Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To de-arrange the funeral?

255 replies

Funeraldilemma1 · 02/05/2024 16:16

NC but reg poster.

An old person I’ll call Sam recently died. They were the parent of someone I’ll call Bob. Bob was severely neglected by Sam right from birth - his practical needs like feeding and washing not attended to with neighbours having to step in, frequently told he was unwanted, banned from the house if Sam had “company” over, I believe Bob spent some time in care but was never removed from Sam’s custody. They went NC around 30 years ago.

Sam has never acknowledged Bob’s existence. Gleefully told Bob he’d been written out of the will. Now they’ve died, some of the admin has fallen to a relative of Bob, as Bob can’t handle having any involvement due to lasting trauma. The relative has ascertained there may not be a will, and is going to deal with the admin and paperwork. Relative has been informed by friends of Sam that Sam wished for a lavish funeral, and had lots of local friends who liked them and want to attend a funeral, but these people never knew Sam had a child as they completely denied Bob’s existence. Sam’s friends have no idea of the abuse and neglect Bob endured.

Bob and his relative are not willing to arrange a funeral. They have said they don’t intend to carry out Sam’s wishes and want to cancel any pre-arranged plans Sam may have made. Friends of Sam feel this is cruel and they should “be the bigger people”. As there’s no will, Bob is legal next of kin so in a procedural sense he does have the final say but who is BU?

OP posts:
PigletJohn · 03/05/2024 12:13

It's unclear what has been prepaid. There's no gain to anyone in refusing to use a prepaid burial. It would just be vindictive.

But Bob is under no obligation to attend or to arrange anything extra.

Funeraldilemma1 · 03/05/2024 12:12

Needanewname42 · 03/05/2024 11:58

I do think the funeral could stir emotions in Bob.
So using the plot that's already been paid for might be better in that Sam's wishes are carried out and theirs no question over what to do with ashes.

Some on the thread are treating the body like a bit of trash.
Bob still needs to be able to live with decisions made. Not just now but for the rest of his life.

Bob would happily chuck the body in landfill if it was down to him and I don’t blame him. We’re still ascertaining if there’s a valid will. If there is, we’re going to let the executors deal with everything and step away completely. If not, we’ll be selling the burial plot and doing a direct cremation.

OP posts:
Needanewname42 · 03/05/2024 11:58

MeTooOverHere · 03/05/2024 09:40

I recall a story of a woman whose abusive mother died across the country. She and her husband drove over for the service and cremation and headed for home again with the ashes. On the way she began crying. He asked what was wrong and she said she didn't want her mother's ashes in their home but she was an only child and didn't know what else to do with them. He knew about the abusive mother and the miserable childhood. So he stopped the car, took the urn, walked off the carriageway and down the slope to the bottom where there was a small stagnant pool. He emptied the ashes there, and took the urn back to the car and they drove off.

My husband's ashes, half of them anyway, are buried with one of his beloved cats in our backyard garden. The other half is here for when his other cat passes away.

Lots of options.

I do think the funeral could stir emotions in Bob.
So using the plot that's already been paid for might be better in that Sam's wishes are carried out and theirs no question over what to do with ashes.

Some on the thread are treating the body like a bit of trash.
Bob still needs to be able to live with decisions made. Not just now but for the rest of his life.

MeTooOverHere · 03/05/2024 09:43

crockofshite · 02/05/2024 21:05

Or cremate Sam, scatter the ashes, sell the burial plot to pay for the cremation.

Oh yes!!!!

MeTooOverHere · 03/05/2024 09:40

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 03/05/2024 06:20

We've just arranged a direct cremation for a relative who wanted one.

We've been told it could be 12 weeks before we get the ashes back. Which is fine.

But it struck me that if you have a similar time frame with Sam these 'friends' will have probably buggered off by the time that rolls around.

Absolutely the estate should do nothing less than is required by law, if that's just disposing of the body in a hygienic way, then that's what happens. Cremation's the cheapest and no need for anyone to be present or any sort of service at all.

I wouldn't use the burial plot either I don't think. Fuck Sam. Tbh I'd be tempted to send the ashes to landfill if Bob thinks that would be cathartic. Or use them for cat litter.

I recall a story of a woman whose abusive mother died across the country. She and her husband drove over for the service and cremation and headed for home again with the ashes. On the way she began crying. He asked what was wrong and she said she didn't want her mother's ashes in their home but she was an only child and didn't know what else to do with them. He knew about the abusive mother and the miserable childhood. So he stopped the car, took the urn, walked off the carriageway and down the slope to the bottom where there was a small stagnant pool. He emptied the ashes there, and took the urn back to the car and they drove off.

My husband's ashes, half of them anyway, are buried with one of his beloved cats in our backyard garden. The other half is here for when his other cat passes away.

Lots of options.

MeTooOverHere · 03/05/2024 09:30

PosyPrettyToes · 03/05/2024 06:32

No funeral at all, Bob donates body to science. Job done.

LOVE IT !!!!

AnnaMagnani · 03/05/2024 08:58

Not only is science fussy, you have to be signed up before you die.

NoBinturongsHereMate · 03/05/2024 08:46

PosyPrettyToes · 03/05/2024 06:32

No funeral at all, Bob donates body to science. Job done.

Science is very fussy. Most bodies are rejected.

WappityWabbit · 03/05/2024 08:44

Bob and friend should do the legal bare minimum and leave Sam’s friends to pay for their own party, if they so desire.

MissSookieStackhouse · 03/05/2024 08:22

Not being unreasonable at all. Let Sam’s mates arrange their own wake if they want to. Bob and other relatives don’t have to do anything they don’t want to in these circumstances.

Actually there is form in my family for friends doing something like this. When my Dad died, we only had immediate family at the funeral at my Mum’s request as she couldn’t face a big do at the time. My Dad’s mates did subsequently organise their own memorial/ wake a couple of months later, which I attended. So, my point being if Sam’s friends want to give him their own send off, there’s nothing stopping them. Bob shouldn’t be guilted into doing it. He can organise a ‘direct cremation’ - minimal cost, no fuss, no attendees.

chaticat · 03/05/2024 08:15

Funeraldilemma1 · 02/05/2024 17:00

Looks pretty unanimous so far! Thanks all. I am Bob’s relative. I fully support him, I have seen the effects of the trauma on Bob and Sam really was a horrendous woman. “De-arrange” was possibly not the correct wording, I don’t know if Sam pre paid for any funeral arrangements beyond reserving a burial plot.

In that case then use the plot and anything already paid for. Nothing else

chaticat · 03/05/2024 08:14

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 02/05/2024 22:13

I'd fake a will and donate Sam to medical science so she can be of some use to someone.

Or the bodyworlds people

bodyworlds.com/plastination/bodydonation/

That's isn't how it works. You can't just fake a will

Motomum23 · 03/05/2024 08:14

It's totally irrelevant what Sam's wishes were - these are presumably 2nd hand accounts of that and not detailed on paper. If I were Bob I would cancel all but the minimum legal requirement and get on with my life.

Uricon2 · 03/05/2024 08:09

Donating a body to science has to be officially arranged in advance of death, by the person concerned and even if that's in place, there is no guarantee it will be accepted when the time comes (factors such as cause of death, etc)

TeaMistress · 03/05/2024 07:52

If the supporting relative can ascertain whether there was a prepaid funeral plan then any arrangements made can go ahead. Neither the supporting relative or Bob should get involved or attend. If no prepaid plan then the supporting relative could arrange the cheapest direct cremation possible and the bill can be paid from Sam's estate and the ashes scattered. If Sam's "friends" wish to organise and pay for a wake that's fine but Bob and relative need not be involved.

Woohow · 03/05/2024 07:19

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 02/05/2024 19:47

I should have said "memorial" or "party". No idea what happens in terms of decisions about actual funerary arrangements. Wouldn't the LA pay for it if the NOK didn't want to spend the money on it?

It's the dead person that pays for their own funeral, the LA will only take over if there are no assets. And the funeral comes first before any debtors are paid.

It sounds like Sam had assets. Bob should do a direct cremation and ask the crematorium to dispose of the ashes any way they wish.

Willmafrockfit · 03/05/2024 07:02

Floralnomad · 02/05/2024 16:22

I’d have a direct cremation , if Sam’s friends want a big knees up they can have a memorial at their own cost .

good plan

Beautiful3 · 03/05/2024 06:48

I'd do a direct cremation and give it to the mates. I wouldn't want to be organising it at all. If it's already been paid for then ring up the company and ask them to sort it all out with a nominated mate if the deceased, at no extra cost.

Brefugee · 03/05/2024 06:34

Octavia64 · 02/05/2024 16:18

Bob and his relative are not being U in the slightest.

I wouldn't be arranging a big knees up to celebrate someone who had abused me.

If sam's friends want a party they can organise their own!

Are the friends on glue? Bob & relativeshould ignore them. If pressed tell them to do it themselves.

PosyPrettyToes · 03/05/2024 06:32

No funeral at all, Bob donates body to science. Job done.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 03/05/2024 06:20

We've just arranged a direct cremation for a relative who wanted one.

We've been told it could be 12 weeks before we get the ashes back. Which is fine.

But it struck me that if you have a similar time frame with Sam these 'friends' will have probably buggered off by the time that rolls around.

Absolutely the estate should do nothing less than is required by law, if that's just disposing of the body in a hygienic way, then that's what happens. Cremation's the cheapest and no need for anyone to be present or any sort of service at all.

I wouldn't use the burial plot either I don't think. Fuck Sam. Tbh I'd be tempted to send the ashes to landfill if Bob thinks that would be cathartic. Or use them for cat litter.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 03/05/2024 06:10

Cheapest coffin, no flowers, just a direct burial. Her friends can pay their own respects and organise a wake. It’s a wonder she has any friends if she was like that. I know they don’t realise that but people usually show their true colours at some point!

bloodyplumbing · 03/05/2024 06:02

Friends of Sam feel this is cruel and they should “be the bigger people”. As there’s no will, Bob is legal next of kin so in a procedural sense he does have the final say but who is BU?

Why the fuck do people think you become an angel when you die?

Bob should arrange the least he can as low key as possible, he also does not need to attend.

No wake required.

Poettree · 03/05/2024 05:49

Sounds like Sam's friends want a nice pre-paid piss up.
Definitely don't spend much - a dignified send off but no celebration of life is more than enough.
I'm glad Bob is next of kin and will hopefully inherit the money and use it to make his life better.

MrsMacGyver · 03/05/2024 05:35

Let the friends organise and pay for what they feel Sam deserves. Sam deserves nothing from Bob.