Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
17
zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:33

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/04/2024 09:07

Because Fox News is ‘ridiculous’. Thats why it’s ridiculed.

In your opinion.

LakeTiticaca · 29/04/2024 09:33

Just ask Jews in the UK how safe they feel right now

EasternStandard · 29/04/2024 09:32

DifficultBloodyWoman · 29/04/2024 09:25

Can you read the sign, Adam?

It says ‘Caliphate is the Solution’.

The protest is happening in Germany. ‘Caliphate is the Solution’. I can easily see why people think this ‘means that they are trying to bring a caliphate to Germany’. And that is without reference to the nature of historical caliphates and their expansionist nature, or to more modern attempts at creating a caliphate that crossed international borders.

I am surprised that only one poster has picked up on the language used. When was the term ‘Lösung’ last used in a similar context in Germany? Any guesses?

Back then, people were calling for ‘Endlösung’. That was ‘the Final Solution’. 6 million people were murdered in a mechanised, industrial method. You wouldn’t want waste time dealing with people individually when you can just group them together, after all.

Now, I am using the word ‘people’. The death toll was, of course, much higher. But the six million ‘people’ that faced the Final Solution were all Jewish.

Calling for a Caliphate as a Solution when anti-semitism is on the rise all the way around the world? Yes, I do think this warrants publicity and discussion because I really don’t want another European (or world) war to break out.

And I don’t blame people for being worried about this.

Edited

Interesting post on the language

Primroseoil · 29/04/2024 09:32

MrsCrumPinnett · 29/04/2024 08:03

Probably worth always bearing in mind that:

  1. political parties often plop posts on here to test the water
  2. there is a general election looming
  3. polling yesterday showed Reform ahead of the LibDems in third place in GE voting intentions, and likely looking for ways to increase that.

I'm a mother not a politician, I saw the Fox News story online & Googled it & saw lots of other media sites have also covered it!!! Jesus as a mother of girls I have every right to be bloody concerned!
Germany is not far from us, it doesn't take long for these protests to sweep a continent especially these days with social media
I will not be gaslit.

OP posts:
Lottie2shoes · 29/04/2024 09:32

As a Muslim, I did wonder whether to write a post or not as I know I will get flamed etc.
But just wanted to put out there another opinion as I've read alot on this thread about separation and how all Muslims want caliphate etc.
The majority of Muslims I know, including my family just want to live normal peaceful lives. Being able to follow our faith but not affect anyone else.

I pray in my own home, eat halal food etc, wear a hijab but I would never expect others whether they are Muslim or not to do the same. All the Muslims I know are also like this.
I funnily enough, also like interactions with non Muslims and chat on a weekly if not daily basis with people of all different faiths. I have no problems with them.
But as a Muslim, when I hear people talk of no go areas, the whole rhetoric of separate lives and how Muslims wish to take over the world.... people then coming on and saying islamophobic stuff, it does make me be wary of talking to new people wondering if the majority of people feel the same. Then it's a catch 22 because then I do stick to the people I know (ie people similar to me) which probably creates the no go areasÛ”

People hearing about the other "sides" hatred with inflammatory posts like we are scared of the Muslims and they all "West " hating people etcÛ” (and vice versa)
This is actually what had divided us and separated us and then we hear all about the segregation, not realising our actions have caused that.
I grew up with Muslims and non Muslims and never had any issues at all. They were respectful of us, just as we were respectful of their values. Its just this last 10/20 years or so, its become more of an issue.

Solgrass · 29/04/2024 09:29

DifficultBloodyWoman · 29/04/2024 09:25

Can you read the sign, Adam?

It says ‘Caliphate is the Solution’.

The protest is happening in Germany. ‘Caliphate is the Solution’. I can easily see why people think this ‘means that they are trying to bring a caliphate to Germany’. And that is without reference to the nature of historical caliphates and their expansionist nature, or to more modern attempts at creating a caliphate that crossed international borders.

I am surprised that only one poster has picked up on the language used. When was the term ‘Lösung’ last used in a similar context in Germany? Any guesses?

Back then, people were calling for ‘Endlösung’. That was ‘the Final Solution’. 6 million people were murdered in a mechanised, industrial method. You wouldn’t want waste time dealing with people individually when you can just group them together, after all.

Now, I am using the word ‘people’. The death toll was, of course, much higher. But the six million ‘people’ that faced the Final Solution were all Jewish.

Calling for a Caliphate as a Solution when anti-semitism is on the rise all the way around the world? Yes, I do think this warrants publicity and discussion because I really don’t want another European (or world) war to break out.

And I don’t blame people for being worried about this.

Edited

Hear hear

AdamRyan · 29/04/2024 09:26

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:18

Bravo! This Forum is an absolute disgrace of virtue signalling numpties trying to out do each other whilst mocking anyone who dares to hold an opinion that isn't in keeping. It's scary and laughable in equal measure.

Interesting. My perspective is there are increasing numbers of right wing conspiracy theorists on here.
Isn't it strange how different people can have different views of the same thing.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 29/04/2024 09:25

AdamRyan · 29/04/2024 08:44

1000 people at a protest in Germany, and one of them had a sign. It was an anti-Israel demonstration, so not sure why you think this means they are trying to bring a caliphate to Germany.

YABVVU. I suggest you go and talk to some real life Muslims rather than posting on the Internet. There is a lot of misinformation on this thread.

Can you read the sign, Adam?

It says ‘Caliphate is the Solution’.

The protest is happening in Germany. ‘Caliphate is the Solution’. I can easily see why people think this ‘means that they are trying to bring a caliphate to Germany’. And that is without reference to the nature of historical caliphates and their expansionist nature, or to more modern attempts at creating a caliphate that crossed international borders.

I am surprised that only one poster has picked up on the language used. When was the term ‘Lösung’ last used in a similar context in Germany? Any guesses?

Back then, people were calling for ‘Endlösung’. That was ‘the Final Solution’. 6 million people were murdered in a mechanised, industrial method. You wouldn’t want waste time dealing with people individually when you can just group them together, after all.

Now, I am using the word ‘people’. The death toll was, of course, much higher. But the six million ‘people’ that faced the Final Solution were all Jewish.

Calling for a Caliphate as a Solution when anti-semitism is on the rise all the way around the world? Yes, I do think this warrants publicity and discussion because I really don’t want another European (or world) war to break out.

And I don’t blame people for being worried about this.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/04/2024 09:24

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:22

Anything that veers from the accepted left is called far right these days and people are falling for it.

Yeah sure.🙄

This is why a Tory minister has just defected to Labour. He says his party is too right wing.

Is he the ‘accepted left?’ Cos he was a Tory minister for years.

Toddlerteaplease · 29/04/2024 09:23

It's not going to happen!

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:22

swimsong · 29/04/2024 07:55

So you think a small demonstration is petrifying but the far right extremist Alternative for Germany (AfD) is currently polling 2nd at 22% and that doesn't bother you or Fox News?

Anything that veers from the accepted left is called far right these days and people are falling for it.

1dayatatime · 29/04/2024 09:21

@Ponoka7

"My (Christian) Nigerian friends, here in the UK are having family and friends murdered daily, land is being stolen and girls kidnapped, by Muslim groups. They don't understand why this is just ignored. "

You raise a really interesting point here. I could also add that no did much about the 276 Christian school girls kidnapped by Islamic terrorist in Nigeria in 2014, with a 100 girls still missing. Or the ongoing slave trade in Sudan of black Christians by Arab Muslims:
www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-53147864.amp

In answer to your friend's questions of why this is being ignored is that the liberals in the UK would call out any criticism of persecution of Christians in Africa by Muslims as Islamophobia or racism or call out any criticism of the ongoing slave trade in Sudan in 2024 as hypocritical because the UK was engaged in slave trade up until its abolition in 1807.

So ironically one of the reasons that modern Africans face persecution because they are black and Christian and don't get any support from the West is because the liberals in the West would denounce any condemnation of this persecution as racist.

The logic is so messed up but in the meantime innocent black Christian school girls pay the price.

inamarina · 29/04/2024 09:20

IClaudine · 29/04/2024 09:02

Are you in Germany?

