Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be angry about the benefits system

690 replies

Daffodilsinfebruary · 07/04/2024 16:23

I have recently discovered by using a free, independent benefits calculator called entitledto that had I applied for Universal Credit over 2 years ago, me and my family would be over £16,000 better off.

I had assumed that benefits were for either single-parent families or people unable to work due to disability.

The majority of our savings would have been from claiming 85% back in childcare costs. We also would have had a payout of over £200 each month in addition.

For context, we bring in just shy off £4,000 a month. I thought this was a very reasonable income and we would be entitled to nil.

I feel angry that we did not know about this. A friend of mine who I met through our children attending the same nursery told me she claims 85% back in childcare costs during a conversation in which I complained of my childcare going up £150.

I did further research and 19 billion pounds apparently goes unclaimed every year.

I’ve never claimed benefits in all my life and worked hard to get on the property ladder.

should I be angry that we didn’t claim, or take it in my stride.

I wonder how many other families who could have claimed but haven’t.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Redrum00 · 09/04/2024 01:46

£4000 a month is not hard fucking done by. I earn £800 a month. That’s it. The health care system has utterly failed me by not being able to assess me and diagnose my health issues due to waiting times. So I just have to settle for working part time so I can actually manage the work I do. No diagnosis - no benefit entitlements. £4000 a month is more than I could dream of.

Please get your head out of your arse.

smooththecat · 09/04/2024 01:31

I have to say too, as it’s relevant, the government seriously need to raise the tax threshold (personal allowance), probably to around 15k.

smooththecat · 09/04/2024 01:25

Twonewcats · 09/04/2024 00:57

But that's what people are asking - how do you get UC when bringing in 4k a month??

Well I imagine, given the government are not known to give a crap about keeping people above the poverty line, that the massive lack of growth in our wages over the past 15 years, combined with huge cost of living rises means that OP is entitled to it due to specific circumstances.

Twonewcats · 09/04/2024 00:57

smooththecat · 09/04/2024 00:26

Don’t know why people are giving OP a hard time, clearly many many people also don’t know. If you’ve not ever accessed any benefits you might not consider it. On the converse, when I was on a v v low income my friend encouraged me to access benefits, assuming I’d be able to. Reader, as a single adult with no kids I am entitled to absolutely nothing.

But that's what people are asking - how do you get UC when bringing in 4k a month??

smooththecat · 09/04/2024 00:26

Don’t know why people are giving OP a hard time, clearly many many people also don’t know. If you’ve not ever accessed any benefits you might not consider it. On the converse, when I was on a v v low income my friend encouraged me to access benefits, assuming I’d be able to. Reader, as a single adult with no kids I am entitled to absolutely nothing.

TotoroElla · 09/04/2024 00:24

I didn't think you could get SMI if you worked. It may have changed but I went through a period of not been able to work many years ago. I had to go the Jobcentre periodically for them to show me the 'you're better off in work' calculation, even though the calculation showed I was better off not in work due to the SMI stopping the moment you started work.

Twonewcats · 09/04/2024 00:21

I havent rtft because it'd take forever. But wtf am I reading?? 4K a month AND you'd be getting UC??
can someone tell me how??

Taxbreak · 09/04/2024 00:10

Babyroobs · 08/04/2024 00:22

No problem. It really isn't the easiest benefit to get your head around !

This thread has been a real eye-opener for me. Due to distress caused by DWP demanding swift repayment minor overpayments due to DWP error, a relative stopped claiming much-needed child allowance.
I pay £60k a year in tax and NI and had always thought that the U in UC was DWP irony. It looks like some relatives that I support are likely to be entitled to claim.

Babyroobs · 08/04/2024 23:47

Nicetobenice67 · 08/04/2024 23:25

i work long hours I’m single I get minimum wage don’t even bring in half of the 4000 and I cannot claim anything …some of the women with children work at my place 15hr a week but benefits make it up to 26 thousand a year she has 2 children …tbh I was better off on tax credit when my children were young

Yes because it's the child related elements and costs that get people the UC. And they get the work allowances too.
I don't know how people are still just working 15 hours unless they are still on tax credits. On Uc , a lone parent with a child over 3 will soon be expected to look for up to 30 hours of work a week. The conditions of claiming are getting stricter.

Nicetobenice67 · 08/04/2024 23:25

i work long hours I’m single I get minimum wage don’t even bring in half of the 4000 and I cannot claim anything …some of the women with children work at my place 15hr a week but benefits make it up to 26 thousand a year she has 2 children …tbh I was better off on tax credit when my children were young

PayBalanceInFull · 08/04/2024 23:18

so do you bring home £4000 net income (after taxes etc)??

and you’re entitled to an extra £1333 from the government?

the total of £5333 is £70 short of what my husband and I both bring in - no child benefit payments and a higher tax rate on what the government deems a minimum household income to live on as you need the universal top up to a minimum living wage??!
for context, I work 30 hours so I can pick the kids up from school (start at 8!) and not have to pay wrap around care.
my husband works 9-5.30 - box standard hours but earns just above the child benefit threshold so we don’t even get that!

I’m so angry at the government benefit system . Apologies if there’s been further updates/context to the £4000 but I don’t understand why we work in (slightly!) higher than average paid jobs to get the same money as someone on benefits

fashionqueen1183 · 08/04/2024 23:06

Depending when you bought your house, savings over 16k would have made you ineligible anyway.

PrincessTeaSet · 08/04/2024 22:58

Daffodilsinfebruary · 07/04/2024 16:58

I appreciate this but so many people claim benefits and also don’t work.

I was brought up by my family to work, had a paper round age 11 and worked in a cafe at weekends from 15. From there I’ve never not worked apart from maternity leave however I was still employed.

I know acquaintances who ‘play’ the system, but generally don’t work although they could as have school aged children and no disabilities x

Because I am entitled to claim should I automatically claim?

We haven’t struggled but that’s due to budgeting, planning and saving.

We are looking to put a claim in now, as with increased nursery costs and other bills increasing we are now struggling if are to many Ian the same lifestyle so I guess without it now we would find it hard to stay in the green. Although our claim hasn’t yet been improved. It is complicated to set up, and my DH has to attend an appointment at the Job Centre to prove identity etc.

It appears that from the comments on this thread I am silly to not have tried to claim, I thought there would be more comments from people being shocked at the thought we could with our joint income being £4000.

Just did the calculator again on entitled to again and it’s more than I thought
total a month we are entitled to is £1,140 not
including the 85% childcare we can claim back)
£460 universal credit a month
£500 a month towards our mortgage loan
£42.55 (child benefit we already get this)

Yes it's ridiculous. There was a poster on here earned 60k and people were telling her she would get UC. Single parent but still it's a huge wage. Benefits should be for people who are on a low wage not more than double the average wage. I really don't understand it

Bamboobzled · 08/04/2024 22:57

Daffodilsinfebruary · 07/04/2024 16:23

I have recently discovered by using a free, independent benefits calculator called entitledto that had I applied for Universal Credit over 2 years ago, me and my family would be over £16,000 better off.

I had assumed that benefits were for either single-parent families or people unable to work due to disability.

The majority of our savings would have been from claiming 85% back in childcare costs. We also would have had a payout of over £200 each month in addition.

For context, we bring in just shy off £4,000 a month. I thought this was a very reasonable income and we would be entitled to nil.

I feel angry that we did not know about this. A friend of mine who I met through our children attending the same nursery told me she claims 85% back in childcare costs during a conversation in which I complained of my childcare going up £150.

I did further research and 19 billion pounds apparently goes unclaimed every year.

I’ve never claimed benefits in all my life and worked hard to get on the property ladder.

should I be angry that we didn’t claim, or take it in my stride.

I wonder how many other families who could have claimed but haven’t.

We receive a tiny bit (less than £100) a month and we bring in less than your £4000 a month, so it's likely you wouldn't be eligible. If you have savings over £6,000 they would also start reducing your award. You sound bitter.

CurlyJB88 · 08/04/2024 22:38

MrsRaspberry · 08/04/2024 21:37

Sure i read somewhere that you can't get universal credits if you claim the tax free childcare though its one or the other you can't have both

@MrsRaspberry this is correct, it’s one or the other

Concannon88 · 08/04/2024 22:38

So you checked before you had a child and then after you had a child you didn't think it was worth checking again? 😆

CurlyJB88 · 08/04/2024 22:36

Daffodilsinfebruary · 08/04/2024 06:49

Overall I think I was misinformed as the 85% back in childcare costs is after a very complex calculation taking into account earnings, actual childcare costs, number of children etc. It technically isn’t 85% for everyone who applies to Universal Credit. So I take back what I posted in my OP.

There is so much hassle involved in claiming I should have probably put the claim through last October when I began paying 2 lots of childcare costs and would have benefited for a while. Now it seems to complicated putting the application through and now I’m worried if I will be able to use the Tax-Free childcare in September when my child attends morning and afternoon club and my other one goes to nursery and I have to pay for additional hours and food. As Universal Credit and Tax Free Childcare are 2 separate systems.

I understand why people don’t claim Universal Credit now.

I don’t think I should not be out of pocket for having children I take full responsibility, got on the property ladder and had considerable savings before having them. I didn’t plan for such a large increase in my nursery costs which came into effect on the 1st April 2024 due to minimum wage increasing so much and Cost of Living Crisis.

Obviously if there is help available for childcare I would be stupid not to apply.

Hello, not sure what you decided to do but just to let you know as I work for DWP - you won’t be entitled to the SMI loan as you’re in work. So when you remove that amount from the calculation, your entitlement will be lower so may not be as entitled as the calculator suggests. @Daffodilsinfebruary

Headfirstintothewild · 08/04/2024 22:18

Fawklight · 08/04/2024 22:04

I will have 2 children under the age of 4. I'm currently pregnant. If I was to put them in child care full time it would be more than my current pay. So I won't put them in full time.

My mortgage is more than 1k thanks to the interest rates. I was lucky it wasn't higher.

Maybe I could talk to Citizens advice but tbh I'd rather not claim if I really don't need it.

It would only be used for my husband diagnosis using private health care. On going issue. But he's not classed as disabled and with our a diagnosis we wouldn't even get PIP.

Well if the only elements are the standard allowance and 2 child elements you won’t get it anyway. OP’s circumstances mean she has the childcare element so would be eligible.

You don’t need a diagnosis for PIP.

Fawklight · 08/04/2024 22:17

@Lougle

Ok, I'll check again when I'm awake incase I missed something out. But it's not important.

Lougle · 08/04/2024 22:13

Fawklight · 08/04/2024 21:56

My family earns the same amount. But I'm not entitled to anything. I've checked again.

I'm just confused. I'm guessing OPs family might have disabilities or some other thing that gives her entitlement to benefits.

I don't even have savings.

It's a mathematical formula. It's as simple as:

A
Household makeup
+/-
Disability
+/-
Housing costs (rent)
+/-
85% allowable childcare costs

B
(income - work allowance) x 0.55.

Total award = A-B

If you are on £4000 per month and don't get Universal Credit, it's because your total A isn't more than either £1977.88 (renters) or £1829.85 (non-renters).

It's that simple.

Fawklight · 08/04/2024 22:04

Headfirstintothewild · 08/04/2024 21:59

Just because you earn the same amount doesn’t mean your circumstances are the same. If you and DH have 2 DC and high childcare costs (i.e. the OP’s situation) you would be eligible. I put the calculation for 23/24 further up the thread. It would be slightly more with the 24/25.

I will have 2 children under the age of 4. I'm currently pregnant. If I was to put them in child care full time it would be more than my current pay. So I won't put them in full time.

My mortgage is more than 1k thanks to the interest rates. I was lucky it wasn't higher.

Maybe I could talk to Citizens advice but tbh I'd rather not claim if I really don't need it.

It would only be used for my husband diagnosis using private health care. On going issue. But he's not classed as disabled and with our a diagnosis we wouldn't even get PIP.

AgileMentor · 08/04/2024 22:03

You get 4 grand a month and you’re angry over £200? Get a grip.

Headfirstintothewild · 08/04/2024 21:59

Fawklight · 08/04/2024 21:56

My family earns the same amount. But I'm not entitled to anything. I've checked again.

I'm just confused. I'm guessing OPs family might have disabilities or some other thing that gives her entitlement to benefits.

I don't even have savings.

Just because you earn the same amount doesn’t mean your circumstances are the same. If you and DH have 2 DC and high childcare costs (i.e. the OP’s situation) you would be eligible. I put the calculation for 23/24 further up the thread. It would be slightly more with the 24/25.

Fawklight · 08/04/2024 21:56

Headfirstintothewild · 08/04/2024 21:41

If you had the same circumstances as the OP you too would be eligible for UC.

My family earns the same amount. But I'm not entitled to anything. I've checked again.

I'm just confused. I'm guessing OPs family might have disabilities or some other thing that gives her entitlement to benefits.

I don't even have savings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread