Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should petrol money and accommodation be charged?

291 replies

PinkStarAtNight · 11/04/2024 10:23

I am looking for opinions on whether a person should be charged petrol money and accommodation fees or not.

So the situation is, person A and person B agreed to go on holiday with each other and booked a holiday together last year. They paid half for the holiday itself and, because it involves person A driving them there, they of course agreed they would split the petrol money.

Months later, person C, who is a close family member of person A, is going through a tough time and was invited to tag along on the holiday as they live alone and are struggling.

There is now a debate as to whether person C should pay a third of the petrol money and a third of the accommodation costs.

Accommodation has already been paid in full between person A and B, so paying for accommodation would involve person C handing over cash to person A and B to make it so they have essentially all paid a third each. And petrol money would be split three ways on the days of travel.

So...
Should person C pay an equal share of accommodation and petrol?

Or should they not have to pay, because person A and B planned this trip a while ago and would be paying half regardless of whether person C attends or not.

Person C will not be increasing costs in any way as the accommodation has always been big enough for three people, as person A and B booked a large caravan. Person C has agreed that they will not be dictating what happens on the holiday or factored into any decisions or plans for the activities, as they are only going because they don't want to be alone right now.

Also, does it make a difference that person C is close family member of one of the original people?

OP posts:
DoreenonTill8 · 11/04/2024 23:37

CastleCrasher · 11/04/2024 23:30

So is C A's (adult) child? That's what the dynamic sounds like. And A is bringing them along because for whatever reason, C doesn't fare so well on their own.

If this is the case, I'd be surprised if the holiday isn't changed as a result of C coming along. Maybe not intentionally, but A appears to put a big emphasis on C and their wellbeing, so is likely to prioritise them to Bs cost. Either way, the holiday is now for three people, three people should share the cost of it. If A doesn't want C to have to pay, they should cover their cost.

Agree, is A used to everyone just 'loving" her bring dc C along and saying how much joy they bring to things...

Mookie81 · 11/04/2024 23:33

Team B.
A and C are arseholes.

CastleCrasher · 11/04/2024 23:30

So is C A's (adult) child? That's what the dynamic sounds like. And A is bringing them along because for whatever reason, C doesn't fare so well on their own.

If this is the case, I'd be surprised if the holiday isn't changed as a result of C coming along. Maybe not intentionally, but A appears to put a big emphasis on C and their wellbeing, so is likely to prioritise them to Bs cost. Either way, the holiday is now for three people, three people should share the cost of it. If A doesn't want C to have to pay, they should cover their cost.

DoreenonTill8 · 11/04/2024 23:26

But who are a and c? Spouses? Parent and child? Feel c is either dm or overly loved child?

Ddff · 11/04/2024 23:23

So if the holiday park aren’t going to make up the double bed where do they think the 3 guests are sleeping? all 3 on the sofabed?!
FFS just give B her money back and A & C go away together…

literalviolence · 11/04/2024 23:14

So person B seems to perhaps have some money issues - she's trying to shave costs where possible with the bedding? But still you think maybe B should pay for C's holiday? A and C are being incredibly tight here. In terms of the holiday not being what C chose, when she doesn't have to go and if she wants to she needs to suck up the choices other made and pay the £60 for her share. To do anything else would be really unreasonable.

caringcarer · 11/04/2024 23:10

3 people each should pay 1/3 each and 1/3 petrol money too. It's obvious.

Riverlee · 11/04/2024 23:03

DragonFly98 · 11/04/2024 22:54

No person C should not pay are people always this petty.

Edited

Why shouldn’t C pay?

If A and C live together, is C bringing food as well, or is A?

RitzyMcFee · 11/04/2024 23:01

DragonFly98 · 11/04/2024 22:54

No person C should not pay are people always this petty.

Edited

So if you arranged to go away with a friend and then she said to you that her 27 year old was very upset because someone had attacked his Minecraft village and so he could not bear to be alone for a week so could he come with you two you would just be fine with it?

Or if your friend's husband was upset about something that he would not mention and could not stand to be without the friend for a week you would be OK with him coming along with you bit not paying?

DragonFly98 · 11/04/2024 22:54

No person C should not pay are people always this petty.

PurplePattern · 11/04/2024 22:48

ThinWomansBrain · 11/04/2024 22:31

if I was person B and a third person was invited along (assuming not asked first and able to say no), I'd probably be telling person A what to do with a third of a caravan.

Agree...Team B😆

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 11/04/2024 22:45

MetalFences · 11/04/2024 22:42

Person B likes to save money wherever possible

What! Rather than subsidise the holiday of someone who can't deal with being alone for a week? Shocking.

As an aside this sounds like a terrible holiday.

You say that like it's a bad thing 😱 NOT to want to fund a dramatic free loader?

WhyIOughtTo · 11/04/2024 22:45

So C has manipulated A in to coming on the holiday then A has manipulated B into paying for it but you think B is unreasonable for not wanting to pay for some beds to be made? £20 as obviously C couldn't be asked to pay for anything at all.

MetalFences · 11/04/2024 22:42

Person B likes to save money wherever possible

What! Rather than subsidise the holiday of someone who can't deal with being alone for a week? Shocking.

As an aside this sounds like a terrible holiday.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 11/04/2024 22:40

But they have the joys of person c, and reading through the thread I can absolutely see why A leapt at the chance to support C through the trauma that they of course won't mention .. and B just of course had to delight in paying for them to come on the hols!

GRex · 11/04/2024 22:38

MsGrumpytrousers · 11/04/2024 22:31

I must say, it's making me feel very cheerful about my dull plans for the weekend. Imagine being stuck in a caravan with A, B and C arguing over every teabag.

They are taking their own food, but I was similarly wondering if they would debate sharing the used teabag.

At this stage, I would pay the full costs to be allowed to not go.

Itsanothermanicmonday · 11/04/2024 22:38

Itsokish · 11/04/2024 22:32

Agree …quite glad I am working this weekend!

Agreed this grim.

Better a wet weekend at home than an atmosphere in a caravan and no booze or nice food to liven things up.

Inertia · 11/04/2024 22:36

Christ on a bike, this all sounds like a bloody miserable holiday. Emotional blackmail, squabbling over bed linen, and not even any wine/crisps/ chocolate to dull the pain.

Itsokish · 11/04/2024 22:32

MsGrumpytrousers · 11/04/2024 22:31

I must say, it's making me feel very cheerful about my dull plans for the weekend. Imagine being stuck in a caravan with A, B and C arguing over every teabag.

Agree …quite glad I am working this weekend!

ThinWomansBrain · 11/04/2024 22:31

if I was person B and a third person was invited along (assuming not asked first and able to say no), I'd probably be telling person A what to do with a third of a caravan.

MsGrumpytrousers · 11/04/2024 22:31

CelesteCunningham · 11/04/2024 21:55

Now you're all quibbling over £13 each?

I must say, it's making me feel very cheerful about my dull plans for the weekend. Imagine being stuck in a caravan with A, B and C arguing over every teabag.

Roryhon · 11/04/2024 22:25

Why not ask person C to pay the £40 linen fee and the £40 fuel cost, which would mean they’ve paid almost as much as what persons A & B have paid for the caravan.

DoreenonTill8 · 11/04/2024 22:23

MsGrumpytrousers · 11/04/2024 22:21

"No. Not all. Just person B. Person B likes to save money wherever possible."

So why on earth is there any question about C paying their fair share? B is going to be royally pissed off if she doesn't.

Well got to find a way to make b look unreasonable?...

MsGrumpytrousers · 11/04/2024 22:21

"No. Not all. Just person B. Person B likes to save money wherever possible."

So why on earth is there any question about C paying their fair share? B is going to be royally pissed off if she doesn't.

SD1978 · 11/04/2024 22:18

I'm feeling sorry (slightly) for B- they knew it was an inevitability that C would have to come, because C doesn't want to be on their own- so basically that's not really a choice a B, is it. It's emotional blackmail from C, which A is happy to allow, and B basically gets no real choice without sounding like a heartless bitch. B didn't want to lay for linen, so I assume they were always planning to take their own linen, so surely then it doesn't matter if the main bed isn't made up, because they were never going to pay. So their option is the double with their own bedding, or a single and pay their share of £10? I'll stick with, C is an emotional manipulator, A, is happy to be manipulated, B is being a tight arse over the linen, and c should be paying because they interjected themselves on a holiday they were never invited to, and probably planned on all along..........and that A & B should probably not plan anything similar again........

Swipe left for the next trending thread