Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sex for rent

186 replies

Hartley99 · 08/04/2024 23:16

I was just watching a documentary on the sex for rent scandal. Basically, landlords offer a room in exchange for sex. In most cases, the landlords are older men and the renters are young women. Apparently, it is common in places with large student populations - in other words, where there are lots of very young women who are struggling with debts/ loans.

The whole thing really sickened me. A journalist (herself a young woman) secretly filmed a meeting with one of these landlords. She posed as a young student who had seen his ad and wanted to know more. It made my skin crawl. He was late 40s, and a repulsive, creepy little nerd who could hardly contain his excitement. But what sickened me the most was that not only did he not think he was doing anything wrong, he thought he was being generous! He seemed to think he was doing her a favour! That seemed to be the attitude of all these men.

The other thing that got me was the comments below the video. I had naively expected people to write how vile it all was, how these men were taking advantage of the housing shortage, how they were targeting very young women, and so on. In fact, I read comment after comment (all by men) angrily defending the landlords! The general view seemed to be that it was a big fuss over nothing, that it was up to the women, and that if it was consensual it was OK and we should mind our own business. So many people were defending the landlords that I honestly began to doubt my own judgement. Is it wrong? Am I being over-sensitive and naive?

OP posts:
AquaDuck · 10/04/2024 18:19

Nobody is paying though. *This was in response to the comments

"What do you call paying for sex?"

I really don't understand why my replies never "QUOTE"

UGH

Liferiddle666 · 10/04/2024 18:17

I do agree it is absolutely disgusting! Male privilege is astounding :( But in my opinion this government is a problem! Allowing rents to go so high people cannot afford it, causing cost of living crisis, pushing human beings to the brink of extreme poverty. Higher education shouldn't be a privilege of selected few (middle class and white). Everyone should have the right to do it and be able to support themselves by doing "normal while studying" jobs like hospitality for example.

Disturbia81 · 10/04/2024 10:45

If someone I knew did this (the man) I wouldn't know them anymore and neither would most.
They probably wouldn't care as long as they get to get their dick wet. I just keep thinking of all the women who have been under a man and not wanted to be there and are disgusted by it. While he's grunting away sweaty and oblivious. Ugh stop the world!
I know some good men but men are the cause of so much horrifying shit

Another2Cats · 10/04/2024 08:49

Another2Cats · 09/04/2024 07:28

Yes, it's an offence under the Sexual Offences Act 2003. Section 52 and Section 53, causing and controlling prostitution.

But the CPS hadn't really thought about it until there were a couple of undercover TV shows that highlighted it (the other was on ITV) which led to the issue being raised in parliament in 2018. Only then did the CPS change it's guidance which now says this:

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/prostitution-and-exploitation-prostitution

The first prosecution was in 2022 and the guy got 12 months in prison:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10800957/Sex-rent-landlord-52-jailed-year-giving-room-woman-sex-him.html

@Ecstaticmotion "What law is he breaking?"

If you see my post from earlier (quoted above), it explains the situation

@cariadlet "I'd love to see a prosecution on those grounds."

The first prosecution was in 2022.

Ecstaticmotion · 10/04/2024 08:19

cariadlet · 10/04/2024 01:05

It's illegal to pay for sex if someone is forced or threatened into it.

It could be argued if someone agreed to have sex with a disgusting landlord because they were afraid of being made homeless then they aren't in a position to freely consent ergo they are indirectly forced into it.

I'd love to see a prosecution on those grounds.

Interesting, however abuse of a position of vulnerability is usually not used with regard to economic circumstances, (instead of things like learning difficulties, disabilities, addictions), because doing so would open up a can of political worms regarding what counts as consent in a capitalist system. If poverty and need can be factors in exploitation, a lot of ‘work’ would be exploitation.

ageratum1 · 10/04/2024 05:49

It is disgusting and exploitative, but women are doing it because it is less awful than their alternative.I think if my choice was sex with a creep or sleeping in a box in sub-zero temperatures with the risk of being attacked/robbed/raped whilst I slept, I would choose the former.

cariadlet · 10/04/2024 01:05

Ecstaticmotion · 09/04/2024 22:36

What law is he breaking?

It's illegal to pay for sex if someone is forced or threatened into it.

It could be argued if someone agreed to have sex with a disgusting landlord because they were afraid of being made homeless then they aren't in a position to freely consent ergo they are indirectly forced into it.

I'd love to see a prosecution on those grounds.

Lavender14 · 09/04/2024 23:41

Notimeforaname · 09/04/2024 18:21

can it really be a consensual choice if the alternative is homelessness?

Yes it is a choice to look to exchange sex for a rent-free home.

Like op says many of them are students. If you make a choice to go to uni while living outside of your means and then choose to have sex for free rent, yes this is a choice and consent has been given.

Edited

@Notimeforaname I see what you're asking, but i wouldn't consider university a necessity. You can work and earn etc etc instead of going to university. A roof over your head is necessity not luxury. So if the alternative is homelessness then it's not a choice? It's something you need to do because you can't afford rental prices due to the massive increase. That's why its exploitative.

Ecstaticmotion · 09/04/2024 22:36

SabreIsMyFave · 09/04/2024 00:21

Gobsmacked at the fella with the Geordie accent near the end, who is utterly denying that he has done anything wrong. 'Well I just want a fuck in exchange for a free room, so what? I'm not forcing the lasses to come here.' Shock

YOU ARE BREAKING THE LAW, YOU DUMB FUCK-NUT! I hope you get caught -and serve 7 years in JAIL, you pervy piece of shit!

Then at the VERY end, all the landlords featured (around half a dozen,) were questioned afterwards, and denied doing anything wrong - OR they refused to comment. Not one of them expressed shame or contrition, or offered a single apology, for treating young vulnerable women like pieces of meat, prostitutes, and borderline sex slaves.

I am fucking RAGING after watching this! Angry

Tragic thing is, this will not stop, ever. As long as MEN exist.

What law is he breaking?

Hartley99 · 09/04/2024 22:31

MintGreenC · 08/04/2024 23:48

I know someone that does this, he has a flat in central London and rents rooms out for sex..

Jesus, is this a friend? Does he openly admit it?

OP posts:
SabreIsMyFave · 09/04/2024 21:44

I love how furious and passionate you are @Hartley99 More people should think like you, and be as angry too! I think exactly the same as you, and I am angry! VERY fucking angry. The world seems to be full of seedy vile misogynistic men. I mean there a few 'good uns,' but even THEY have misogyny lurking underneath.

I know a bloke who lives near me who is really chirpy and friendly, and always says hello. I have known him (casually as a neighbour,) for about a year. I spotted him on Twitter last month, and looked at his page. There were plenty of messages about his favourite TV show on there, LOL-ing at comedies, and suchlike. All seemed OK. Then out of curiosity, I had a look at his 'likes.' Where he had not commented or said anything, or re-tweeted, and had just stayed silent and 'liked.'

For as far as I could see, he had 'liked' 100s and 100s of posts that featured photos of 16-20 year old South East Asian girls, dressed in heels and stockings, basques, bras, see-thru negligees with the nipples showing, and quite a number of pictures of them naked. Clearly thought because he was only 'liking' them that no-one would notice.

It made my skin crawl, and I looked at him in a different light. When I see him coming up the road now, (and I am in the front garden,) I slip in the back garden, so I don't have to talk to him.

But yeah, you're right @Hartley99 these repugnant and vile 'landlords' don't see a THING wrong with what they're doing, (as I said in a post last night after watching the show!) And they DO think they're doing the girls a favour, letting them have a room for 'free' if they have sex with them!!! And the nerve of that one turd on the show, telling the young reporter (who was posing as a woman who wanted a room,) 'if you're not going to agree to have sex with me, then you're wasting your time, and mine!' (And he wanted her to go with him to look at the room right then!) And the one who wanted her to come to his bedroom and sleep with him on her first day, and keep her pyjamas on. Just lie in bed with him, and 'see how it goes...' VOMIT!

And the buy-a-bride cunts are the worst. As you say, repulsive-looking, sweaty, smelly, dull men who can't get a woman over here, who shell out 1000s of £££ to bring a vulnerable, poor young woman (sometimes a GIRL) over here to be his wife. It's sickening and vile, And as you say, the places advertising 'hot young Ukrainian brides' was abhorrent!

The older I get, the more revolting I realise many men are. Misogynistic, lazy, sleazy, think women are only good for cooking, sucking, and fucking, and boak at the idea of women being high achievers, being successful, and knowing more than them about anything! As I said, it's so depressing and sad that even the 'good ones' are not as 'good' as we think!

Fuck me sideways, it's 2024, and many women think they are equal and a lot more heard now, and have all these rights, and there's never been a better time to be a woman. We have not moved a fucking inch! The misogyny and hatred for women, and women being thought of as sex toys and servants to men is as rife as it was 100 years ago and beyond.

Yes yes yes I KNOW 'not all men are like that la la la...' But many ARE, and it's not good enough! Sadly I don't see it ever changing. And I just can't figure out why! WHY is it never changing? What is going wrong? They are not born this way! At what point are they turning into arseholes? #baffled

Hartley99 · 09/04/2024 20:52

BlancheSaysYes · 09/04/2024 19:07

I have very little time for men who 'buy' young brides from the Philippines, Thailand, Russia etc and absolutely no respect for them whatsoever. A man I know is in his early 60's, overweight, scruffy, poor personal hygiene, has recently introduced us (neighbours) to his beautiful new wife. She's tiny, very young, speaks very little English, but seems happy enough on the surface, at least. I hope she is astute enough to get away from him when she can - if that's what she wants. He's acting as if it was a wonderful holiday romance that turned into true love. Maybe it is. I am judgemental though and I see an unpleasant, predatory older single man with the wherewithal to buy himself a wife.

There used to be a guy in my local Sainsbury’s who’d married a young Asian girl. He was late 50s and hideous looking (short, fat, bald, smelly). She was about 20 and stunning. I mean just stunning. What sickened me most was the sniggering and nudging you’d see as they walked past. Everyone seemed to find it funny. I never saw anyone look at the girl with pity.

The delusions of these men also sickens me. I’m sure the ones who offer such arrangements to vulnerable teens, or Ukrainian refugees, actually think they’re being noble and generous. Same with men like your neighbour. But what puzzles me is whether they really believe that. Is it how they justify to themselves what they’re doing? Or do they think they’re fooling the rest of us? I remember a post on this forum about an old man who’d married a beautiful young Russian woman. The woman had a little girl, and he used to tell all the neighbours that he’d “saved” them - like he was a fucking knight in shining armour. Now did he really believe that, or did he know precisely what he was doing but just hope to win over his neighbours? It genuinely puzzles me.

OP posts:
PerfectTravelTote · 09/04/2024 20:25

Never read the comments. That's where the crazy people live.

Notimeforaname · 09/04/2024 20:24

@Hartley99
I'm sorry, maybe I shouid have been clearer. I was responding only to the part about the women who seek out these arrangements for free rent to put themselves through college or uni.

Not someone who was threatened with being made homeless if they dont have sex, or someone fleeing their country.

WillimNot · 09/04/2024 20:18

This is nothing new.
I grew up in a very abusive household, not physically but mentally with a mother who was mentally unwell. So as soon as I could get away, I did.

At 17 legally I was unable to hold a tenancy in that era. However, one landlord offered to let me join an existing house share.

I turned up to view the room, only for him to tell me the rent was far more than he originally said over the phone.

He said it didn't matter as he could have an arrangement with me similar to other tenants. He also owned a shop so I assumed he meant working in his shop. No, he said, my wife and mother work there, and pointed to the bed, saying I could work there for 80% of the rent removed. He said I would be entertaining him and his brother and possibly other associates.

Literally ran out and down the road in tears.

Luckily I found out about a charity for teens escaping abuse who housed me in a flat, no strings attached. They told me I wasn't the first to be offered that for rent reduction.

Looking back, there were 4 girls in that shared house, and he had two other shared homes too. It didn't occur to me to report it and I wouldn't have known who to report it to, that and the girls involved probably wouldn't have owned up because they'd have been homeless.

That was way back in the late 90s!

OnHerSolidFoundations · 09/04/2024 19:55

LlynTegid · 09/04/2024 18:05

@OnHerSolidFoundations animals is an unfair description, be considerate of animals and do not compare such men with them. It is minimising what such men do.

Ofcom are useless and I don't expect them to hurry up with guidelines or requirements to reduce the advertising of such a vile practice.

Hmmm
Have you met animals? Ducks are the worst!

BirthdayRainbow · 09/04/2024 19:45

You KNOW you're not being over sensitive and naive. Come on.

onlywomengetperiods · 09/04/2024 19:44

Paying a woman for sex is rape. It's literally just rape.

onlywomengetperiods · 09/04/2024 19:42

This should carry the harshest legal penalty possible. It's RAPE.

BlancheSaysYes · 09/04/2024 19:07

I have very little time for men who 'buy' young brides from the Philippines, Thailand, Russia etc and absolutely no respect for them whatsoever. A man I know is in his early 60's, overweight, scruffy, poor personal hygiene, has recently introduced us (neighbours) to his beautiful new wife. She's tiny, very young, speaks very little English, but seems happy enough on the surface, at least. I hope she is astute enough to get away from him when she can - if that's what she wants. He's acting as if it was a wonderful holiday romance that turned into true love. Maybe it is. I am judgemental though and I see an unpleasant, predatory older single man with the wherewithal to buy himself a wife.

Hazey19 · 09/04/2024 18:36

Disgusting.

Hartley99 · 09/04/2024 18:31

Notimeforaname · 09/04/2024 18:02

Yes its absolutely disgusting but if these women are contacting them, arranging meet ups, considering it and then acting on it, then it's a choice.

But you must always consider the circumstances in which they chose - the condition they were in.

First of all, what was their mental health like? Were they depressed? Had they been through a traumatic childhood that left them feeling worthless? Had they been through some kind of breakdown? Were they so desperate and unhappy they didn’t care what happened to them?

Second, what was their financial situation? Was it a case of sleep with me or you’re homeless (and so is your child)? Were they in debt? Would they have been kicked off their university course?

No happy, stable, financially secure young woman would choose to have sex with an ugly old man in some filthy bedsit whenever he felt horny. And no pretty young girl from Thailand or Ukraine would marry such a man if she wasn’t desperate for a new life. Spin in however you like, these men are predatory vermin.

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 09/04/2024 18:21

can it really be a consensual choice if the alternative is homelessness?

Yes it is a choice to look to exchange sex for a rent-free home.

Like op says many of them are students. If you make a choice to go to uni while living outside of your means and then choose to have sex for free rent, yes this is a choice and consent has been given.

MintGreenC · 09/04/2024 18:21

See in the situation I know of the alternative wasn't being homeless it was women who wanted to live in a nice location but not have to pay for it, the women were usually living with parents or in a room in a house share in a rotten area and fancied living in a nicer area in zone 1 central London so it seemed way more of a transaction rather than desperate women doing it because they would be homeless otherwise! Hence not reporting it as it seemed very much a two way thing.

Lavender14 · 09/04/2024 18:18

Notimeforaname · 09/04/2024 18:02

Yes its absolutely disgusting but if these women are contacting them, arranging meet ups, considering it and then acting on it, then it's a choice.

@Notimeforaname can it really be a consensual choice if the alternative is homelessness? I think that muddies the waters massively. To me, it's always difficult if money is changing hands- for it to be fully and completely consensual it needs to be something the woman doesn't feel she 'has' to do (either to pay bills/ put a roof over her head etc etc). Where its landlord who is probably also trying to avoid appropriate landlord duties such as deposit protection, providing an above board contract etc and in the midst of a crisis leaving many priced out of much needed accommodation- then it's exploitation and it becomes harder to argue consent. The other trouble is, what if she no longer wants to have sex- does she lose her home/ is evicted so another vulnerable woman can be moved in? How does that affect her ability to fully consent?