Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is the obsession with 2 under 2?

318 replies

2under2blah · 03/05/2024 06:15

I see so many threads where people are worried that they're going to have a 3/4/5 year age gap between their children.

Didn't this used to be normal?

Why is 2 under 2 seen as the only way to do it?

Looks absolutely intense to me!

OP posts:
caitlinsjoy · 03/05/2024 09:34

4 year age gap between my two children - by choice. We wanted to spread childcare costs when they were young and be able to put each through university when they are teenagers without stress on our finances. They get along well and I have no regrets. I dread to think about how my friends will afford to put their two children through university at the same time, as it will be such a financial burden.

Perfectpots · 03/05/2024 09:33

2under2blah · 03/05/2024 06:15

I see so many threads where people are worried that they're going to have a 3/4/5 year age gap between their children.

Didn't this used to be normal?

Why is 2 under 2 seen as the only way to do it?

Looks absolutely intense to me!

There isn't an obsession with it. There never has been and there isn't now.

HooverTheRoof · 03/05/2024 09:32

I specifically waited until my first was eligible for the funded preschool hours to make it easier (financially and mentally) I can't imagine many people can afford nursery fees for two at once

I also know someone whose second turned out to be twins so they had 3 under two 😬so that was something that made me think carefully too 😅

AffableApple · 03/05/2024 09:30

I had a three minute gap between mine 🤣. Just under two and running rings round me.

Merryhobnobs · 03/05/2024 09:29

I saw another post like this on another site recently. There is no such thing as the perfect scientific age gap because humans are all different, different personalities, different circumstances. Even parents change over time! It is so judgemental, and it reeks of people wanting to validate their own decisions by putting others down or 'it is wrong'. Sometimes in life there is no one right wat and that is cool.

AlltheFs · 03/05/2024 09:29

SometimesIDowonder · 03/05/2024 09:24

Really? I've never met someone with two under two thinking they're doing this for attention. Surely there are easier ways to get attention.

Though I do think sometimes there's an attitude of invincibility amongst some - thinking I can do this even though everyone says its tough.

Not having 2 under 2, the endless hand wringing posting about what age gap is “best”. Bollocks.

Rickrolypoly · 03/05/2024 09:28

OliviaHart · 03/05/2024 06:55

We had two under two because I had awful pregnancies and just wanted to get them over with.

It’s been perfect for us. They’ve always played together well, we got the hardest childcare bit over in one go and now they are best mates (who of course try to kill each other regularly also!). I didn’t find it some frazzled, stressful nightmare (weird people assume that when they haven’t experienced it, I don’t assume I know what a bigger age gap feels like).

Also - I have siblings ranging from 18 months older than me to 15 years younger than me. I have different relationships with all of them that having nothing to do with the age gaps, just the individuals!

Edited

I could have written that whole post lol.

I'm from a big family and have different relationships with all my siblings which has changed over time. I spent hardly any time as a child with one of my siblings (went to college when they were 4) but we are very close now.

It really depends, there is 17 months between my 2 and although it was challenging at times, it really wasn't the chaotic mess people are making it out to be. I think what helped was having a husband who isn't a big man baby expecting me to just do everything. It's all hands on deck in this house, no one sits down until we can both sit down lol.

Bibbitybobbity70 · 03/05/2024 09:26

I had 3 under 5, all older teens now & still close. Meant the frazzled yrs were over quicker, ready playmates on hand so lots of fun at home. Toilet training 1st was easy actually as still on mat leave & 6mth old was okay to be put down for spells while I focused on that, younger 2 were a breeze cos they wanted to copy everything the older one did! Tbh even night time routine was OK, DD had lovely bedtime stories read to her by her big brothers as they practiced their reading skills & snuggled up to their favourite girl.
I took a couple of yrs as sahm due to childcare costs (before any funded hours, count yourselves lucky ladies who know get 30hrs!) & due to our specific family circumstances at that time. But I was back working relatively quickly so lack of career progression was reduced. Don't think we could have managed with a longer fap between children, I certainly couldn't have gone back to sleepless nights if we'd waited longer.
Used to be common for smaller gaps so seems to be coming back

SometimesIDowonder · 03/05/2024 09:24

AlltheFs · 03/05/2024 09:10

It’s just attention seeking bollocks.

Really? I've never met someone with two under two thinking they're doing this for attention. Surely there are easier ways to get attention.

Though I do think sometimes there's an attitude of invincibility amongst some - thinking I can do this even though everyone says its tough.

DryIce · 03/05/2024 09:24

Really? Maybe it's confirmation bias but I had two 18 months apart, and all I heard was people telling me I was crazy for having 2 under 2 - not that it was the ideal!

Fwiw I have found it a lovely age gap, don't think I have been especially frazzled (well any more than any other parent of young children). But of course it is my only experience, maybe a 2 or 4 or 6 year gap would have been great it it's own way also

Fran91 · 03/05/2024 09:19

Not sure how it’s attention seeking and never knew I being judged for it!

I have a 22 MO gap and it’s great, hard work at times but then I think any gap would be imo! There’s 5 years between me and my sibling and DH has a range but I wanted to have two close together, nursery is financially doable for two so that wasn’t a consideration just wanted them close to get it over and done with so to speak and then be able to have the holidays we like to when they get to school age and can tolerate sight seeing more. Potty training has been ok and within two weeks was done, sleep is ok as the eldest is a good sleeper.

it’s perfect for us and I hate how judgy everyone is, it’s not attention seeking, it’s doing what’s right for your family whether that’s a small or larger age gap whether planned or not!

Boxerdor · 03/05/2024 09:19

My kids age gap is 3 years which seems to be a very common age gap with my friends and with their school mates. Worked well for us. I always wanted a really close gap because I have a big gap between me and my siblings and I hated it and always wished I had someone to play with. We couldn’t afford 2 in nursery at the same time though and to be honest I wasn’t able to even consider ttc again until ds was 18 months. Dh wasn’t ready to consider it until ds was 2. It worked out that ours have a 4 school year gap due to the eldest being august and the youngest being September so now I have a year 8 and a year 4. I would say there is no jealousy at all but possibly because they have very different interests. They don’t play together all the time but I know that even if they were twins they wouldn’t either- their personalities are so different with one who used to want to always play imaginary dress up play and one just wanting to play football. They do now play games on the Xbox together a lot which is lovely and most of the time get on well and laugh together- although they do of course have the odd fall out.

theres a lady who lives by me who has a 3 year old who is a pre school, a 2 year old and a baby. Just the walk to pre school with all of them looks exhausting.

BringMeSunshineAllDayLong · 03/05/2024 09:16

We wanted a 2.5 year gap but took us over a year to conceive our first. Thought it might be similar with the second and was still breastfeeding. One fucking shag later I was pregnant.
Now I love it as they are so close, share friends (DS1 went to a concert last night with DS2s schoolmate). We ended up having another one with a 3 year gap and it was a bit easier but a bit harder in finding them at different stages. There was a bit of jealousy and some hard times with fighting.
Now though they are all best friends and me and DH are mainly ignored 😁

Sdpbody · 03/05/2024 09:12

I truly hated the first 9 months of my first DD life. She NEVER slept. I said to my DH, I either get pregnant now and get this all out of the way, or I will never have a second. I was pregnant shortly after.

justlonelystars · 03/05/2024 09:10

Seems like madness to me. We were originally planning a 4 year age gap but DD will arrive when DS is 3 years 2 months old. He will have his 30 hours funding for nursery meaning he can still go whilst I’m on maternity leave, and will start school when DD starts at nursery, so financially it works well for me. I was 29 when I had DS and will be 32 when I have DD, and no issues with conceiving, so we did have time on our side when making our decision.

AlltheFs · 03/05/2024 09:10

It’s just attention seeking bollocks.

mondaytosunday · 03/05/2024 09:08

Childcare cost wasn't a consideration for me - it was more than my wage to have them both in all day nursery so fortunately my husband earned enough.
Two things: I got married at 40 so did not have the luxury of time;
And I have a sister two years older and one three years younger and that three year gap was much more noticeable. Two years and under and they are closer developmentally, in to the same sort of things (soft play etc). A bigger gap and harder to entertain them both together.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 03/05/2024 09:06

I had two under two - it broke me in some ways, but it was better in others. I had one young one on her own and yea gods was it relentless in a way it never was when I had the two at the one time!

SometimesIDowonder · 03/05/2024 09:06

Needanewjobsoon · 03/05/2024 08:36

@MJCadman it truly wasn't meant to be rude. I was thinking on a global scale as it was a WHO (world health) recommendation that there are many areas where contraception either isn't affordable/available or the knowledge isn't there.

Also a lack of awareness of toll on the mothers body/kids health that neuro diversity doctor mentioned.

Apologies if it came off rude.

Edited

Its not necessarily a lack of knowledge thing. I've seen more well educated and well off people do it. If you have your first in your late 30s and want two or three you need a small age gap.

MJCadman · 03/05/2024 08:53

Neurodiversitydoctor · 03/05/2024 08:01

Less than 2 years is associated with physical and mental health risks for the mother and child. Optimal age gap is described as 2-3 years by WHO

Where did you read this.

Littlesunshinemoon · 03/05/2024 08:48

Giraffesandbottoms · 03/05/2024 06:21

It works better IMO because they are closer in age and therefore the elder child doesn’t really remember life without the younger one - ergo much less jealousy. And then they play together and share more common ground early on.

its actually proven a bigger age gap is better, I think it’s approx 3 years?

SometimesIDowonder · 03/05/2024 08:45

I think its outdated. It made sense when women had to give up with young kids so they were getting it out of the way, two at once.

Also there weren't as many groups etc and parents didn't play with kids as much so it was how you got a playmate for your kid.

These days as nurseries are more prevelant but also more expensive and being raised as an only child for a bit isn't seen as spoilt, I see more 3-4 year age gaps.

We have a 5 year age gap - its wonderful.

LaWench · 03/05/2024 08:43

That would have been hell for me and I had 2 very easy babies and toddlers.

I have 4.5yrs between mine and it was perfect, lots of time with the youngest 1on1.

Doodahday88 · 03/05/2024 08:42

Yeah it’s BRUTAL… I think it’s taken me 10 years to recover! I did have one autistic child of the pair (unbeknownst to me at the time) which definitely made it harder.

MJCadman · 03/05/2024 08:42

I meant the contraceptives bit. If that wast the case my kids would be closer in age. I got pregnant within 1-3 months. If I had a 3rd it could take a year. You just don't know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread