring ‘behaviour specialists’ for every classroom because parents don’t want to discipline their own children, giving you money towards virtually anything you ask for because it’s not fair you have to pay for anything yourself.. I find it absolutely wild and don’t think it’s at all realistic or representative of what most adults believe?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
ShyPoet · 14/05/2024 20:54

I remember a dentist coming into our school in the early seventies to check all children's teeth. A lot of things did used to happen that no longer happen.
In the very deprived areas in the early seventies, buses with mobile showers used to visit schools for the children who were dirty.

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 20:53

Thank you @Againname And @Giraffesandbottoms ❤️

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 20:48

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:23

At least he is not in her life anymore. I really hope things get better for her.

Me too he really was a piece of work! Thank you so much❤️i'm really proud of the woman she has become and she is a fantastic Mam to my beautiful Granddaughter

Againname · 14/05/2024 20:39

@JenniferBooth It's very important kids are supported as they don't choose to be born but it's also very wrong imo to penalise childfree and childless people. They deserve enough money to live on and decent homes too. It isn't even a choice for some people (a friend and her DH are struggling right now with fertility treatments and it's very tough on them) and even when it's a choice childfree people pay tax too.

JenniferBooth · 14/05/2024 20:30

started by Labour, introduced an effective subsidy for companies to pay workers lower wages

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 21:28
@Againname I was signing on in the 90s just before minimum wage came in and there were jobs paying £50 a WEEK. My rent then was £48 a week for a one bedroom flat. Nothing else available. If i had had a job paying that i would have had £2 left to pay for everything else except rent. No top up because "you dont have kids

A hell of a lot of gaslighting and rewriting of history going on here when the low wages were already there beforehand.
@usernamealreadytaken Going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you are too young to remember the Low Pay Unit or the abolition of it in the EARLY 90s which lead to the low pay (particularly for those without children) before working tax credit came in.

OneTC · 14/05/2024 20:29

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 20:11

Oh come on - I would disagree with that absolutely. It’s basically medical yes, which is why medical insurance covers most dental procedures.

and even if not, expecting teachers to pick up the slack on basic shit like that is embarrassing.

No you come on

Self care is personal development.

Regardless whether you accept the terminology, the pp above who said you just incorporate it as a daily activity for the class after lunch, everyone does it, not just the ones that need help. This is actually what happened at my school. The point is to catch the few that have been embarrassingly (agreed) failed by their parents.

I don't think there being such a simple backstop would encourage more hands off parenting, it would just help catch a few furry green teethed kids.

Also I meant it as much as an example of things that a government or authority can be involved in without overstepping. That opinion doesn't mean I think you specifically should spend the whole day with your hand in a kids mouth

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 20:27

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:23

At least he is not in her life anymore. I really hope things get better for her.

Same - all the best @ChishiyaBat

Againname · 14/05/2024 20:26

Would the toothbrushing school sessions need to everyday? I'm tired and probably being stupid and missing something but what about a one off school dental visit, perhaps with a follow up 6 months or a year later.

Dentist comes to school, does one class lesson on how to brush properly, then hands out a starter pack to take home (toothbrush, toothpaste, daily sticker chart or similar, to encourage the child to brush regularly).

When I was at primary school, we had someone come in once. I remember us all taking dissolving tablets that turned any plaque on the teeth pink. (I'd been taught to brush at home but I don't see the harm in a one off visit, to help kids whose parents for whatever reason haven't taught them at home).

@ChishiyaBat I'm sorry for your daughter's situation (and your granddaughter). It's very unfair and I hope the rules change. She's the victim in this situation and shouldn't be liable for his debt xx

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:23

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 20:15

She isn't really in the right frame of mind to do that right now to be honest. She pays £5 a month. I just hope that when he gets out of prison he becomes responsible for his own debt. Even the dwp said it was unfair, but the rules.

At least he is not in her life anymore. I really hope things get better for her.

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 20:15

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:09

It is really unfair that your daughter is having to pay off an overpayment caused by him.

Have you tried contacting your MP to see if they can persuade DWP to write the debt off given the circumstances? It would be worth a try.

She isn't really in the right frame of mind to do that right now to be honest. She pays £5 a month. I just hope that when he gets out of prison he becomes responsible for his own debt. Even the dwp said it was unfair, but the rules.

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:12

ArseholeCatIsABlackAndWhiteCat · 14/05/2024 20:06

Are you sure she got nothing?

No council housing?
No milk vouchers?
No family allowance (available in the 70's to unmarried mothers too)?

There was Supplementary Benefit too, for people on low incomes. And Family Income Supplement.

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 20:11

OneTC · 14/05/2024 19:45

Tooth brushing isn't only a medical consideration it's a social one. social development is definitely under the remit of pastoral care

Oh come on - I would disagree with that absolutely. It’s basically medical yes, which is why medical insurance covers most dental procedures.

and even if not, expecting teachers to pick up the slack on basic shit like that is embarrassing.

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 20:09

Samlewis96 · 14/05/2024 19:44

Well u wouldn't supervise tooth brushing individually surely. So after lunch ALL kids brush teeth while someone supervises. Done in 5 mins. .

I used to watch my kids brush their teeth at the same time

But that’s pointless. 7 and under an adult needs to be brushing the teeth themselves.

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:09

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 20:03

Well not technically no, but apparently he should have told uc. I'm assuming they would have got less uc because he was claiming carers. Now my poor daughter is stuck with his debt. While he's getting 3 meals a day in prison!

Edited to add she didn't know he was claiming carers allowance, the 1st she heard of it was when they started taking money off her uc! She tried fighting it, but they said because it was a joint claim she is liable. Which is unfair as he was financially abusing her!

Edited

It is really unfair that your daughter is having to pay off an overpayment caused by him.

Have you tried contacting your MP to see if they can persuade DWP to write the debt off given the circumstances? It would be worth a try.

ArseholeCatIsABlackAndWhiteCat · 14/05/2024 20:06

Rudicoolcat · 14/05/2024 16:50

The expectation from the entitled to be automatically be given council housing, subsidised childcare, free social care and a whole lot more is to me quite staggering.

I agree with other PP who can see that no government, whether it is Tory or Labour can pay for it all for everyone.

It seems knowledge about entitlements is clear but some refuse to acknowledge nor accept their responsibilities.

Very different from when I was growing up, one of three children, in a one parent family in the 70's. She budgeted, scrimped and saved. There was no real handouts from the government or anyone else for my mother except from her best friend and my grandparents.

But at school we did get the free (cold/tepid/warm/sour) milk...🥛🤮

Are you sure she got nothing?

No council housing?
No milk vouchers?
No family allowance (available in the 70's to unmarried mothers too)?

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 20:03

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:00

Ah, I just saw this. I thought he was claiming it for his daughter, which confused me.

So although he was clearly a complete scumbag, he wasn't doing anything wrong claiming Carer's Allowance?

Well not technically no, but apparently he should have told uc. I'm assuming they would have got less uc because he was claiming carers. Now my poor daughter is stuck with his debt. While he's getting 3 meals a day in prison!

Edited to add she didn't know he was claiming carers allowance, the 1st she heard of it was when they started taking money off her uc! She tried fighting it, but they said because it was a joint claim she is liable. Which is unfair as he was financially abusing her!

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 20:00

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 19:37

He was claiming it for looking after his father who had cancer nothing to with his daughter who thankfully he never really bothered with!

Ah, I just saw this. I thought he was claiming it for his daughter, which confused me.

So although he was clearly a complete scumbag, he wasn't doing anything wrong claiming Carer's Allowance?

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 19:58

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 19:55

By disability payment, do you mean DLA @ChishiyaBat ?

Yes it was dla.

IClaudine · 14/05/2024 19:55

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 10:41

But who decides who is genuine and who isn't? No one is having children to get benefits and housing I can assure you! My daughter is living on a bed setee in my 2bedroom house with my granddaughter in a cot in my bedroom, along with her brothers in the 2nd bedroom, she didn't choose this, she was abused in every way you can think of, then she found out when the police knocked the door tgat on tip of all her suffering he was a paedophile who is now thankfully in prison. He is allowed no contact with his children or anyone else's thank fuck. My point is she has been living with me for 14months despite being in the emergency housing bracket! Her and my granddaughter with cerebral palsy who has been denied disability payment, too young apparently, are living on £500 a month hardly milking the system is it?

By disability payment, do you mean DLA @ChishiyaBat ?

