Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents and DH feud

637 replies

eveningqueen456 · 29/04/2024 21:51

I have been married for 20 years and have 2 children. My DH and parents have never really got on it goes back to a feud over our wedding plans 20 yrs ago - they had tolerated each other and come together for events and birthdays etc but there was always a horrible atmosphere when we are all together.

My parents are in their 70's but very young at heart and very active and enjoy nice holidays restaurants and going out and about with friends, my DH is very frugal and won't spend money on anything nice and gets very het up about their lifestyle.

It was my dad's 75th birthday 5 years ago and he wanted a meal at a really nice restaurant - he knew my DH wouldn't be ok with this so to make it fair he invited myself and my sister but neither of our partners or children. DH hated this as he felt my dad should have had a get together in the local brewers fayre so that he could have been included along with brother in law and all our children. Ever since then he has had nothing to do with them and won't have them in the house or let me even talk about them. For the first 15 yrs of our marriage things were always tense between us because I always felt on edge trying to keep the peace and be fair to both parents and DH when I knew they really didn't like each other and after the big meal fiasco 5 yrs ago things got better between me and my husband because he said the only way to move on was to never talk to him about them or expect him to have anything to do with them and it was ok - we rarely argued any more because all our arguments were usually about my parents.

5 yrs have gone on now and I am beginning to resent him for making me choose (which it feels like) although he has never expected me to not see them - only never see them when he is about or talk to him about them.

My DS is 18 this year and wants to have a party but DH refuses to be at his son's party if DS decides to invite them.

We could have 2 parties one for DH's family and one for mine but I just want them all to get on. AIBU to think my DH needs to get over it and just for one day tolerate them for the sake of our son?

OP posts:
justasking111 · 04/05/2024 13:40

SaintVitasShagulaitas · 04/05/2024 13:33

My dad was a bit like your DH. I didn't forgive him and I didn't forgive my mother for putting up with it.

This is my concern going forward

SaintVitasShagulaitas · 04/05/2024 13:33

My dad was a bit like your DH. I didn't forgive him and I didn't forgive my mother for putting up with it.

Covidwoes · 04/05/2024 10:02

This thread has made me really sad. The thought of the poor OP and her kids being stuck with this man who clearly wants to suck every ounce of joy from life is just, well, depressing.

Slinky40 · 04/05/2024 09:31

OP your husband is awful and this is NOT normal. You will regret the way he’s treated your lovely parents. Get out of this relationship where you seem to be submissive to his demands - he sounds like a petulant child and you let him get away with it.

justasking111 · 04/05/2024 08:15

I expect that @eveningqueen456 has a lot to think about and process. When you've had twenty years of attempted conditioning which you've resisted for yourself at times but otherwise fallen in with. You don't think ahead as to how it will affect your relationship with adult children, but that day does come and it's here now.

On mothers day my youngest was away. So a month later when they were all free, they took me out to dinner sans father. It was lovely he wasn't there to be honest because he'd have driven the conversation.

My eldest said to his face recently that he'd been very strict, husband honestly thought he was a laid back dad. If we had laid back times it was because I'd put my foot down.

Sceptical123 · 04/05/2024 06:19

OP won’t come back to this thread now bc she’ll have probably been expecting a lot of comments that advise her how to persuade her FH (FOUL husband) to swallow it for the day for the sake of their son. What she’s received however is 99-100% of posters telling her what a complete and utter shit he is and advising/telling her to leave him. Also criticising her for abandoning her parents by meekly falling into line on his say so. After 20 years she has probably convinced herself this is acceptable to some degree so she has been able to live with it, but 100’s of posters are telling her this is out of order and absurd, and warning her of the further damage it will likely wreak on her and her kids’ relationships in the future. If she doesn’t want to leave him there’s really nothing she can say which won’t be torn apart by attempting to defend him.

But it’s not too late OP - don’t let him ruin another 20 years for God’s sake! He will only get worse and you are allowing him to dictate yours and your children’s lives!

That’s not love.

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/05/2024 06:07

How can you better live with this man? How do you have any respect for yourself living with a man who is so awful to your parents?

Sceptical123 · 04/05/2024 05:58

eveningqueen456 · 29/04/2024 21:51

I have been married for 20 years and have 2 children. My DH and parents have never really got on it goes back to a feud over our wedding plans 20 yrs ago - they had tolerated each other and come together for events and birthdays etc but there was always a horrible atmosphere when we are all together.

