Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so sad about what happened to our town?

644 replies

AbstractThought · 26/04/2024 16:05

I wasn't born here, DH was, and I have seen it discussed on MN in the past. I am aware that many towns across the UK are in a similar situation, so this probably isn't anything special, but since most people talk about shop closures I wanted to look at it from a different angle.

In the past decade we have a ton more issues in the town than previously, often relating to homelessness and addiction, and the town centre, what's left of it, has become completely over run by these problems with groups of people fighting and street drinking. A lot of these people are in extreme difficulty, whether mental health related and/or drug issues. Crime shot through the roof, and even about 8 streets away from this it spills outwards to us in what was once a fairly quiet place to live.
We now have a constant stream of siren noise, day and night, helicopters are daily and whilst we personally haven't felt in any actual danger there is a horrible sense of decay and hopelessness. Just nipping to the closest supermarket is depressing, there are a lot of neglected animals and people having meltdowns in the streets.

It is how it changed so quickly though. I can't get my head around where it all started or why. I am aware of the contribution of politics, covid, all of that stuff, but it seems so incredibly extreme. The siren noise is the worst, it is piercing and never seems to end. This also seemed to explode around the same time as the area went downhill. Probably a mix of police and emergency vehicles. It is difficult to work or relax at home and if you are a light sleeper it can have an impact there too.

What I am wondering is if this is commonplace now, in what was once a thriving town? It is the sheer amount of troubled people which seems to have escalated the most, and I can't get my head around how this has evolved, in such a short space of time. It is like they weren't here, then suddenly appeared, it is difficult to describe it. Obviously the council can't do a great deal to help and I have no idea what the answer is. The most upsetting thing is that a lot of these people are so messed up that they can barely talk in a way that is decipherable. This includes children, and there is a growing amount of people who have barely any teeth. This is a fucking severe problem and I have no idea what will help it. We have mucked in with a few local charities but it barely scratches the surface in my opinion.
We are moving due to work relocation soon, so whilst it may not be 'our' problem after we have gone, this isn't the point. I am just so sorry that it has come to this, in likely even more places than just here. WTF happened??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Pllystyrene · 27/04/2024 08:33

We live in the village my husband grew up in and an incredibly/idyllic rural part of the country... For years my children could go to the parks, the beaches, out to ride their bikes by themselves. They're in there teens now and it's no longer safe, unless they're with an adult. We have gangs of teenagers roaming around at all hours. Throwing rocks at old peoples windows, smashing cars up, stealing from shops, vandalising the area etc... Things have changed so suddenly it's actually shocking.

sakura06 · 27/04/2024 08:25

@AbstractThought The serious decline of my home town definitely started when the M&S closed down! As a coastal town, there were always problems before with substance abuse, poverty, mental health etc. but the loss of M&S triggered the total collapse of the high street. There's nothing but charity shops now.

sakura06 · 27/04/2024 08:17

My home town is like this. It's so depressing. The death of the high street really didn't help. The local authority don't try to get private landlords to look after their buildings (in fairness, I'm not too sure what their powers are in this regard). Once buildings become dangerous, they're put under a compulsory purchase order and knocked down. There are many empty plots in the town centre now.

Alexandra2001 · 27/04/2024 08:15

BoobyDazzler · 26/04/2024 20:09

it’s everywhere and it sucks doesn’t it.
I think there’s a variety of reasons for society’s decline:

  • Low wages. Why would you work if you could get a similar amount for doing fuck all. A PP mentioned the lack of easy jobs and I guess she meant jobs you could do without qualification- but care work (not easy!) pays peanuts and why would you do it if you could get a similar amount for not working. I don’t think benefits are too high, but wages are too low…because low payers get away with doing so because of UC - we’re subsidising their profits.
  • decriminalisation of weed, theft, nuisance etc
  • Lack of support for small businesses in small towns - here it’s all charity shops and dodgy money laundering barbers the rest are priced out due to high rates
  • Boredom- what is there to do if you’ve got no money and no hope?
Primarily, though, I think it is because life is so shit for a lot of people they’ve got no aspirations - they’ll never be able to afford the life they want, never travel, never own their own home or a car. What’s the point in trying if even if they do try it’ll still be out of reach.

Thats a fair summary.

Though i think employers would still pay the lowest wages they can get away with, regardless of UC.... or as my mum used to say "Employers would make you pay them to work if they could"

Employers have been paying shit wages long before income support was introduced after WW2 BUT it has got a lot worse in recent years.

Many people are working v hard to stay poor and after rent and bills, many people aren't really better off then if they were on benefits and getting help with these.

Business rates and car parking charges are killing town centres.

But the biggest issue is Austerity, the cuts in services destroyed the social fabric of the UK to a far greater extent than other European countries, who stopped it after 3 or 4 years and started off with better services.

LaurieFairyCake · 27/04/2024 08:04

This is why I moved to London, it never goes downhill like that. Every town I've ever lived in before (lived everywhere) has never fully recovered.

The sheer volume of people in London to pay council tax means services are so much better.

Just as an example I've got an online NHS doctor - there are still appointments available for tomorrow (Sunday!)

Abhannmor · 27/04/2024 07:51

XenoBitch · 26/04/2024 21:22

The same in my town too. Druggies/drinkers, empty units, mostly phone shops, vape shops, and Turkish barbers. It is bloody horrible.

Interesting. In the 90s when a place was hollowed out it was mainly bookies , off licences and charity shops that sprung up.

GoodnightAdeline · 27/04/2024 07:21

swimsong · 27/04/2024 06:43

You really agree that "money is being ploughed into them"? It's nonsense. Since the Conservatives gained power 14 years ago funding for services that would help them have been savagely cut.

It's bizarre that so many are discussing this with no context - not acknowledging, or are ignorant of, how and why this has happened. Behind the banal platitudes, the Conservative Party has been in the grip of an extremist economic ideology that will only ever benefit their already wealthy friends and family.

I work in this area and it’s not nonsense. You can’t force treatment on people - all you can do is offer it. It is offered, they accept and don’t turn up, or they refuse. Do you work in this area?

swimsong · 27/04/2024 06:43

FixItUpChappie · 26/04/2024 22:18

As I said I work in this area and see a LOT of the kind of people you are talking about, and in most cases they are not ‘vulnerable’ - they’re aggressive, intimidating and care nothing for anyone but themselves. It’s quite soul destroying seeing the money ploughed into trying to help them, only for them to not engage with any support offered and simply carry on. They’re a black hole of ‘need’ and very very very very few ever go on to live a remotely productive life. The justice system, A&E, the benefits system, police - they exhaust public services and merely keeping them alive costs a fortune. And in return, as you say they make our towns and cities a destructive or oppressive place to be.

I work in this area too and just wanted to say thank you for expressing this so well - this is exactly my experience and I feel like there is so much resistance to just stating the situation outright.

You really agree that "money is being ploughed into them"? It's nonsense. Since the Conservatives gained power 14 years ago funding for services that would help them have been savagely cut.

It's bizarre that so many are discussing this with no context - not acknowledging, or are ignorant of, how and why this has happened. Behind the banal platitudes, the Conservative Party has been in the grip of an extremist economic ideology that will only ever benefit their already wealthy friends and family.

AbstractThought · 27/04/2024 01:44

To be honest I am tired of this issue only ever being reduced to poverty.

I actually believe, from what I have witnessed, that there is far more to it. Far more that is complex, cultural; sub cultures made up of people who have stepped out of society whether as a result of addiction issues or multi generational exposure to crime, welfare dependency or trauma. People who think anything outside of their street is their enemy.
They are honestly a different breed altogether, and I strongly doubt money would alter that mindset. It wouldn't increase their interest or belief in education.
There are people living in terrible conditions trying to thrive, who care about their environment and want a better life, decent schools that aren't rife with disruption. If I was dealing with poverty I would not want to be lumped in with that. Simplifying this behaviour as only the result of poverty hurts those who are actually enduring it.

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 27/04/2024 01:27

We luve in a holiday area on the SC .town centre has gone downhill.lots of homeless people, went to town .two were having a fight very scary 😨. M and S closed ,nothing in its place . Seems a national problem

AbstractThought · 27/04/2024 01:27

We are in a non council area that is separated by a busy road from a lot of single person council flats. It was very quiet and uneventful only a decade ago, but something changed quite suddenly. I heard that problem tenants were moved over as the elderly residents died off. It seems that way, but I don't know for sure if that was the how it began.
A friend who works for the housing dept told us that this was planned as far back as 2007. I agree with a pp who mentioned the welfarisation of council housing. Many things have had an impact, austerity just rammed in the last nail.
The previous residents were single working or disabled folk and the elderly. Now most of the windows and doors of these flats are permanently being put through. These are flats and homes that used to look cared for and inviting.

To watch this happen to what used to feel like our 'home' town is distressing. You see it chipped away at bit by bit. It isn't merely council areas that are affected. It is like watching something die.

I lived in rented properties for much of my life, and mostly had good experiences. What I will never, ever understand is why someone who is fortunate enough to have their rent secured will just piss it up the wall and destroy a home - not to mention the lives of those around them.

OP posts:
silverneedle · 27/04/2024 01:23

BringMeSunshineAllDayLong · 27/04/2024 01:21

It's never been this bad since I was an adult and I'm 50.
The Tories have stripped out assets and made themselves and their millionaire mates money.
In front of our eyes they have demonised the poor and made the wealthy have more money.
Only a fool or a selfish well off person would vote for them again.

Agree.

BringMeSunshineAllDayLong · 27/04/2024 01:21

EmmaEmerald · 26/04/2024 16:38

Not defending this govt

the last time I saw this was the end of the Brown government

before that, the end of the Major government

maybe government always does nothing at the time they expect to be kicked out?

This time I think will be harder because of technology and overpopulation- yes I said the o word. But it does seem a familiar decline. The worry this time is that recovery won’t happen in the ways we’ve seen before because of tech doing so many jobs.

also I’ve never seen such a lackadaisical approach to drug use. I don’t know how to feel about that. I thought legalisation was the right path but now I’m confused.

It's never been this bad since I was an adult and I'm 50.
The Tories have stripped out assets and made themselves and their millionaire mates money.
In front of our eyes they have demonised the poor and made the wealthy have more money.
Only a fool or a selfish well off person would vote for them again.

passtheajax · 27/04/2024 01:16

I just want to go outside and see normal people again. Everyone seems so crazy now. I worry about how many animals and wildlife are suffering at the hands of these out of control humans.

silverneedle · 27/04/2024 01:15

user8800 · 26/04/2024 16:46

Since 2010...
Tory Austerity policies
Cutting public services to the bone
Brexit...
Nhs on its knees
Education ditto
Covid...
Tories dishing out £billions to their mates
Rishi sunak causing a housing bubble in 2020-22
Invasion of Ukraine...
Food and energy prices go up ^
Trussonomics...
Nuff said. Mad bint.

Not that difficult to understand, really 😡

This ^

Meanwhile:

Total wealth of UK billionaires

▪️2012: £212 Billion
▪️2022: £653 Billion

That's up 3-fold.

EmmaEmerald · 27/04/2024 01:14

Turns out there's a name for what I'm seeing with the teeth - it's called Meth Mouth.

Sorry to harp on but just wonder if some posters are aware of what huge drug problems we have. It's a very specific thing and not about lack of NHS dentists (a separate problem).

The horror on the "needles in Gregg's" thread really surprised me. That was going on when I was a teen....probably longer but I only noticed as a teen.

Was 20+ years ago that my GP said they didn't like prescribing Valium because they had to risk assess who might be selling it to heroin addicts - if you can't get heroin, apparently Valium helps. It's only in later years they raised the addiction issue as a reason for refusal.

Btw my life is really not as depressing as it might look from my MN posts 😳😂

silverneedle · 27/04/2024 01:02

Cumulative, austerity- biggest, Brexit and covid

JenniferBooth · 27/04/2024 01:00

Well i doubt the millions sitting on NHS waiting lists waiting for hip and knee replacements are able to wander up and down pedestrianized high streets. Someone im close to has been waiting five years for a knee replacement and hasnt been into his local town centre for years, Cant park Cant get a blue badge because despite the long wait the situation is seen as temporary

Wineatfiveisfine · 27/04/2024 00:54

This is the main reason we moved out of a large town to somewhere rural. We only moved about 15 miles away, but when we drive back through, there are huge differences - and it’s heartbreaking to witness.

We moved in 2018 and in that space of time, there are stabbings, a massive rise in homelessness, high street break ins, and even gun crime. (Home Counties). I’m so glad we now live somewhere that is essentially crime free and safe for our children to grow up.

LightSpeeds · 27/04/2024 00:43

user8800 · 26/04/2024 16:46

Since 2010...
Tory Austerity policies
Cutting public services to the bone
Brexit...
Nhs on its knees
Education ditto
Covid...
Tories dishing out £billions to their mates
Rishi sunak causing a housing bubble in 2020-22
Invasion of Ukraine...
Food and energy prices go up ^
Trussonomics...
Nuff said. Mad bint.

Not that difficult to understand, really 😡

^ Yep, this sums most of it up.

Oh, and no NHS dentists anymore (and no dentists for a lot of people). That could partly explain the teeth issue, as well as the fact that, if you're in a bad life situation and maybe can't get healthy food, brushing your teeth may not be a priority.

JenniferBooth · 27/04/2024 00:42

user1484492781 · 26/04/2024 21:11

I live in social housing. 10 years ago where I live would most definitely not be defined as " rough "
Cue now ...my neighbour downstairs is an alcoholic with a ketamine habit . Other side of me is a house . Young male deals class a drugs . Police have turned it over twice since Christmas . Other side ..two flats . Both addicts .

Other side average family home ...two buildings next door , 4 flats , each with a tenant with addictions .
It's fun trying to get up in the morning here I can tell you .
I constantly say to friends and family when did things get so wild in this part of town ?
It must be a reflection of current issues in the city but tbh although I waited a long time for this property ( was homeless for a while ) I do not want to live like this forever and yet , see no way out . Its hectic and scary at times x

John Boughton (author of Municipal Dreams The Rise and Fall of Council Housing) on the welfarisation of council housing.

//www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-rise-and-fall-of-council-housing-56139

In the 1980s, residualisation may have been a partly unintended consequence of housing policies pursued with varying ideological intent

Since 2010, and more so since the return of single-party Conservative government in 2015, we’ve seen something further: welfarisation – ‘a conception of social housing as a very small, highly residualised sector catering only for the very poorest, and those with additional social “vulnerabilities”, on a short-term “ambulance” basis

The Rise and Fall of Council Housing

To mark its paperback release, we are republishing an extract from acclaimed history book Municipal Dreams: the rise and fall of council housing. Here, author John Boughton explains how council housing became ’welfarised’

https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-rise-and-fall-of-council-housing-56139

Sladuf · 27/04/2024 00:42

YANBU OP.

@taxguru’s posts in particular struck a chord with me. Anti-car councils, of which there are sadly many, have been responsible for the death of many town centres. I think this business of new housing developments being required to have so many set aside for social housing hasn’t helped. From what I’ve seen even in pretty respectable villages the people who have moved into the social housing are often troublesome and troubled.

The fact astronomically high rates are charged seems to go in hand with the anti-car councils. I lived in a coastal town that had a reputation for being a bit rough back in the day though it depended which parts you lived and visited. A man we knew was stabbed to death walking through a park in the 90s near the town centre but he had some enemies.

The town centre was a decent place to shop until the 90s. It even had an independent family owned department store, which was great, a decent branch of Burton’s, shoe shops, jewellers, electronics stores. Now it’s like a lot of places - charity shops, fast food places, vape shops, barbers, salons, nail bars.
WH Smiths has recently left. I’m amazed Boots and Superdrug are still there. It lost New Look, Dorothy Perkins and Sports Direct all within a few months of each other and that was before Covid.

in short there’s bugger all to go there for really. Sadly the nearest retail parks aren’t up to much good either. You have to drive at least 15 minutes out of town to get to decent shops.

LightSpeeds · 27/04/2024 00:39

My (small) city isn't as bad as yours but there has been a significant decline in the past few years.

The police used to move homeless and drunk people on in the centre but now the homeless are actually living in shop doorways, often begging or accosting people.

At least two of the big hotels in the city are now being used for the homeless and refugees.

Loads of good shops have gone and are either empty or now vaping/betting shops.

The bus services are really shit but the council has almost doubled parking charges, further deterring people from going into the city centre.

Critical services have been cut (community meals for the elderly and vulnerable) but the council has an endless pot of money for new cycle lanes (many of which seem barely used).

Every newly tarmacked road is starting to go to pot(holes) after just a few months.

Roadworks everywhere all the time (often with no-one actually there working).

The police don't pick up the phones (to 111) or properly deal with crime and other complaints (not their fault - but it's just been cuts cuts cuts and services 're-focused').

There is a fairly huge and growing population of young people with on-going mental health problems who cannot work and hang around town the whole day long (this is not conjecture - I know these people and their situations).

It's sad and depressing for all involved.

PuppetQueen · 27/04/2024 00:13

Most of our nature areas and footpaths are destroyed by off road bikes now, the council won't even bother locking the gates that stopped vehicles gaining access. We have a small nature reserve that keeps getting set on fire. Benches in the area are chained together by their feet, it's just so depressing. No police presence at all. There's this feeling that no authority cares.
**
This makes me feel so sad.

RM2013 · 27/04/2024 00:09

The town I live in is a pretty Georgian riverside town and has been popular with tourists but over the years shops were closing and we seemed to have empty shops replaced with mostly charity shops and takeaways
many things have contributed, cost of living, online shopping, less provision to help those that need mental health services etc.
however there seems to have been a little bit of regeneration with some new bars and eating places opening making the place a bit more social again. Many surrounding towns though seem to be run down and have an air of neglect about them. Times have definitely changed and not necessarily for the better