Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think change is desperately needed in schools?

612 replies

GibberingPeck · 18/03/2024 18:46

I work with young children. Today I was hit twice and scratched on the face so hard it drew blood. This has not happened to me before and I’ve worked in schools for many years. I was trying to stop a child hurting another child. The school’s stance seems to be that I shouldn’t have intervened or somehow dealt with the situation badly. I think they saw I was bleeding, but ignored it as they have so much to deal with. This year, I think I’ve seen more violent and aggressive behaviour from children than I’ve ever seen. And no way of dealing with it - it seems to have become acceptable or ‘the norm’.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
echt · 19/03/2024 20:50

@karriecreamer
But hardly surprising when todays' kids are being brought up by parents who weren't "properly" brought up back 20/30 years ago.

Where on earth do you get that from? Any evidence at all?

Mumma2024 · 19/03/2024 20:41

User8646382 · 19/03/2024 20:09

So many kids are on medication now for conditions like ADHD, it’s mind boggling. I honestly don’t mean to sound judgemental, but don’t you worry about the long term effects? My kids are grown up now (thank God, because I wouldn’t want them to be in a school like the ones described on here), but I could never have put them on medication like that - I wouldn’t have dared. Twenty, thirty years ago, no one would. Now it’s the norm.

It makes you wonder, honestly.

Considering you've quoted the poster who responded to my post, where I said we are seeking to medicate my DD I feel I need to interject.

She's 9 now, we were first offered medication the week after she turned 6 (I hadn't realised declining would get us discharged and cause this issue now).

My DD doesn't harm anyone but has fairly severe ADHD. She doesn't sit on screens all day because her ADHD means she physically can't. She can't sit still, at all. She can't focus and her executive functioning is poor. She has had 4 years of huge modifications to avoid medicating her. In school she has movement breaks regularly in and out of the class (at least once per hour), she routinely works out of the classroom on her own because she can't stand all the distractions, she has a rocking chair as her regular seat.

No one wants to medicate their child but if it's being considered, there must be fairly significant issues. The implications of medication is scary, they have to have 6 monthly ECGs and height/weight checks. It affects their appetite etc.

You say you could never have put them on medication, but unless you've watches your child whose mind goes so 100mph they can barely string a sentence together, and who desperately wants to achieve in school but just can't. Then you can't say you would never do something.

For us, it will be to get her through school. To improve her quality of life so she can be the person she wants to be, not the impulsive, jittery, overwhelmed ADHD version.

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 20:34

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:30

I never said it's all due to entitled MC parents, I also never said private schools are full of entitled parents. You can click on quote history if you need to see what I said, as I think you've misread my posts or are quoting someone else.

At 20.06 you wrote: If anything SEN kids are screwed over in private schools and they are full of entitled parents that are very difficult to deal with.

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:30

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 20:26

I commented on the first page and have just come back to it.
I wasn't the one who brought up it being due to entitled MC parents, you did and you then went on to say that private schools are all full of entitled parents. I haven't RTFT no but entitled attitudes exist across all sectors and all I can say is that DDs private school isn't an example of this. We are rural NE England though so no uber wealthy, just parents invested in getting a decent education for our DC.

I never said it's all due to entitled MC parents, I also never said private schools are full of entitled parents. You can click on quote history if you need to see what I said, as I think you've misread my posts or are quoting someone else.

downbutnotouttake969 · 19/03/2024 20:30

Parents no longer have the time or energy to 'parent' in the ways of old. They are too busy and exhausted from keeping a roof over their families head, food on the table and heating in the cold.

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 20:26

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:18

You've clearly not bothered to read the thread, which I don't blame you as it's long, but the OPs second post says they're in a private school. The many many posts from teachers all talk about how the wealthier parents often make up the bigger problem. That's not my own opinion.
Inverted prejudice of course exists, and your assumption that my child is at a state school is probably part of that.
You've illustrated perfectly what money gets you- choice. It's not state Vs private. Also, the 1:1 the SEN school get, might well be the OP!

