Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what jobs the government are expecting people to get?

79 replies

Nosleepforthismum · 02/05/2024 23:12

Following on from the many, many threads about this. I’m genuinely wondering what jobs the government are expecting people who claim disability benefits to do, specifically those suffering with their mental health? From an employers perspective, it would be very difficult to run a successful business with an employee that took a lot of time off work. You’d need a job that had no deadlines and didn’t need a physical presence and I can’t think of many jobs off the top of my head.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lindy2 · 28/11/2024 09:02

I'm worried for my DD16. She has ADHD and ASD as well as other stuff going on such as emotional disregulation.

I don't know what job she would be able to do. Hopefully there is something. It would very likely need to be part time. She would need a supportive and flexible employer though and they are a rarity.

If there were more flexible jobs available then that would help people with disabilities and also working parents. Unfortunately we still have a full time, long hours culture and I don't really see that changing regardless of Government initiatives.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 28/11/2024 08:25

@Nat6999

Do you find the b12 helpful?

My dd has endometriosis and is always exhausted. I wonder if it may help. Thank you

Nat6999 · 27/11/2024 01:26

Brainded · 03/05/2024 07:32

@Nat6999 some of those conditions are very much treatable…I think if you can have kids and run a house with those conditions then a part time job would suffice. Unless I’m wrong and you don’t have kids/run a house. I find working easier than being at home to be fair. I also have an underactive thyroid, polycystic ovaries (which can cause pain at times of the month), tachycardia, high blood pressure, adhd. All except the adhd are managed with meds, the adhd I have learned to manage myself. I’m not saying this is the same for you, I’m aware we are all different….

I self inject B12, who would employ me when I don't know from one day to the next how well I can be? You say all my conditions are treatable, I wish they were, I've been under the hospital & various clinics for 14 years & I'm no further forwards. You say looking after kids & running a home prove I can work at least part time, ds has been my carer for the last 8 years, it takes me 2 hours to manage to get up, do my meds, get washed & dressed, I haven't been outside my home for over 2 years. I have to have a cleaner to manage my home, I live on convenience food because I can't stand up long enough to prepare a meal & can't peel or chop ingredients due to having numb hands & fingers, I'm often asleep again within 3 hours of waking up & I'm only out of bed maybe 7 hours a day. My memory is rubbish, I can't retain information so learning anything new is out of the question, I have terrible social anxiety so anything involving people is out, I wet myself a lot. If the DWP agree I'm not fit for work, what makes you think I can work? I worked for 27 years before being finished due to ill health & the amount of time I was off sick, not because I didn't want to work.

Papyrophile · 26/11/2024 21:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Roundandroundthegard3n · 04/05/2024 23:04

Hereyoume · 04/05/2024 21:27

Well you aren't in charge of the benefit system.

Um.. yes. Good spot well done. Neither are you, thank fuck.

Hereyoume · 04/05/2024 21:27

Roundandroundthegard3n · 03/05/2024 09:46

Same.

Well you aren't in charge of the benefit system.

Hereyoume · 04/05/2024 21:26

BubziOwl · 03/05/2024 09:42

Seeing someone with one arm struggling through manual labour and thinking "yes, that's how disabled people should live" is just simply incompatible with my belief system.

And paying endless amounts of tax payers money on benefits is incompatible to others belief systems.

But seeing as the others are paying, there may not be much choice.

OriginalUsername2 · 03/05/2024 12:07

TheTartfulLodger · 03/05/2024 09:42

Can you give some examples of the far more WFH jobs please?

Yes, please do link some.

AlizeeEasy · 03/05/2024 11:53

It’s an utterly cruel thing to put people through, the stress alone for disabled people and those with MH issues would be unbearable. If you can work and you are keen to work then absolutely support systems should be in place to help you, but for so many work is just something that is unrealistic.

I know multiple people who would love to work, make good money , not struggle everyday. They aren’t lazy or entitled, but they just can’t do it. One person has complex physical issues and one friend has severe mental health issues, though she is actively looking for work it has to be flexible and low stress.

why can’t we focus more on getting people who want to work back in the workforce rather than demonising people who can’t

HelpIneedaworktop · 03/05/2024 11:42

MattDamon · 03/05/2024 11:16

Taking phone calls all day is taking phone calls all day.

