Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried DD is going to end up with an unequal relationship

267 replies

andthatsaswan · 06/05/2024 10:39

My DD is 25, last summer (age 24!) she married a man 20 years older than her. I’ll be honest the relationship has always made me uncomfortable but I’ve been supportive for DDs sake. This man is well off, tbh I’m not sure how to measure how well off he is, DD has never given me a figure, but very comfortable, he works in finance, in a C-Suite role and has a good chunk of inheritance from his family behind him. He is nice enough, he worships DD and I do believe he’d never want to see her come to harm.

DD is 16 weeks pregnant, they currently live in a flat in west London, DD is working in a prep school as a teacher (entirely by choice rather than need, part-time with small class sizes), they are mortgage free.

I had dinner with DD last night and she told me the plan is to buy somewhere rural, a large house in either Berkshire, Buckinghamshire or Surrey. Sell the current flat and get a smaller 1 bed in London. Then her partner will stay in the flat Monday night - Thursday morning, he works from home Monday and Friday so he could come home for that. She won’t work at all.
Now this seems like a terrible idea to me! The house she showed me is up for 2 mil!!! Now I don’t know if any of that will be mortgage or not but I somewhat doubt it. Surely with the 2 million + a 1 bed flat they could find something in London that would mean he was home every night.
When DD was showing the house it sounded like she was planning at least 1 if not 2 more children and I just worry about her being out in the middle of nowhere with the baby/children alone while he is living his best life. It feels very unequal and as though he’s not really prepared to give up his freedom for his family.

AIBU to be worried about this and think it’s an awful idea? Should I try talk DD out of it?

OP posts:
Getonwitit · 06/05/2024 20:12

SluggyMuggy · 06/05/2024 20:06

I really disagree with this. She is not moving to a City with lots of baby classes but to a rural area. This may mean she has to drive a fair distance to go to any groups. Not always easy with a new baby and no support.

It is Surrey not Sutherland. Rural in Surry means there is another village within 2 miles and London within the hour on the train. More than half a million people live in the county. That is not rural.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 20:09

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/05/2024 20:05

True equality would be both parents considering the choice and it not seen as a choice that only women make once they become parents. We need to be asking men when they become fathers ''Are you going back to work?'', ''How much time are you having off?'' etc which mothers are usually asked during maternity leave.

We also need to offer men more than just 2 weeks off with their new baby.

Agreed, I'll admit that one didn't occur to me because that's a conversation DH and I had between us anyway, and we both (now, DH didn't at the time) work for companies with "parental leave" as opposed to "maternity leave", meaning either of us could take a significant amount of time off if we had another.

SluggyMuggy · 06/05/2024 20:06

PitterPatter3 · 06/05/2024 19:53

Re: her being lonely. Having a baby can provide lots of opportunities for developing a new social circle. It’s arguably one of the best times in life for moving to a new area. At 25 I imagine her existing friends are probably not also yet at the stage of having babies(?) so those friendships would likely change anyway. I honestly don’t think this will necessarily be a terrible situation from a loneliness perspective. It could work out very well for her.

I really disagree with this. She is not moving to a City with lots of baby classes but to a rural area. This may mean she has to drive a fair distance to go to any groups. Not always easy with a new baby and no support.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/05/2024 20:05

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 18:28

Maybe because we're made to feel shame regardless of our choice, and so we don't fight for what we're worth when we do work.

I also think that true feminism is that we are able to choose what we do, without judgement, in the same way men do. Being able to earn our money, and jobs, and respect. Not the "token" feminism of putting women in 50% of top jobs by X date. Because in that scenario, if I'm promoted over a man with similar experience, is that only because I'm a woman? Not because I deserve that role?

Theres many reasons the gaps still exist. Some are because not all women want to work, some do genuinely want to be mothers and with their children. Some of the reasons are because the feminist "cause" has gone too far the other way and instead of demanding equal opportunity the uber feminists are demanding equality on the most literal sense (i.e. exactly the same amount of men Vs women in roles). But if the women promoted into those roles don't actually deserve them, that sets us back again.

I'm not going into it anymore because it'll derail this thread, but letting women choose their own lives without judgement of those choices is the first step to achieving true equality.

