Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if church schools are becoming undated

130 replies

Notasproutbutagiantpea · 28/04/2024 23:46

*outdated ?

My youngest DC is off to start school in September and we are in catchment of a relatively new modern school with 5 class intake and also same distance is a church of England school with 2 classes. Both same good ofsted, both in past 2 years.

The church school catchment on the council website is basically the whole wider area, which is slightly confusing. But the church school has been undersubscribed for the last 2 years. Is this a low birth rate thing or the fact the the non- religious school is full more appealing in modern times? Maybe less people are christened, or religious, so find it harder to secure a church school if this is considered part of the application as still goes through the council, but you can add notes as to why you want the school. Plus the church school was saying before the place allocation that they still had spaces for September. A friend has said years ago that the head had said they pick who they want, in terms of family fit so distance isn’t an issue.

A couple of smaller schools (single intake) in the area have become academies so maybe it’s just smaller schools are struggling?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notamum12345577 · 03/05/2024 03:42

Diggby · 01/05/2024 15:01

Our C of E school is vastly oversubscribed and requires church attendance as well as baptism, signed for by the vicar, to get a place. It is a superb school with a particularly good reputation for SEN. And of course if the local churches are full of parents and young children then it is self-perpetuating as there is a social element for young families, which there wouldn't be if the churches were three old ladies and a hearing loop.

The only mild criticism I have is that Year 3 have recently got into heroin, but it's worked out alright on balance as it calms them down after lunch time and means they don't go on the rob down the high street any more.

Better than speed which would make them hyper 🤣

TizerorFizz · 02/05/2024 19:39

@Sooooootired01 Not sure what you mean? I think many are happy with light touch, as I was, but in your face every day is too much where the vast majority of pupils aren’t devoted to anything. So they do not need it. Unfortunately it’s difficult to get into another school.

Sooooootired01 · 02/05/2024 12:51

@TizerorFizz Devoted Christians?

User364837 · 02/05/2024 11:28

In my experience with C of E schools the church links are pretty tenuous and you hardly notice a difference.
Catholic schools it can be a bit more pronounced

AliceMcK · 02/05/2024 11:24

TizerorFizz · 01/05/2024 21:35

I’ve seen RC schools only want RC teachers. It’s discrimination in my view. Excluding others based on religion who could be more than qualified or better qualified for the job. It’s not acceptable. At least our local CofE junior was VC and a bit light touch until new Head arrived. I now hear it’s gone evangelical and DC are turned off by prayers before lessons and all sorts of bible phrases all over the place. Many DC are questioning what’s being said. My DC would have left. It used to be Harvest Festival, Christmas and the vicar once a month. The Diocese education service is pushing all of this. Who honestly needs it in school?

There are plenty of non RC teachers in my DCs RC schools. Also those annoying ones who get their children baptised just to get them a school place. The only requirement is the HT is catholic which I think is fair enough in a faith school.

The previous RE teacher at my DDs high school was a female minister, I’m not sure of her faith as she left not long after dd started but she’d been there for years before leaving. The school chapel is designed for children of all faiths to enjoy. The school has a number of teachers who are not RC, I’ve seen at least 2 female teachers wearing hijabs.

TizerorFizz · 02/05/2024 08:48

It’s also how they are required to teach! Where I live, no RC is a local catchment school. CofE is and it doesn’t seem there’s much light touch CofE now. They feel very more religious than they used to. A neighbour is Head of a CofE primary. Her newsletters to parents always start with a bible quote. Hardly anyone chooses this school because they are church goers. They go because there is nowhere else. It’s so unnecessary to have bible quotes all over the place and prayers all the time. Who does this in normal life?

Blahdymcblahdyface · 02/05/2024 06:33

Church attendance is at an all time low, by insisting on that when recruiting teachers some of these schools are shooting themselves in the foot.

TizerorFizz · 01/05/2024 22:29

This is my nearest RC VA school. How does a standard teacher do the attached?

To wonder if church schools are becoming undated
Sooooootired01 · 01/05/2024 22:19

I just had a look around a CofE primary with a view to applying for a class teacher role. The Head was great and made it very clear that applicants didn't need to have a faith, or could have another faith that wasn't Christianity, providing they upheld the Values of the school eg. personal responsibility etc.

x2boys · 01/05/2024 22:13

TizerorFizz · 01/05/2024 21:35

I’ve seen RC schools only want RC teachers. It’s discrimination in my view. Excluding others based on religion who could be more than qualified or better qualified for the job. It’s not acceptable. At least our local CofE junior was VC and a bit light touch until new Head arrived. I now hear it’s gone evangelical and DC are turned off by prayers before lessons and all sorts of bible phrases all over the place. Many DC are questioning what’s being said. My DC would have left. It used to be Harvest Festival, Christmas and the vicar once a month. The Diocese education service is pushing all of this. Who honestly needs it in school?

I think that used to be the case ,my sister was a primary school teacher and she qualified in the mid 90,s in her first appointment at a RC primary school they specified they preferred RC teachers which she was
However my own son and I can only talk about his school his RE teacher at his RC high school was Muslim as was his maths and science teachers

TizerorFizz · 01/05/2024 21:35

I’ve seen RC schools only want RC teachers. It’s discrimination in my view. Excluding others based on religion who could be more than qualified or better qualified for the job. It’s not acceptable. At least our local CofE junior was VC and a bit light touch until new Head arrived. I now hear it’s gone evangelical and DC are turned off by prayers before lessons and all sorts of bible phrases all over the place. Many DC are questioning what’s being said. My DC would have left. It used to be Harvest Festival, Christmas and the vicar once a month. The Diocese education service is pushing all of this. Who honestly needs it in school?

Blahdymcblahdyface · 01/05/2024 20:11

Looks like this.

To wonder if church schools are becoming undated
DahliaMacNamara · 01/05/2024 20:00

That hiring policy certainly isn't universal. When DD was at primary school, nobody on the staff was a practising Christian, and while interviewees for SLT posts were asked by church governors about how they'd promote a Christian ethos, fudging it with a broadly humanitarian rather than religious approach didn't lose them any points. (I was a non-church governor serving on interview panels.) It didn't come up at all when hiring other teaching staff.
I'd say that most of the diocese-appointed governors weren't actually in favour of church schools per se. They saw their role more as an extension of the church's duty to serve the community.

AliceMcK · 01/05/2024 19:54

DahliaMacNamara · 29/04/2024 00:00

Your friend, or the head, is talking bollocks about picking family who fit into the school. They have to stick to their published admissions criteria.

Not necessarily.

We looked at a school it was Methodist. It was also an academy. We had to submit proof of worship, I.e if we weren’t part of their church community where your attendance was mandatory, they wanted a letter from our priest stating we were regular worshipers in our religion. 99% of admissions were selected on attending some form of church and, there was a minimum church attendance required.

The local C of E was also overtly religious, my niece went to it and the whole school attended a full mass each week as well as individual year groups going to year group masses.

I was relived when we visited the catholic school, it was nothing like the other 2. Thankfully we left the area so didn’t go to any of those schools.

I absolutely do think the first school was very much if your face fits. Thankfully ours absolutely didn’t.

x2boys · 01/05/2024 19:35

BigAnne · 01/05/2024 19:27

Do you honestly believe that it's only teens in "rough" areas who smoke weed?

No🙄

Pin0cchio · 01/05/2024 19:31

Blahdy yup I'm pretty sure ours does this. And permanent jobs are only advertised via the diocese.

The amount of religious interference imposed by the local church is much higher than it was in cofe schools when i was a child. The cofe is panicking about falling numbers and a core part of its strategy is a desperate attempt to reach children via upping presence in schools.

Its not working though. Parental influence continues to override. My eldest told me at age 7 that he didn't believe in god and only pretended to join in prayers at school.

BigAnne · 01/05/2024 19:27

x2boys · 29/04/2024 10:23

I live in a pretty rough area lots of teens smoking weed etc
But i find it hard to imagine children of 4/5 smoking 🚬.

Do you honestly believe that it's only teens in "rough" areas who smoke weed?

Blahdymcblahdyface · 01/05/2024 19:14

Sooooootired01 · 01/05/2024 18:53

@Blahdymcblahdyface I've worked in C of E schools for many years and have never heard of this. I'm not a Christian; had Naming Days for my own children, didn't get married in a church...

I’ve seen it many times on teacher recruitment forms - usually CofE

Sooooootired01 · 01/05/2024 18:53

@Blahdymcblahdyface I've worked in C of E schools for many years and have never heard of this. I'm not a Christian; had Naming Days for my own children, didn't get married in a church...

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 01/05/2024 18:47

The Church of England school near me is closing at the end of this year. Falling roll and a bad Ofsted.

Blahdymcblahdyface · 01/05/2024 18:08

I think the policy of many to only hire staff if they can give a priest / vicar as a reference is ridiculous. They’re losing out on good staff

G123456789 · 01/05/2024 17:52

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 01/05/2024 08:05

I went to a church school, despite not being christened, and have nice memories of singing hymns and nativity plays and all that stuff, so I had no qualms about sending DD to one. But boy, was it overkill! The vicar in every week, SIAMS inspections, the lot - seemed so much more than when I was a kid. She now goes to a secular secondary school, which I am glad about.

On a side note I don't think smoking 5 year olds is too representative of the average C of E school🤔

Ditto. Local primary was c of e...the biggest different I notice is my friends know how to behave in a church and they sing the hymns. Quite a few still ended up in prison though!

TizerorFizz · 01/05/2024 17:17

Liverpool has 3 state schools which are inadequate or RI. All faith schools. It guarantees very little if the education isn’t great.

Diggby · 01/05/2024 15:01

Our C of E school is vastly oversubscribed and requires church attendance as well as baptism, signed for by the vicar, to get a place. It is a superb school with a particularly good reputation for SEN. And of course if the local churches are full of parents and young children then it is self-perpetuating as there is a social element for young families, which there wouldn't be if the churches were three old ladies and a hearing loop.

The only mild criticism I have is that Year 3 have recently got into heroin, but it's worked out alright on balance as it calms them down after lunch time and means they don't go on the rob down the high street any more.

Dotdashdottinghell · 01/05/2024 14:31

So in my city the CofE school is the local school, everyone who loves close by goes there. But the Catholic schools cover catchments of about 6 primaries each, and are very strict based on Baptism, attending Mass etc. Some families choose it because they have a strong faith, others choose it (and jump through the hoops) because the Catholic High School is outstanding in every way, and the only guaranteed entry is through a feeder school.