Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to praise the police - London sword attack

139 replies

boozeclues · 30/04/2024 21:46

I have just watched the footage of some very young police officers who detained the man in London today wielding a sword. Not only had he already killed a child, he was determine to kill anyone he met.

The video I watched is here: https://news.sky.com/video/share-13126428

These are mainly very young officers, not wearing much protection (e.g. their whole heads and faces are exposed), and not many of the people in the video can be more than 20 to 30 years old.

Truly heroic IMO. They all deserve a medal. The police bashing in this country also has to stop, we are not America, most of our police force is full of people who want to protect the public, bad management, lack of funding and politics aside.

I am also truly very sad for the young boy who lost his life today and his family, I hope they know the whole country is mourning their loss and want to support them.

Hainault: Moment sword attack suspect tasered and arrested

Dramatic footage shows the moment police tasered and arrested a 36-year-old man after a stabbing attack in northeast London.

https://news.sky.com/video/share-13126428

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sashagabadon · 02/05/2024 10:21

NeelyOHara1 · 01/05/2024 20:09

YANBU. Highlighting credit where credit is due is important as a counter balance to what can often seem to be a constant drip feed of negativity towards eg. police, politicians, social workers etc as otherwise the good ones will continue to get discouraged and leave!

Hear hear! I completely agree , counter balances to the constant negative portrayal of the police is very much needed.

NOTANUM · 02/05/2024 08:55

This thread has also made me feel sad @boozeclues . Such criticism of a police force which isn’t even armed. Not all Met police even have Tasers.

Never mind that we have barely mentioned the boy who died, a young man whose school, community and church say was an absolute gem. We aren’t talking about the injured police or how much worse it could have been. We are talking about how the police hesitated in the face of extreme violence.

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/05/2024 07:44

OneTC · Yesterday 14:04
FFS!! Can we not just have one thread where we can discuss how brave all those police officers were yesterday.

Start one.
**
This thread is about how you shouldn't criticise the police”

Is it? I don’t think so. That’s what it’s become. Don’t think that’s what OP intended?

boozeclues · 01/05/2024 20:35

Just catching up, didn’t have the emotional capacity to read through the replies today.

My intention was to never to start a debate on the overall condition of the police force in this country, hence my “America” comment in my op, who have, IMO ,much greater systemic problems in their police forces.

It’s been heartbreaking to read about some of the injuries sustained today, a female officer nearly lost her hand.

And for the pp, yes they are doing their jobs, but they get very little compensation for it! What is it like £28k avg per annum for an officer? That is mental, front line officers are clearly not in the job for money or power.

Really interesting reading different perspectives, but can we just make this thread about supporting the vast majority of our police force please xx

OP posts:
NeelyOHara1 · 01/05/2024 20:09

YANBU. Highlighting credit where credit is due is important as a counter balance to what can often seem to be a constant drip feed of negativity towards eg. police, politicians, social workers etc as otherwise the good ones will continue to get discouraged and leave!

PostItInABook · 01/05/2024 20:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TotteringonGently · 01/05/2024 19:49

MariaLuna · 01/05/2024 02:56

They're just another gang.

To me seeing the footage on BBC he seemed to be a loner.

How terrifying, that poor child and his family. Devastating.

Also the others who were stabbed.

Yes, the police were brilliant.

I agree though, where the fuck can an ordinary citizen get hold of a weapon like that?!

The internet. Freely available with a quick google. It's a massive problem.

Iwasafool · 01/05/2024 19:41

Workhardcryharder · 01/05/2024 19:02

Because my friend needs to bloody decompress after constantly traumatising events.

Nothing she tells me is identifying info.

Maybe you should contact everyone that’s ever written a book about their time in the emergency services and have a pop at them too.

Now bore off

She needs to decompress with her colleagues who were at the same event. It is wrong to discuss it with you.

Workhardcryharder · 01/05/2024 19:33

ElatedShark · 01/05/2024 19:23

It's not infrequent though, just doesn't make it to the media.

And yes I know for a FACT without outing myself as to how. The stories I could tell.

Anyway my thoughts are with the child that was brutally murdered on his way to school by a thug. Sending his parents and loved ones my condolences and love.

Glad the police were eventually able to stop him, curious to see how long he gets in prison.

And yet they are still a drop in the ocean compared to all the good….. I’m sure you know better than anyone else though

ElatedShark · 01/05/2024 19:23

Workhardcryharder · 01/05/2024 19:16

Yes instead let’s cherry pick the incredibly infrequent bad things they do and judge them based on that! 🙄

It's not infrequent though, just doesn't make it to the media.

And yes I know for a FACT without outing myself as to how. The stories I could tell.

Anyway my thoughts are with the child that was brutally murdered on his way to school by a thug. Sending his parents and loved ones my condolences and love.

Glad the police were eventually able to stop him, curious to see how long he gets in prison.

Workhardcryharder · 01/05/2024 19:16

Dotjones · 01/05/2024 12:23

I don't think we should praise them too much or let this one incident improve our perception of them. Bad people can sometimes do the right thing, but it doesn't stop them being bad people. Wayne Couzens sometimes arrested criminals and sometimes protected the public. That didn't stop him abducting and murdering sometone though. He was still a bad person.