True equality would be both parents considering the choice and it not seen as a choice that only women make once they become parents. We need to be asking men when they become fathers ''Are you going back to work?'', ''How much time are you having off?'' etc which mothers are usually asked during maternity leave.

We also need to offer men more than just 2 weeks off with their new baby.

PitterPatter3 · 06/05/2024 19:53

Re: her being lonely. Having a baby can provide lots of opportunities for developing a new social circle. It’s arguably one of the best times in life for moving to a new area. At 25 I imagine her existing friends are probably not also yet at the stage of having babies(?) so those friendships would likely change anyway. I honestly don’t think this will necessarily be a terrible situation from a loneliness perspective. It could work out very well for her.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 19:49

Getonwitit · 06/05/2024 19:41

So women aren't allowed a choice as they should live how you tell them ? Do you think every other women is an idiot ?

Exactly. She's a 25 year old, university graduate, teacher who is married with a child on the way. But this decision she can't possibly have made for herself or have thought through.

CurlewKate · 06/05/2024 19:48

@Getonwitit "Do you think every other women is an idiot ?"

Of course I do, that's exactly what he think......🤔

If my still quite young dd was about to make choices that had the potential for significant downsides, I would want to do everything I could to make sure she had considered them carefully, and taken steps to protect herself and her children.

Getonwitit · 06/05/2024 19:41

CurlewKate · 06/05/2024 17:55

Sometimes I think in Mumsnetland feminism never happened.

@andthatsaswan I would be trying to have conversations with your dd about her future. When the babies are grown up, or if they never happen. What if she changes her mind. What about her pension? What if at some point she wants a different sort of life?

So women aren't allowed a choice as they should live how you tell them ? Do you think every other women is an idiot ?

SleepingStandingUp · 06/05/2024 19:36

andthatsaswan · 06/05/2024 18:54

To answer a few questions.

I don’t think he is sleazy in anyway, he’s never been married before and having had long chats with him it’s clear he devoted himself to his work and let life pass him by, he didn’t really have any long term relationships.
They met at a tennis club, DD had just turned 20, he was almost 40, they were paired up for mixed doubles at the club tournament and well that was that.
DD is extremely clever, however she is much happier pursuing things as they interest her, she was never one to really have a career in mind (she studied classics and English).
I think DD is with him as he treats her like she’s a princess! I truly believe he does love her and he has dedicated his life to her since they met which is why I’ve bit my tongue and been supportive!
DD grew up outside of London, I lived in a town but her dad had a lovely cottage in a village, I think DD is hoping to recreate that.

He is chief investment officer for a private bank, he is in office for not much past 7 most days and won’t leave until 6, often it will be followed by a meal with sales rep from a fund house or similar.

My concerns are with DD being alone, I don’t live near any of the places she wants to live, nor does her dad or sister. She is certain it will be an hour on the train to London if she wants to go meet friends for lunch - I don’t think she yet understands how time consuming babies and children are! She can drive though which I know will help!

So you don't think your daughter loves him, just what she can get from him? In which case perhaps she's thrilled he'll be away half the week and she'll be able to live her best SAHM life

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/05/2024 19:32

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 06/05/2024 17:01

I hate the trope that marriage is some magical legal protection, many of my friends and acquaintances have either been fucked over in a divorce or trapped in unhappy marriages due to finances. Yes, it affords you some protection but being financially independent is the only way to fully protect yourself.

OP I agree, I would be worried too but there is nothing you can actually do or say other than perhaps suggests she has an exit fund or keeps her part time work hours.

I hate it too. Marriage is a very important piece of legal insurance for someone in this situation and obviously it’s a good thing she has this protection.

But the idea that it’s some sort of talisman that wards off unhappiness or any relationship issue or financial challenge is misguided. Its possible to be married and still be trapped or married and abused in a variety of ways or married and just very unhappy.

From the OP’s most recent post the guy does sound decent and principled and as if he will do his best by her (from his own perspective at least), which would reassure me.

But it still is at heart a very unbalanced and unequal relationship.

adviceneeded1990 · 06/05/2024 19:30

BIossomtoes · 06/05/2024 14:24

I’m also baffled by the number of women who consider shagging a rich older guy as “landing on your feet”.

I don’t know why you’re baffled or why you think not doing paid work means low aspirations. Marrying someone who’s wealthy gives you choice. I’d have loved to use my skills to benefit a charity, I could have done that if I’d married a wealthy man. There’s nothing noble, feminist or aspirational about being a wage slave if you don’t have to.

That isn’t happening in this case? And marrying a rich guy very young often means you’ve had no chance to develop any skills or aspirations of your own. Check the relationships board which is full of trapped SAHMs who are desperate to leave wealthy men but can’t due to lack of money/career/earning potential/suitable property/confidence/self esteem. Independence, or wage slavery as you call it, creates options.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 19:24

OverpricedTea · 06/05/2024 19:05

I believe it’s wrong for society as a whole. Read my other posts. Individuals of course can do as they please.

Society as a whole is now broken beyond repair, but not because some women want to be staying at home mothers. We should by rights be starting again and kicking out the ones responsible, but that's also not a thing that gets discussed on MN.

Glipsy · 06/05/2024 19:12

i get that you’re worried. But he sounds like he loves her and 24 is young. If she decides she wants to become a doctor at the age of 35, there’s time for her to do it!

In a way, this sounds like a better way to spend your twenties than falling out of pubs at closing and on to an afters which is what everyone I know did. We all only started ‘real lives’ in our thirties and nobody’s worse off for it.

Just keep being her mum and if she sounds lonely get her down to stay with you or take the kids so she can go for a night out with friends maybe.

OverpricedTea · 06/05/2024 19:05

GoodAfternoonGoodEveningAndGoodnight · 06/05/2024 19:01

Oh give over, she's an adult.
If that's what she wants to do then what's wrong with that?!

I believe it’s wrong for society as a whole. Read my other posts. Individuals of course can do as they please.

Mrsjayy · 06/05/2024 19:02

Reading your update Op it doesn't sound like you trust your daughter to be a grown up and able to look after herself and the baby. She will learn like we all had to learn to be mothers if she needs you or help she will ask.

GoodAfternoonGoodEveningAndGoodnight · 06/05/2024 19:01

OverpricedTea · 06/05/2024 18:04

I would be so disappointed if my daughter did this. Yet another woman lost to the workforce and the gender pay gap continues. How depressing. You can do nothing other than support her of course. She is so young though. What a shame.

Oh give over, she's an adult.
If that's what she wants to do then what's wrong with that?!

diddl · 06/05/2024 18:57

I just worry about her being out in the middle of nowhere with the baby/children alone while he is living his best life.

It might also be her best life?

I think she needs to make sure to not be so isolated that she can't get to baby/toddler groups, find & babysitter for hobbies/go out with others.

AquaFurball · 06/05/2024 18:55

DdraigGoch · 06/05/2024 16:35

Assuming she has a degree if she's a teacher. Good grief she's not an idiot.

Why can't graduates be idiots? There's a difference between knowledge and wisdom

And why can't a "concerned" mother just be an over bearing one who is jealous her daughter is making a better life for herself?

andthatsaswan · 06/05/2024 18:54

To answer a few questions.

I don’t think he is sleazy in anyway, he’s never been married before and having had long chats with him it’s clear he devoted himself to his work and let life pass him by, he didn’t really have any long term relationships.
They met at a tennis club, DD had just turned 20, he was almost 40, they were paired up for mixed doubles at the club tournament and well that was that.
DD is extremely clever, however she is much happier pursuing things as they interest her, she was never one to really have a career in mind (she studied classics and English).
I think DD is with him as he treats her like she’s a princess! I truly believe he does love her and he has dedicated his life to her since they met which is why I’ve bit my tongue and been supportive!
DD grew up outside of London, I lived in a town but her dad had a lovely cottage in a village, I think DD is hoping to recreate that.

He is chief investment officer for a private bank, he is in office for not much past 7 most days and won’t leave until 6, often it will be followed by a meal with sales rep from a fund house or similar.

My concerns are with DD being alone, I don’t live near any of the places she wants to live, nor does her dad or sister. She is certain it will be an hour on the train to London if she wants to go meet friends for lunch - I don’t think she yet understands how time consuming babies and children are! She can drive though which I know will help!

OP posts:
wintersgold · 06/05/2024 18:54

LondonJax · 06/05/2024 18:51

I agree it's entirely her choice but rural Berkshire, Buckinghamshire or Surrey isn't exactly the north of Scotland so I don't understand his need for a flat in London for three days a week.

We live in a rural area in the Home Counties but I can get into London in just over an hour by train and I used to every single day before DS came along. Unless he works very long hours I can't understand why he can't do a commute.

OP was vague about his job but finance includes IB, which have notoriously long days that can get to 100+ hr/week.

LondonJax · 06/05/2024 18:51

I agree it's entirely her choice but rural Berkshire, Buckinghamshire or Surrey isn't exactly the north of Scotland so I don't understand his need for a flat in London for three days a week.

We live in a rural area in the Home Counties but I can get into London in just over an hour by train and I used to every single day before DS came along. Unless he works very long hours I can't understand why he can't do a commute.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 18:44

OverpricedTea · 06/05/2024 18:34

exactly the same amount of men Vs women in roles). But if the women promoted into those roles don't actually deserve them, that sets us back again.

Why should we not naturally have as many women as men in most roles (other than the caring industry)? Why is there an imbalance?

letting women choose their own lives without judgement of those choices is the first step to achieving true equality.

But choices are not made in a vacuum. They are a function of the society, values and expectations we live under. If we do nothing and just accept the status quo without question, then things will never change.

I am always surprised at how ‘unfeminist’ most of MN is.

We should naturally have them. But setting the target of a certain number by a certain time means those that are put in to hit the quota are unqualified and not ready for the role.

I've worked for several of these and they let women down massively.

Tripeandonions · 06/05/2024 18:36

@pistonsaremachines well no , she'll get her husband's wealth surely?

I don't know what wealth he has.

And this all assumes she can manage him on her own until his demise and he is safe to be left alone while she goes say, shopping.

Eventually she may need extra night-time care at £28.00 ph, or there will be care home fees at £1000+ per week when they can no longer manage him at home.

  • Annual average residential care home fees: around £51,000
  • Annual average nursing care costs: around £62,000

This all soon eats into the 'pot'.

OverpricedTea · 06/05/2024 18:35

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 18:32

Have you met 24 year old men? I didn't want to marry one when I was 24 never mind later.

So why are old men marrying 24y women?

ETA I met my husband when he was 24 and I was 23. We got on brilliantly. We are still together 30y later. Both working. Equal relationship. No regrets.

OverpricedTea · 06/05/2024 18:34

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/05/2024 18:28

Maybe because we're made to feel shame regardless of our choice, and so we don't fight for what we're worth when we do work.

I also think that true feminism is that we are able to choose what we do, without judgement, in the same way men do. Being able to earn our money, and jobs, and respect. Not the "token" feminism of putting women in 50% of top jobs by X date. Because in that scenario, if I'm promoted over a man with similar experience, is that only because I'm a woman? Not because I deserve that role?

Theres many reasons the gaps still exist. Some are because not all women want to work, some do genuinely want to be mothers and with their children. Some of the reasons are because the feminist "cause" has gone too far the other way and instead of demanding equal opportunity the uber feminists are demanding equality on the most literal sense (i.e. exactly the same amount of men Vs women in roles). But if the women promoted into those roles don't actually deserve them, that sets us back again.

I'm not going into it anymore because it'll derail this thread, but letting women choose their own lives without judgement of those choices is the first step to achieving true equality.

exactly the same amount of men Vs women in roles). But if the women promoted into those roles don't actually deserve them, that sets us back again.

Why should we not naturally have as many women as men in most roles (other than the caring industry)? Why is there an imbalance?

letting women choose their own lives without judgement of those choices is the first step to achieving true equality.

But choices are not made in a vacuum. They are a function of the society, values and expectations we live under. If we do nothing and just accept the status quo without question, then things will never change.

I am always surprised at how ‘unfeminist’ most of MN is.