My parents are in their 70's but very young at heart and very active and enjoy nice holidays restaurants and going out and about with friends, my DH is very frugal and won't spend money on anything nice and gets very het up about their lifestyle.

It was my dad's 75th birthday 5 years ago and he wanted a meal at a really nice restaurant - he knew my DH wouldn't be ok with this so to make it fair he invited myself and my sister but neither of our partners or children. DH hated this as he felt my dad should have had a get together in the local brewers fayre so that he could have been included along with brother in law and all our children. Ever since then he has had nothing to do with them and won't have them in the house or let me even talk about them. For the first 15 yrs of our marriage things were always tense between us because I always felt on edge trying to keep the peace and be fair to both parents and DH when I knew they really didn't like each other and after the big meal fiasco 5 yrs ago things got better between me and my husband because he said the only way to move on was to never talk to him about them or expect him to have anything to do with them and it was ok - we rarely argued any more because all our arguments were usually about my parents.

5 yrs have gone on now and I am beginning to resent him for making me choose (which it feels like) although he has never expected me to not see them - only never see them when he is about or talk to him about them.

My DS is 18 this year and wants to have a party but DH refuses to be at his son's party if DS decides to invite them.

We could have 2 parties one for DH's family and one for mine but I just want them all to get on. AIBU to think my DH needs to get over it and just for one day tolerate them for the sake of our son?

Leave him for the good of your current and future family. X

thebestinterest · 04/05/2024 05:17

Your husband sounds like a manchild. What a terribly sad life situation for you.

I don’t think I could have been with someone so easily ticked over nonsensical stuff. You say he didn’t expect you to chose, but he did and you did. The fact that you’ve gone about your life for 20yrs without being able to talk to your life partner about the people that gave you life is astounding. Truly, truly astounding.

Harry12345 · 03/05/2024 23:56

SloaneStreetVandal · 30/04/2024 09:29

I think you have a point.

I've read both of the OP's posts, and she describes her husband as frugal (maybe they're on a tight budget?). He wouldn't be my cup of tea, but the hysteria about him being an abuser and a bully is quite something!

It's interesting too that most have decided that the OP's Dad excluding his grandson from his 75th birthday meal was entirely acceptable in order to keep the peace, but the OP's Dad being excluded in order to keep the peace is tantamount to murder! Maybe the husband is annoyed on his son's behalf? It's almost certain that there is more to the story than has been described. Personally I think @eveningqueen456 needs to let it go, and just accept that they don't get along.

But the grandad would be happy for his sil to come if he came along happily, clearly over the years he hasn’t and thinks he can dictate where the grandad has his birthday, the husband doesn’t want to include grandad full stop! Your post makes absolutely no sense

Bluewater1 · 03/05/2024 23:39

I'm sorry OP but your DH sounds just awful. I would honestly seriously consider leaving him. He is controlling and miserable and is making life harder.

Codlingmoths · 03/05/2024 23:34

I hope the ops parents are at her house now , having had a lovely dinner with op and the grandchildren, and her Dh has taken himself out of the house to sulk like the judgemental teenager he is.

Yalta · 03/05/2024 22:38

I have known a couple of women who were married to tight fisted men.

One died in a work related accident and his wife blew through the compensation and all his savings accounts within a year. Her house became party central as she made up for lost time

The other was a much older woman. When her miserable tight fisted husband (who didn’t believe in banks and paid for everything from money made from his cash only business) had a stroke.
He was put in a home and she ripped the house apart pulling up floorboards, taking the backs off paintings and ripping open mattresses. She even got someone to blow his safe.
There was money everywhere

What I can tell you about these men was for all their controlling behaviour and careful savings through complete meanness, when it came down to it. No one shed a tear over them.
It was just a huge relief when they died

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 03/05/2024 22:29

Scottsy200 · 03/05/2024 19:54

So he wanted you to have a shit wedding when you were being offered the one of your dreams and he wanted your mum to give up work so he wouldn’t have to pay for childcare, wow red flags a plenty with this one

I can't believe the level of cheeky fuckery and entitlement in this alone its madness the husband is away with the fairies no wonder the OP's family don't like him, he looks down on them, is rude and treats them and the OP like shit and then gets pissed off his MIL didn't give up her job to save him paying for childcare! Utterly batshit crazy logic and extremely entitled god I couldn't bare a man like that to touch me his personality is so unattractive I'd rather be celibate.

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 03/05/2024 22:17

I can't believe what I've actually read my jaw will remain on the floor for while!

@eveningqueen456 your husband has more red flags than a bloody Communist party meeting! He sounds like a massive snob and a hateful, controlling childish cunt! Having a sulk because he couldn't dictate where your dad held his own bloody birthday!

OP never mind about him leaving you kick his tight fisted arse out the door why on earth are you still with this man he basically wants to control how, when, where, what and cost they spend its none of his fucking business for a start HE ISN'T PAYING FOR THEIR LIFESTYLE so your parents can live and spend how they want!

Even tantruming over the wedding ffs he wasn't paying for it that was incredibly generous of your parents no wonder they don't like him he rudely threw their generousity back in their faces and insulted them because he doesn't agree with their lifestyle. Its madness.

Your husband is also a massive cheeky and entitled fucker he treats your parents like shit, looks his nose down at them and gets angry because THEY LIKE TO SPEND THEIR MONEY and thinks he's entitled to them providing free childcare for him!!! He's absolutely fucking crazy, taking the piss and overall a selfish miserable cunt!

Regarding your sons birthday why do you want him there seething because of the cost that he isn't even covering? And all because your parents are there. Its nuts tell him he doesn't have to come and he isn't wanted because he spoils the evening with his hateful and incredibly rude behaviour and the same with your dad's birthday. Tell your dad to do and invite whoever he likes and if H goes mad he wasn't invited point out to him that rightly your father wants to enjoy his birthday and doesn't want H there because he's nasty hateful and rude.

You can't behave like a cunt and then be pissed off the people you treat badly don't want you around and your dad can't win anyway unless he allows your H to dictate it all. Either way your H would still complain and get angry so stop pandering to him and enjoy your celebrations.

Throw him out OP and start enjoying your life without that miserable fuckwit dragging you down find a man who isn't so tight and unpleasant. I couldn't ever find a man like that attractive just the description of your husband makes me wanna puke.

TheAlchemy · 03/05/2024 21:27

I cannot get over the fact a grown man has spent 5 years sulking that he didn’t get to go to a Brewers Fayre. LTB. You only get one life and this is a beyond grim way to spend it.

fuckssaaaaake · 03/05/2024 21:14

Bloody hell I can't stand my in laws but they would never know and I try my best to not let me husband know either as unless something REALLY bad has happened then it's not fair to make them feel that way. Your husband sucks a bit .

PensionedCruiser · 03/05/2024 21:12

SpeedyDrama · 29/04/2024 22:06

there was always a horrible atmosphere when we are all together.

Well of course there is, your husband is Scrooge - sucking the life and fun out of any event that cost more than a half penny and tap water it seems. Why on earth have you let him get away with being such a miser about your parents way of enjoying themselves? He genuinely thought he had a right to dictate where your dad had his birthday meal and has sulked since? Honestly I don’t see how you find this man attractive, especially now foot stomping about his own son’s birthday.

I can’t believe you’re actually considering two parties to placate him, a supposed grown man who the party isn’t even for. One party, either he comes or he doesn’t. Stop the pandering, your parents and son deserve more respect.

What are you going to do if your children get married? Have 2 weddings?

Noseybookworm · 03/05/2024 20:04

Your husband sounds very judgemental. I couldn't live with someone who felt like that about my parents, it would be a deal breaker for me.

Scottsy200 · 03/05/2024 19:54

So he wanted you to have a shit wedding when you were being offered the one of your dreams and he wanted your mum to give up work so he wouldn’t have to pay for childcare, wow red flags a plenty with this one

Scottsy200 · 03/05/2024 19:52

Your husband sounds like d!ck and if he treated my parents that way i wouldn’t have taken long to make my decision and choose them over him

DeeCeeCherry · 03/05/2024 19:41

I reckon the DH has £££ so OP isnt going anywhere. Again - she said she likes her husband. & can go out and spend her money as she likes. Yet still, advice is 'leave him' when she's not asked for advice on leaving him and nor has she said that she wants to

DecoratingDiva · 03/05/2024 19:35

So your DH is prepared to boycott his own child’s 18th birthday party because he doesn’t want to be in the same place as your parents & his son’s grandparents.

Im not the biggest fan of my in laws but honestly your DH sounds unbearable. Does he have any redeeming features? How have you & your kids put up with him for so long?

Devon23 · 03/05/2024 19:32

Wowser it's nit like your parents,expected you to pay. Sounds like your hubby has a inferior complex- why have you stuck by him he sounds toxic.

Swanfeet · 03/05/2024 19:19

Bloody hell. Just leave your husband out of the party!

on a more serious note, this is horribly controlling. I hope this is not indicative of how he treats you in general.