Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a potential 2% pay rise for the NHS staff is ridiculous?

282 replies

Sunflowers68 · 28/04/2024 08:01

NHS England is cautioning against giving employees raises of more than 2%. is A band 2 salary is now only 10p above minimum wage due to the recent increase in the minimum wage. Surely, a 2% increase is insufficient for a job this challenging? If you are still working in the NHS, can you share your reasons why?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sunflowers68 · 28/04/2024 21:40

jamimmi · 28/04/2024 17:28

Reading this with interest, NHS band 7bsraff, contributions for pension now 10.7% so not small. No pay rise been top of band for years, every time I ask for rebanding there's no money, so I'm now refusing to do anything that's 8a based. I'm in my 50s so won't leave as I'm lucky I'm in the old scheme for most.of.my pension and due about £ 15000 a year from that. The new scheme is dreadful. We can't recruit or retain NHS staff, young physios all going private to the money and no nights on call with standby of £ 11 a night ( yes a night) . It been brought home to me how badly we are treated and I'm trying to work out the perks as Son just gained a graduate role. Pay slightly less than a band 5 but, company car, free parking ,private health, pension and shares plus free gym, milage and laptop from the get go. Annual Leave 33 days a year same as mine plus BH and Xmas shut down. I pay £20 a week to park at work or rather on the car park new work that runs a shuttle bus as staff can't park on site. If I was young I'd be going, just counting down the years here.

Edited

I appreciate your input. It appears that higher taxes and pension payments swiftly offset any increases in NHS salaries. It makes sense why people are leaving.

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 28/04/2024 18:05

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 14:24

The annual leave works out pretty much the same. If you do a 9-5 role you get bank holidays off unlike most NHS roles you are expected to work bank hol and the Xmas period and NY also. If this is what is selling you... join with NHS!

it depends which department you work for, my own department doesnt open bank holidays.
though no closing for christmas period, unlike some private sector roles.

PleaseBePacific · 28/04/2024 17:56

Warmfuzzyblankets · 28/04/2024 11:42

Reasons for working for NHS Vs private sector

  1. Pension
  1. Sick pay, you can pretty much have the 6 months off and not worry
  1. Maternity. Most people have a year off no questions asked. Yes only full pay for 8 weeks, then half pay, but your job will be there when you come back absolutely no question.
  1. Flexibility..if you ask to go part time, it's extremely likely you will be allowed. They are very family friendly and will accommodate most requests.
  1. Opportunity. There are always other roles coming up. If you already work for the NHS you have a foot in. I've known people come in as a band 2 and progress to band 5 through promotions and apprentice schemes etc.
  1. Funded training courses. See above. Plenty of opportunities for additional training, paid for.
  1. Job satisfaction. Yep it's bloody hard work absolutely. But on days where you've helped lots of people in need, you've achieved something worthwhile.

I could do a post with all the points AGAINST it too but that wouldn't be as long.

I agree with a lot of this. Personally...

  1. I'm unlikely to be able to retire but I keep paying in in the hope...
  1. Never really needed to use it beyond normal short term sick, e.g COVID d&v etc but know many that have (and some that have royally taken the piss)
  1. Maternity is good, if you come back
  1. Agree with the flexibility. Not benefited personally but know plenty that have
  1. Yes. I started at band 2, am now 7. Non clinical
  1. Plenty of theoretical opportunities but actually being given time to take them is another matter
  1. No satisfaction for me. My role means I often get constant grief from staff and patients alike.

I should also say I work well above my 37.5 hours a week (unpaid) and often feel tearful and ground down by it all.

I stay because I don't have the mental energy to find anything else. Plus as a perimenopausal woman it doesn't feel like a great time to look elsewhere

Atethehalloweenchocs · 28/04/2024 17:43

I work for the NHS because I can provide quality care to people that most people would not be able to afford to pay for, and I believe everyone has the right to good mental health, regardless of salary.

I voted for the 5% pay rise last year because I bought the story we were told. And got freelance work which means I am working the equivalent of 6 days a week to afford my bills. Suddenly after the pay rise was imposed (the nursing union never accepted it) there was suddenly money for bigger pay rises for lot of other groups.

So fuck their 2% - strikes are coming.

jamimmi · 28/04/2024 17:28

Reading this with interest, NHS band 7bsraff, contributions for pension now 10.7% so not small. No pay rise been top of band for years, every time I ask for rebanding there's no money, so I'm now refusing to do anything that's 8a based. I'm in my 50s so won't leave as I'm lucky I'm in the old scheme for most.of.my pension and due about £ 15000 a year from that. The new scheme is dreadful. We can't recruit or retain NHS staff, young physios all going private to the money and no nights on call with standby of £ 11 a night ( yes a night) . It been brought home to me how badly we are treated and I'm trying to work out the perks as Son just gained a graduate role. Pay slightly less than a band 5 but, company car, free parking ,private health, pension and shares plus free gym, milage and laptop from the get go. Annual Leave 33 days a year same as mine plus BH and Xmas shut down. I pay £20 a week to park at work or rather on the car park new work that runs a shuttle bus as staff can't park on site. If I was young I'd be going, just counting down the years here.

HeresMyBreakdown · 28/04/2024 17:07

How many people with the DB pensions would rather have more pay but pay into a DC scheme?

Aishah231 · 28/04/2024 15:48

KoalaKube · 28/04/2024 08:33

The negotiations only started in December - late again. Should have been paid in April. Yet again no sign of any progress. Industrial action costs the NHS billions, which could/should be invested in staff instead. Government want yet another season of disputes. They gave MPs 5.5% with no hassle.

This! Lawyers and judges also got their pay rise without having to strike. In what world is a well below inflation pay 'rise' acceptable. Teachers are also being offered 1% at present. The government honestly just doesn't give a shit. They'll clap and draw rainbows but fuck all else.

Warmfuzzyblankets · 28/04/2024 14:48

aodirjjd · 28/04/2024 13:51

This is such a stupid thing to say. Of course private sector jobs can be just as stressful as an nhs jobs and hell some nhs jobs will be really chilled out and easy. There is to broad a range on both sides to compare.

I've worked in a private hospital and for a private healthcare provider..the stress was worse. At least in the NHS I don't have any worry about profit and billing. Meetings about targets and feedback, and Google/trustpilot reviews. The management were real cutthroat. Plus the pay wasn't any better really. The only upside was the free parking and nicer uniform 😀

PermanentlyTired03 · 28/04/2024 14:42

With spending needed absolutely everywhere including pay rises the government can’t/wont increase higher than that.
Unfortunately many of the NHS staff are unlikely to walk away to private industry and the government knows it.
Im in civil service- I haven’t seen anything about pay rises yet as it is still with the unions. I doubt it will be much better! Our pay was restructured last year to align closer to industry- still a lot lower but we get a better pension. Every other perk (sick leave, mat leave, private healthcare etc) now been matched by the main private competitors.

Back21970 · 28/04/2024 14:32

The rise should be the current rate of inflation at least, anything less is effectively a pay cut.

In my workplace our board decided not to award any pay rise this year as they believed the cost of living crisis was over!

I totally agree that even an entry level role in the NHS should be better paid than just a few pence over the minimum wage.

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 14:24

Willmafrockfit · 28/04/2024 11:00

the sick pay is an absolute bonus, as is the annual leave

The annual leave works out pretty much the same. If you do a 9-5 role you get bank holidays off unlike most NHS roles you are expected to work bank hol and the Xmas period and NY also. If this is what is selling you... join with NHS!

Hateam · 28/04/2024 14:23

purplesparklydinosaur · 28/04/2024 14:17

Midwife here. I’m still with the NHS because I adore the women I look after and am devoted to them.

The pay is more than I’ve ever earned before and there is scope to progress. Im relatively new though and still in the phase where I’d do the job for free! 😂 we will see how I feel in ten years!

