Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I increasingly resent my in-laws!

220 replies

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 21:35

I'll start with I know I can't do anything about this and I should be happy for them but it's hard.
DH and I have 2 kids, I work 28 hours a week, he works 40 hours. I'm on little above minimum wage, he makes £14 an hour. 2 years ago my parents were able to give us £10,000 we used this a deposit on a house. We are in Scotland so that was little less than 10%. We were in a council house before that, but the area was awful, we were planning to use MIL for childcare and our kids would have to share a small room, plus I don't like the idea of boy/girl siblings sharing.
Our house is fine, it's not modern at all, basic and tired but functional.

DSs sister lives in a council house. She struck gold and got a council house on a private development when she had her twins as that put her up to 3 kids and classed as overcrowded, it's beautiful the houses on the estate all sold for 220k for a 3 bed which is double what our house was! She works 14 hours a week, makes a little more an hour than I do. Her husband is a joiner for the council and makes 33k a year.
PIL are also in a council house.

Here's the issue, they seem to live a much better life than we do! They go on 3 holidays a year (yes usually it's haven and euro camp but still!), have a nice newish car on lease etc.
This is mainly as they still get UC, which covers their full rent and then some. Since we bought we no longer qualify for any UC and as such we also can't get the Scottish child payment!
To top it off, they have just installed a new kitchen and bathroom in the house, it was basic before, but still it was only 2 years old!!! I know her DH is a joiner and did all the fitting himself and his dad is a painter and decorated so helped. Now they are doing the same for PIL.
It's so frustrating, we thought we were doing the right thing buying but now we are worse off, work more, make less when benefits are added.

AIBU to be really resentful that they are able to do all this and we can't? It feels like the system is broken!

OP posts:
Nospecialcharactersplease · 19/04/2024 23:19

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 23:06

That doesn't necessarily make sense though, both SIL and her partner have qualifications but still use benefits?

Are you really using your sample of 1 person you know to suggest that getting qualifications is a waste of time?

Here’s another sample of 1. I have qualifications too OP, and I’ve never received benefits in my life. I was homeless at 16 too. Worked minimum wage waitressing until 2am each night then went to college all day. No parents on the scene flinging deposits my way. No council house. Went to uni, graduated, forged a career (starting with unpaid internships, relocating three times), paid my student loans, bought a house, paid for my wedding. Just passed my driving test (at nearly 40) because I could finally afford lessons. Next stop is the dentist, to fix my teeth, because I didn’t have the money to go for 20 years.

Stop bloody whining about the system being broken. If you want nice things go and earn them, like almost everyone else (just not the ones you know, clearly).

Piglet89 · 19/04/2024 23:17

OP: [moans] AIBU?
PPs: yeah, here’s how you might fix it.
OP: yeah, no, here’s why I can’t do that [moans].

what did you want from the thread, OP? Just some tea and sympathy?

Piglet89 · 19/04/2024 23:14

@Time4achangeithink putting “one of the best universities in the world” in quotation marks suggests you think I may be lying about that.

I am not, so you can stand down.

nadine90 · 19/04/2024 23:14

Comparisons and jealousy will never get you the things you want or lead you to happiness. There will always be someone better off than you. Equally, there are more people much worse off than you can imagine. Practice gratitude op. That’s the only way you’ll ever be happy with what you have

YabbaDabbaDooooo · 19/04/2024 23:13

Nospecialcharactersplease · 19/04/2024 23:05

You didn’t get qualifications and don’t want a mentally taxing role, but you want a higher salary. You didn’t save a deposit, you were gifted it, and still you’re moaning about all the free rent you’re missing out on. And you don’t pay for childcare, your MIL does it.

Stop moaning about how big your life raft is, and whether someone else had a better one, and just learn to swim a bit better.

Edited

This x 100 👏👏👏

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 23:06

Nospecialcharactersplease · 19/04/2024 23:05

You didn’t get qualifications and don’t want a mentally taxing role, but you want a higher salary. You didn’t save a deposit, you were gifted it, and still you’re moaning about all the free rent you’re missing out on. And you don’t pay for childcare, your MIL does it.

Stop moaning about how big your life raft is, and whether someone else had a better one, and just learn to swim a bit better.

Edited

That doesn't necessarily make sense though, both SIL and her partner have qualifications but still use benefits?

OP posts:
everydaywonderful · 19/04/2024 23:05

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 23:04

@everydaywonderful how do I do that when I need to earn and have small children to care for?

you study when they are in bed. You clearly are able to use the internet. You need to find a way.

Nospecialcharactersplease · 19/04/2024 23:05

You didn’t get qualifications and don’t want a mentally taxing role, but you want a higher salary. You didn’t save a deposit, you were gifted it, and still you’re moaning about all the free rent you’re missing out on. And you don’t pay for childcare, your MIL does it.

Stop moaning about how big your life raft is, and whether someone else had a better one, and just learn to swim a bit better.

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 23:04

@everydaywonderful how do I do that when I need to earn and have small children to care for?

OP posts:
everydaywonderful · 19/04/2024 23:03

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 21:41

Not really, I don't have any skills or qualifications past age 16. I work in a supermarket and obviously take more hours when I can but we are limited by childcare, obviously don't want to overly rely on grandparents. MIL already does pick up 4 days a week and has them 4 days in all the holidays.

get more qualifications then.. Thats up to you.

Yes, I do think YABU. I bought in London as a single parent. Yes I was well below the bread line for over 10 years, until I stopped needing to pay childcare. I struggled financially for another 10 years, only holidays were taking a tent by public transport. Now though, mortgage is paid, and I am rent and mortgage free!

