Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

They have enough money I don’t need to pay them back?

111 replies

beenoutontheopenroad · 28/04/2024 20:53

Has anyone come across people with this attitude before? I fear it’s really common.

A friend told me her boyfriend didn’t pay his friend back for tickets he bought as he was rich and didn’t need it.

A colleague took our deposits for a lunch (outside of work) she didn’t book it and paid us all back apart from one person - who was definitely earning a good £20-30K more.

Such a shit attitude and I’m having it done to me now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newestname002 · 01/05/2024 19:48

TodaysNameIsBoring · 01/05/2024 19:05

@AliceMcK That's great that they have been such good friends.

Even better that the dickhead Ex and your equally challenged FIL are now out of your life. 🌹

TodaysNameIsBoring · 01/05/2024 19:05

@AliceMcK That's great that they have been such good friends.

AliceMcK · 01/05/2024 18:38

@TodaysNameIsBoring yes. My friends were amazing, the day I told them I’d left my ex the husband did a little cheer and punch in the air and said finally I hated him 😂 They regularly treat me, they earned a lot more than me, we all lived together when I first met my ex. My ex didn’t see that the friendship wasn’t just about them earning more and covering my costs, i couldn’t afford the take them for nice meals like they did for me, but I could cook for them, pick up their favourite chocolate or wine as a treat on my way home for work, bake them birthday cakes etc.. My ex only ever saw life through monetary value, I could have bought him the perfect gift, but if I hadn’t spent a lot of money on it he’d sulk.

TodaysNameIsBoring · 01/05/2024 16:53

@AliceMcK
That sounds awful. Did you manage to pay all the money back?

AliceMcK · 01/05/2024 11:52

Just thought of another, my ExH.

Our wedding was supposed to be very small, no more than 10 people at a registry office. Days before his aunt kicked off she wasn’t going to get to see her “nephew” by marriage get married. It turned into a big thing the next thing I know there are almost 50 people there. The plan was we’d have lunch at a local pub, everyone to pay their own, then we had a big party laid out for everyone that night, all welcome, free beer & wine, some spirits and free food.

Anyway at the lunch my ex dick of a fil announced that the meal was being paid for by my dad. My dad lived 12000 miles way and had no money, he’d sent me a chq for £250 as a wedding gift which FIL found out about. I was mortified, FIL was a loud prick and even though my ex was one too he couldn’t stand up to his dad. DH and I had spent every last penny we had on the party.

Very good friends of mine who were my surrogate family just paid for everybody on the quiet. I’m talking a young couple our age, not particularly well off.

I promised to pay them back, but when it came to it my exs attitude was they earn more than us and are your best friends so why should we pay them back. I was mortified. My friends had my ex pegged long before I did. In the end I paid them in instalments from a secret bank account I’d quickly realised I might need. Id started to pay a small amount of my salary in it each month after I’d gotten a pay rise and didn’t tell my ex. It was empty by the time we split up because I was always paying off things he refused to. He once stopped paying rent because the property managers sacked his dad. Apparently not paying rent showed them! Us having our credit destroyed was a small price to pay, fucking idiot.

it was a short marriage and I left in so much debt because I took loans out to protect my credit score.

Newestname002 · 01/05/2024 06:57

@ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves

This is what he's taken to doing now. He'll send a reminder out a day or two before the deadline as a reminder but he'll still get comments of "mate, it's only £10!"

Yes those "only £10" soon add up though, especially if people - often the same people - do this often. 🌹

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 30/04/2024 16:59

Newestname002 · 29/04/2024 13:52

I'd be inclined to say that there's a deadline for receipt by DH of the deposits. One week before (or whatever the restaurant's requirements are plus a few days for the tardy) DH must have all the deposits in hand - it just a promise of the money. If people have not paid by then he'll assume they no longer want to attend, and the group booking will not have their names on. Everything in writing so there's no misunderstanding. 🌹

This is what he's taken to doing now. He'll send a reminder out a day or two before the deadline as a reminder but he'll still get comments of "mate, it's only £10!"

I wouldn't be organising it if it was my friends, but, thankfully, my friends don't operate like that!

Gunkle1 · 29/04/2024 23:47

exomoon · 29/04/2024 06:55

But if they spot me shopping or a meal, I have to transfer the money before leaving or I get the silent treatment.

What does this mean sorry?

If I am out with them, and they pay for my shopping as I don't have my card or its easier for then just to pay. I need to give it back ASAP.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 29/04/2024 21:28

It's incredibly entitled to not pay someone back on the basis of your opinion of their finances. It's nothing to do with you. Anyone doing this is deliberately taking advantage of the lenders generosity, and is one of life's takers.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 29/04/2024 20:11

Maninthemoonsmiles · 29/04/2024 07:42

I don’t understand why people say eg my sister made me pay. Noone can actually force you to show them your bank statements or go to the shop to buy them takeaways. Just don’t move! My parents drummed into us not to borrow or lend money (except mortgage me) and I think it’s excellent advice. Once got stung by student we helped with emergency accommodation for a year but eventually drover her to cash machine and said I needed the money NOW! Only time I have ever done this and never again.

It's easier said than done though. You get the guilt trips, "but I've driven two hours to see you", "I don't like the food you've made", in reality, she's invited herself and spent the whole time on her phone messaging her friends rather than actually engage with us. Some people are rather manipulative. But everyone has a breaking point, I had mine, and I no longer will stand for it. I guess some people try the peaceful route to have relationships with family members, but sometimes you get pushed too far, then break.

Caroparo52 · 29/04/2024 16:00

Not acceptable

LemonySnickets · 29/04/2024 15:58

My sister would always 'borrow' money from our father. Always for important bills. She never used the money for bills, and she never paid it back. Cause 'he doesn't need it'.

Neveralonewithaclone · 29/04/2024 15:45

No, they don't really stand back but there's an anxiety from them (i know them very very well and they talk about other people and bills) about being taken for a ride during bill paying. They are not an anxious person just continuously on the look out for being cheated due to being very very rich. I know they're rich because they tell me. I know they're on the look out because they tell me. I've never borrowed anything from them. No, i don't like them. But I'll buy the coffee 😂 because it's worth it.

exomoon · 29/04/2024 15:38

Neveralonewithaclone · 29/04/2024 15:34

Someone asked who i know who doesn't buy me coffee 😂
It's an immediate family member who is a multimillionaire, i know this because the person continuously talks about it. They don't buy me coffee, I don't want them to I'm happy to buy my own but I KNOW (because I know them well and they are very garrulous about money and paying for meals, coffee, holidays) that if they paid for my coffee it would be a massive issue. I find it embarrassing that they watch 'fair shares' like a hawk and would rather just pay for theirs too.

To answer all upcoming questions - I have known them all my life, they tell me how much they have (i don't ask), I'm not interested in poncing a coffee, I know they watch like a hawk because they talk endlessly about others people.

I think it's sad how fearful they are.

That was me. Do they stand back and let you pay for their coffee?

I would just buy my own!

Theothername · 29/04/2024 15:36

It extends to business practices too and is a significant factor in small to medium businesses sinking.

Neveralonewithaclone · 29/04/2024 15:34

Someone asked who i know who doesn't buy me coffee 😂
It's an immediate family member who is a multimillionaire, i know this because the person continuously talks about it. They don't buy me coffee, I don't want them to I'm happy to buy my own but I KNOW (because I know them well and they are very garrulous about money and paying for meals, coffee, holidays) that if they paid for my coffee it would be a massive issue. I find it embarrassing that they watch 'fair shares' like a hawk and would rather just pay for theirs too.

To answer all upcoming questions - I have known them all my life, they tell me how much they have (i don't ask), I'm not interested in poncing a coffee, I know they watch like a hawk because they talk endlessly about others people.

I think it's sad how fearful they are.

BruFord · 29/04/2024 15:23

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 29/04/2024 14:05

SIL has been very open about the fact that, despite DH earning £100+, she will deliberately make sure she never earns enough to ever pay her student loan back.

That's not right

@tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz Ugh, that’s disgusting behavior, so unnecessary.

JustEatTheOneInTheBallPit · 29/04/2024 15:15

Yes, my brother still owes me hundreds of pounds. My family tell me that he's told them all I don't need the money so he won't pay me back. Then he fell out with me for something unrelated. Probably because he feels some kind of shame about it on some level. I don't know. I've ceased caring. He's right, I actually don't need the money but I did need my brother.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 29/04/2024 14:08

Apologies not quite the point of thread Grin

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 29/04/2024 14:05

SIL has been very open about the fact that, despite DH earning £100+, she will deliberately make sure she never earns enough to ever pay her student loan back.