I'm a teacher and I see new staff with your attitude regularly.

Thing is, by working the way you do you're messing things up for everybody. There is no need to pay people properly if people like you will do it all for next to nothing.

purplesparklydinosaur · 28/04/2024 14:17

Midwife here. I’m still with the NHS because I adore the women I look after and am devoted to them.

The pay is more than I’ve ever earned before and there is scope to progress. Im relatively new though and still in the phase where I’d do the job for free! 😂 we will see how I feel in ten years!

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 14:09

@socks1107 I can believe you were doing more it sounds about right. Ahhh sounds like you have made cracking progress and things have picked up for you, well done you. The NHS is not for single parents unless you have a fabulous support network. They promote that sh*t but its a thing of the past I know a few people on "term time only contracts" they don't offer those any longer in my trust unless you had one from years ago already.

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 14:00

ChunkyMonkey2020 · 28/04/2024 10:16

I am a band 2.

It works around childcare and it has decent enhancements for working weekends.

I love my job, however it's very stressful on a busy and demanding ward.

There isn't no pay grades in a band 2. It's just one set wage. So unless I move to a band 3 ( which then my weekend enhancements go down) there is no pay rise for me.

It's kinda a lose lose situation.

Your weekend enhancements will still be the same or a bit more tbh there's not much pay difference between a B2 and B3 anyway.

Eastcoastie · 28/04/2024 13:57

innerdesign · 28/04/2024 11:36

How do the overall gross pay, working conditions, stress and responsibility compare?

In the private sector at the moment there is the continued threat of redundancy that comes with an unstable market. Gross pay inc pension likely to be lower for most people in private sector v public at a comparible level. Stress and responsibility will be job and person specific. Both sectors will have roles more personally demanding than the other. Id expect the public sector to be generally more supportive if you needed time off because of this though.

socks1107 · 28/04/2024 13:54

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 13:43

@Warmfuzzyblankets I think what you have forgot to add to your post is. In NHS as a band 2 HCA you work unsociable hours, nights and days all in the same week, 13 hour shifts and there is no Monday to Friday role unless you bag outpatients. An early shift is still 8 hours long and so is a late shift and these are from 7am till 3pm and 12.00am till 8pm.

Bank shifts have been utterly diabolical since last year and this year also! I thought bank shifts would of picked up but there isn't 1 single shift as a HCA that's released on the "bank" for June. NHS also are not family friendly and if you are a single mother it's extremely hard. Personally I feel they need an overall of the hours available especially as a single parent.

All of this! I was a single mum working in outpatient maternity as a band 2, absolutely loved my job at school hours and always did extra when needed and I could.
A new head of midwifery put a stop to all that and insisted we all rotated and did unsociable shifts which were totally undoable for me. It was unnecessary andI couldn't stay. So I went into admin and tbh it's been a good break. I have done course after course and progress to a band 5 in an area I love and there's scope for me to be a 7 eventually. I got lucky, I got good management and a small community trust that invested in my development when I was there. At band 2 I was a doing everything in including taking blood, that a midwife did in clinic apart from measure the fungal height and listen to the heartbeat. The rest was my job and I often covered reception too!

aodirjjd · 28/04/2024 13:51

Sunflowers68 · 28/04/2024 13:04

But this thread is specifically about NHS staff. The stress, workload conditions and responsibility of working for the NHS is not the same as other jobs. The private sector does NOT have the same amount of stress or workload.

Edited

This is such a stupid thing to say. Of course private sector jobs can be just as stressful as an nhs jobs and hell some nhs jobs will be really chilled out and easy. There is to broad a range on both sides to compare.

Emiliaswrath · 28/04/2024 13:50

innerdesign · 28/04/2024 13:07

This is crazy. These are the unforeseen consequences of all these initiatives that will supposedly make life better for lower paid workers.

Yes, our Trust has suspended parking permit payments for band 2 for now until the pay increase comes in when they will collect the outstanding payments from the back pay but as you say a 2% pay rise won't be enough 🤨

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 13:48

dollymixedup · 28/04/2024 11:48

I'm a band 2 on a complex geriatric ward - I do observations (BP, temp etc) basic wound care as well as personal care, repositioning, feeding etc we also have to record all of this on the (electronic) patients notes.

The nurses and drs don't spend enough time with the patients to know what is normal for them, or whether they are deteriorating - that's on us to alert medical staff.

The job is emotionally draining and physically demanding. Our patients generally have some type of cognitive impairment, confusion or safeguarding issues, some are end of life. It's a fraught environment with the patients requiring constant supervision.

To become band 3 I need to become competent in, venepuncture (taking blood)bladder scans and ECG's which I hope to do later this year.

People assume it's just wiping bums at band 2 - it's much more than that, we have a lot of responsibility.

The paper work has also increased compared to 10 years ago too as a B2.

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 13:43

@Warmfuzzyblankets I think what you have forgot to add to your post is. In NHS as a band 2 HCA you work unsociable hours, nights and days all in the same week, 13 hour shifts and there is no Monday to Friday role unless you bag outpatients. An early shift is still 8 hours long and so is a late shift and these are from 7am till 3pm and 12.00am till 8pm.

Bank shifts have been utterly diabolical since last year and this year also! I thought bank shifts would of picked up but there isn't 1 single shift as a HCA that's released on the "bank" for June. NHS also are not family friendly and if you are a single mother it's extremely hard. Personally I feel they need an overall of the hours available especially as a single parent.

Wonderwater2 · 28/04/2024 13:41

Currently none of the HCA's I work with now eligible for things like fleet cars which used to be a nhs perk. Band 2,3,4 using this scheme will be facing a pay cut in reality

In fact I've recently had a staff member declined for a bike to work scheme support because the salary sacrifice scheme puts them below minimum wage. Same with some childcare schemes and even car parking.

I've even seen one trust that's had to cancel their lottery scheme because the £1 a week was putting people under minimum wage

It's really awful for those staff because before hand they were paying pre tax for cars. Now they are forced to look else where pay higher amounts of tax, higher lease car fees but it's allowed because it doesn't make the trust look like it's paying less than minimum wage

IsTheOffDutyDoneYet · 28/04/2024 13:32

I’m a band 6 district nurse on the starting wage of the band. My mental health alone has been incredibly tested by the role, never mind the state my back is in. I contribute 9.8% to my pension. I know of many colleagues who are currently opted out because they’re trying to save as much going out as possible. I ended up needing to get a lease car through NHS Fleet Solutions when my old car gave out and we didn’t have the money to get another one. My mileage needs to be high because of this, most of my mileage goes on my job as I have a 25 mile round trip commute (you don’t get to chose your own base) before I even start to see patients. The cost per month of the fleet vehicle is ridiculous. For some reason I don’t get the full tax free allowance, my tax code is lower and I don’t understand why despite querying it a number of times. I pick up additional shifts because we are always short staffed, though these have to be through the bank and aren’t classed as overtime even though it’s for my own team. We don’t have permits, many of our patients are in the city centre and as such we either pay for parking or if there isn’t parking because it’s resident only permits (and not all patients have a permit), then we end up with a parking fine. The trust won’t pay the fines for us or back to us, the unions are painfully slow to do anything about it. The amount in parking alone to do our actual jobs day in day out is scandalous.

At the end of the day I’m still in my job because of the patients, they are my priority. That and keeping a roof over my children’s heads. Some days it is really testing.

Hateam · 28/04/2024 13:31

Gall10 · 28/04/2024 13:25

my brother is a plumber….his hourly rate to install a boiler is more than the neurosurgeon gets!

They are quite similar jobs.

The neurosurgeon drained some fluid and is thinking of fitting a header tank next time.

Could you get your brother to quote?

Sweetheart7 · 28/04/2024 13:28

PhuckyNell · 28/04/2024 08:22

Band 2 jobs aren't difficult but can be stressful imo

What do you do for a living?

Swipe left for the next trending thread