No, but I don’t need to be in Germany to be able to read German news online.

ClareBlue · 29/04/2024 09:18

@IClaudine
If you Google Birmingham Islamic takeover of schools you will get BBC and other reputable links. Birmingham is just a high profile, not unique.
I have not offered any opinion in my posts about the validity of the issues I posted about. There could be very good reasons why the disconnected communities are being created for those communities.
All those saying it is all rubbish maybe Google that MN favourite beacon of Liberal and environmental progessivenes, Denmark, and see what concerns they have about disconnected communities and how they are dealing with them.
Our response at the moment is either extreme radicalisation against the communities as we are seeing, which is an indication of a complete failure on everyone's part and an even bigger problem, or close debate down and say it's all rubbish when anyone questions the narrative.

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:18

blimeyslimey · 29/04/2024 07:45

that should have said ‘ using the Charlie Hebdo murders as an example’ ( not excuse).

Bravo! This Forum is an absolute disgrace of virtue signalling numpties trying to out do each other whilst mocking anyone who dares to hold an opinion that isn't in keeping. It's scary and laughable in equal measure.

Rocknrollstar · 29/04/2024 09:17

The caliphate will be introduced gradually. there is already a desire for sharia law in parts of this country. The Muslim population is large and growing. It’s really a Handmaid’s Tale scenario.

AdamRyan · 29/04/2024 09:13

Noicant · 29/04/2024 09:07

I do think the concern should be that it happened not who reported it.

Why are you concerned about a tiny number of people protesting in Germany?

Seriously. 1100 people is nothing.

Fox News are reporting it because they have an agenda. Most demonstrations of that size wouldn't make the news at all, let alone internationally.

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:10

AlexaPlaySomeHappyHardcore · 29/04/2024 06:32

It’s a Fox News story. The whole premise of FN is to scare one group of (white) people into hating other groups of (usually non white) people.

This is not going to happen.

So you're saying only white people watch FN? You have a very simplistic world view indeed,and quite an offensive one at that.

Underthinker · 29/04/2024 09:10

DrJoanAllenby · 29/04/2024 08:51

It's too late, it's going to happen here.

Why do you think there is a massive increase in pushing transgender.

A population of weak and feminised men will not be able to stand up and fight.

Well the joke's going to be on them when a commando squadron of transmen jacked up on testosterone with rippling muscles and pink white and blue AK47s ride in and save western civilisation.

AdamRyan · 29/04/2024 09:10

ClareBlue · 29/04/2024 08:50

Worked in Dewsbury in public services, been schooled in Bradford have you @AdamRyan
I have. Close family lived in Berlin for years.
Seen issues with the education system in Birmingham. Seem English as a foreign language in areas of London schools and communities, etc etc.
What is rubbish about it from your experiences, @AdamRyan

It's right wing scaremongering nonsense is what's wrong with it. There hasn't been a "separation" of the school system in Birmingham, that was a hoax

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/politics/2022/feb/04/michael-gove-acted-on-bogus-allegations-of-islamist-plot-to-take-over-birmingham-schools

I'm not sure what you think the issue is with "Seem English as a foreign language in areas of London schools and communities".

Gove acted on ‘bogus’ allegations of Islamist plot to take over Birmingham schools

Trojan horse podcast reveals then education secretary went ahead with interventions despite ‘serious credibility gap’

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/politics/2022/feb/04/michael-gove-acted-on-bogus-allegations-of-islamist-plot-to-take-over-birmingham-schools

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/04/2024 09:07

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:05

This whole forum is an echo chamber of The Guardian,BBC,CNN,MSNBC. Step outside of these accepted parameters and you're bullied and ridiculed. No one is allowed a different opinion or a discussion that differs from the status quo. There's a whole lot of useful idiots on here.

Because Fox News is ‘ridiculous’. Thats why it’s ridiculed.