That's not right

Newestname002 · 29/04/2024 13:52

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 29/04/2024 12:15

I've seen it too, but the well off ones are the worst for paying too sometimes.

DH organises group meals each year for his mates around Christmas. Because it's a big group and it's Christmas, the restaurants usually charge a deposit.

DH tells his mates that they have to pay the deposit to him too, as some of them are flakey and are likely to back out too, so he doesn't want to be out of pocket, even though he can afford to be.

The lowest paid of the group are always the first to pay their deposit. There's one mate in the group that's the most well off by far and DH has to chase him over and over again to get the money. Yes, he can afford it, but so can they. Just because you're "wealthy" doesn't mean you should sub others.

I'd be inclined to say that there's a deadline for receipt by DH of the deposits. One week before (or whatever the restaurant's requirements are plus a few days for the tardy) DH must have all the deposits in hand - it just a promise of the money. If people have not paid by then he'll assume they no longer want to attend, and the group booking will not have their names on. Everything in writing so there's no misunderstanding. 🌹

ThinkingAgainAndAgain · 29/04/2024 13:44

I learnt my lesson when I was 16yo. I’d just started work at a big supermarket (I did three evenings a week then), and one of the Saturday girls needed someone to work her rosta-ed on shift one weekend because she had plans. It came after the cut off date that month for payroll, so she was paid it, and she said she’d give me the money. She never did. I felt awkward raising the issue, this went on for months. She then went to university, but would come home every weekend to work her Saturday shift. By then I’d also swapped to working Saturdays. I finally said something. She said that she was living hand to mouth so didn’t have the money to give me, and as we also both worked Saturdays, she couldn’t offer to work my shift for me like I’d offered to work hers for her. So I didn’t get the money back. It was about £25 in 1992, it was a lot to me.

I’ve only ever lent someone money twice since, and each time decided that unfold afford to lose the money if they never paid me back. I was in a much better position than they were and was happy to have given it as a gift. They both paid me back without any drama.

Missmarple87 · 29/04/2024 13:27

LakeTiticaca · 29/04/2024 07:47

Just because someone appears to be "wealthy," it doesn't necessarily mean they are. A nice house in a good area and a nice car need paying for, they don't suddenly appear out of nowhere. Just because you have a nice holiday every year doesn't mean your rich. You have probably forgone other stuff to pay for it.
What people perceive is not necessarily the truth.
"Never a lender nor a borrower a be" was my Dad's favourite mantra and a very wise one!!

Exactly this. I had a friend ask me why I shopped at Aldi because 'im so loaded'. I didn't respond but part of me felt like saying 'part of the reason I have nice things is because I dont waste all my money in Waitrose!'.

I cringe for people like this who make huge presumptions about people's finances and are so chippy about people who earn well as if it's ALL just good luck or privilege. They make themselves look so thick. Part of the wider trend for everyone to be either victim or victimiser.

Maverickess · 29/04/2024 12:50

I think the attitude exists in rich and poor (for want of better descriptors) and the people who are not paying up will use any excuse to justify it, and "You're alright for money so don't need it" is just a convenient excuse imo.

Probably because I'm not well off I've only come across it the other way, as a few pp have said, struggling to get money out of people who are well off for events or things I've booked. I don't book now until the money is in, and if there's a time limit then that person is not included, I will try and add them if they pay up.
I've found people in a similar situation to me are the first ones to pay up, or tell me when they can.

My sister is a prime example of this, her household income is probably 3/4 times mine, though like everyone they have struggled a bit recently to maintain what they're used to. We meet for walks/food fairly regularly, I was actually thinking that I probably couldn't afford it last time it was arranged and was going to suggest buying some stuff to eat at mine. She suggested the same thing because she didn't want to spend out too much either, fair enough for both of us. Only I bought, paid for and cooked everything, cleared up afterwards and am still waiting for my reciprocal invite! I spent the same on a home made meal for us both as I would have done just me eating out and she spent nothing!
Which is probably why she has money and I don't! 🤣

Chatonette · 29/04/2024 12:41

I had a friend who asked her aunt for a loan to cover a breast reduction operation. She was NOT happy that she had to pay it back, and thought that the aunt should just write off the loan, as ‘she could afford it’.