Edited

I commented on the first page and have just come back to it.
I wasn't the one who brought up it being due to entitled MC parents, you did and you then went on to say that private schools are all full of entitled parents. I haven't RTFT no but entitled attitudes exist across all sectors and all I can say is that DDs private school isn't an example of this. We are rural NE England though so no uber wealthy, just parents invested in getting a decent education for our DC.

WearyAuldWumman · 19/03/2024 20:23

bobotothegogo · 19/03/2024 19:06

Another teacher here... 40y/o, primary, central scotland, 17 years in the job. Will be dropping a day after summer and taking the hit financially as I can't suffer it any longer and don't know what else I could do job-wise.

Lack of funding for staffing and resources combined with apathetic parenting (by no means all parents but certainly more and more each year).

Beware: I dropped to a 4 day week and found myself doing 5 days' work in the space of 4. A year later, my Heidie wouldn't let me drop to 3, so I quit. (I was 58 at the time and DH was in poor health.)

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:23

User8646382 · 19/03/2024 20:09

So many kids are on medication now for conditions like ADHD, it’s mind boggling. I honestly don’t mean to sound judgemental, but don’t you worry about the long term effects? My kids are grown up now (thank God, because I wouldn’t want them to be in a school like the ones described on here), but I could never have put them on medication like that - I wouldn’t have dared. Twenty, thirty years ago, no one would. Now it’s the norm.

It makes you wonder, honestly.

I agree with you and I do worry. Tbh for us the meds are just to get her through school. She would be dead without them, genuinely. And no, she doesn't have a smart phone. Our psychiatrist is lovely and also sees it as a means to an end to get her through this part of education in one piece. We're lucky that they've helped tremendously but I didn't agree to them until she overdosed and at that point you really chuck anything you hope will help at your kid.

izimbra · 19/03/2024 20:21

@Hikingonmonday "I realise that might come across judgemental" in fairness 10 minutes in a FB group for parents whose children are severely mentally ill and under CAMHS would show that most judge CAMHS as more neglectful, inadequate and ineffectual than you're judging struggling, desperate parents to be.

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:18

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 20:09

I am saying in DDs school SEN have 1'-2-1 support that is an additional cost.
And you call other people prejudiced when you come out with "they are full of entitled parents that are very difficult to deal with"
Maybe check your own prejudices, inverted snobbery exists!

You've clearly not bothered to read the thread, which I don't blame you as it's long, but the OPs second post says they're in a private school. The many many posts from teachers all talk about how the wealthier parents often make up the bigger problem. That's not my own opinion.
Inverted prejudice of course exists, and your assumption that my child is at a state school is probably part of that.
You've illustrated perfectly what money gets you- choice. It's not state Vs private. Also, the 1:1 the SEN school get, might well be the OP!

izimbra · 19/03/2024 20:18

Hikingonmonday · 19/03/2024 20:02

I work in CAMHS and I’m shocked at the lack of boundaries parents are putting in place to keep their children healthy and safe. They can do what they want when they want with little to no consequences of it. Parents are scared to do anything that might cause their child any sort of upset or distress. Children are spending far too much time on screens and doing this well into the night. When you advise cutting this down you’re met with “Oh No I can’t take his phone off him because he’ll have a meltdown” meanwhile their 10 year old is being groomed online because they have unlimited access to all areas of the internet. I often ask children to tell me what their screen-time average is and I’m now not shocked to hear of teenagers spending 10-14 hours a day on their phones. Children have phones and iPads shoved in front of them to keep them quiet and easy to manage from a few months old whilst parents sit on their own phones ignoring their children (real life still face experiment in action!). I honestly feel that this is having such a detrimental impact on children’s concentration levels, social skills etc and then a few years down the line the parents want an autism/adhd assessment.
Obviously there are a load of other factors as well and the bottom line is that these are genuinely very distressed, dysregulated and unhappy children who have been let down by those around them.
Anyway, that’s my view. I realise that might come across judgemental and I know that parents are under a lot of pressure themselves but it is just depressing. It’s been a long day..

Would it occur to you that some children aren't made mentally ill by their phone use?

Their phone use is a self soothing technique?

When my anxiety is terrible (which it often is because I have a child with leukaemia) I find my phone use becomes really dysfunctional. Sometimes being in my phone is a huge escape from the incredibly difficult feelings I'm experiencing when my reality is so tough.

BTW - when a teen is severely isolated and oppositional, parents often feel helpless and eventually exhausted and demoralised. They're often the subject of violence at the hands of their children. When we were going through this with our 15 year old daughter (eventually diagnosed with BPD) and were BEGGING for help, CAMHS completely let us down. 'You should stop her using her phone' would have been met with disbelief.

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 20:09

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:06

No clue what your point is. The OP works in a private school. Lol private schools do not give 1:1 to all SEN kids. If anything SEN kids are screwed over in private schools and they are full of entitled parents that are very difficult to deal with.

I am saying in DDs school SEN have 1'-2-1 support that is an additional cost.
And you call other people prejudiced when you come out with "they are full of entitled parents that are very difficult to deal with"
Maybe check your own prejudices, inverted snobbery exists!

User8646382 · 19/03/2024 20:09

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 16:10

@Mumma2024 That's incorrect, they shouldn't have done that. It's against NICE guidelines. If she's got a diagnosis from NHS and the money, reach out to a private psychiatrist. We managed to get a medicine review with one on zoom for £300 as we had a diagnosis already. It was about £100 a month in private prescriptions until titration was done, so about 3 months, than our GP took over on a shared care agreement. Eventually CAMHS agreed to take it over as they said she's been on medication with a positive effect 🙄

So many kids are on medication now for conditions like ADHD, it’s mind boggling. I honestly don’t mean to sound judgemental, but don’t you worry about the long term effects? My kids are grown up now (thank God, because I wouldn’t want them to be in a school like the ones described on here), but I could never have put them on medication like that - I wouldn’t have dared. Twenty, thirty years ago, no one would. Now it’s the norm.

It makes you wonder, honestly.

WearyAuldWumman · 19/03/2024 20:08

izimbra · 19/03/2024 19:28

"No one is saying that. For the most part this thread is filled with people saying social media and phones are the problem. Parents letting screens raise their kids from extremely young ages (under 2)."

But this seems to be a fairly new complaint - that kids starting reception & year 7 are now feral, but weren't before lockdown?

No, it was happening before.

bertflugg · 19/03/2024 20:06

Hikingonmonday · 19/03/2024 20:02

I work in CAMHS and I’m shocked at the lack of boundaries parents are putting in place to keep their children healthy and safe. They can do what they want when they want with little to no consequences of it. Parents are scared to do anything that might cause their child any sort of upset or distress. Children are spending far too much time on screens and doing this well into the night. When you advise cutting this down you’re met with “Oh No I can’t take his phone off him because he’ll have a meltdown” meanwhile their 10 year old is being groomed online because they have unlimited access to all areas of the internet. I often ask children to tell me what their screen-time average is and I’m now not shocked to hear of teenagers spending 10-14 hours a day on their phones. Children have phones and iPads shoved in front of them to keep them quiet and easy to manage from a few months old whilst parents sit on their own phones ignoring their children (real life still face experiment in action!). I honestly feel that this is having such a detrimental impact on children’s concentration levels, social skills etc and then a few years down the line the parents want an autism/adhd assessment.
Obviously there are a load of other factors as well and the bottom line is that these are genuinely very distressed, dysregulated and unhappy children who have been let down by those around them.
Anyway, that’s my view. I realise that might come across judgemental and I know that parents are under a lot of pressure themselves but it is just depressing. It’s been a long day..

This with bells on.
DD best friend is four and her overly permissive parents let her doom scroll Facebook for whatever videos she's interested in, quite literally all day, zero supervision. They have just carried on their covid parenting even tho it's years since any kind of lockdown.
I have had to cut contact with them as I just can't deal. Of course they think she has ADHD. She doesn't, she has lack of boundaries and no sleep/too much screen time.