People need to stop being so unrealistic.

I 100% agree that people need to stop being so unrealistic as to say that people with MH issues can’t work.

But I do think taking phone calls all day might not work well for someone with anxiety.

The role I did in my recovery was gardening. That was excellent for me. Not overstimulated. Not under stimulated. Fresh air, sunlight and exercise. Some minor social interaction with normal people but not too much. A degree of flexibility. Really it was absolutely perfect and so good for my mental health.

PassingStranger · 03/05/2024 11:27

ATerrorofLeftovers · 02/05/2024 23:17

They don’t expect them to get jobs, they merely need the rhetoric as cover to be able to pull the rug out from under people who are already suffering. .

This, they know they won't.

MattDamon · 03/05/2024 11:16

Hermittrismegistus · 03/05/2024 10:40

100%. Most people with mental health issues will likely struggle. Imagine having such overwhelming anxiety that you can barely leave the house, then being forced to speak to a hundred people a day on the phone. It's not feasible.

It depends on the role. Taking calls from virgin media customers would probably be a no, taking calls to book appointments for housing repairs or some of the DWP lines could be a yes.

People need to stop being so defeatist.

Taking phone calls all day is taking phone calls all day.

People need to stop being so unrealistic.

Magicpaintbrush · 03/05/2024 11:00

If you already have a job when you fall ill and they are able to make things flexible for you around your illness then brilliant, that means you can work around your illness - however I suspect it's a very different situation to be job hunting from scratch when you have a long term illness, both in terms of finding a job that is flexible enough to suit from day 1, but also because potential employers might be put off (even if they say otherwise). Employers shouldn't descriminate but I bet they do. If you already have employment and a supportive employer then that's a head start already if you fall ill and need to adjust your hours or working conditions.

Bibnle636 · 03/05/2024 10:58

Hermittrismegistus · 03/05/2024 10:40

100%. Most people with mental health issues will likely struggle. Imagine having such overwhelming anxiety that you can barely leave the house, then being forced to speak to a hundred people a day on the phone. It's not feasible.

It depends on the role. Taking calls from virgin media customers would probably be a no, taking calls to book appointments for housing repairs or some of the DWP lines could be a yes.

People need to stop being so defeatist.

There is nothing defeatist about my daughter. She has battled more the past few years than many do in a lifetime. She is being told by highly qualified professionals that to get well and avoid crisis she needs to be aware of her emotions/ struggles and reach out more to professionals be kinder to herself, pull back and be more aware of her needs and struggles NOT battle on regardless until she reaches overwhelm which is what has lead to crisis over and again.

This is exactly the big concern. People who are ignorant re ND and MH and know nothing about individual cases telling very ill people what they should and shouldn’t do. It’s hugely dangerous.

Hermittrismegistus · 03/05/2024 10:40

100%. Most people with mental health issues will likely struggle. Imagine having such overwhelming anxiety that you can barely leave the house, then being forced to speak to a hundred people a day on the phone. It's not feasible.

It depends on the role. Taking calls from virgin media customers would probably be a no, taking calls to book appointments for housing repairs or some of the DWP lines could be a yes.

People need to stop being so defeatist.

Baconisdelicious · 03/05/2024 10:22

In the UK, he could simply sign on benefits and not work, as he is disabled, and the thought of a one-armed tyre fitter would give the Health and Safety guy at Halfords a coronary

Just so I'm clear...you think that someone with one arm would be able to claim disability benefits and never work?

MattDamon · 03/05/2024 10:11

Bibnle636 · 03/05/2024 06:08

Like people people with autism my autistic daughter finds using the phone incredibly hard.

100%. Most people with mental health issues will likely struggle. Imagine having such overwhelming anxiety that you can barely leave the house, then being forced to speak to a hundred people a day on the phone. It's not feasible.

Darhon · 03/05/2024 09:55

Roundandroundthegard3n · 03/05/2024 07:42

If you have zero understanding of how to use Microsoft office applications, who is going to train you?

They are fairly intuitive systems. Everyone in their 40s and older were digital adopters and did not grow up with these systems and had to learn them, usually with no explicit training. Excel is trickier. If you’re under 40 though, you should have word processes things and most 20 somethings are digital natives.

Darhon · 03/05/2024 09:52

Lots of people work with mental health conditions, some of them with significant ones. Though I think some jobs are more flexible than others and make adjustments. So it’s a difficult balance.

HelpIneedaworktop · 03/05/2024 09:50

SummerFeverVenice · 03/05/2024 09:39

You don’t think good MH care or luck had anything to do with the speed of your recovery or the absence of a relapse?

Also PIP is not an out of work benefit, going on PIP doesn’t mean you’d be stuck at home on benefits your entire life

Edited

Yes of course. It’s a combination of everything. The nhs was incredibly good for me. They really threw the kitchen sink at me. I feel bad as I know others didn’t get similar care from what I heard in the wards. I think that was privilege. A white, middle class masters educated woman. They said it themselves. You shouldn’t be here. But I was. And the stats were really not in my favour.

I do believe work was incredibly important too. I don’t think I would have been recovered without it. I was still borderline psychotic when I took that role and it gave me structure and stability to recover properly and reassimilate into normal life.

Roundandroundthegard3n · 03/05/2024 09:46

BubziOwl · 03/05/2024 09:42

Seeing someone with one arm struggling through manual labour and thinking "yes, that's how disabled people should live" is just simply incompatible with my belief system.

Same.

BubziOwl · 03/05/2024 09:42

Hereyoume · 03/05/2024 08:57

If there were no benefits, what would you do?

That's the basis of this policy.

I saw a TicTok recently of a one armed tyre fitter in Hyderabad, India. His channel is all about how he manages to do the work, even though he is disabled. He does these TicToks where he works against the clock, timing how fast he can change a tyre.

In the UK, he could simply sign on benefits and not work, as he is disabled, and the thought of a one-armed tyre fitter would give the Health and Safety guy at Halfords a coronary.

I'm NOT suggesting the above as a serious proposition.

However, the Government is looking at what people can do, not what they can't.

Seeing someone with one arm struggling through manual labour and thinking "yes, that's how disabled people should live" is just simply incompatible with my belief system.

TheTartfulLodger · 03/05/2024 09:42

Meadowfinch · 03/05/2024 01:14

Since covid, there are far more work-from-home jobs that may suit people who have different issues.

For example, during covid, I underwent chemotherapy. There were days when I slept at lunchtimes and days when I struggled to pull a thought process together but because I could work my own hours through a week, I was able to make it work.

For those who have some forms of anxiety or agoraphobia, wfh may work well.

Can you give some examples of the far more WFH jobs please?

SummerFeverVenice · 03/05/2024 09:39

HelpIneedaworktop · 03/05/2024 09:37

I don’t know. I had a bad psychosis late 20s. Typical presentation of schizophrenia. I was sectioned. Really the odds were against me. It was textbook.

Do you know a major contributing factor to getting it? Being out of work and having to much time to get lost in rabbit holes. And a major contributor to now 5 years later being med free and having beat 99% of that stats that say I should be a schizophrenic right now… getting back to work. I was still borderline psychotic when I started that role. But I faked it until I made it and it did work.

They would have put me on pip. I could have been unemployed and supported for the rest of my life. And what a shit life that would have been.

You don’t think good MH care or luck had anything to do with the speed of your recovery or the absence of a relapse?

Also PIP is not an out of work benefit, going on PIP doesn’t mean you’d be stuck at home on benefits your entire life

HelpIneedaworktop · 03/05/2024 09:37

I don’t know. I had a bad psychosis late 20s. Typical presentation of schizophrenia. I was sectioned. Really the odds were against me. It was textbook.

Do you know a major contributing factor to getting it? Being out of work and having to much time to get lost in rabbit holes. And a major contributor to now 5 years later being med free and having beat 99% of that stats that say I should be a schizophrenic right now… getting back to work. I was still borderline psychotic when I started that role. But I faked it until I made it and it did work.

They would have put me on pip. I could have been unemployed and supported for the rest of my life. And what a shit life that would have been.