Noicant · 29/04/2024 09:07

AdamRyan · 29/04/2024 08:56

The Telegraph, Express, Daily Mail and GB news are basically now the UK version of fox and just share stories round each other. Anything from them needs an automatic Google to see if 1) any other outlets are reporting it and 2) what they are saying

I do think the concern should be that it happened not who reported it.

zoom1982 · 29/04/2024 09:05

Solgrass · 29/04/2024 06:53

Interesting that all the posters mocking the OP for using Fox News, as a source.

Not discrediting this has actually happened. You’re not interested that there are people calling for a caliphate but it does interest you someone uses Fox News?

Also, it’s using the words ‘solution’ on the march in Germany, we all know what that is alluding to. I can see from the posters on here already, that that wouldn’t bother them much either.

This whole, YABU to be scared is the same gaslighting nonsense that’s used to silence women and children.

So yes, OP. YANBU if you are scared

This whole forum is an echo chamber of The Guardian,BBC,CNN,MSNBC. Step outside of these accepted parameters and you're bullied and ridiculed. No one is allowed a different opinion or a discussion that differs from the status quo. There's a whole lot of useful idiots on here.

Primroseoil · 29/04/2024 09:04

blimeyslimey · 29/04/2024 07:38

I’m interested in all the people accusing Fox News of being biased whilst simultaneously refusing to recognize their own bias.

in the 70s/ 80s animal rights campaigning was more of a Thing. Most campaigners were peaceful but a few were extremists who engaged in direct action of various sorts. Now animal rights was a small movement, so a small percentage of a small movement is not such a big issue. Especially as, as far as I am aware, they never killed anyone.

There are an awful lot of Muslims. They are a huge population. So even a ‘small minority’ of Muslims being extremists is a lot of people. And they are very extreme. Much more so than the 1970s/80s animal rights people.

it is worrying. If you have a large population that produces a minority who kill people, that wants to impose its woman disadvantaging laws on its population living in the West, , that wants to impose its blasphemy ideals on everyone on pain of death. That is a problem.

Are posters here aware that a teacher is still in hiding in the UK ( which means he has lost all his friendship groups and community and home and career, everything, it’s deeply traumatic) who has had his life utterly destroyed, because he gave a school sanctioned lesson on free speech using what happened with the Charlie Hebdo murders as an excuse?

Did posters here hear the Anti Social episode on radio 4 based on the boys who took a Koran into school and dropped it on the floor, and the young autistic boy who did this has received death threats and was utterly incapacitated and suicidal with terror and his mum was filmed crying and begging with apology at the mosque in the Muslim community, like she was at some Sharia court, in a desperate bid to save her son? And the ‘respectable’ Muslim representative on AntiSocial talked of how dear and venerated the Koran was to Muslims and how terrible it was for it to touch the floor. But when asked about the death threats to the teenage child ( who remember was in an extreme and terrified state of mental distress) laughed and said. ‘Oh boys will be boys, that’s just what boys are like’.
Let that sink in.

There is a problem. We should uphold values of tolerance in all communities. We should uphold our rule of law in all communities. We should not let fear or being called names, mean we are to scared to stand up to one group of people over another.

The posters here pretending there is not an issue, sneering at Fox News, are of the same mentality as those who, when whistle blowers were trying to get police and social services to take action to protect the teenage girls being raped and sexually tortured by men from predominantly Muslim communities in Rotherham ( and many other places, and it’s still going on), turned their faces away and doubtless sneered, ‘ did you read that in the Daily Mail?, because they were more concerned with not being seen as racist, in their own eyes and others, than they were about safeguarding children from sexual abuse

It’s not anti-racist to refuse to see a concern in front of you. It’s a failing, not a principle.

Edited

Thanks for the excellent reply. It is a worry, I saw videos of the march in Hanbury & it appeared to be all young men, no women. Is that because the women don't agree or want a caliphate or they were not allowed protest?

OP posts:
Perzival · 29/04/2024 09:04

I don't want any extremism stance to get traction in the UK. I do believe that multiculturalism doesn't work- I don't believe I'm racist to say that, I just don't think the vast differences in beliefs can be overcome. Just visit Oldham, Rochdale, Bradford etc.

It's a shame, in a perfect world it would and we'd all love in peace and respect each other but the reality is that this doesn't happen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread