Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people shouldn’t have new babies when there’s so many unresolved issues with older kids

215 replies

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 16:17

Yes it’s very judgy but I actually despair at rate of which some people are having new children when they already have problems with their other children.

I say this because there is a girl in DD’s class (year 6, this girl is 10) that is an absolute nightmare. DD only started her new school in September because we relocated and several other girls warned her about this child. Nevertheless, DD is naive/too nice and befriended her to her detriment. I had to get VERY arsey with the school before they actually did something about the fact this girl was calling DD nasty names every day (ugly, fat etc - DD is actually skinny and this girl is overweight), making fun of the fact DD has learning support, shoving past her hard (she’s much bigger than my DD) but never hurting her badly or obviously enough to raise suspicion from teachers she always does an ‘oops didn’t see you there’ thing, and teaching DD very inappropriate things (for example she taught DD a ‘blow job’ gesture 😡). If DD didn’t one day behave however this 10yo liked - such as didn’t play with her that day - the 10yo, who has a TikTok account, would make TikTok’s about her even naming her (I actually pulled her aside in the playground and told her to stop). I know because I found her and follow her!

I didn’t like to ban DD from being friends with anyone as I think it’s important that they navigate friendships themselves but because my DD is gullible this girl would make her feel like shit for 4 days then be sweetness and light on day 5 and DD would say “Oh no she’s apologised and she is sorry for what she did.” I just thought the situation was too toxic. So I have said to DD that she isn’t to go anywhere near this girl and if I found out she did she’d be punished. The mums of other girls experiencing the exact same with their DDs and this child have said the same to their girls. This 10yo has been the same since infants apparently And has a long rap sheet of bullying, inappropriate behaviour and nastiness.

Anyway this 10yo has an interesting family tree. Her parents (who are fully aware of what she is like because I’ve told them, as have others, as have the teachers) were married and had her and her older sibling. They then split up, the mum met a new man and had a baby who is now 3. She then split with him, had a new baby with an even newer man, this baby is 6 months old. The dad remarried and had another child who is now 6, they divorced and him and his new wife, wife no 3, have just had a baby a few days ago, the dad was showing the baby off in the playground at pick up.

I suppose I’m angry because she shoved past my DD again today in the corridor and hurt her shoulder and I’m fucking sick of all this never ending. I’m here fretting my backside off about my my DD getting picked on and her bully’s parents are just in the business of churning out more and more kids. Surely a half decent parent whose existing children have serious problems would prioritise that rather than just constantly changing partners and popping out more?

DH’s sister did the same but on a different level. She split up with her DH (whom she had 2 kids with) and immediately started dating a colleague. She was pregnant within three months of them dating, they weren’t using protection because it’s a ‘mood killer’. Her existing teen and pre-teen were really hit hard by their parents split and within 4 months they were meeting a new partner and preparing to welcome a half-sibling. My niece, who was a pre-teen when this all happened, is very close to us now as a young adult and the anger she feels at her mum moving on and having family no 2 in less than a year of her splitting with her dad has just about broken her, and they barely have a relationship. She feels her mum never considered her or her sister in her plans post-split and I’d have to agree with her.

AIBU to think people should get their houses in order before they bring new people into their kids lives - partners AND babies? I feel that particularly with DD’s bully it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out that a lot of her issues will stem from so many changes and inconsistencies in her life, and it’s people like my DD and the other girls in year 6 paying the price for that.

OP posts:
Papyrophile · 09/04/2024 21:02

Not sure that I would have been as controlled as the OP frankly.

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:56

RockyRogue1001 · 09/04/2024 20:55

You have ‘pulled the child aside’, reported her to the school, reported the school to ofsted, spoken to other parents about them, threatened your daughter with punishment if she associates with her. The child has been punished and spoken to

And all since September @SpiritOfEcstasy
Hasn't she been busy!

Yes, I have. Obviously.

OP posts:
YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:55

RockyRogue1001 · 09/04/2024 20:52

OP seems to know a LOT about a family she's only known 6 months.

And I absolutely don't believe a school would do nothing about a pupil of their school making bullying tik toks whilst wearing an identifiable school logo
I just don't believe it.

What powers do you think they have to remove a video for an account they have no access to? AFAIK they flagged it with the parents but the video is still up

OP posts:
RockyRogue1001 · 09/04/2024 20:55

You have ‘pulled the child aside’, reported her to the school, reported the school to ofsted, spoken to other parents about them, threatened your daughter with punishment if she associates with her. The child has been punished and spoken to

And all since September @SpiritOfEcstasy
Hasn't she been busy!

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:54

Workhardcryharder · 09/04/2024 20:53

No they just let the first half of their children parent the second half…

Yep!! Whenever they have one of those creepy family photos I think the older ones just radiate sadness

OP posts:
Workhardcryharder · 09/04/2024 20:53

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:35

Or they love pregnancy. I’m sure that weird kids and counting woman said she’s addicted to being pregnant. There’s no way you can have 23/24 kids and be the mum they need to ALL of them

No they just let the first half of their children parent the second half…

RockyRogue1001 · 09/04/2024 20:52

OP seems to know a LOT about a family she's only known 6 months.

And I absolutely don't believe a school would do nothing about a pupil of their school making bullying tik toks whilst wearing an identifiable school logo
I just don't believe it.

Workhardcryharder · 09/04/2024 20:52

gratefulbutsad · 09/04/2024 19:58

@CultOfRamen they might have more money if they stuck to two children. I wonder if OP can share weather these parents both work full time like me and DH do? If not, That's why they don't have a disposable income.

Back to OPs point, why do people have children when they can't look after the ones they have.

You're right. I am annoyed. Not only do I don't qualify for a single hour free childcare because of my salary and yet because of my salary I am taxed more to subsidise other people's 15 hours free childcare and the rest.. I'm not the only one if this article has made it into The Times.

Yes, because that creates a fairer and more stable society..

What would you prefer, slums? Malnutrition? Poverty?

christ.

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:49

SpiritOfEcstasy · 09/04/2024 20:46

OP I am clearly in the 31% that believe that you are being unreasonable. I have DDs and they have encountered bullies in school. I have obviously talked to them about how they feel and they have naturally chosen to distance themselves and hang out with other children. You have ‘pulled the child aside’, reported her to the school, reported the school to ofsted, spoken to other parents about them, threatened your daughter with punishment if she associates with her. The child has been punished and spoken to …what will make you happy? She clearly comes from a challenging background but I imagine expulsion and nimby may be the only appeasement…

I want the school to do more, to give her a harder punishment.

But I’m satisfied, for now, that DD isn’t engaging with her - and that’s only because I’ve been done all those things you’ve listed, and I’m not sorry i’d do it again in a heartbeat.

And I’m pleased your girls had the nouse to distance themselves from their bullies. I actually said yonDD’s teacher that I wish this child was an ‘old school’ bully that was just only ever mean to her, not half-in half-out. It would be easier. But this is how toxic relationships operate and too right I’m getting my DD out of that and teaching her why it’s so bad for her

OP posts:
SpiritOfEcstasy · 09/04/2024 20:46

OP I am clearly in the 31% that believe that you are being unreasonable. I have DDs and they have encountered bullies in school. I have obviously talked to them about how they feel and they have naturally chosen to distance themselves and hang out with other children. You have ‘pulled the child aside’, reported her to the school, reported the school to ofsted, spoken to other parents about them, threatened your daughter with punishment if she associates with her. The child has been punished and spoken to …what will make you happy? She clearly comes from a challenging background but I imagine expulsion and nimby may be the only appeasement…

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:35

oObyeOo · 09/04/2024 20:13

Some people have children because ‘they love babies!!’ I’m sure they forget that babies grow in to children 🙄

Or they love pregnancy. I’m sure that weird kids and counting woman said she’s addicted to being pregnant. There’s no way you can have 23/24 kids and be the mum they need to ALL of them

OP posts:
YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:32

SpiritOfEcstasy · 09/04/2024 20:02

Sadly your DD is going to come across many more people like the bully you describe in her life. Bullies don’t grow out of bullying they just become more subtle and clever about how they go about it and pick their victims. You’re doing your daughter a disservice by helicoptering in and rescuing her. How will she learn the skills to step away and/or judge how she feels about the treatment she receives from others - good and bad - if you manage every negative scenario for her? There’s something to be said for letting children sort of their own relationships. And also for not sitting in judgement of the choices made by others.

She’s 10. 10 and in a toxic friendship. I will always step in when she needs me to and with this she didn’t have the maturity or foresight to realise that people like that are NOT your friend just because they’re super sweet a fraction of the time.

OP posts:
YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:29

gratefulbutsad · 09/04/2024 19:58

@CultOfRamen they might have more money if they stuck to two children. I wonder if OP can share weather these parents both work full time like me and DH do? If not, That's why they don't have a disposable income.

Back to OPs point, why do people have children when they can't look after the ones they have.

You're right. I am annoyed. Not only do I don't qualify for a single hour free childcare because of my salary and yet because of my salary I am taxed more to subsidise other people's 15 hours free childcare and the rest.. I'm not the only one if this article has made it into The Times.

The dad is a teacher no idea about the mum if she works or not.

It’s a shame this thread has taken a dark turn with benefits bashing. Especially when you consider that the 2-child cap has put so many children in poverty. Is that a better alternative than people earning £200k being a bit inconvenienced?

OP posts:
YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:23

MrMucker · 09/04/2024 19:50

Meant nicely, your post is all about what you think of a load of people and very little about what your daughter is actually feeling.

It's a shame you have not mentioned how to bolster her own abilities to deal with people like this, because she is growing up and needs to practice skills of brushing off, avoiding, compromising, blanking, supporting, understanding.
At her age you ought to take a big step back and allow her to feel her way around relationships and make decisions for herself.
Not "allowing" her to mix with people is a complete recipe for disaster when her teens come, and I worry it will backfire on you, with her purposefully seeking out relationships to challenge you, rather than growing into relationships where she flourishes.
Stand back, Stop judging others. Give your kid a shed load of hugs and treats after a bad day. Rather than denigrating others, use that breath to remind her how great she is. Then send her back in the next day with the promise that some people are not nice but there are always nice ones out there somewhere, keep looking. And stop there.

It's a shame you have not mentioned how to bolster her own abilities to deal with people like this, because she is growing up and needs to practice skills of brushing off, avoiding, compromising, blanking, supporting, understanding.

I have - i think you’ve assumed I’ve shared every word verbatim that I’ve exchanged with my DD on here. I haven’t. We have had many long conversations and my no 1 priority right now is to boost her self esteem

Stand back, Stop judging others. Give your kid a shed load of hugs and treats after a bad day. Rather than denigrating others, use that breath to remind her how great she is. Then send her back in the next day with the promise that some people are not nice but there are always nice ones out there somewhere, keep looking. And stop there.

No, now way, I am not going to take such a feeble nanny pamby route with the person I love most in the world.

This is my little girl and it’s her life. Going to a place that where she should be learning, experiencing someone who 80% of the time passive aggressively shoves her( which when you’re tiny and this girl is a foot taller and much wider, is horrible) calls her fat, ugly, r*tard, makes her feel stupid because she needs help with maths, mocks her and makes her uncomfortable…the same person 20% of the time says she loves her she’s brilliant and funny and cute and kind and she doesn’t mean to be so nasty and is very sorry.

If this was a person she was dating I’d be calling the police for emotional abuse and my DD needs to learn that THIS, this very friendship is the epitome of emotional abuse and she needs to take a zero tolerance approach - a stance she needs to carry with her her whole life.

So no I will not be the parent who only says “You’re so kind and lovely and an awesome person, here have some crisps and ignore her and speak to nice people”. To me that’s what a parent who is quite happy for bullying to continue does. I’d rather take the affirmative action route even if my DD doesn’t like it and it might upset a random 10yo. But at least I’m doing something more than giving her a treat like a dog and spelling out the bleeding obvious

OP posts:
KomodoOhno · 09/04/2024 20:15

StarbucksQueen1 · 09/04/2024 19:49

You’re getting a lot of unnecessary stick on here. She sounds bloody awful and I’d hate it if I were you too. Sorry your poor daughter is going through this! I totally agree with people churning more kids out… it’s because they’re completely ignorant!

Agreed. There was girl like this at my dd's school. Chaotic home life, mother in prison, living with religious fanatic granny and Satan worshipping aunt. I can't make this up. I feel for her but I was not about to allow my dd to be the latest in a long line of bullying over many years.

CultOfRamen · 09/04/2024 20:15

gratefulbutsad · 09/04/2024 20:05

@CultOfRamen I'm not going to pity people who don't own their homes, don't go on two week holidays, or have a disposable income because they choose not to work and have 4 children. Nor am I going to compare myself to them. I will however feel like OP does, that they are irresponsible for having so many children when they can't control, pay for or look after the ones they have. Even elements like a poor diet can hinder behaviour, what do they live on food wise? I would imagine a beige diet filled with e-numbers, again have less kids and feed them better.

Ah the imaginations of the down trodden hard done by six figure salary earners 😂😂😂

oObyeOo · 09/04/2024 20:13

Some people have children because ‘they love babies!!’ I’m sure they forget that babies grow in to children 🙄

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:11

CultOfRamen · 09/04/2024 19:42

Interesting how everyone who seems to be in agreement is only using blended or re-partnered families as an example.

what- no married people have children too soon after each other- or do problem children only exist as a result of divorce.

TBF, research shows that children are more likely to be ‘problem’ children if they’ve experienced a family split. And people who are together and only have kids with each other - yes there is such thing as have too many and too close together. Look at that ‘kids and counting’ family, it’s totally selfish behaviour. but they provide consistency that someone constantly meeting new partners and having babies with them doesn’t provide

OP posts:
Pyaar · 09/04/2024 20:10

OP I think you're doing the right things and I completely agree about the judge pants around these family set ups, its bonkers.

I'm navigating something similar with bullying currently and first thing I did was to tell my DC to stay away from the bully and not interact. If he was in a cycle that you describe with your daughter I'd be reacting the same way and doing everything to keep them apart.

I know approaching the bully in the playground is risky but i love that you did that. You're showing your DD that you're sticking up for her, it's so valuable.

Bullying has long lasting effects and while it's sad that some kids have crappy lives that they end up bullies in the first place, that's not your problem.

Cant believe some of the responses on this thread.

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:09

I think people assume their kids don't need them much as they get older but they are wrong. My 9 year old for example needs emotional support and attention from me but in a different way from when he was 2. Just because he can play upstairs without my supervision doesn't mean he doesn't need me.

@cadburyegg this is so true. I was actually having this conversation with my friend the other day. The toddler says felt long and relentless and I longed for the days when they weren’t as needy. But now she’s 10 it’s a different kind of need and in a way it’s harder because what she needs isn’t always obvious.

Im in early peri-menopause so unlikely to have another baby but even if I did want to (and there’s always a bit of broodiness lurking!) there’s no way I’d dream of it because my DD is really gonna need me, undistracted and readily available, to battle the impending teen years which I already know are gonna be tough. I just couldn’t juggle a toddler and be the mum she needs.

Im not saying all mums of 10yo’s shouldn’t have other kids, every child is different. I didn’t feel like I ever needed my mum during the teens years but that’s because she wasn’t the kind of mum I could open up to, but my DD is very different as am I and I think she’s the type who, if she thought I was too busy, wouldn’t want to bother me.

OP posts:
Itsdeepitsblue · 09/04/2024 20:08

You’re not wrong op and it is frustrating because ultimately this is all the parents fault, not the young girls who home life has clearly been erratic and probably caused her some issues. The problem is that her parents probably had similarly dysfunctional childhoods, so to them it is somewhat normal.

Whilst it is obviously frustrating for you, I think your daughter is clearly the lucky one who has a steady home life and a mum looking out for her so try to remember that when you get angry at this girl. By all means continue to address issues with the school but I think judging/getting angry with the girl who her parents is just going to eat you up and they will be non the wiser.

gratefulbutsad · 09/04/2024 20:05

@CultOfRamen I'm not going to pity people who don't own their homes, don't go on two week holidays, or have a disposable income because they choose not to work and have 4 children. Nor am I going to compare myself to them. I will however feel like OP does, that they are irresponsible for having so many children when they can't control, pay for or look after the ones they have. Even elements like a poor diet can hinder behaviour, what do they live on food wise? I would imagine a beige diet filled with e-numbers, again have less kids and feed them better.

YaMuvva · 09/04/2024 20:04

mathanxiety · 09/04/2024 19:31

Also, OP, I'd mention the child's TikTok account to the safeguarding lead.

This is all sorts of wrong.

I’ve mentioned it to her teachers, who did seem concerned but ultimately they have no control or say over social media. But I do hope safeguarding steps are being taken as yes the blow job gesture is seriously concerning at age 10!

OP posts:
SpiritOfEcstasy · 09/04/2024 20:02

Sadly your DD is going to come across many more people like the bully you describe in her life. Bullies don’t grow out of bullying they just become more subtle and clever about how they go about it and pick their victims. You’re doing your daughter a disservice by helicoptering in and rescuing her. How will she learn the skills to step away and/or judge how she feels about the treatment she receives from others - good and bad - if you manage every negative scenario for her? There’s something to be said for letting children sort of their own relationships. And also for not sitting in judgement of the choices made by others.

CultOfRamen · 09/04/2024 20:02

gratefulbutsad · 09/04/2024 19:58

@CultOfRamen they might have more money if they stuck to two children. I wonder if OP can share weather these parents both work full time like me and DH do? If not, That's why they don't have a disposable income.

Back to OPs point, why do people have children when they can't look after the ones they have.

You're right. I am annoyed. Not only do I don't qualify for a single hour free childcare because of my salary and yet because of my salary I am taxed more to subsidise other people's 15 hours free childcare and the rest.. I'm not the only one if this article has made it into The Times.

Oh if it’s in the times then my bad yes, all of your problems are the fault of poor people with lots of kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread