Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grown Men Dating Teenagers

457 replies

ReallyDubious · 05/05/2024 21:57

I have a male acquaintance who expressed a really concerning opinion about age gap relationships. He thinks that it is ok for a much older man to date younger women and teenagers as 'some women (or girls) are more mature than others'. Although I agree with that in principle, I do not agree that a teenager is ever mature enough to date a grown man.

He said he dated 'mature' teens when he was in his 40s and I'm seriously revolted at the thought. AIBU to think there is something seriously wrong with this man?

OP posts:
CantBelieveNaive · 06/05/2024 11:03

AlmostAJillSandwich · 06/05/2024 00:34

Recently found out my ex who i was with late 2011- early 2015 started dating a girl at the start of her final year of highschool (don't know if she had turned 16 yet or not) when he was 26 Easter Confused, and didn't mention it on social media til new years the year after she graduated, but a friend of hers commented on the status outing it was a year late, giving them away. He will be 30 in a few months, and shes 19 at the oldest.

Edit, just looked up to see if her profile states her birth month, they're engaged! I genuinely feel sick, this makes him the second predator i dated. His interest in me way back then was me being a virgin still, I was a couple years older than him at 22, and he'd already had 3 sexual partners and, i quote, said to me, "I hate the idea of a bunch of men being inside a girl before me".
He was also a compulsive liar, cheated with atleast 3 other girls in some capacity, was emotionally abusive, and used me for over £1000 of gifts and money and never so much as got me a tesco value birthday card in return.
From the looks of it she's estranged from all her own family, i hope she's alright.

Edited

Why don't you contact her and her family on social media to give her the heads up? Xxx

Nicole1111 · 06/05/2024 11:02

Regardless of the maturity of that particular individual, science tells us people that age haven’t reached their full maturity. That makes me question what the motivation is to date them, and in my experience it’s typically about a desire for power in the relationship.

AGodawfulsmallaffair · 06/05/2024 11:00

randomchap · 06/05/2024 10:24

It's the rule according to some. Personally I don't agree, but as no one else had mentioned it thought it would add to the debate.

I understand - I was about to post my ds wouldn’t date a teen although a 5 yr age gap isn’t the end of the world and the ages were the same as your post!

IcedPurple · 06/05/2024 10:59

And odd as it may seem if it isn't your thing, quite a lot of younger women find older men attractive, and sometimes even more attractive than younger men.

"Quite a lot" of women do not. A small minority might.

The vast majority of women prefer to date men around their own age.

SabreIsMyFave · 06/05/2024 10:57

OneStepBeyond2 · 06/05/2024 10:51

What do you think about the concept of a woman raping a man? I think it's quite a new concept legally. I guess the reason is that a man can rape a woman even if she's not aroused and that can do her immense mental and physical harm but if a woman wants to rape a man he's got to be up for it.

Gosh I will have to give that a bit of thought, but yeah, the chance of a woman raping a man has surely got to be vanishingly rare! Unless she drugs him then does things to him (Sorry not sure how to word it without sounding grim!) I can imagine this being an extremely rare occurrence though.

As you say, it would be pretty hard for a woman to rape a man. I doubt anyone in the age gap relationships I mentioned - where the younger person was only 18-ish was raped (I hope not!) But there is still something very unsavoury about a teenager and a middle aged person. And it's a bit worse (IMO) when it's the man who is older. (That's just my opinion, and I can't explain why I feel like this!)

OneStepBeyond2 · 06/05/2024 10:51

SabreIsMyFave · 06/05/2024 10:38

Yes they are, continually. I won't say too much, as there is not much I can say without potentially breaking MN rooolz! but their relationship gives me the MASSIVE ick. She was 40 and he was 15 when they met! She was his teacher.

Wrong. On. SO. Many. Levels! Just soooooo wrong. Shock

What do you think about the concept of a woman raping a man? I think it's quite a new concept legally. I guess the reason is that a man can rape a woman even if she's not aroused and that can do her immense mental and physical harm but if a woman wants to rape a man he's got to be up for it.

SabreIsMyFave · 06/05/2024 10:50

Also, whilst I adore Celine Dion, and am pretty sure her love for her husband was pure and genuine, something about the fact they met when she was 12 and he was 38, (and started their relationship when she was 19 and he was 45,) makes me feel a bit 😖!!!

Very few people bring up Celine and her husband Rene, but they are definitely one of those big age gap couples where the younger partner was very young when they started.

Maxwell Caulfield and Juliet Mills is a similar example, but Maxwell was a little older. He was 20 when he met Juliet Mills. Not such a big age gap - 18 years - but now he is 64 and she is 82, she 100% looks like his mother.

SabreIsMyFave · 06/05/2024 10:38

AlpineMuesli · 06/05/2024 10:27

Oh please, as if Macron and Brigitte aren’t relentlessly ridiculed.

Yes they are, continually. I won't say too much, as there is not much I can say without potentially breaking MN rooolz! but their relationship gives me the MASSIVE ick. She was 40 and he was 15 when they met! She was his teacher.

Wrong. On. SO. Many. Levels! Just soooooo wrong. Shock

Pleiades2020 · 06/05/2024 10:36

It's up to the individuals who they go out with. You or I may think its wrong but its not up to us. Both parties are consenting adults.

AlpineMuesli · 06/05/2024 10:27

Oh please, as if Macron and Brigitte aren’t relentlessly ridiculed.

randomchap · 06/05/2024 10:24

AGodawfulsmallaffair · 06/05/2024 08:42

I was just going to say my 24 yr ds would not date a 19 year old. He definitely doesn’t think it’s ok to date a teenager, even a nearly 20 yr old.

It's the rule according to some. Personally I don't agree, but as no one else had mentioned it thought it would add to the debate.

Olivegardenishome · 06/05/2024 10:16

Foxblue · 06/05/2024 09:49

Good question.
There's a lot of these types of relationships that have lasted.
But I've never understood why people see a long relationship as automatically a successful one.
Or a seemingly happy relationship as a one without problems.

Or, and people who've never experienced a breakdown of this type of relationship might read this and think I'm being patronising - please know that's absolutely not my intent.
It is quite easy, if a relationship is your first, or you had flings or terrible relationships previously, to be in a relationship where you would declare yourself as happy, and to the outside world you might seem a good match.
But sometimes in these relationships, because you have little context for what's 'good' or the person you are with has conditioned you into thinking certain things are normal, you are a boiled frog, and it's only once you are free that you can look back and go 'I would describe myself as happy, because when things were good, they were very good, but I had no access to joint money without questioning, he would fly off the handle at minor things, and he left all the housework and parenting to me'
And I wonder how many of these age gap relationships fall into this category.

Because it also happens with same age couples. I know of at least two couples who have been together since university, who would describe themselves as happy, yet in one the husband actively despises the wife, and shuts her down constantly, and talks down to her, and she has developed exagerrating illness as a coping mechanism because that's the only time he eases up on her. The other, they argue constantly and think anyone in a relationship who doesn't is weird. Now a lot of people might read that and say 'but if they think they are happy, then what's the harm, if they don't know any different, other people don't get to dictate happiness'
Which is a fair point, but anyone whose ever suffered with chronic stress, or a bad relationship, knows the toll it can take on your health long term. Never mind the fact that these relationships often produce children who look to their parents relationship model, so in fact, there is a 'harm'. But also often these relationships can entail financial control and abuse, because 'he's better at the money side' and suddenly he's run off with a 21 year old from his work and she's posting on here saying 'he was older and good with money, so he dealt with everything so I have nothing' - you see it all the time. It was good, until it wasn't. And no, as I've just explained, not exclusive to age gap relationships. But the risk of a power imbalance, or one person subconsciously taking the standard that the other person sets as 'normal' as part of relationships and being unable to know what's normal ups and downs and what is something more sinister, is more heightened when one person just has more life experience than the other.

I got with my DH, who is 7 years older than me, when I was 17. This was 22 years ago now. Granted, this isn’t a huge age gap relationship.

Nobody was concerned or batted an eyelid. It was just perceived as normal.
Times must have changed?? I know though, perhaps hypocritically, that if my now 17 year old daughter came home with a 24 year old man, I’d be not at all happy.

But in saying that, we have the best marriage. Thank goodness young, naive me managed to find a very incredible, kind, supportive and loving man.

When I see men in their late 30’s-40’s with women who are 19, it’s just sickening.

SabreIsMyFave · 06/05/2024 09:54

@KreedKafer

A man in his 40s dating a teenager is pretty dodgy, because it’s pretty clear that he will have been actively seeking out the very youngest girls he can legally date. If he’s attracted to younger women he could easily meet women in their mid-20s, the kind of women who could be his peers at work, have their own flat, and generally have their shit together. But if he’s meeting teenagers, then he’s definitely deliberately trying to find them because he’s got some ghastly ‘barely legal’ fantasy going on. Which is gross.

YES to all of this! ^ Well said. 👏

SabreIsMyFave · 06/05/2024 09:53

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/05/2024 00:45

Do you think gay relationships are wrong?

Holy False Equivalency Batman.

