Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that ex named his daughter like mine?

87 replies

Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 17:06

I really would love some opinion. Ex and I have 2 daughters, and are both from Latin America. We picked names that reflected our culture. The two girls are 14 and 11.

I have since remarried, for the past 7 years. I had a third baby girl. Her father is from East Africa, and she was named after her grandmother. She is now 4.

My ex had a baby girl a year ago with his girlfriend ( who is Spanish) , and they named her just like my daughter and MiL. It annoys me so much, I am having a hard time.

My 2 eldest refer to their siblings as "Little X and big X". I haven't said anything, but it really annoys me.

My husband is more relaxed , he finds it hilarious that a little white girl has that name. He hasn't shown any anger.

Albu, right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JadeandGreen · 08/05/2024 00:02

ShadesofPoachedSmoke · 07/05/2024 22:50

Well they are not Bio siblings are they.

OP and her new DH
Ex DH and his new GF

No bio link.

But there's a bio link with the first two daughters. They now have 2 little sisters with the same name!

Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 23:50

Eastcoastie · 07/05/2024 23:13

Im not clear if im following correctly but if you are saying you and ex both are both latin american and have 2 latin american named kids, you have since had a baby with an african man and the baby has an african name, you ex had another kid with a spanish lady and they have given the child an African name that is also the same name as your child then yes your ex is absolutely nuts.

I would say Aaliyah is somewhat common in the UK in that iv heard of it. If both parents were white id still think it was an odd choice but Buuxo/Guedid, iv never heard of in my life. Id be very surprised if a friend gave their child one of these names.

My ex and I are both from South America, his wife is Spanish, my new husband is African. So you got everything correct.

My two eldest have names that are common South America ( think names like Teresa , Ximena etc...)

Aaliyah is very pretty, but it is nowhere near as common. It is my husband's mother name.
He doesn't really care, doesn't want our girl's name being associated to something negative.

I can respect that, but I am still p*seed off. I guess I will just move on. Poor little girl will always be little X while mine is big X. That's how my other daughters refer to their 2 siblings.

OP posts:
Eastcoastie · 07/05/2024 23:13

Im not clear if im following correctly but if you are saying you and ex both are both latin american and have 2 latin american named kids, you have since had a baby with an african man and the baby has an african name, you ex had another kid with a spanish lady and they have given the child an African name that is also the same name as your child then yes your ex is absolutely nuts.

I would say Aaliyah is somewhat common in the UK in that iv heard of it. If both parents were white id still think it was an odd choice but Buuxo/Guedid, iv never heard of in my life. Id be very surprised if a friend gave their child one of these names.

ShadesofPoachedSmoke · 07/05/2024 22:50

GardenGnomeDefender · 07/05/2024 17:11

Two siblings or half siblings with the exact same name is unfair on the children. You want to at least have a unique name amongst your siblings.

In some countries they put known siblings on the birth certificate of younger siblings and this would be flagged up when they tried to register the birth and rejected by the registrar.

Well they are not Bio siblings are they.

OP and her new DH
Ex DH and his new GF

No bio link.

LadyHavelockVetinari · 07/05/2024 22:48

The people saying that the OP is racist are really missing the point. The point is that they (both the ex, her new DH and the OP herself) have always named their children with a name that reflects their own culture. Then out of the blue her ex names his daughter not only a name that has 0 relevance to his or his wife's culture but is from his ex's new husbnad's culture, but is the exact same name as his ex's new daughter.

I'm sorry but if my husband divorced me and remarried a Japanese woman, and I chose to call my new non-japanese daughter the exact same japanese name they had chosen...... then yes, that would obviously be pretty funny. Having a causasian Haruki and a Japanese Haruki in the same family, with the same sisters, is very funny.

LadyHavelockVetinari · 07/05/2024 22:39

Unhinged even if the name were Ava or Sophie. I wonder why on earth the wife went along with it??

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 07/05/2024 22:36

I think it’s ridiculous he chose it but I also think you sound racist OP.

Noseybookworm · 07/05/2024 22:25

Well it's definitely odd, I'm not sure I'd be angry, I'd just think it's wierd! Presumably his new partner knows you have a daughter with the same name? I would try and not let it bother you, he's nothing to do with you now and you're only hurting yourself by being angry. You should feel sorry for him, it's a bit pathetic really!

Kelly51 · 07/05/2024 22:12

It's very odd he's done this. I know 2 sisters, very close, who have sons with the same name, I find that odd too.

0wlQueen · 07/05/2024 21:22

His lack of imagination is embarrassing. Also, giving a Spanish/British child an African name is going to sign her up for a life time of explanations.
"No no never been there"
"No, um, my dad just liked it"
"Um yeh my half sisters' sister on their mum's side is called the same name ...."

Nuts

Kesio · 07/05/2024 21:17

This is seriously weird and selfish.

You have 2 kids with him
You have a littler one with someone else, a half sibling for your 2 kids.
Then he has a baby, also the half sibling of your 2 kids and calls the baby the same as their existing half sibling. Has he given even an ounce of consideration to the eldest 2??

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2024 21:17

Yes, I am bringing discrimination into it, because it might not be your reality, but it is of a lot people with distinctive name from a perceived place
But that's a totally different discussion. And if anything, the more common the name becomes, the less likely to become a reason for idiots to discriminate.

No I don't find it odd that a white girl could have a typical Swahili name just as I wouldn't find it odd for a Black girl to have a very old and standard Irish name.

Many pick names because they find them pretty or nice sounding regardless of the origin.

Again, it's not your feelings I question, I too would have been very bemused and annoyed. It's the unnecessary comment your husband made about the girl's race.

Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 21:11

@Createausername1970 He is a pathological liar, told his partner how crazy I am. I doubt he changed. I have never heard his partner complain to me , the girls never told me anything negative about her either.

I really don't know why she agreed.

OP posts:
tridento · 07/05/2024 21:10

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2024 17:14

Also, not sure about the 'white' girl with an African name highlight. Do names have skin colours?

Oh come on. Some names are very much of a culture. Calling a white girl Ki Soon Yu would be fucking weird.

tridento · 07/05/2024 21:09

Limberinta · 07/05/2024 17:14

He has called 2 of his daughters the exact same name?

No

Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 21:08

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2024 20:49

Who do you think would be more likely to be discriminated based on names : Ciara or Hashaan?
Oh so now you are bringing discrimination into it! What next?

I do find the action of your ex very odd, but I find the reference to the fact it's a white baby of bad taste and unnecessary.

Oh and according to Google, Amina is a Swahili name too, not just Arabic.

Yes, it is also a Somali, Persian, Malian, Afghan etc... too then. Come on.

Do you really not see the difference between a name like Aaliyah/Aisha/Imani and Buuxo/Guedid ?

Yes, I am bringing discrimination into it, because it might not be your reality, but it is of a lot people with distinctive name from a perceived place.

I will say it one more time, it is not an international/widely known name ( even if it was, it annoys me that their daughter is named like my 4yo).

Thanks. Good luck.

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 07/05/2024 20:55

Your ex is an idiot, but you probably knew that?
Of course he is not angry, he finds it hilarious and the fact that it pisses you off is a bonus.

That said, you have nothing to gain being angry about it and the name isn't going to change, so all you can do really is make peace with it somehow.

StormingNorman · 07/05/2024 20:52

MumblesParty · 07/05/2024 20:27

Does his new wife know that their daughter has the same name as his ex wife’s daughter?

It seems bizarre to me.
”darling, what shall we call our new baby daughter?”

”how about XXX(unusual name from a completely unrelated country/culture)?”

“what made you think of that name?”

”it’s what my ex wife has called her daughter”

”ah OK, that sounds prefect”

crazy!!!

She must have heard the 2 DD speak about their new sister.

I don’t think the new wife has much of a say.

StormingNorman · 07/05/2024 20:50

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2024 19:56

Well I looked it up. Dalila and Amina are Swahili it would seem. I wouldn't find it shocking to name white girls these.

Or maybe a couple from Uganda should never call their girl Ciara?

These Swahili names are really pretty. The odd bit is that he chose the same one.

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2024 20:49

Who do you think would be more likely to be discriminated based on names : Ciara or Hashaan?
Oh so now you are bringing discrimination into it! What next?

I do find the action of your ex very odd, but I find the reference to the fact it's a white baby of bad taste and unnecessary.

Oh and according to Google, Amina is a Swahili name too, not just Arabic.

BlueSlate0 · 07/05/2024 20:49

It’s really really weird. I feel bad for his new partner. I wonder what she makes of it? That he’s clearly still preoccupied by you.

I feel bad for the child as well, “little x”. They’ll find out soon enough from their siblings. I wonder what they will think of their name? Super odd.

Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 20:45

@Createausername1970 That is a good question. She is a quiet woman, never talks, I honestly never managed to get to know her properly.

OP posts:
Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 20:43

Deedeeee · 07/05/2024 20:40

Yes it’s weird but you clearly have great taste. Iniko is a gorgeous name (first time I’ve heard it).

Thank you so much.

OP posts:
marmiteoneverything · 07/05/2024 20:41

You’re not unreasonable to be upset. It’s weird. I imagine he potentially hadn’t ever heard the name until you called your youngest daughter it?

Even if he heard it (or his new wife did) and thought “that’s the most beautiful name I’ve ever heard!”, which they might well have done, you still just wouldn’t do it.

Spanishbydora · 07/05/2024 20:41

vivainsomnia · 07/05/2024 19:56

Well I looked it up. Dalila and Amina are Swahili it would seem. I wouldn't find it shocking to name white girls these.

Or maybe a couple from Uganda should never call their girl Ciara?

What are you on about ? Amina is an Arabic name ( Swahili is related to Arabic so not that shocking). Amina is a name used throughout the Islamic world too, from Niger to Indonesia.

Uganda is also a Christian country, plenty of Christophers or Mary ( and I know what you'll probably claim biblical name as "English"). CULTURE IS NOT RACE FFS. If that hypothetical Ugandan couple, name their baby after the husband's ex. Yeah they would be crazy.

Who do you think would be more likely to be discriminated based on names : Ciara or Hashaan?

Mohamed/Mohammad/Muhammed is an example of a trans-culture name. Binti is not.

OP posts: