Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable?

289 replies

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 12/04/2024 09:24

My husband and I are having a debate and I would like to know who is wrong. I am posting in AIBU for traffic.

We are a family of 5.

3 working full time. 1 working part time and one at Sixth form.

How many of the following do a family like ours use.

Toilet rolls
Kitchen rolls
bottles of shower gel
Bottles of shampoo and conditioner
Fabric conditioner
Washing pods
Deodorant
Tooth paste
Gas and electric per month.

And any other items that you buy weekly/monthly.

Settle a debate and help me prove my Husband wrong.

OP posts:
clary · 14/04/2024 12:20

Hmm @TheSpoonyNavyReader I've just noticed that you op says three full time at work, one part time work and one in sixth form.

Then in your reply to me you say two kids are at home most if the day. Sixth form is usually full time IME so that's not adding up. If one dc is studying part time and has a part time job they're not going to be home that often.

Anyway I am not virtue signalling gosh no. After all I drive a petrol car a lot. I'm just too stingy to use so much shower gel when soap is cheaper and flatly refuse to waste money on kitchen roll.

If you want ways to cut your consumption there are plenty of suggestions here. But I think you just want your ways reinforced and justified. I mean you do what you want for sure.

jannier · 14/04/2024 12:13

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:23

19k a year, sorry for the typo.

That's a huge amount £365 a week I'm sure there are savings you can make is there much wasted food? Do you only buy brands. Cleaning materials can be cut down with white Vinager ....there is a low scent version....it's antibacterial and combined with bicarb or on its own cleans most things...stains, glass, microwaves, air fryer, limescale, fabric softener it's endless.

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 14/04/2024 11:59

PeterGabrielsunderpants · 14/04/2024 11:40

I think that in the future, people will need to live much simpler lives. Not batshit at all. Can you imagine the environmental impact if all the Indian masses suddenly started consuming hundreds of thousands of loo rolls?

If you think we need to live a simpler life and the answer is not to use toilet paper then there is an issue with you.

Please start using your hand to wipe your arse and tell me how you get on.

OP posts:
TheSpoonyNavyReader · 14/04/2024 11:57

MolkosTeenageAngst · 14/04/2024 11:47

When I was in India every supermarket sold toilet roll and most of the Middle classes had sit down toilets and toilet roll available in their homes. I’m also not sure what you mean about most people only having one ‘wearing cloth,’ even when I was staying in the middle of a slum and when I was staying in a tribal community in the middle of the jungle those I was living with and near had more than one outfit each.

The poster was trying to do some pearl clutching which has failed, honestly it is funny that their attempt was to use the poorest on the planet.

OP posts:
MolkosTeenageAngst · 14/04/2024 11:47

PeterGabrielsunderpants · 14/04/2024 11:40

I think that in the future, people will need to live much simpler lives. Not batshit at all. Can you imagine the environmental impact if all the Indian masses suddenly started consuming hundreds of thousands of loo rolls?

When I was in India every supermarket sold toilet roll and most of the Middle classes had sit down toilets and toilet roll available in their homes. I’m also not sure what you mean about most people only having one ‘wearing cloth,’ even when I was staying in the middle of a slum and when I was staying in a tribal community in the middle of the jungle those I was living with and near had more than one outfit each.

PeterGabrielsunderpants · 14/04/2024 11:40

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 14/04/2024 11:14

I have been to India, thanks and understand poverty, do you really think that the people there would not use toilet roll instead of their hand to wipe themselves if they could..
This comment is batshit and India's carbon footprint is even larger than the UKs per head.

As I have said I will not be washing my towels so often.

Edited

I think that in the future, people will need to live much simpler lives. Not batshit at all. Can you imagine the environmental impact if all the Indian masses suddenly started consuming hundreds of thousands of loo rolls?

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 14/04/2024 11:14

PeterGabrielsunderpants · 14/04/2024 11:01

OP, I think you need something to break your routine. You are leading a luxury life, and your mind is in a fixed loop of thoughts about cleanliness. Some pps have suggested OCD. Maybe (and I mean this kindly) take a long trip to somewhere like India...not much loo roll around there, just people using their left hand and water to clean their bums. Poor people there have one wearing-cloth which they wash in the river and dry in the sun. You need to break free of your own thoughts...

I have been to India, thanks and understand poverty, do you really think that the people there would not use toilet roll instead of their hand to wipe themselves if they could..
This comment is batshit and India's carbon footprint is even larger than the UKs per head.

As I have said I will not be washing my towels so often.

OP posts:
PeterGabrielsunderpants · 14/04/2024 11:01

OP, I think you need something to break your routine. You are leading a luxury life, and your mind is in a fixed loop of thoughts about cleanliness. Some pps have suggested OCD. Maybe (and I mean this kindly) take a long trip to somewhere like India...not much loo roll around there, just people using their left hand and water to clean their bums. Poor people there have one wearing-cloth which they wash in the river and dry in the sun. You need to break free of your own thoughts...

