Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want a second limited holiday with friend.

461 replies

Borntorun123 · 20/04/2024 06:27

NC for this.

I will start by saying I am lucky enough to have 3-4 budget holidays/ short breaks a year.

My last one was with an old friend who has mobility problems. She can manage most things but walking is very limited.

I willingly carried bags, pushed a wheelchair when necessary ( longer distances than she couldn’t walk in airports, etc), offered her first choice of seating, popped to shops for items, did everything I could to make things as comfortable and easy for her as possible.

She said that she had a good time and I am pleased. On the other hand I found that the holiday was so limited that I felt guilty and frustrated. I felt sorry for her, and very much appreciated my own physical health, but I constantly felt restricted. I run every day and was still able to do that, but whilst out saw places I would have liked to spend time exploring, or nice looking restaurants for a long dinner, etc. So many things to see and do.

Apart from travel by taxi to a few carefully chosen places, we could only go to one place on the beach where sun beds were provided
( charged) , and just one restaurant.

I can’t imagine how frustrated my friend is with being so immobile. I know I am very lucky.

She has now suggested going away together again. We’ve only been home a few weeks and it wouldn’t be until Autumn. She is looking to me to arrange everything as before. It took a lot of research, trying to ascertain what roads and paths are like, exact proximity to attractions, contacting property owners with several questions, etc. and despite my best efforts a few things still didn’t go to plan, which were commented upon.

I don’t want to go away with her again, at least not for the second time in a year. As well as being restricted it cost me significantly more due to taxis ( I rode in the taxi so of course split costs), it was always me popping to the shops for minor purchases, which individually seemed too trivial in cost to split, but actually totted up to a significant sum.

AIBU to tell her no? She couldn’t holiday alone, whereas I plan to do that for my next trip.

OP posts:
JMSA · 21/04/2024 08:09

If you do go away with her, try an all-inclusive resort. What you've just described sounds too much like hard work for a holiday.

Riverlee · 21/04/2024 08:05

@Borntorun123

’ I can that I have already made plans for Autumn, and can’t commit to another week long holiday abroad’

i think that’s a good response. Regardless of anyone’s personal circumstances, it’s a big ask to ask someone to go on holiday twice in one year. She may then start trying to pinpoint a holiday for next year, in which case you’ll just have to say you’ll worry about that next year etc. If she gets insistent, maybe point her in the directions of the links above and say you don’t know what your plans are yet. You’re not obliged to go on holiday with her - her holidays aren’t your responsibility.

BlueLimeRun · 21/04/2024 07:59

It’s the OP’s experience and thoughts that matter in this scenario- not yours @wombat15

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 07:52

Needanewname42 · 21/04/2024 07:48

Op said in her first post that friend has mobility problems and she'd sometimes used a wheelchair ♿️ like in airports and longer distances.

And they'd used lots of taxis so if they stayed in the UK lots of different cities to visit she could use a wheelchair/ mobility scooter and use buses / trains. And most visitor attractions are wheelchair friendly.

Airports provide wheelchairs and push them. It didn't sound like she uses one outside the airport. A mobility scooter is very different to a wheelchair and wouldn't require any pushing.

Needanewname42 · 21/04/2024 07:48

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 07:29

I don't think the friend is in a wheelchair and maybe drives.

Op said in her first post that friend has mobility problems and she'd sometimes used a wheelchair ♿️ like in airports and longer distances.

And they'd used lots of taxis so if they stayed in the UK lots of different cities to visit she could use a wheelchair/ mobility scooter and use buses / trains. And most visitor attractions are wheelchair friendly.

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 07:29

Needanewname42 · 21/04/2024 07:26

I'd say possibly a uk short break, you know the UK is fairly wheelchair friendly due to the disabled access laws introduced around 2003.

But I'd also be making sure a kitty is used for everything. So you don't end up paying more than your fair share

I don't think the friend is in a wheelchair and maybe drives.

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 07:27

LemonPeonies · 21/04/2024 02:37

"Caring for someone " involves assisting a person with things they're unable to do. It's not just personal care/ toileting. Having to manage a holiday based on limited choices, navigate places to go/ things to do, shopping etc falls under that. I bet there's more smaller things OP ends up doing that she hasn't mentioned as well.

Booking a holiday and doing some shopping on holiday doesn’t make someone a carer. If it does, I must be DH's carer.😂

Needanewname42 · 21/04/2024 07:26

I'd say possibly a uk short break, you know the UK is fairly wheelchair friendly due to the disabled access laws introduced around 2003.

But I'd also be making sure a kitty is used for everything. So you don't end up paying more than your fair share

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 07:22

pikkumyy77 · 21/04/2024 03:26

Why is it so hard for people to admit that the OP’s description of her experience is simply true? Her friend is technology impaired, likes one beach snd one restaurant , and doesn’t like walking. That would be true whether she is disabled or not. Its not the kind of holiday OP wants. So she shouldn’t agree to go again.

Has op said that her friend only liked one beach or one restaurant?. More likely that is all she did because that is all she could do due to her restricted mobility (not her fault) and the destination ( which OP chose). Do you think all disabled people can do everything non disabled people can do and are just choosing not to?

BlueLimeRun · 21/04/2024 07:21

It doesn’t matter what the 2or 3 guilt tripping posters say - it’s about what op wants to do. It’s not your responsibility, just say you’ve other holidays planned. No need to explain more.

pikkumyy77 · 21/04/2024 03:26

Why is it so hard for people to admit that the OP’s description of her experience is simply true? Her friend is technology impaired, likes one beach snd one restaurant , and doesn’t like walking. That would be true whether she is disabled or not. Its not the kind of holiday OP wants. So she shouldn’t agree to go again.

Catsmere · 21/04/2024 02:55

Janiie · 20/04/2024 12:39

'I didn't read the OP as moaning about disability, she's talking about the restrictions imposed'

Yes correct, she is moaning about the restrictions imposed. Caused by a disability.

I guarantee the friend finds it all much more of a bore than the op does. I just feel so sorry that the friend has no idea that her pal is online whining about said 'restrictions'.

Being a caring supportive friend isn't for everyone I suppose.

Being a caring supportive friend unpaid carer expected to organise everything and pay for their friend's extras and be complained at if everything isn't as friend wants it isn't for everyone I suppose.

FTFY.

Catsmere · 21/04/2024 02:39

exomoon · 20/04/2024 07:21

Don’t be guilt tripped into going away with her again, this year, next year or any year.

I think she is a bit of a CF for letting you pay for the shopping as well and also expecting you to organise it all.

She sees you more as a carer and a secretary, not a friend.

Yes, this. OP's friend is using her as an unpaid carer.

OP, if she needs this level of assistance she needs a professional carer, not you. She really is in CF territory expecting this of you even once, let alone repeatedly! Sounds like you didn't have a holiday at all.

And what happens if (or when) her health deteriorates further? Will she expect help with medications, toileting, whatever? I've just come off seven years as my mother's carer and you don't want to go there.

LemonPeonies · 21/04/2024 02:37

"Caring for someone " involves assisting a person with things they're unable to do. It's not just personal care/ toileting. Having to manage a holiday based on limited choices, navigate places to go/ things to do, shopping etc falls under that. I bet there's more smaller things OP ends up doing that she hasn't mentioned as well.

LemonPeonies · 21/04/2024 02:33

@NoisySnail This limited their choices though as it sounds like they couldn't get taxis for whatever reason. Its in the OP's title "limiting my holiday ". If she can't walk far and OP wanted to go for a walk, she can't. She's clearly taken the caring role without it being discussed first, just expected to do it all.

ABirdsEyeView · 21/04/2024 02:20

Friendships are rooted in equality - it's not the same as love, where you might make personal sacrifices and not mind so much.

If one friend is pushed into the carer role or ends up with the responsibility of planning and booking and paying for more than their share, this isn't an 'equal' experience. It actually damages the friendship. And it's not your job to ensure someone else has a good time at the expense of your own experience.

I don't see this as attacking disability, more that 2 people have very different requirements from a holiday and their particular styles aren't compatible for a whole week at a time.

OP, I wouldn't criticise to get the holiday you went on as it will hurt her feelings unnecessarily and what's done is done and cannot be changed now. I think the best approach is to say you have things planned already/that you want a more active experience. Don't make it personal, even if she has been a bit thoughtless re the planning and spending.

I think you'd be okay doing a short break with her in the future, but changing how you go about it, so that you do get to go off and see what you want to see and meet up for dinner etc. But let her know in advance that you are going to explore a bit , so she knows not to expect you with her 24/7.

NoisySnail · 21/04/2024 01:10

@LemonPeonies The friend does not appear to use a wheelchair normally. She can not walk longer distances so takes taxis. The only "care" OP provided was to go shopping for supplies and push a wheelchair in the airport - she did not need to push the wheelchair, staff will do that.

