Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I increase the rent?

257 replies

Everywheretwice · 03/04/2024 07:30

I own a property that I rent to a lovely family, a couple and their primary age son. They both work full time. The wife's father also lives with them, he works full time too.

They've been in the property for 6 years, they have always paid £800pcm, on time, no issues, and I've never raised the rent. Market value now would be at least £1100.

I'm torn between raising the rent slightly to help cover increasing costs associated with the property, or leaving it as it is because I like them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TeaandChoc222 · 14/04/2024 11:53

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 12:04

@Amelie2024 I think it is most definitely not me that needs to grow up!

The average landlord in London makes £996.76 in profit per month, in Manchester £423 - so yes I think we can safely say they are lining their profits nicely!

Obviously on an individual basis it will depend when they brought the house, how big the mortgage is etc. Places where they rent out the rooms and have more occupants will make more profit.

Landlords that brought ages ago, barely do maintenance and keep hiking up the rent are definitely lining their pockets!

Well said, and let's not forget the likely doubling or tripling of the assets value over the next twenty years or so. Often with mjnimal expenditure.

Now look at those yields again as a long term jnvestment...hum not so bad 😁

The only idiots exposed to misery ,and really shouldnt be in business because they dont see it as a business,are those who've taken on too much debt .Unfortunately these are often the ones who inflate the market rate.

ManchesterBeatrice · 07/04/2024 15:54

I think you're an absolute pushover.

HappiestSleeping · 07/04/2024 14:41

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 12:24

It was from this: https://manorestateagent.co.uk/the-most-profitable-places-to-become-a-landlord/

Its from 2022 so presumably pre interest rate hike.

My point wasn’t about whether or not it’s profitable to be a landlord though. If you look at my original post we were discussing whether the OP should charge market rent just because it’s the market rent.

Landlords do extremely well in popular places in London & Brighton where there’s a housing shortage and huge demand. They can make vast profits because the ‘market rent’ is so high.

In my eyes it’s greedy - I don’t agree with pricing out people and hiking up rent because you can. I get it’s the same as anything else in life - why wouldn’t you maximise your returns. However, people do need somewhere to live and we need people to do low paid jobs as well. Moving is a huge ordeal so having big increases and forcing people to move as a result is awful. I don’t agree with landlords who just see $$$ when they rent out a property.

That’s not all landlords and it’s certainly not the OP!! But we would have a much fairer world if some people were a little less money grabbing and a bit more reasonable.

That article doesn't list all the actual costs either, only the compulsory ones, so the real profits are much lower.

I take your point about greed, although personally I object to the greed of landlords who do not maintain their properties, or do basic repairs in a timely manner to save money. I don't object to market forces as they can go down as well as up, and the landlords have to cope with these lows as well as the highs. Also, there are an increasing number of bad tenants these days which is why many landlords are selling up. This will make the problem worse.

The thing we probably both agree on is that there is a housing issue, and that people are often stuck between a rock and a hard place in terms of housing affordability. The government (in fact successive governments) have exacerbated this by under investing in social housing and relying on private landlords to pick up the gap.

HoneyPie12 · 07/04/2024 12:26

My rent has increased each year since I lived here. They calculate it with the RPI index. Its gone from 1100 - 1210 - 1290 and the 1290 is only that figure because we pushed back from a 9% increase proposed. We pay on time every month and I would go as far to say we are amazing tenants. We get on well with them but it does sting to see them raise it so much which we struggle with, and then take the Aston Martin out at weekends for a "jolly". However, this is the price we pay to have a nice house in a nice area. It stings but its just one of those things, if you don't have to increase the rent I wouldn't, but I've never owned a house and I'm coming from purely a tenant perspective

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 12:24

It was from this: https://manorestateagent.co.uk/the-most-profitable-places-to-become-a-landlord/

Its from 2022 so presumably pre interest rate hike.

My point wasn’t about whether or not it’s profitable to be a landlord though. If you look at my original post we were discussing whether the OP should charge market rent just because it’s the market rent.

Landlords do extremely well in popular places in London & Brighton where there’s a housing shortage and huge demand. They can make vast profits because the ‘market rent’ is so high.

In my eyes it’s greedy - I don’t agree with pricing out people and hiking up rent because you can. I get it’s the same as anything else in life - why wouldn’t you maximise your returns. However, people do need somewhere to live and we need people to do low paid jobs as well. Moving is a huge ordeal so having big increases and forcing people to move as a result is awful. I don’t agree with landlords who just see $$$ when they rent out a property.

That’s not all landlords and it’s certainly not the OP!! But we would have a much fairer world if some people were a little less money grabbing and a bit more reasonable.

The most profitable places to become a landlord - Manor Estate Agent

With savers receiving poor returns from banks and building societies, thousands of people unsurprisingly continue to turn to residential property as a means of supplementing their income, supported by low mortgage borrowing rates, solid demand from ten...

https://manorestateagent.co.uk/the-most-profitable-places-to-become-a-landlord/

HappiestSleeping · 07/04/2024 12:13

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 12:04

@Amelie2024 I think it is most definitely not me that needs to grow up!

The average landlord in London makes £996.76 in profit per month, in Manchester £423 - so yes I think we can safely say they are lining their profits nicely!

Obviously on an individual basis it will depend when they brought the house, how big the mortgage is etc. Places where they rent out the rooms and have more occupants will make more profit.

Landlords that brought ages ago, barely do maintenance and keep hiking up the rent are definitely lining their pockets!

I'd like to see where your statistics come from. Everything I am reading suggests that profits are at a record low, and well below the averages you quote.

Those numbers look more like income numbers (I.e. average rent charged) than profit (I.e. what's left after expenses).

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 12:04

@Amelie2024 I think it is most definitely not me that needs to grow up!

The average landlord in London makes £996.76 in profit per month, in Manchester £423 - so yes I think we can safely say they are lining their profits nicely!

Obviously on an individual basis it will depend when they brought the house, how big the mortgage is etc. Places where they rent out the rooms and have more occupants will make more profit.

Landlords that brought ages ago, barely do maintenance and keep hiking up the rent are definitely lining their pockets!

Amelie2024 · 07/04/2024 09:26

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 08:26

You crack me up @Amelie2024 !

I can tell you what I said is basic economics!!! Back to school for you

@Squiggles23

Grow up.

But they aren’t just paying the landlords mortgage, in most cases they are paying vastly more to line the landlords pockets

this is NOT 'Basic Economics'. It's just bullshit.

Squiggles23 · 07/04/2024 08:26

Amelie2024 · 03/04/2024 10:15

@Squiggles23

no, they're not, not the vast majority of private LL's. That's a misconception of people who don't understand the costs involved in owning/running a rental property.

it IS basic evonomics, it's a shame you don't understand them.

You crack me up @Amelie2024 !

I can tell you what I said is basic economics!!! Back to school for you

Amelie2024 · 04/04/2024 00:56

5128gap · 03/04/2024 10:49

Its only an unfair summary if you focus on the first perspective I offered while ignoring the counter argument. Taking both together, its a balanced summary. I also said 'if you can afford not to' and 'if you're not out of pocket'. The original post said only that the OP was charging £800 and could get £1100 but she 'liked them'. I responded to that.

@5128gap

No, that's not all she said. She also said...

I'm torn between raising the rent slightly to help cover increasing costs associated with the property

it's clear she is out of pocket on the house.

CarrotCake01 · 03/04/2024 21:03

My landlord increases the rent every year. It's like £50 extra per month that it goes up each year.
Definitely not unreasonable for you to increase the rent, you're not doing it maliciously or because you hate them and they're nasty! It would be because the costs of everything is increasing and you're just keeping in line with that. You need to be receiving your money worth, I'm sure they'd understand.

Caerulea · 03/04/2024 20:58

OP - you need cloning.

Cherrysoup · 03/04/2024 20:57

Raise the rent. You’re not a charity nor are they your family/mates. There are 3 working adults in the property (which would break my tenancy agreement, only 2 allowed in my 2 bed property). Raise the rent to near comparable market value.

ThisOldThang · 03/04/2024 20:53

SabreIsMyFave · 03/04/2024 20:11

But the supermarkets DO that. Loads of retail businesses do. Including the petrol suppliers. Buy in bulk and buy cheaper, but still ramp up the prices later on (even though their surplus was bought cheaper.) Ditto the energy companies.

I thought this was common knowledge. Confused

Some people appear to live in a dream world of pretty colours and unicorns.

SabreIsMyFave · 03/04/2024 20:11

sheroku · 03/04/2024 16:24

This. I’m a good customer at Morrisons but they still put the prices up and don’t give me a discount even though I pay for all my shopping EVERY SINGLE TIME and I’m polite to the staff.

Now imagine it's COVID, people have overbought so there's a shortage of supply. Morrisons costs haven't gone up but they decide to massively ramp up the price of goods because there's a market shortage, people have to eat and so that's what they can get away with. The rest of the supermarkets follow suit as that's the new "market rate". Would you say that's just "good business"? No you'd say it's profiteering. This is the exact state of our housing market right now.

But the supermarkets DO that. Loads of retail businesses do. Including the petrol suppliers. Buy in bulk and buy cheaper, but still ramp up the prices later on (even though their surplus was bought cheaper.) Ditto the energy companies.

I thought this was common knowledge. Confused

Crowgirl · 03/04/2024 20:06

Zanatdy · 03/04/2024 07:33

I think it’s fairly normal to have a rise most years, I do in my rental property. They have 3 incomes so should be able to stretch to a higher amount

Most years!?!

valensiwalensi · 03/04/2024 19:27

Everywheretwice · 03/04/2024 18:10

Thank you for the comments and advice!

I've had a good chat this afternoon with the tenants (they invited me over) and I have given them notice of a rent increase, from £800 to £850. They were grateful it's not been raised previously and said they were expecting something as others they know have been given huge increases, I think they were relieved.

I said I'll now likely raise it annually in line with inflation, if needed, certainly no large increases and always with discussion and notice.

This will cover any increased costs and it's still much lower than 'market value' which, let's face it, is ridiculous anyway.

Some people will say I'm soft, others say I'm a greedy arsehole, I can live with both as I'm doing what I feel is about right!

I think you are a great Landlord! Sensible and fair

Notanevillandlord · 03/04/2024 19:13

@Everywheretwice that's a great solution and fair. Like you I don't feel the need to raise rents just because and a good tenant is worth so much more than a couple of hundred extra quid a month..

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 03/04/2024 19:06

Everywheretwice · 03/04/2024 18:10

Thank you for the comments and advice!

I've had a good chat this afternoon with the tenants (they invited me over) and I have given them notice of a rent increase, from £800 to £850. They were grateful it's not been raised previously and said they were expecting something as others they know have been given huge increases, I think they were relieved.

I said I'll now likely raise it annually in line with inflation, if needed, certainly no large increases and always with discussion and notice.

This will cover any increased costs and it's still much lower than 'market value' which, let's face it, is ridiculous anyway.

Some people will say I'm soft, others say I'm a greedy arsehole, I can live with both as I'm doing what I feel is about right!

Great and excellent outcome

Those that say the BS to you are just jealous and know naff all.

You are one of the millions of good LL's around and a credit to your community.

What you are is, a very caring, thoughtful, helpful, sensitive, sensible, astute and decent person. Do not let anyone else tell you any different

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/04/2024 18:23

Menomeno · 03/04/2024 15:43

So where will rental properties come from if only those that are owned outright can be rented out? Half the population would be on the street.

Whether or not a landlord has a mortgage is actually none of a tenant's business, but for the "all landlords are bastards" persuasion restricting lets to only properties owned outright would be even worse

You can hear it now: "They're lucky to own a property which some will never have, so why should they make money out of it?"

RandomButtons · 03/04/2024 18:13

titbumwillypoo · 03/04/2024 17:28

RandomButtons
Without private landlords rent will be controlled by mega rich property investors who will over inflate rental prices more.
Or the Government could stop subsidising the market and build its own houses, only 17% of households in England live in social housing so plenty of room for competition to be introduced into the market.

I don’t disagree that more housing needs to be built, but the government will never build its own houses - it will use the existing house builders to do that, which it already does. Whether right or wrong all new estates have to have 10% social housing, though it’s down to council and local one here makes it 30%.

Everywheretwice · 03/04/2024 18:10

Thank you for the comments and advice!

I've had a good chat this afternoon with the tenants (they invited me over) and I have given them notice of a rent increase, from £800 to £850. They were grateful it's not been raised previously and said they were expecting something as others they know have been given huge increases, I think they were relieved.

I said I'll now likely raise it annually in line with inflation, if needed, certainly no large increases and always with discussion and notice.

This will cover any increased costs and it's still much lower than 'market value' which, let's face it, is ridiculous anyway.

Some people will say I'm soft, others say I'm a greedy arsehole, I can live with both as I'm doing what I feel is about right!

OP posts:
Treaclespoon · 03/04/2024 17:43

3 adults working full time, that’s a £50 per month each increase, after six years, sounds reasonable to me.

Notanevillandlord · 03/04/2024 17:39

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/04/2024 13:39

Why is anyone presuming they’re on minimum wage?

Maybe because it helps with the narrative of poor, crushed, underprivileged tenants and foul, greedy bastard landlords?

Never mind that each of them may be neither; as so often on SM the storyline has to be maintained, even if it means inventing things to suit

This in spades.

There's a current London thread where the Op is asking about areas to relocate in North London

She has a rental budget of £4k a month. She's only here for 2 years so renting is ideal.

For those of you who say banish BTL where do you propose she live? She could hardly rock up to the LA and ask to rent a council property.

Not everyone renting is on NMW, UC with 4 kids and 2 dogs squashed into a 2 bed flat.

titbumwillypoo · 03/04/2024 17:28

RandomButtons
Without private landlords rent will be controlled by mega rich property investors who will over inflate rental prices more.
Or the Government could stop subsidising the market and build its own houses, only 17% of households in England live in social housing so plenty of room for competition to be introduced into the market.