Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so fed up of my entitled sibling?

31 replies

TakesTheCake12 · 04/05/2024 11:39

I've always had a fractious relationship with my elder sibling. She is the type of person who is never wrong, super insecure, sensitive and defensive, terrified of conflict so bottles up any perceived slights/insults (sometimes over years) and hurls them back in your face when she eventually explodes. She's very passive aggressive and generally draining to be around. I'm always walking on eggshells, never sure what she'll take offence to next.

I'm sad that we've never been close because of this. Sometimes I think about laying it all out on the table and trying to forge a path to a better relationship but I'm worried that would mean the end of any relationship.

We live in the same city, after both moving back to this country from abroad, we have DC of similar ages, so there are many reasons to be close. I've reached the end of my tether on this one thing that keeps cropping up.
She and her family don't have a car, they could easily afford one but want to save money and use public transport instead. This inevitably means that I end up doing most of the travelling, if we ever go out for dinner or anywhere for the day it has to be somewhere convenient that doesn't take too long for them to get to. Or they tell me to come to theirs for dinner which I do frequently. They very rarely come to mine as they say it takes them too long on the train/bus, and never for dinner. When I point out that I'm doing most of the travelling, she says this is because I have a car and it doesn't take me as long, so that's fair. Yes, a car I pay for! If I ever bring up how convenient thier lives would be with a car (esp with 2 small DC) it's "we don't NEED a car. We can get everywhere we need to without one. They're too expensive. You spend a stupid amount on your car". She's such hard work, it's exhausting.

There was one incident I haven't been able to forget where one year I was hosting 13 people for Xmas dinner, she and her DH had been invited (pre kids) and she rudely demanded that they be collected, because there was no public transport. I pointed out taxis were running and she told me "yes and that will cost us about £60!. If you won't pick us up we won't come!" I was so furious I was ready to tell them where to stick it but my peacekeeper DP just collected them.

Any advice on dealing with her?

OP posts:
CanaryCanary · 04/05/2024 12:13

I think people who don’t drive don’t always know all the costs that go with running a car. So if she’s saying she can’t afford a taxi, you could choose to point out how much the car costs you, tell her you can’t afford to subsidise her choices. So if she’s choosing not to run a car, that doesn’t mean you have to do all the driving.

Maybe laying everything out as calmly as possible would help to reset your relationship?

chipsandpeas · 04/05/2024 12:07

stop running after her

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/05/2024 11:51

I would've told her not to come over the Christmas thing. She is very cheeky to host and also pick her up and take her back.

BroughttoyoubyBerocca · 04/05/2024 11:49

Offer to meet in town? Not at yours?

OnehundredStars · 04/05/2024 11:47

Why do you run after her ? I wouldn’t. Fuel for your car is expensive!!
offer an invite and if she doesn’t take it then don’t run after her

something2say · 04/05/2024 11:42

Yes. Make yourself happy. That's it really. Don' do things that piss you off, do do some things when you're not so pissed off.

She has to wear the consequences of her choices, but they don't need to come from you. Just say no to the things that irritate you. When she complains that you don't see her that much any more, say why. She has to suck up the consequences like we all do.

I hate people who don't pay for things but then expect to use other people's.