WelshTattySlippers · 21/04/2024 00:33

YANBU OP. It sounds you each have very different ideas about what you want from a holiday so you are not compatible holiday buddies. Why would you spend money on another holiday you know isn’t going to be your idea of a great holiday. Use your money to benefit yourself. Your friend can do the same.

I have some friends I would go on holiday with because they enjoy walking, sightseeing, history, trying different foods and pretty much the same things as me. I have other friends who are great for a night out or to meet with the D.C. in the park. I wouldn’t think about going on holiday with them though. Their idea of a great holiday is sitting by the pool all day, everyday, drinking and topping up their tan. That would bore me to death.

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 00:25

LemonPeonies · 21/04/2024 00:12

It's not just that the OP had to organise absolutely everything though. She sacrificed a lot of time staying in certain places rather than exploring because the friend can't walk far, requiring OP to push her in a wheelchair for longer distances. The OP had to keep topping up supplies in the shop and pay. The list goes on. Sounds like a boring holiday of an unpaid carer, so yeah the cf friend should get a support worker to do these things if she can't do them for herself.

Given that all they did was go to one beach and one restaurant it doesn't seem that the organisation of absolutely everything involved much. I'm not clear on where OP was pushing the friend in a wheelchair either apart from the airport where she made a choice to push the wheelchair. Surely the OP would have had to top up supplies for herself even if the friend hadn't been there and she could have asked for the money. The paying for everything doesn't seem to be anything to do with disability.
Yes, it does sound like a boring holiday but some people like those sort of holidays. OP obviously doesn't which is fair enough but suggesting she is a carer just because she booked the boring holiday, didn't explore by herself and went to the shops is ridiculous.

LemonPeonies · 21/04/2024 00:12

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 00:00

I don't think someone who can walk short distances, uses taxis and does not have impaired cognitive function requires a carer and don't get why the holiday required OP to do a huge amount of research.

Perhaps she let OP do the "research" because she thought that would mean she was choosing a holiday she would like. Maybe she thought OP chose the holiday she did because she likes going to a beach in the day and a restaurant in the evening and doesn't care if it is the same one. Maybe she didn't think OP was doing her a huge favour by going on holiday with her and thought that she actually liked going on holiday with a friend rather than by herself.

It's not just that the OP had to organise absolutely everything though. She sacrificed a lot of time staying in certain places rather than exploring because the friend can't walk far, requiring OP to push her in a wheelchair for longer distances. The OP had to keep topping up supplies in the shop and pay. The list goes on. Sounds like a boring holiday of an unpaid carer, so yeah the cf friend should get a support worker to do these things if she can't do them for herself.

NoisySnail · 21/04/2024 00:09

The popping to shops for items is obviously equivalent to being a full time carer.
Bloody ridiculous this thread.

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 00:04

katebushh · 20/04/2024 21:54

YANBU at all, you're her friend not her carer.

I get that OP felt restricted on the holiday but in what way was she her friend's carer? All I can see is that she "offered her first choice of seating and popped to shops for items". She didn't need to push the wheelchair at the airport either.

NoisySnail · 21/04/2024 00:03

Exactly! The huge amount of research will just be booking a hotel with a lift that you can get a taxi to, and with a beach that you do not have a long walk to. Loads of places meet that criteria.

wombat15 · 21/04/2024 00:00

LemonPeonies · 20/04/2024 23:49

@graceinspace999 you're missing the point. I didn't generalise to say anything about disabled people. I'm pointing out this particular "friend" needs to sort how she will travel and get about rather than relying on someone she's supposed to be enjoying a holiday with. She sounds like she lacks insight into how her lack of capabilities affect others.

I don't think someone who can walk short distances, uses taxis and does not have impaired cognitive function requires a carer and don't get why the holiday required OP to do a huge amount of research.

Perhaps she let OP do the "research" because she thought that would mean she was choosing a holiday she would like. Maybe she thought OP chose the holiday she did because she likes going to a beach in the day and a restaurant in the evening and doesn't care if it is the same one. Maybe she didn't think OP was doing her a huge favour by going on holiday with her and thought that she actually liked going on holiday with a friend rather than by herself.

LemonPeonies · 20/04/2024 23:49

@graceinspace999 you're missing the point. I didn't generalise to say anything about disabled people. I'm pointing out this particular "friend" needs to sort how she will travel and get about rather than relying on someone she's supposed to be enjoying a holiday with. She sounds like she lacks insight into how her lack of capabilities affect others.