OneTC · 14/05/2024 19:45

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 19:26

Where is the time to brush the children’s teeth coming from? If you have a class of 30 and 15 need their teeth brushed for 2 mins 2 x a day that’s an hour of the day. Where’s that coming from?!

that’s setting aside the fact you think it’s under “pastoral care” which it most certainly isn’t.

Tooth brushing isn't only a medical consideration it's a social one. social development is definitely under the remit of pastoral care

Samlewis96 · 14/05/2024 19:44

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 19:26

Where is the time to brush the children’s teeth coming from? If you have a class of 30 and 15 need their teeth brushed for 2 mins 2 x a day that’s an hour of the day. Where’s that coming from?!

that’s setting aside the fact you think it’s under “pastoral care” which it most certainly isn’t.

Well u wouldn't supervise tooth brushing individually surely. So after lunch ALL kids brush teeth while someone supervises. Done in 5 mins. .

I used to watch my kids brush their teeth at the same time

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 19:42

Noras · 14/05/2024 19:22

Our Child Development and Neurodisability Team have expertise in the assessment, diagnosis and management of cerebral palsy. We work with children and their families from Sheffield and beyond to deliver therapy that maximises potential and minimises functional disability.
Cerebral palsy is an umbrella term used to describe a group of conditions that affect movement, posture and co-ordination. It can affect other areas of functioning as well including vision, hearing, speech and learning.
Children with cerebral palsy may have difficulties from birth or may have slow development of motor and other skills. A diagnosis may not be possible until the child is 2-3 years old depending on the individual child’s progress.
We have a range of specialists in our team, including specialist developmental and neurodisability consultants, physiotherapists, occupational therapists and speech and feeding therapists. We work closely with other specialists in the Trust to support children with cerebral palsy and offer a full service from birth to adolescence.

My daughter knew there was something not right from the start, but they kept saying she was paranoid as a 1st time mother. It was 18months before anyone took her seriously, but the diagnosis was relatively quick from there. She couldn't crawl and didn't walk until she was almost 2 and even now she can't walk any great distance, she kind of lurches when she walks and falls at least 10times a day. She does wear glasses, but is still waiting for a hearing test.

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 19:37

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 19:23

But was he technically entitled to it as the father of a disabled child, or did he actually need it, as it doesn’t sound like he did anything to support her?

there’s a big difference

@ShyPoet
i don’t know if that’s true, because I would need to look at all of the other countries and their systems and it’s quite hard from an outside perspective to even know where to start.

I don’t think it’s that black and white though. I agree that it’s a false economy cutting expenditure on support services and then paying people directly.

He was claiming it for looking after his father who had cancer nothing to with his daughter who thankfully he never really bothered with!

ChishiyaBat · 14/05/2024 19:33

Noras · 14/05/2024 19:21

How old is she exactly? Is she not under child development clinic?

No idea what a child development clinic is, but no she isn't she is almost 2 and a half. She has a consultant who we saw once prior to diagnosis last summer, then she was given an mri scan in October last year, a few weeks after the mri scan we had a video call to give us the diagnosis of cerebral palsy left sided hypotonia, left leg shortening with talipes. An eeg was given as we thought she was having absence seizures, but that wasn't the case the eeg result said mild periventricular leukomalaxia and asymmetry with focal slowing on the left occiput and sharp transients whatever the hell that means, no one has explained to us what any of this means She still spaces out ar least a few times a week, the lights are on, but no one is home it's so strange. Also the physical problems and sleep disturbances, but we have no idea what to expect now or in the future. We are just looking after the best we can.

Giraffesandbottoms · 14/05/2024 19:26

OneTC · 14/05/2024 18:51

I do think that the government gets into some weird parts of people's lives but some posters ITT are really sink or swim.

I mostly just think we should be able to smoke inside, take drugs and enjoy ribena.

I'm not about gutting the NHS or removing essential safety nets.

Govt can build roads, infrastructure etc. They should devolve health.

I think teaching kids essential life skills should probably be done at school, if kids aren't getting their teeth brushed then someone needs to help them do it, if their parents are failing them. Improving the lives of the youth benefits everyone. If you don't want to be involved in any pastoral care at all I wonder why you're a teacher.

Where is the time to brush the children’s teeth coming from? If you have a class of 30 and 15 need their teeth brushed for 2 mins 2 x a day that’s an hour of the day. Where’s that coming from?!

that’s setting aside the fact you think it’s under “pastoral care” which it most certainly isn’t.