Obviously, people on benefits can have far more income than people paying a mortgage, it has always been like that. But it is a long game

Everydayimhuffling · 19/04/2024 22:59

OP, I think your last comment really hit the nail on the head: all jobs SHOULD pay enough full time to live off. It's totally reasonable to feel angry about that, and to feel angry that the government subsidises companies to pay less than the living wage and that screws people over because the line of when you can and can't claim has a big effect.

But it's not your in laws' fault. And feeling jealous and resentful of them is not good for your life and family relations. Try to keep the anger where it should be, if you can.

Thedogscollar · 19/04/2024 22:55

You are way beyond unreasonable.
Count your blessings and stop with the comparisons and the jealousy it's eating you up.

Runnerinthenight · 19/04/2024 22:54

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 22:39

Maybe all jobs should pay enough that no one needs to live off the state then!
It's not like I don't work!!

A lot of us have had to work full-time and pay for extortionate childcare. You are doing neither.

LenaLamont · 19/04/2024 22:50

Your parents gave you a £10K deposit for a house and you have free childcare. From where I'm sitting you are looking pretty damned fortunate.

Maybe focus on the positives in your own life rather than comparing yourself to those on benefits.

GodspeedJune · 19/04/2024 22:49

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 21:44

I've put it in the benefits calculator and they are!! All of their children count for benefit purposes as there are twins, so they get about £650 according to the calculator and Scottish child payment which is £26.70 a week per child.

It’s weird that you’ve done that. Focus on your own life. Comparison is the thief of joy.

User1979289 · 19/04/2024 22:48

You own your house!!! Nothing beats that. You have to realise that they will always be reliant on this system due to rent, it may seem great now but when they retire and are on a pension, unless they have contributed to a private pension they will be struggling. You need to try and improve yours and your husbands incomes as the kids get older it will get easier - pay as much as you can down on the mortgage and contribute to any work pensions available. Then you will be doing better and better as you get older. The mortgage gets paid off, ou have good pensions and can enjoy holidays and relax! You are the ones with the aspirational lifestyle.

HornyHornersPinkyWinky · 19/04/2024 22:45

OP you have so much to be grateful for, maybe just try and focus on that.
You were gifted a deposit for your house, you will eventually own it and be able to pass it on to your kids, or sell up and move somewhere else if you like in the future. You work part time so have more time with your children when they are young, they have a bedroom each.

You need to let go of what your SIL has vs. what you have. It's just different. If your sister ends up with a horrible neighbour there won't be much she can do about it. There are so many people worse off than you.

If it makes you feel any better, I'm renting and will probably never be able to afford my own place, It's so difficult to save a deposit, and I wouldn't get enough of a mortgage as a single person, unless I wanted to live in a shed or something.

Piglet89 · 19/04/2024 22:42

@AmesandKe ok let’s leave education off the table.

you have in laws who have children. Your kids (presumably) have cousins to play with. My only child (and I’m an only child) has no such thing. I don’t want more kids (as I work 4 days in a demanding job and have no family support). Would love my son to have some cousins to play with.

seriously: count your blessings otherwise you’ll end up seriously embittered.

Sunquest · 19/04/2024 22:41

Must be because she has twins.

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 22:39

Piglet89 · 19/04/2024 22:38

Just because you’re “not smart” doesn’t mean you’re entitled to have your family and the state support you for the rest of your days.

Maybe all jobs should pay enough that no one needs to live off the state then!
It's not like I don't work!!

OP posts:
YabbaDabbaDooooo · 19/04/2024 22:39

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 22:36

Well I'm very happy for you and that you were able to do that.
I wasn't, and not everyone can. Someone will always have to staff the supermarket, wait tables and work in care homes!
The reality is I don't want a professional job, I like what I do. I like that when I leave work I don't have to do extra work on the evenings, I like that I can live rurally.
I'm not smart that's ok.

The next time your in the supermarket why don't you let the person serving you know that you think you are superior to them as you are so clever, maybe tell them to grow up to!

The reality is I don't want a professional job, I like what I do. I like that when I leave work I don't have to do extra work on the evenings, I like that I can live rurally.

Sorry, so what is the problem then?

If you're happy with what you've chosen for yourself, why do other people's lives bother you?

Piglet89 · 19/04/2024 22:38

Just because you’re “not smart” doesn’t mean you’re entitled to have your family and the state support you for the rest of your days.

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 22:38

LordPercyPercy · 19/04/2024 22:21

As a fellow Scot, the general attitude of entitlement towards benefits in Scottish society is staggering.
OP why don't you look to retrain once both children are at school and progress your career? That would be a far better use of your mental energy.

What would I do about earning during that time? I need to earn money and be present for my kids.

SIL has a qualification (SCQF level 7 so first year of uni equivalent) and is still only making a little more than minimum wage ... would I really be better off?

OP posts:
Time4achangeithink · 19/04/2024 22:37

Piglet89 · 19/04/2024 22:14

Stunned you’re not getting your arse handed to you, TBH, OP. Your entitlement is UNREAL.

Unlike you, I didn’t finish school at 16, studied hard, got a degree from one of the best universities in the world and progressed to a professional career.

No siblings, no parental help on tap whatsoever, we are on our own and must pay for everything (including extortionate childcare) ourselves.

Time to grow up.

Just goes to show you can be educated at 'one of the best universities in the world' and still be so ignorant.

YabbaDabbaDooooo · 19/04/2024 22:36

AmesandKe · 19/04/2024 21:44

I've put it in the benefits calculator and they are!! All of their children count for benefit purposes as there are twins, so they get about £650 according to the calculator and Scottish child payment which is £26.70 a week per child.

This is weird behaviour.

Stop it and keep your nose in your own life.