Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Divorcing a teacher

237 replies

MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 11:12

I'm splitting from my husband. We are only at the start. He is a teacher and arguing for almost all school holidays as I will need to use childcare and summer camps as I work full time. He is arguing it makes more sense just for him to have them for the whole of the holidays with me having weekends during all school holidays. DC are 5 and 6. He is also arguing this is reason for him to stay in family home and for me to rent somewhere.

AIBU to say I still want normal arrangements during holidays? He says yes, becasue I would be paying for childcare - which is true at least some of the time as only have 25 days leave.

We haven't even worked out a schedule yet and still living together but this is one the first arguments that has come up.

AIBU to think that even if I have to use childcare, it's not fair on the kids to be separated from me for the whole of holidays (excdept for weekends).

OP posts:
HMW1906 · 07/04/2024 19:32

Why would you prefer for your kids to be in a kids club/childcare rather than with dad? What do you do now in the holiday? Do they go to kids club whilst dad sits at home?just agree with him which holidays you will have and let them stay with dad for the rest of them.

MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 19:32

Thank you for all the helpful practical examples of how we can split time so they get proper time with both parents during holidays.

I resent the idea though that them being in a club, being picked up early and then with me until bedtime isn't parenting somehow and that they'll be better off with their dad the whole time. I don't think that's true.

OP posts:
MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 19:27

DragonGypsyDoris · 07/04/2024 19:09

Your judgement is clouded. What's the point in you having them if you're just going to use childcare? If a Dad did that, he'd be called a deadbeat. Take advantage of what's being offered, because it's best for your kids. It's mostly about them, not you.

He would be called a deadbeat for working full time, paying for 80% of everything, putting them in the school club and picking them up at 3pm and then catching up on work after their bedtime - all to ensure they still see their mum regularly through the holidays?

OP posts:
Kalevala · 07/04/2024 19:24

KoolKookaburra · 07/04/2024 18:24

I don't see why a 4 week/2 week split wouldn't work just as well

Something like two weeks summer, one week Christmas and Easter and one half term. Then you could cover most or all of that with annual leave.

TimeGrabsYouByTheWrist · 07/04/2024 19:19

MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 18:23

I'm not suggesting kids will be in holiday clubs for days on end. I'm suggesting that if we go for 5050, this should be retained in holidays (despite him being a teacher) and that if I need to use clubs during my time - then so be it - but of course I will be taking annual leave and i work flexibly and from home a lot anyway. What I'm saying is that just becase he is a teacher doesn't mean our arrngement goes out the window and he has them for the whole 6 weeks.

this is not being not wanting them to see their dad or being jealous/petty - i just think it's better for them to spend time with both of us during the holidays.

But you will be seeing them loads if he has offered you every single weekend in the summer...

I think you having them 2 weeks and him 4 weeks in the summer makes sense. Then half the Christmas and half the easter holiday, and I'd suggest he has them half terms, but you have them the weekend before and after half term.

Assuming you get the statutory 5 weeks holiday, that then leaves you with 5 emergency days.

DragonGypsyDoris · 07/04/2024 19:09

Your judgement is clouded. What's the point in you having them if you're just going to use childcare? If a Dad did that, he'd be called a deadbeat. Take advantage of what's being offered, because it's best for your kids. It's mostly about them, not you.

ziggies · 07/04/2024 19:06

But if you'll be WFH while keeping an eye on them, how is it any better than your grouses about him? ("He takes them to park but he also puts on a lot of youtube. He also doesn't plan ahead and DS struggles a lot with not doing what he is doing from one day to next.")

Really not trying to pile on, just trying to understand??

ChangeAgain2 · 07/04/2024 19:05

kitsuneghost · 07/04/2024 18:54

It makes sense for them to be with their dad.
I think you are being precious about them being away from mum when the alternative is away from dad,
It's not like you arc sticking them into a club with strangers looking after them.

I disagree. Them going to clubs is the status quo. They have gone to these clubs previously at dads request for ME time. His job and the holidays haven't changed. They enjoy the clubs. They are with their friend. They aren't with strangers. and OP will be able to be with them after 3. The relationship has changed and he just wants a leg up to get the house.

Causewerethespecialtwo · 07/04/2024 18:54

He is also arguing this is reason for him to stay in family home and for me to rent somewhere.
I would keep reminding him that the custody plans for the children and the future ownership of your current home are two separate issues and need to be negotiated separately.

If he wants to stay in the family home then he needs to buy out your share, or take over the rental by himself if it’s rented. The times you each have the children is a completely separate topic to this.

kitsuneghost · 07/04/2024 18:54

It makes sense for them to be with their dad.
I think you are being precious about them being away from mum when the alternative is away from dad,
It's not like you arc sticking them into a club with strangers looking after them.

ChangeAgain2 · 07/04/2024 18:53

I think you should fight for what you feel is best for the children. I don't think he should get all the holidays because he's a teacher. I don't actually think it's in their best interests. I think he's being guided by greed over what's best for the kids. He needed me time during your marriage and was probably a better person for it. Why doesn't he need me time now?

Applesandpears23 · 07/04/2024 18:46

If he wants to do all childcare in the week during school holidays you should let him. Can they do an overnight or two during the week with you so you see them after work on weeks where he has them and they aren’t away?

Howldens · 07/04/2024 18:36

He’s doing it so he gets more rights over the marital home. He’s manipulating you.

50/50 on an ongoing basis - irrespective of school holidays or anything else.

Stay strong OP. Get a lawyer.

p.s. to all the judgemental people: summer school clubs etc are great for kids - structured play, socialising with peers, away from devices & TV.

Don’t add guilt about having to work during holidays as MILLIONS of parents HAVE to do, on to her shoulders too.

maddening · 07/04/2024 18:36

Zyq · 07/04/2024 17:35

I'd seriously question whether the children really would prefer to be in a holiday club all day every day during the holidays, especially in the summer. Surely they need some time just to chill at home without having other kids around them all the time, being expected to take part in activities etc etc.

But the op would be using annual leave in the hols - probably only needs a week over the year for holiday clubs, less once the dc are 9 and over - the op is not even considering full summer hols in holiday club.

Additionally- the father has had all the hols off and still Sent his dc to holiday club to have some "him time" - so he was more than happy to use holiday clubs while he was off work just to chill our but now it is divorce and trying to wrangle himself the house he is against the idea -.he is a total bullshitter

Dibbydoos · 07/04/2024 18:32

Why does he keep the house if they're with you for most days of the year? Def don't say yes to that. He can bloody rent!

Ref holidays, you will take time off with them at least a week at Christmas, Easter and 2 weeks over the summer, so tell him to sod off.

Get advice, he's trying to railroad you x

jeaux90 · 07/04/2024 18:27

Agree with you OP...if you do 50/50 week on and off I'd do a handover in the week so you can also plan weekends away if you want to do that.

KoolKookaburra · 07/04/2024 18:24

MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 18:23

I'm not suggesting kids will be in holiday clubs for days on end. I'm suggesting that if we go for 5050, this should be retained in holidays (despite him being a teacher) and that if I need to use clubs during my time - then so be it - but of course I will be taking annual leave and i work flexibly and from home a lot anyway. What I'm saying is that just becase he is a teacher doesn't mean our arrngement goes out the window and he has them for the whole 6 weeks.

this is not being not wanting them to see their dad or being jealous/petty - i just think it's better for them to spend time with both of us during the holidays.

I don't see why a 4 week/2 week split wouldn't work just as well

MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 18:23

I'm not suggesting kids will be in holiday clubs for days on end. I'm suggesting that if we go for 5050, this should be retained in holidays (despite him being a teacher) and that if I need to use clubs during my time - then so be it - but of course I will be taking annual leave and i work flexibly and from home a lot anyway. What I'm saying is that just becase he is a teacher doesn't mean our arrngement goes out the window and he has them for the whole 6 weeks.

this is not being not wanting them to see their dad or being jealous/petty - i just think it's better for them to spend time with both of us during the holidays.

OP posts:
TheSnowyOwl · 07/04/2024 18:18

Make sure birthdays (including his and yours) as well as any other special days like Mother’s Day etc are also covered in whatever you agree.

TheSnowyOwl · 07/04/2024 18:16

MarioBrothers · 07/04/2024 11:26

Yes, I would take my leave during summer, but i don't have enough to cover 50% of easter, half terms, xmas, summer. But I think we should just keep to alternative weeks and that if i need to use summer clubs then fine. They like clubs with all their friends from school more than sitting at home all day. But perhaps i'm letting emotion cloud my judgement

How about you agree you each have a week over Christmas and Easter. You have the weekends each side of the half terms and you have two weeks of the summer holidays as well as all the weekends (unless he is taking them away on holiday)? Unless they go to the same school as their father, the responsibility to cover inset days will also need to be addressed since he is unlikely to be able to get the time off. This suggestion gives you 25 days a year with the children and enables you to fix the dates in advance for trips and holidays.

I think they should have the option of being with a parent rather than holiday clubs.

Lazydomestic · 07/04/2024 18:11

Whilst having flexibility over school holidays makes sense - Where does he propose they live for the other 39 weeks a year during term time ?

ChangeAgain2 · 07/04/2024 18:06

I wouldn't discuss logistics. I think it's best to discuss them with a mediator or 3rd party present.

I think alternate weekends and 50:50 holidays is reasonable. He gets father's day and you get mother's day as part of the agreement

You could alternate who does the week half terms in Feb, May and October. You both get a week at Easter.and Christmas..Then 3 weeks each over summer holiday. That gives you time to have a holiday with the kids.

ziggies · 07/04/2024 18:04

honeylulu · 07/04/2024 11:50

Is no one reading what OP has written? Her kids like holiday clubs and would prefer to go there than be at home. Mine are the same and so was I as a child - no clubs but bored rigid stuck at home and desperate to get back to school! Considering that preference, there is no reason why the holidays can't be split between parents. Dad won't have to pay for childcare on his weeks, mum will (though obviously she can use annual leave for some of it), fair enough.

Cynically, it sounds like dad is engineering things so he can keep the house and claim maintenance from OP. Oh yes, and have every weekend free to please himself. He might change his tune in a year or so when he realises he can't go on holiday with his new girlfriend because he has his kids every weekend ...

I've always been the type to prefer activities to lazing around... But I was one of the "permanent club kids" there the whole day 5 days a week, and at some point when no other kids are really there, you get bored, the teacher gets bored, you all have cabin fever stuck in there with each other, they stick some Youtube on for you or just stare into space despite what the written itinerary/programme says...

ziggies · 07/04/2024 18:01

He takes them to park but he also puts on a lot of youtube. He also doesn't plan ahead and DS struggles a lot with not doing what he is doing from one day to next.

With all due respect, this drip feed sounds a bit like you're trying to justify your jealousy/pettiness/etc... Are YOU the perfect parent during the school hols? Will all childcare and wrap around care be 100% "on" and enriching for them?

I think him having them during the hols, with a few clubs sprinkled in, and him having his me time + you seeing them on weekends during the hols sounds perfect. The house is another matter.

Runninouttatime · 07/04/2024 17:52

I haven’t read the full thread but have you totalled up the number of days over the year and looked to see what that means from a CMS point of view. It’s a tiered system and depends on whether you will need to rely on CM to support the kids.