😂

Foxblue · 06/05/2024 09:49

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 06/05/2024 09:10

Is there anyone who met their much older oh as a teenager and ate still together 40 plus years later and happy?
The only couples I know who are still together and met as teenagers, we’re both a similar age.
So I know one couple who were approx. 16 and 18. Still happily married both in their 50s.
Several couples who met in early 20s still together and now in their 50s.
I remember a girl at school who was dating the DJ- she was 13 and he was about 30. He ran the youth club discos.
He later had a relationship with a much younger woman and had a child with her. She was 20s he was 40s. He beat her.
Very dodgy man.
I don’t know of anyone who met their long term partner when they were a teenager and he was much older and are still together in later life.

Good question.
There's a lot of these types of relationships that have lasted.
But I've never understood why people see a long relationship as automatically a successful one.
Or a seemingly happy relationship as a one without problems.

Or, and people who've never experienced a breakdown of this type of relationship might read this and think I'm being patronising - please know that's absolutely not my intent.
It is quite easy, if a relationship is your first, or you had flings or terrible relationships previously, to be in a relationship where you would declare yourself as happy, and to the outside world you might seem a good match.
But sometimes in these relationships, because you have little context for what's 'good' or the person you are with has conditioned you into thinking certain things are normal, you are a boiled frog, and it's only once you are free that you can look back and go 'I would describe myself as happy, because when things were good, they were very good, but I had no access to joint money without questioning, he would fly off the handle at minor things, and he left all the housework and parenting to me'
And I wonder how many of these age gap relationships fall into this category.

Because it also happens with same age couples. I know of at least two couples who have been together since university, who would describe themselves as happy, yet in one the husband actively despises the wife, and shuts her down constantly, and talks down to her, and she has developed exagerrating illness as a coping mechanism because that's the only time he eases up on her. The other, they argue constantly and think anyone in a relationship who doesn't is weird. Now a lot of people might read that and say 'but if they think they are happy, then what's the harm, if they don't know any different, other people don't get to dictate happiness'
Which is a fair point, but anyone whose ever suffered with chronic stress, or a bad relationship, knows the toll it can take on your health long term. Never mind the fact that these relationships often produce children who look to their parents relationship model, so in fact, there is a 'harm'. But also often these relationships can entail financial control and abuse, because 'he's better at the money side' and suddenly he's run off with a 21 year old from his work and she's posting on here saying 'he was older and good with money, so he dealt with everything so I have nothing' - you see it all the time. It was good, until it wasn't. And no, as I've just explained, not exclusive to age gap relationships. But the risk of a power imbalance, or one person subconsciously taking the standard that the other person sets as 'normal' as part of relationships and being unable to know what's normal ups and downs and what is something more sinister, is more heightened when one person just has more life experience than the other.

Mammyloveswine · 06/05/2024 09:43

When I was 16 I went out with a 25 year old and honestly it still shocks me that I was just "allowed"... all my family just accepted it, his friends used to come out with us too even though we were all at college! I ended up almost moving in with him until my dad refused to be my guarantor. I was 19 by this point and ended up working in a law firm with lots of young secretaries/accountants all early 20s and I discovered having a life and fun with people my own age!

I'm Facebook friends with him and he's married now and has kids etc but still gives me the ick.

OneStepBeyond2 · 06/05/2024 09:34

They say there's nowt so queer as folk, but as I understand it, the best theory evolutionary science has come up with is that men and women both want nothing more than to get laid and have babies.

MrsCherryCrest · 06/05/2024 09:30

It’s grim. I was 17 when I had my first relationship with a man I worked with who was 28. Looking back, there was a clear power imbalance and he used me for sex and easy company.

My uncle would make jokes about me dating an old man at the time and I have no idea why my parents went along with it. They probably thought it wouldn’t last long. And they were right, after a couple of months he dumped me.

I remember when I turned 28 I was repulsed at the thought of having sex with a 17 year old. I don’t think I’d be so laid back if my 17 year old started dating someone who was 28.

Olivegardenishome · 06/05/2024 09:29

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/05/2024 22:17

Men always think girls and women are more mature when it comes to them having sex, but never when it comes to running companies, ruling countries or making decisions.

I wonder why...

God, you always speak wise words. This is one of the most truthful things I’ve ever read on here.

OneStepBeyond2 · 06/05/2024 09:24

coxesorangepippin · 06/05/2024 02:43

Men always think girls and women are more mature when it comes to them having sex

^

Also includes cooking dinner, running a house

But not running a company, holding positions of power etc

I'm not suggesting there is anything wrong with women running companies or being successful, but to me they've got to get it right. Is there a trend amongst some of these successful women to wake up one morning at 45 in the 5 bed house with merc on the drive and wonder why she never chose to have kids rather than chase that promotion. One woman who has got it bang on in this regard in my opinion is fund manager Nicola Horlicks; successful career and six kids.