DirectionToPerfection · 14/04/2024 10:57

We're just two adults so will obviously use less than a family with kids, but I'm amazed how much shampoo and conditioner most people here are getting through.

You only need a small amount. Unless every member of the family is washing their hair every single day, a standard bottle should last much longer than a week.

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 14/04/2024 10:56

clary · 14/04/2024 10:45

Our use of other things mentioned are comparable to most

Sorry @TheSpoonyNavyReader but I don't agree. Most people don't seem to be using the amount of toiletries you use.

Personally I change sheets weekly too but I shrink from judging those who don't.

Also I'm not sure what you wanted here - lots if ppl disagree with you but apparently they are wrong. 🙄

Where have I stated how much shower gel, shampoo we use and I have stated that we are in line with what most posters have said on here.

I am also not going to take what most people have said here as the truth as most seem to be environmentalist's that are not happy with anything that does not align to their beliefs.

You know that judging works both ways and believe me I have been judged on everything I have said.

OP posts:
clary · 14/04/2024 10:45

Our use of other things mentioned are comparable to most

Sorry @TheSpoonyNavyReader but I don't agree. Most people don't seem to be using the amount of toiletries you use.

Personally I change sheets weekly too but I shrink from judging those who don't.

Also I'm not sure what you wanted here - lots if ppl disagree with you but apparently they are wrong. 🙄

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 14/04/2024 06:53

Nanny0gg · 13/04/2024 23:38

What?

I don't have these conversations with her. She's pretty sensible about these things. And I don't judge her. You put your methods and spending on here. Were you not expecting comments?
But she does have a nose for smells. and dirt.

And you must think the majority of people you come across are dirty.

Well even my hyper sensitive DiL- That is a judgement.

Everyone I know showers daily, without fail.

Of course I was expecting comments, but the batshit ones of I am killing the planet made me laugh and made me see that there are crazy people on here. Our use of other things mentioned are comparable to most, and I am happy and more importantly my husband can see that we are reasonable in our use.

The virtue signalling on here was off the scale.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 13/04/2024 23:38

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:09

Easy, when visiting anyone I would not get into a bed that is not fresh and clean.

Your hyper sensitive DIL is correct, maybe she just rolls her eyes at you and your child is telling her that's Mum, her standards are not great but its what I am used to. Your comments on here make you feel sorry for your DIL, you must be the most judgemental MIL ever.

What?

I don't have these conversations with her. She's pretty sensible about these things. And I don't judge her. You put your methods and spending on here. Were you not expecting comments?
But she does have a nose for smells. and dirt.

And you must think the majority of people you come across are dirty.

neilyoungismyhero · 13/04/2024 20:08

@InTheShallowTheShalalalalalalalow Not wishing to derail the thread but there are two of us older people in a small two bed house and our gas/electric is 150 pounds a month! Need to lie down in a darkened room literally I think

clary · 13/04/2024 20:03

Ah Ok I have read some of your posts now @TheSpoonyNavyReader and I apologise for my clearly unclean family (!) not getting through a 12 rolls of loo paper a week. It's not something I police for others tbh but speaking for myself, I am clean and do not smell.

The towels thing is bonkers - I wash ours (everyone has their own) once a week. Between showers and baths they are hung up to dry. I agree with others - no need to wash all clothes every wear - and if you cannot see how "top and underwear" is a lot less laundry than "top, underwear, jumper and trousers", esp when multiplied by five people, then I give up tbh.

I've never used conditioner or artificial scents myself as DD has bad eczema and anything like that flares it up. We still all smell lovely, I promise. I believe laundry conditioner is not good for your clothes long term anyway.

My deodorant is not roll on, it;'s a solid stick thing. Worth a try as it's a lot longer lasting by the sounds. We have more than one loo too but I don't see why that means more loo roll tbh. More loos to clean tho haha

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 13/04/2024 20:02

Everyone in our house has their own shampoo, conditioner, body wash, but no one showers every day so they all last usually a month.

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 20:01

clary · 13/04/2024 19:50

Hey OP not RTFT but we are a family of five adults tho one is not here very much:

Toilet rolls - about 3 a week
Kitchen rolls - never buy, use cloths
bottles of shower gel - use soap, buy that every couple of months max, shower gel bought at Christmas
Bottles of shampoo and conditioner - about one bottle of H&S a month
Fabric conditioner - ugh never use
Washing pods - use big box powders, about 6-7 washes a week so a box of 100 washes for about £13 lasts about 3 months +
Deodorant - ? every few months
Tooth paste - again, every few months
Gas and electric per month - not sure atm but more than it was

WOW at some of these posts. 2-3 loads of laundry a day? Two bottles of shampoo a week?

@TheSpoonyNavyReader you are doing 22 washes a week? You each use a can of deodorant in a fortnight? Maybe you need to make some swaps. My deodorant is a solid stick and it lasts a lot longer than a fortnight. And 12 loo rolls a week? Are you all at home all the time? even so - that's almost two a day!

The toilet rolls is for 3-4 bathrooms and we have lots of guests staying overnight like girlfriend/boyfriends, we have 2 kids home most days as they are studying part time.

I cant use roll on as they bring me up in a rash.

OP posts:
clary · 13/04/2024 19:50

Hey OP not RTFT but we are a family of five adults tho one is not here very much:

Toilet rolls - about 3 a week
Kitchen rolls - never buy, use cloths
bottles of shower gel - use soap, buy that every couple of months max, shower gel bought at Christmas
Bottles of shampoo and conditioner - about one bottle of H&S a month
Fabric conditioner - ugh never use
Washing pods - use big box powders, about 6-7 washes a week so a box of 100 washes for about £13 lasts about 3 months +
Deodorant - ? every few months
Tooth paste - again, every few months
Gas and electric per month - not sure atm but more than it was

WOW at some of these posts. 2-3 loads of laundry a day? Two bottles of shampoo a week?

@TheSpoonyNavyReader you are doing 22 washes a week? You each use a can of deodorant in a fortnight? Maybe you need to make some swaps. My deodorant is a solid stick and it lasts a lot longer than a fortnight. And 12 loo rolls a week? Are you all at home all the time? even so - that's almost two a day!

MolkosTeenageAngst · 13/04/2024 19:41

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 12:10

Yes
Your bedding is dirty if you only wash it every 2 weeks, and I am sure that there is an odour.

Do you wear pyjamas? I shower before bed and wear pyjamas so if I sweat it’s not going on the bed clothes, I don’t wash my bedding weekly but it smells fine.

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 19:06

YeahComeOnThen · 13/04/2024 18:51

@TheSpoonyNavyReader

£19k ... depends on what it includes I suppose, but PP that's about what I spend on groceries/toiletries etc.

Great thank you, that is good to know.

OP posts:
YeahComeOnThen · 13/04/2024 18:51

@TheSpoonyNavyReader

£19k ... depends on what it includes I suppose, but PP that's about what I spend on groceries/toiletries etc.

Jeezitneverends · 13/04/2024 17:51

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:12

As I have said countless times, I do too much washing, also use too much powder but live in a hard water area so have to use more powder anyway, double the amount for a soft water area.

I see that….if you add a cup of soda crystals along with the recommended amount of powder, that’s a brilliant water softener

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:23

TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:17

My husband was not concerned about the amount of laundry we did, he thinks it is normal to wash towels and clothes after every use.

He was more concerned with the amount of shower gel etc. Having asked on here we use the same amount as most, so not a problem.

We were looking at our monthly expenditure and our grocery bill was huge and total spend was 19K hence us asking questions.

19k a year, sorry for the typo.

OP posts:
TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:17

YeahComeOnThen · 13/04/2024 15:58

@TheSpoonyNavyReader

I live alone now & can't remember how much of what I bought when I didn't. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I wash my bed linen once a week in winter, twice (or more) in summer. I like a fresh bed especially when it's hot! (Yes, I do air it, but washing two sheets & some pillow cases isn't a hardship (all white so get washed with white t shirts etc). The duvet generally lives folded up on a chair most of the spring/summer (it's there already. I just have a sheet & a light blanket on the bed.

Towels get hung up after a shower and reused. I'm happy to reuse my own towel a few days, then they (towel for hair, towel for body) get washed with the bathroom hand towels (several as they get replaced daily).

T towels & dishcloths get replaced frequently through the day and go in a caddy with laundry cleanse (detol the non sensitive one smells lovely) and washed when the caddy is full. On their own, not with clothes or bath towels).

showers once or twice a day, sometimes more if it's very hot or I'm getting ready to go out again. Just depends what's going on.

clothes - the usual knickers, bra, socks, t shirt are put in the wash each day, but jeans go 2/3days depending on what I've been doing. Cardigans/jumpers several wears - often quite a few wears as I'm a hot person who only has them on for short bursts of time.

you really don't need to be washing your cashmere every 2 wears.

I use olive oil bar soap as it suits my skin. It lasts ages!

I wash my long hair most days & shampoo & conditioner both last ages and I'm not careful about how much I use. (must try harder).

toilet roll - mileage varies.

toothpaste.. ages.

there does seem to be a few things you could change if you were open to it. I see you've said about cutting down on washing, that's a start.

many of us do what our parents did 'as the norm' but I think your parents were a bit excessive & overly concerned about things

what would you like to get out of this thread now??

what was your husband saying that you thought was wrong? Have you changed you mind at all?

My husband was not concerned about the amount of laundry we did, he thinks it is normal to wash towels and clothes after every use.

He was more concerned with the amount of shower gel etc. Having asked on here we use the same amount as most, so not a problem.

We were looking at our monthly expenditure and our grocery bill was huge and total spend was 19K hence us asking questions.

OP posts:
TheSpoonyNavyReader · 13/04/2024 17:12

Jeezitneverends · 13/04/2024 14:55

So do you do 168 loads of washing a month or are you just using far too much?

As I have said countless times, I do too much washing, also use too much powder but live in a hard water area so have to use more powder anyway, double the amount for a soft water area.

OP posts: