Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my parents for financial help

589 replies

concernedchild · 20/03/2024 08:47

I'm 24, I live at home (I know this will attract a lot of criticism but I cannot afford to move out).

I earn £1300 a month after tax etc.

After saving for professional exams (I have to pay for them, I get no help from work) I'm left with £650 per month. Of this I have to pay for uni, all my own expenses and travel to work, as well as other savings.

I'm left with about £75 at the end of each month. From this £75 I contribute what I can to the house but it's not a lot. I feel like a failure. If my friends ask to meet up I have to say no because I can't afford it.

Travel alone is £200 per month. I can't make it any cheaper. Uni is £100 per month. My expenses aren't extravagant - I'm paying for my uni course, my phone, Spotify etc., I'm not spending hundreds on my nails or getting sun beds or anything like that.

I want to approach my parents and ask for some help with the exams but I feel like a total failure for even having to ask. The plan when I moved in after uni was for me to save up and move out, but I had to move company and took a pay cut. I can't relocate my job (I'm on a training contract and I'm unlikely to get another one).

I feel like I'm sinking. I'm working for basically nothing, I can't afford to grab a coffee on my lunch break or even go out at the weekends. I'm trying my hardest to get by but it's having such an effect on me mentally that I feel like giving up and quitting my job all together to find something in a supermarket that's better paid.

Am I being unreasonable to ask them for help? I don't expect them to say yes, I'm expecting them to say no, but I feel like I'm at my wits end. I don't see a point in anything because I feel like I'm wasting my time working and not getting anywhere financially, I feel like I'm behind my peers and I just can't do it anymore

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
fruitbrewhaha · 20/03/2024 16:38

OP, you are going to have much more uncomfortable conversations than this once you qualify. You’ll need to talk to opposing solicitors, negotiate outcomes, talk to judges, senior lawyers, you’ll have to explain to clients why they cant have what they want, why you can’t secure the money they think should be theirs or whatever area of law you cover. You should be able to chat to your own parents an about your finances. None of this is insurmountable. If you don’t ask you don’t get.

JanetareyouokareyouokJanet · 20/03/2024 16:33

You sound like you’re trying really hard for a bright future. You should be proud of yourself. I would help my family in a heartbeat 💓 hope yours help you.

shockthemonkey · 20/03/2024 16:30

Hi OP, I have a son in a similar situation to you and we are continuing to support him financially. It feels totally natural to us.

You should be very proud of yourself, in how far you've come so far, and in your goals that you are moving closer to every day! I am sure your parents are proud of you too.

Please don't feel crap - it would probably kill your parents to realise the agonising you've gone through before approaching them with this request. I am quite sure they will be happy to help - but, like another pp, I'm also puzzled that they haven't already worked out your situation for themselves.

Don't neglect your mental health. Concerts and things are terribly important if they are all that's standing between you and despair. I say this because it seems obvious that your parents easily have the means and will wish to support you.

Please ignore anyone who is saying you're a fool - how terribly cruel and wrong of them - and also ignore any could-have would-have should-have talk. It's pointless and irrelevant.

Happyholidays78 · 20/03/2024 16:30

You should be proud of yourself, you are working hard for a better future/life. Ask your parents I know I would help my child out if I could x

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2024 16:28

Myotheripodisayoto · 20/03/2024 09:05

Literally the only person i know who self funded their law school never got a training contract. It had been a complete waste of 10k.

I self funded mine and am now a senior lawyer on a high salary.

PerfectTravelTote · 20/03/2024 16:24

Sit down with your parents and tell them exactly what you've said here.

I have 2 kids around the same age as you - one living at home. If either of them were in your current predicament I'd help them in a heartbeat.

You're not being unreasonable. You just need a bit of a dig out in the short term.

TR888 · 20/03/2024 16:22

OP, you know what? You're so hard-working and lovely, and so considerate about your parents - you don't feel entitled to their help which is nice. I'd be so proud if my children turn up like you 🙂.

But I almost feel emotional at the thought of a child of mine struggling in this way and feeling sick with worry at the thought asking me for help.

If your parents can afford it, they will want to help you, OP. This is money for your future livelihood, not for some frippery.

Sunshinedayscomeon · 20/03/2024 16:21

I pay for our DD rent whilst at uni £500 per month to help her whilst she's studies and have budgeted for it. It's something I wanted to do as I never had the opportunity to go to uni until later in life due affordability.

concernedchild · 20/03/2024 16:20

IncompleteSenten · 20/03/2024 16:08

Hopefully your parents will help you out but also you need to change the way you think. You are sacrificing in the short term for gains in the long term. Yes things are really tight now but it isn't forever. You'll come out the other side and reap the rewards. You have to look at what you can have long term instead of focusing on what you can't have now.

I do understand that and I can see long term, but right now it would also be nice to not be so stressed about finances all the time

OP posts:
concernedchild · 20/03/2024 16:17

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius @IncompleteSenten, thank you 🩷 I will admit that right now I am very much in the thick of exam and financial stress and probably over thinking this to the extreme! It's a really tough time

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 20/03/2024 16:16

@IncompleteSenten is absolutely right, @concernedchild - I know it isn’t easy, but you need to focus on the fact that, once these exams and this training is over, you will be able to reap the rewards of all your hard work.

Your dad sounds lovely, and I think you do too - and I admire the way you have approached this - it is sensible and reasonable.

We have three dses, and we have helped them all out financially, at one time or another - and we will carry on doing so as long as we can manage to do so. We are in a secure position, financially, and we are happy that we can help them out. Sometimes it’s been a loan, and other times it’s been a gift.

IncompleteSenten · 20/03/2024 16:08

Hopefully your parents will help you out but also you need to change the way you think. You are sacrificing in the short term for gains in the long term. Yes things are really tight now but it isn't forever. You'll come out the other side and reap the rewards. You have to look at what you can have long term instead of focusing on what you can't have now.

Mangolover123 · 20/03/2024 16:06

I think you re doing amazingly well. You are only 18 months from earning real money and no fees! You are getting real experience and studying at the same time.
Once you have a decent law degree there are many jobs open to you.
If you were my daughter I would be very proud of you.
Your parents will be glad to help you, let them help you.

MrsPeannut · 20/03/2024 16:03

Myotheripodisayoto · 20/03/2024 09:17

As I said - you are a fool for taking a TC that isn't paying your fees. You will likely find they don't have a job for you when the TC ends.

If you are only bringing in 1,300 on a TC they are paying you barely more than min wage. What the hell law firm is this?

Seriously showing how little you know with your very unhelpful posts.

You do know there are law firms outside of the City who operate very differently…

HungryBeagle · 20/03/2024 15:53

My cousin self funded and is also now working a City law firm, doing pretty well for herself.

MrsPeannut · 20/03/2024 15:52

Myotheripodisayoto · 20/03/2024 09:05

Literally the only person i know who self funded their law school never got a training contract. It had been a complete waste of 10k.

I self funded. I got a training contract and am now working at a City law firm. Several of my classmates who also funded are similarly qualified, with some working in both magic circle and silver circle firms.

So no, not a waste at all.

Threeboysadogacatandakitten · 20/03/2024 15:36

Ds1 (28) still lives at home. He’s had a slow start to employment, having to repeat a year at uni, ill health, losing his job during Covid. He’s now got a good job and is saving for a house. There are times when he has needed help from me and times when he is able to put a bit into the house. I have very little to spare but I would willingly give him, or his brothers whatever I had if they needed it. I’m sure your parents will feel the same. Don’t make it too complicated. Speak to them and see what they come up with.

honeylulu · 20/03/2024 15:31

You poor thing, I twigged from your first post that this was going to be a law training contract/exams. Guess which profession I am in!

I qualified a long time ago and it was tough then. There were half as many TCs as people wanting them and I've heard it's more like 10 people for every TC now. So people saying you are foolish for not getting a TC at a big/top firm have no idea how hard it is to get one at all. Well done for getting yours.

I too had people shocked I had to pay for my own LPC course and exams. They told me "your firm HAS to pay" because they knew others in this situation. Erm, no, they don't have to at all!

Have you looked into getting a Career Development Loan? I got mine with HSBC but it might be called something different now. That was how I managed ...

IncognitoMam · 20/03/2024 15:21

Good luck. I hope they help you. I helped ds1 as much as possible when he was at uni. He didn't work just studied. He did a law degree but isn't in law. He couldn't get a job. He earns well though.

HorsesDuvets · 20/03/2024 15:17

I would help my DD out (same age as you) in a heartbeat.

It's clear why some help is needed here, and it's for a worthy reason, so I wouldn't hesitate.

I'd be more disappointed that she'd not asked sooner and were feeling so anxious about even approaching us.

concernedchild · 20/03/2024 15:17

Winter2020 · 20/03/2024 15:10

Hi OP,
I hope your parents will be happy to help you.

Are you an only child? If you are your parents might not be too concerned about you paying them back as they will probably hope that a lot of their savings will come to you one day. If you have siblings then they have to consider being fair to each of you.

I also think you are over complicating your request with all the talk of interest/10% of this and that etc. Just ask to borrow 5K and pay it back in regular installments. It's just over 4 years if you pay back £100 each month or just over 2 years if you pay back £200 each month.

Or you could just ask your parents to pay your exam fees direct and you will pay them back say £200 each month after you qualify. Bear in mind when you qualify you will also be wanting to save for a deposit for a house I expect so it will slow your plans down. If your parents offer that you don't have to pay them back accept!

Also remember that if you borrow 5K and pay back 5k no tax is due. If you start paying interest then that interest is taxable income for your parents.

Good luck with your meeting later

I didn't think about interest and tax, thanks I've written that down x

OP posts:
concernedchild · 20/03/2024 15:13

tkwal · 20/03/2024 15:09

You're not being unreasonable in asking for help, there are a few things to consider

  1. Are your parents comfortably able to lend the money
  2. Are there no grants/student loans available to you ?
  3. Will completing your course increase your earning ability?How long will that take ?
  4. Can you make a realistic promise to them about how much you will pay back and when ?
Compared to other posters on MN I have to say you sound as though you have your head screwed on. You're willing to sacrifice in order to enhance your prospects . Wishing you success and happiness x

This is my proposed repayment plan x

To ask my parents for financial help
OP posts:
Bringbackspring · 20/03/2024 15:11

I think you sound really sensible, OP. Your parents will hopefully be impressed to see that you have a plan, and they will already be able to see that you are the not sort of person to waste money. They are your parents and I expect they are really proud of you and can see a bright future. You have to think of the situation you are in now as temporary. You are a student, and your chosen career path may be costly upfront, but you will reap the rewards later on as you are going into quite a stable field with opportunities all over the country. Over the course of your hopefully long career you will earn well for a far greater length of time than when you earned peanuts. Do not be embarrassed, we all need a little help every now and then. We don't all get it but you may as well ask.
Best of luck to you, I hope it goes well with your parents.

Winter2020 · 20/03/2024 15:10

Hi OP,
I hope your parents will be happy to help you.

Are you an only child? If you are your parents might not be too concerned about you paying them back as they will probably hope that a lot of their savings will come to you one day. If you have siblings then they have to consider being fair to each of you.

I also think you are over complicating your request with all the talk of interest/10% of this and that etc. Just ask to borrow 5K and pay it back in regular installments. It's just over 4 years if you pay back £100 each month or just over 2 years if you pay back £200 each month.

Or you could just ask your parents to pay your exam fees direct and you will pay them back say £200 each month after you qualify. Bear in mind when you qualify you will also be wanting to save for a deposit for a house I expect so it will slow your plans down. If your parents offer that you don't have to pay them back accept!

Also remember that if you borrow 5K and pay back 5k no tax is due. If you start paying interest then that interest is taxable income for your parents.

Good luck with your meeting later

tkwal · 20/03/2024 15:09

You're not being unreasonable in asking for help, there are a few things to consider

  1. Are your parents comfortably able to lend the money
  2. Are there no grants/student loans available to you ?
  3. Will completing your course increase your earning ability?How long will that take ?
  4. Can you make a realistic promise to them about how much you will pay back and when ?
Compared to other posters on MN I have to say you sound as though you have your head screwed on. You're willing to sacrifice in order to enhance your prospects . Wishing you success and happiness x