We should remember to judge the police by how they behave as a group at all times, not just cherry pick occasional incidents where they just get on with doing a job that can be difficult at times. (It's the same with other groups like nurses, Lucy Letby for instance helped some patients some of the time, but was convicted recently for some abhorrent offences.)

Yes instead let’s cherry pick the incredibly infrequent bad things they do and judge them based on that! 🙄

Workhardcryharder · 01/05/2024 19:02

PostItInABook · 01/05/2024 12:45

Why is your friend telling you information about the injuries suffered by a victim of crime?

Because my friend needs to bloody decompress after constantly traumatising events.

Nothing she tells me is identifying info.

Maybe you should contact everyone that’s ever written a book about their time in the emergency services and have a pop at them too.

Now bore off

Iwasafool · 01/05/2024 18:00

Delatron · 01/05/2024 17:02

Yes I was wondering what was happening as one police officer was shoving another towards him after the initial taser.

They were very brave (particularly the police woman who walked towards him and tasered him). She was so calm as she was radioing in at the same time as tasering. I sensed less hesitation from her than the others. It was a bit frantic afterwards. Understandable but I guess there is a protocol that needs to happen.

He was tasered 3 times, he was shoved towards him after the third taser. I can't see the rank of the one shouting. The female officer walking towards him fired the third taser.

Treelichen · 01/05/2024 17:12

plominoagain · 01/05/2024 15:29

So , please elaborate as to what you think they should have done ? You know , with your vast experience of highly fluid , stressed fast paced environments involving armed individuals who have already badly injured your colleagues ?

Do you know that these days , apart from the supervisory ranks , most officers on the street have less than 5 years service . Five years . I am a complete exception , but I've been the oldest in terms of service on my team for nearly 10 years now.

When you deal with an incident like that, it's not like bloody tv . It's highly fluid . It's unpredictable, and it's messy . Taser, whilst a really good bit of kit , is not infallible. I've known it to fail , quite a bit . Pava doesn't always work, and has a habit of incapacitating everyone including officers . Extendable baton works , but you have to get within his striking range which is highly dangerous.

So. He gets tasered and goes down, still in possession of that sword . Still got to get it off him ( I had a colleague stabbed twice in the calf trying to do just that with someone detained in the floor) The amount of adrenaline running is still going , and now you have to detain him safely without injury to him either . Of course it sounds confusing . It bloody well is , because it's real life, not the sodding Bill .

Some of those officers will still be in their probation. For some it may be the first really ( and I mean REALLY) serious incident in their service . And yet they still went forward despite knowing their colleagues had been hurt, and knowing the limitations of their kit .

I agree the lack of experienced officers is an issue. I agree that pava isn’t great either and sometimes does more harm than good. My issue with this was after the initial take down with the tasers, there was some hesitancy where decisive action was required. Probably due to lack of experience like you say but good control and restraint training should mean that this stuff is automatic.

It wasn’t bad but could have been better. Every incident is a learning experience.

Delatron · 01/05/2024 17:02

Treelichen · 01/05/2024 16:45

I was a control and restraint trainer for many years for both the police, prison service and forensic environments. Yes I have disarmed individuals and I have been stabbed twice over a 30 year career.
so I’ll break it down: initial contact and use of tasers was good. There was hesitation about what to do next. What should have happened is the nearest officer who hadn’t deployed the taser should have disarmed the subject and restrained and then applied mechanical restraint(handcuffs). This part was delayed and the nearest officer had to be shoved and instructed by a colleague behind him. Not awful but it could have been a lot better. Tasers are not infallible and that hesitation could have allowed the subject to recover and become an instant threat.

Yes I was wondering what was happening as one police officer was shoving another towards him after the initial taser.

They were very brave (particularly the police woman who walked towards him and tasered him). She was so calm as she was radioing in at the same time as tasering. I sensed less hesitation from her than the others. It was a bit frantic afterwards. Understandable but I guess there is a protocol that needs to happen.

Treelichen · 01/05/2024 16:45

Runningbird43 · 01/05/2024 12:59

So how should they have done it?

Presumably you’re a serving officer or police trainer with experience of these situations and speak with expertise?

if not shut up. You know nothing.

it’s like the Nicola Bulley case, and the “paedophile hunters”. All armchair experts who know exactly what the police are, aren’t, should or shouldn’t be doing.

if you’re so great, join up and prove it. You run toward and armed murderer and do it better.

I was a control and restraint trainer for many years for both the police, prison service and forensic environments. Yes I have disarmed individuals and I have been stabbed twice over a 30 year career.
so I’ll break it down: initial contact and use of tasers was good. There was hesitation about what to do next. What should have happened is the nearest officer who hadn’t deployed the taser should have disarmed the subject and restrained and then applied mechanical restraint(handcuffs). This part was delayed and the nearest officer had to be shoved and instructed by a colleague behind him. Not awful but it could have been a lot better. Tasers are not infallible and that hesitation could have allowed the subject to recover and become an instant threat.

ThatRoseBear · 01/05/2024 16:11

AppleCrumbCake · 01/05/2024 00:34

yes the police did an amazing job with this murderer and deserve full acknowledgment, however this does not change the fact that the police are a mixed bag. It’s not just a case of a few bad leaders and underfunding, it’s misogyny and racism bred deep in to policing through every rank, drastically effecting the service they provide to women and how they treat women police officers.

Hopefully you understand that police officers are representative of society as that is where they are recruited from. Misogyny and racism do exist within policing, as they do within many organisations. Not all women will be unhappy with the service they have received and not all female police officers will have poor experiences.
It's really easy to generalise from the outside looking in when you are judging by what is reported via the media. There will be countless female victims that have also felt heard and supportive. Many female officers that are leading the changes. Ultimately front line officers leave the house every day with no certainty that they will return, emergency responders across the board are subjected to repeated trauma throughout their working lives. Would you do it?

NOTANUM · 01/05/2024 15:44

The young teenager who was killed has been named as Daniel Anjorin who looks like a boy any of us would be proud to call our son. It is sad beyond words.
Without the bravery of our police there could have been even more killed.
RIP Daniel

plominoagain · 01/05/2024 15:29

Treelichen · 01/05/2024 11:41

I’d have to disagree. Once the tasers had been deployed, they were a little clueless. There is no time to hesitate in situations like this.

So , please elaborate as to what you think they should have done ? You know , with your vast experience of highly fluid , stressed fast paced environments involving armed individuals who have already badly injured your colleagues ?

Do you know that these days , apart from the supervisory ranks , most officers on the street have less than 5 years service . Five years . I am a complete exception , but I've been the oldest in terms of service on my team for nearly 10 years now.

When you deal with an incident like that, it's not like bloody tv . It's highly fluid . It's unpredictable, and it's messy . Taser, whilst a really good bit of kit , is not infallible. I've known it to fail , quite a bit . Pava doesn't always work, and has a habit of incapacitating everyone including officers . Extendable baton works , but you have to get within his striking range which is highly dangerous.

So. He gets tasered and goes down, still in possession of that sword . Still got to get it off him ( I had a colleague stabbed twice in the calf trying to do just that with someone detained in the floor) The amount of adrenaline running is still going , and now you have to detain him safely without injury to him either . Of course it sounds confusing . It bloody well is , because it's real life, not the sodding Bill .

Some of those officers will still be in their probation. For some it may be the first really ( and I mean REALLY) serious incident in their service . And yet they still went forward despite knowing their colleagues had been hurt, and knowing the limitations of their kit .

Runningbird43 · 01/05/2024 15:21

NoisySnail · 01/05/2024 15:09

They are brave and successfully detained him.
But YABU talking about them as if they are children. They are adult men who are police officers.

Adult Men?

Iwasafool · 01/05/2024 15:18

Ofcourseshecan · 01/05/2024 13:54

And that’s all you can think of when you read about a woman’s hideous murder?

Not her suffering? or the evil of people who could do that? Or the stress suffered by those having to deal with the aftermath? Or even why the hell we have such feeble defences against these gangs?

Just that an attending officer shouldn’t have spoken about it. God almighty.

Well they shouldn't be discussing it, the victim should be respected not made the subject of gossip.

NoisySnail · 01/05/2024 15:09

They are brave and successfully detained him.
But YABU talking about them as if they are children. They are adult men who are police officers.

PostItInABook · 01/05/2024 14:55

Ofcourseshecan · 01/05/2024 13:54

And that’s all you can think of when you read about a woman’s hideous murder?

Not her suffering? or the evil of people who could do that? Or the stress suffered by those having to deal with the aftermath? Or even why the hell we have such feeble defences against these gangs?

Just that an attending officer shouldn’t have spoken about it. God almighty.

Don’t be ridiculous. Of course that’s not all I think about. I’m asking why that info which should be confidential is being shared. No the attending officer shouldn’t be speaking about it to friends. That’s what service / multidisciplinary team debriefs are for. It’s a disciplinary offence to share that kind of info with people that don’t need to know it. I don’t need to share my other thoughts and feelings about it to ask a simple fucking question so do one with your snidey shit.

therealcookiemonster · 01/05/2024 14:50

nonevernotever · 01/05/2024 08:00

Agreed. What stunned me yesterday is that samurai swords can be bought perfectly legally in the UK . The site I looked at talked about traditional craftsmanship and hand polishing etc but they're clearly still fucking swords.

I know it's not the point but these are not authentic katanas. it's been illegal to make katanas in Japan since the 1870s. anything made outside of Japan/not by a traditional swordsmith is not authentic. in this country it is illegal to carry these and other similar weapons unless you have a training license.

OneTC · 01/05/2024 14:04

FFS!! Can we not just have one thread where we can discuss how brave all those police officers were yesterday.

Start one.

This thread is about how you shouldn't criticise the police

Swipe left for the next trending thread