Astronaut79 · 06/05/2024 09:23

I think it may have been more common back in the day. We were in pubs and clubs from 16, whereas boys our own age weren't able to get in. Going out with someone late teens early 20s, even up to 25 wasn't seen as abnormal. But at 25 , I wouldn't have really wanted anyone younger than myself.

I was shagging a 30 year old at 18. He still lives at home and spent most of his spare time playing football or in the pub. Like all the other blokes in our town. We didn't have anything in common, apart from sex, and that was ok as far as I was concerned because I didn't want him as a boyfriend. Even then, I recognised he was a man child.

I did end up in a 10 year age gap reship. I was 24, he 34. I had just come our of a shit 10 year gap reship and did not want another, but this one did not look that much older, so I took him home. We've been together 20 years. We have music, art, literature politics and a strong work ethic in common, although we were initially attracted by looks. We were just lucky.

LakeTiticaca · 06/05/2024 09:17

People just really mind their own business.
Be concerned if your teenage daughter is dating a 40 year old.
Otherwise keep your neb out of other people's relationships and stop judging when you know nothing about what goes on in other people's lives .
Why us it anyone else's business if 30 year old Sandra at number 63 is dating a guy of 50?
Why would you care, except to be a nasty gossip?

OneStepBeyond2 · 06/05/2024 09:11

anon4net · 06/05/2024 03:00

I think these men 30+ who date teenage girls are predators, it's thinly veiled abuse and most of these relationships include massive power differences linked partly to financial differences too.

During my A levels a quieter girl from a vulnerable family age 16 started dating a psychiatric nurse who was 44. They met through work. I also know a social services youth worker (late 50's) who dated a newly minted 18 year old who barely spoke English. For both these men I can't imagine these were their first victims. Victims they were. I could tell you of countless more through work but will stop there.

This isn't just about age differences. A woman or man age 30 could be in a safe and loving relationship with a man or woman age 45/50+.

Relationships with teens and young 20's with 15/20/25/30/35 year age gaps are deeply troubling.

As the parent of a teenage girl I can tell you I would do everything in my power to ensure my daughter is never in a 'relationship' like this.

On your point about the psychiatric nurse, there is a theory that everything we do, men and women is for the purpose of attracting our ideal mate and having children. The psychiatric nurse may have gone into that career because he was attracted to vulnerability. Let's face it some women like being coy, it's another way of appearing vulnerable and men can find this attractive. They say play hard to get don't they.

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 06/05/2024 09:10

Is there anyone who met their much older oh as a teenager and ate still together 40 plus years later and happy?
The only couples I know who are still together and met as teenagers, we’re both a similar age.
So I know one couple who were approx. 16 and 18. Still happily married both in their 50s.
Several couples who met in early 20s still together and now in their 50s.
I remember a girl at school who was dating the DJ- she was 13 and he was about 30. He ran the youth club discos.
He later had a relationship with a much younger woman and had a child with her. She was 20s he was 40s. He beat her.
Very dodgy man.
I don’t know of anyone who met their long term partner when they were a teenager and he was much older and are still together in later life.

Foxblue · 06/05/2024 09:09

I think that the:
Older man > younger woman
Older woman > younger man
Setups get the same amount of grief AND the same amount of passes, tbh, just maybe from different groups of people?
Look how many women on this very website are in relationships that started when they were in their teens/20s and their DP was 30+. It still happens now, you can see 'age is just a number' in any comments section online about men and women and in real life. I think women are more likely to go 'you go girl' about a cougar situation because women are more likely to be the younger party in their own age gap relationships so have been groomed into thinking it's all okay.
You only have to look at the recent resurfaced interest in director Sam Taylor Johnsons' grooming of Aaron Taylor Johnson - people definitely aren't going 'go girl' at that one.

Also again, it's patriarchy isn't it.
Men who go after younger women don't have a name, other than 'predator'.
Women have 'cougar' - so still a predator, but its ultimately a softened version. Not taken seriously.
If you read a news article about a relationship with an age gap, if its about an older woman with a younger man, you can bet that the age gap will be brought up, or she will be referred to as a cougar. Whereas 90% of the articles about couples where the man is older, the age gap is never mentioned - because it's been so normalised, it's not a novelty. Women are still held to different standards, by being marked out when they ape behaviour a man could exhibit without any raised eyebrows.
I mean, to be clear - any woman engaging in this behaviour absolutely should be judged too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread