Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD and her uncle...AIBU to feel uncomfortable?

415 replies

maay · 07/05/2024 00:35

My daughter is 12. In January her uncle started giving her guitar lessons as she really wanted to learn. He has been playing for years and sometimes teaches lessons, so when he offered to teach her for free, it was too good to turn down. The lessons are at our house. She's really been enjoying it. I still offer him money, but it's always a firm no.

He took her to see a band that they both like in March. His wife was also there. DD came back with loads of merch. I was thankful but told him he didn't need to do all of that! I felt like it was really cool they were bonding so well though. DH loved to see it as well.

He has bought her quite a few things now other than that merch. Like a necklace, posters, figurines, he even offered to buy her expensive trainers when she asked me for them in front of him. I said no to that one, because me and DH already decided she didn't need them. (girl has a lot.)

DH and I check her phone regularly. They text each other probably once or twice a week. It's brief and they just send each other memes and links to music they like. I haven't seen an actual conversation with them, so think I'm happy with that.

Yesterday he was at our house. We were all in the same room talking. DD went and sat on his lap and it made me feel uncomfortable. Only because she never sits on an adults lap anymore? I wasn't going to make a scene or anything, so I just made an excuse and asked her to come help me with something in a different room. When she went back into the room, she didn't sit on his lap again.

The same day, he dropped into conversation about how "Asian and half Asian girls are the most beautiful" he looked at DD and she giggled. DD is half Asian. I'm starting to feel a bit uncomfortable with it all. But I'm not sure if I'm being unreasonable? I don't want to break an innocent bond, but I feel like I missed some red flags and I'm now seeing them? DH says he just loves his niece and he doesn't think we have to worry.

OP posts:
SluggyMuggy · 07/05/2024 15:01

Just to add, I know it is tempting to minimise this and see it as nothing really to be worried about. The fact you said nothing at the time about your DD sitting on his lap suggests you avoid confrontation.
But your DD needs you to strong and put a stop to this. I agree with another poster that your DD may have sat on his lap in front of you because he has encouraged her to do this when they are alone - but she feels a bit uncomfortable, so was checking out whether you and your DH thought this was fine.
Children often can not find the words to tell us what they are feeling or thinking. She might have thought that if she said to you she was uncomfortable about sitting on his lap when they were alone, you would ask why, and she would not be able to explain why.
We can not rely on children telling us when they feel uncomfortable about something with words. They do often tell us through their actions.

SenQuestion · 07/05/2024 15:00

Many red flags. Trust your gut instinct

anothermnuser123 · 07/05/2024 14:59

The more you post, the more alarm bells are ringing. You cannot leave your DD alone with him.

I worry for all the people excusing it as a crush or a cool uncle, there are major red flags here and its worrying that there is anyone these days, with the knowledge available, that wouldnt at the very least put some safeguarding in place.

newyear2024 · 07/05/2024 14:58

Honestly this is the second post I've read today on mumsnet where women are standing by like gittery wallflowers while their daughters are in strange/uncomfortable/unusual positions, with males in their family. Bloody stand up and say something there and then, speak your mind, show your daughters when something is weird or inappropriate! And stop letting men be alone with your daughters if your gut instincts are telling you otherwise.

maay · 07/05/2024 14:55

JFDIYOLO · 07/05/2024 14:11

She has probably reached the right age for his interest to be sparked.

You say he's your step brother.
What are your ages? Is there a difference between his and your age?
How old were you when your parents got together?
You say you were close - do you remember anything yourself from back then?
As in - does he have a habit?

He's 32 and I'm 33. Our parents got together when we were 12 and 13. I lived with him ages 15-20. He was nice and normal, never did anything weird with me or anyone that I know of.

I understand about the Anime thing. Adult males into Anime never sits quite right with me. But with him I used to put it down to a "geeky side." DH also finds it weird adults are into it, but he has a very trusting personality and is less likely to see red flags, so he also puts it down as geeky and harmless. I still think it can be, but it's another factor to consider in this situation.

OP posts:
newyear2024 · 07/05/2024 14:51

What was his reaction when she sat on his lap? I know my husband would have leapt of the chair or visibly being uncomfortable and stood up. But if my daughter did this in front of me my first reaction would be 'what are you doing' I would have verbally asked both of them and told them it was weird, but then I am up front and say things as they are happening, rather than go away and think about it from all angles

JamTartLover · 07/05/2024 14:44

If a child came and sat on my lap for the first time, I would be really shocked and ask them to sit elsewhere, especially if they weren't biologically related. Even if I had to be 'polite', I would at least shift in my seat.

I doubt this is the first time she's sat on his lap.

zanahoria · 07/05/2024 14:44

" he even offered to buy her expensive trainers when she asked me for them in front of him. I said no to that one, because me and DH already decided she didn't need them. "

He is really crossing a line there - showing off in front of your daughter. It just seem wrong to openly offer to pay for something for a child when their parent has said no.

If he was really a nice guy he would have respectfully asked you away from your daughter's ears.

SluggyMuggy · 07/05/2024 14:38

And groomers rely on naive parents such as the ones on here saying she just has a crush, or he is just trying to be cool Uncle.

SluggyMuggy · 07/05/2024 14:35

I agree that post from OP paints things worse.

The reality: Uncle is friendly and buys Xmas and birthday presents but does not see a lot of OPs family. But them DD turns 12.

  • Uncle offers free guitar lessons. He gets to give these guitar lessons in a room where it is just him and DD
  • Uncle starts buying lots of presents for DD that are accepted.
  • Uncle starts spending much more time at the family home, offering to do things to help out so he can spend time there.
  • Uncle has 12 year old DDs phone number and can privately message her.
  • Uncle is allowed to take DD to a concert with his wife there, and showers her with presents.
  • Uncle is sitting in living room with parents when 12 year old DD comes and sits on her lap. Her parents say nothing about this, but mum does say to DD come and help me with something.
  • Uncle says in front of parents that "Asian and half Asian girls are the most beautiful" he looked at DD and she giggled.

Honestly this is grooming 101. This is exactly how grooming happens. You need to react strongly to this OP. Your DD is old enough to sneak off and meet the uncle secretly. You need to warn off Uncle so that he will be too worried to come near DD.

Eviebeans · 07/05/2024 14:33

I recently watched a programme about Danielle Jones - your post made me think of it again

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 07/05/2024 14:33

You should have told her to get off his knee and that’s she’s too big to be sitting on knees . Then you could have judged everyone’s reactions. If she doesn’t sit on parents knees then you need to speak to her and say it’s not appropriate at that age as she goes from
being a child to a teen boundaries change.

Pookerrod · 07/05/2024 14:31

OP, your most recent update makes it worse.

White male into anime making comments about half Asian girls being beautiful sounds like he is fetishising your 12 year old daughter.

I think you need to be very direct with him. Tell him you find the “bond” he is developing with her inappropriate. Tell him no more guitar lessons and no more contacting her phone. Tell him you found it disturbing he let her sit on his lap and his comments about beautiful races disgusting.

It doesn’t matter if he is offended. The way he has behaved is wrong. You know that, we all know that.

Richard1985 · 07/05/2024 14:27

maay · 07/05/2024 14:06

Thanks for the replies everyone. I won't be just ignoring it and will be having a chat with DD. It's hard to tell if it's a "cool uncle" situation or something bad. So need to feel things out in a way that isn't going to scar her but will protect her. To answer a few questions and comments...

A crush is possible. He is 32 and conventionally attractive. Dresses trendy etc. However she rarely mentions crushes, but when she does they are boys (like teenagers max) that are celebs or influencers.

When he made the Asian girls comment, I replied with "all races are beautiful" as "a most beautiful race" isn't a message I want her to learn. The only reason I mentioned race here is because of his comment on her looks. He's white and follows a lot of Anime stuff. Which can be innocent, but it can be problematic...if you know, you know. I'm white, so not bashing all white men or anything.

The guitar lessons are in a different room. The "middle room." DH and I usually leave them to it in there. I won't be allowing lessons without being in the room anymore.

Before the lessons, their relationship was different. They still got on well, he bought her something nice for birthdays and holidays. He didn't buy her stuff in between though and he wouldn't have randomly invited her out (the band.) He's also been spending more time here in general. Offering to do nice things for me and DH to help us out. That wouldn't have happened before, unless there was a rare specific reason.

DD also talks about him a lot..."uncle loves this song, uncle said red grapes are better than green, so I want them instead. Uncle would find this funny". Stuff of that nature.

this post has made things seem a lot worse. He's grooming the whole family!

potato57 · 07/05/2024 14:26

I often think mumsnet gets hysterical over nothing but this isn't one of those times.

It is not normal for a 32 year old man to behave this way. It is not normal for a 32 year old man to want a 12 year old girl to sit on his lap.

And the idea that they're good friends - what 32 year old man wants to be friends with a 12 year old girl?

A lot of men that age don't even like their own kids, let alone other people's.

And the guitar lessons are giving me Cruel Intentions cello lesson vibes.

Cut all ties immediately.

Hairyfairy01 · 07/05/2024 14:25

There's an adult nspcc helpline you could call in confidence OP, maybe talk things through with them?

ManchesterGirl2 · 07/05/2024 14:24

There are a lot of alarm bells adding up OP, I'd also be worried. A doting uncle from day one is great, but a sudden interest as she becomes a teenager, combined with his comments on Asian women, the lap thing, and finding lots of excuses for more contact, is concerning.

CustardySergeant · 07/05/2024 14:22

waterrat · 07/05/2024 14:17

Absolutely DO NOT tell this men - who you have some suspicions about - that your daughter has a crush on him.

What an f-ing terrible idea.

I agree. I can't believe some people think that is a good idea.

SluggyMuggy · 07/05/2024 14:21

He is not just iffy. He is grooming you OP and your DD so he can sexually abuse and maybe rape her. It really is 101 grooming plan.
Remember what he wants to do to your child to give you the strength to do what is necessary.

alrightluv · 07/05/2024 14:19

waterrat · 07/05/2024 14:17

Absolutely DO NOT tell this men - who you have some suspicions about - that your daughter has a crush on him.

What an f-ing terrible idea.

Exactly! Shocking idea.

He sounds very iffy.

SluggyMuggy · 07/05/2024 14:18

She is clearly being groomed. I would -

  • Make a Sarah's Law request
  • Stop all guitar lessons
  • Tell Uncle you are stopping guitar lessons as his behaviour is inappropriate, he will deny it and say you are being crazy but so what.
  • Tell Uncle not to contact your DD on the phone again and tell him you have made a Sarah's Law request.
  • Find another guitar teacher.
  • Explain to DD that you think her Uncle was grooming her, so lessons are being stopped and he has been told not to contact her by phone. Tell her you have talked to police about this (you have Sarah's Law) and if he contacts her to let you know asap. She may think you are being OTT, or be a bit relieved, or a bit of both.
  • Never leave DD alone if he is at a family gathering.

I would go in hard ball. He needs to know you will protect your DD fully and DD needs to know this is an appropriate response to a man grooming child.

waterrat · 07/05/2024 14:17

Absolutely DO NOT tell this men - who you have some suspicions about - that your daughter has a crush on him.

What an f-ing terrible idea.

waterrat · 07/05/2024 14:16

A couple of alarm bells for me - he should not allow her to sit on his lap - any adult with clear boundaries would understand this is not okay.

You say he is into anime - sorry but for me I hear 'adult man and anime' and I think PORN. He may well be watching young girls/ cartoon/ anime porn.

I would let him know very clearly you are watching him - say - 'hey - its so nice you guys hang out but obviously I have to set some really specific rules for her and don't want her getting confused. I have told her not to be alone with adult men - so - Im going to have to include you in this rule too'

wont offend him if he is innocent - will warn him off if he is not innocent.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/05/2024 14:16

He's white and follows a lot of Anime stuff.

Nope. That's another red flag. There is innocent anime but there is a LOT of really dark stuff.

He's also been spending more time here in general. Offering to do nice things for me and DH to help us out.

Another really red flag.

Very strong boundaries and a lot of good messaging. I'd find a way to stop the lessons but I used to be a SW. I know CSA is common and happens all the time. I know a lot of people don't think that's true.

Nosleepforthismum · 07/05/2024 14:13

“Alternatively, you could "level" with your brother and confess that you think she has a little crush and could he very firmly discourage her. That means if he is grooming he knows you are on to him and if he is completely innocent he is aware of the problem and should take steps to make sure he is not alone with her or letting her behave in an inappropriate fashion.”

I think this is the approach I would take.