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 20:06

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 19:58

But not all MC and wealthy people send their DC to private schools.
IMO it is more due to the fact that parents who pay school fees have skin in the game. I wonder if the patents who don't engage with schools had to pay for education, whether they would become more invested.
Class sizes 18-20 Vs 30+ makes a massive difference too as teachers really get to know their pupils and can build positive relationships. Very mutually respectful culture throughout the school with staff at all levels. Kids and teachers are friendly and polite towards each other so none of the Us V Them combative relationships you read about on many posts.
SEN kids have 1-2-1 support in all lessons.

No clue what your point is. The OP works in a private school. Lol private schools do not give 1:1 to all SEN kids. If anything SEN kids are screwed over in private schools and they are full of entitled parents that are very difficult to deal with.

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 20:04

Hikingonmonday · 19/03/2024 20:02

I work in CAMHS and I’m shocked at the lack of boundaries parents are putting in place to keep their children healthy and safe. They can do what they want when they want with little to no consequences of it. Parents are scared to do anything that might cause their child any sort of upset or distress. Children are spending far too much time on screens and doing this well into the night. When you advise cutting this down you’re met with “Oh No I can’t take his phone off him because he’ll have a meltdown” meanwhile their 10 year old is being groomed online because they have unlimited access to all areas of the internet. I often ask children to tell me what their screen-time average is and I’m now not shocked to hear of teenagers spending 10-14 hours a day on their phones. Children have phones and iPads shoved in front of them to keep them quiet and easy to manage from a few months old whilst parents sit on their own phones ignoring their children (real life still face experiment in action!). I honestly feel that this is having such a detrimental impact on children’s concentration levels, social skills etc and then a few years down the line the parents want an autism/adhd assessment.
Obviously there are a load of other factors as well and the bottom line is that these are genuinely very distressed, dysregulated and unhappy children who have been let down by those around them.
Anyway, that’s my view. I realise that might come across judgemental and I know that parents are under a lot of pressure themselves but it is just depressing. It’s been a long day..

I agree. Kids need boundaries and rules. It isn't healthy to never say no to your child but I see so many parents who are scared of saying no (including my in-laws!).

Hikingonmonday · 19/03/2024 20:02

I work in CAMHS and I’m shocked at the lack of boundaries parents are putting in place to keep their children healthy and safe. They can do what they want when they want with little to no consequences of it. Parents are scared to do anything that might cause their child any sort of upset or distress. Children are spending far too much time on screens and doing this well into the night. When you advise cutting this down you’re met with “Oh No I can’t take his phone off him because he’ll have a meltdown” meanwhile their 10 year old is being groomed online because they have unlimited access to all areas of the internet. I often ask children to tell me what their screen-time average is and I’m now not shocked to hear of teenagers spending 10-14 hours a day on their phones. Children have phones and iPads shoved in front of them to keep them quiet and easy to manage from a few months old whilst parents sit on their own phones ignoring their children (real life still face experiment in action!). I honestly feel that this is having such a detrimental impact on children’s concentration levels, social skills etc and then a few years down the line the parents want an autism/adhd assessment.
Obviously there are a load of other factors as well and the bottom line is that these are genuinely very distressed, dysregulated and unhappy children who have been let down by those around them.
Anyway, that’s my view. I realise that might come across judgemental and I know that parents are under a lot of pressure themselves but it is just depressing. It’s been a long day..

twistyizzy · 19/03/2024 19:58

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 19:36

You're actually showing your own stereotypes here. The thread was started by someone working in a private school and many teachers on here comment on the middle class and wealthier parents being a bigger problem.

But not all MC and wealthy people send their DC to private schools.
IMO it is more due to the fact that parents who pay school fees have skin in the game. I wonder if the patents who don't engage with schools had to pay for education, whether they would become more invested.
Class sizes 18-20 Vs 30+ makes a massive difference too as teachers really get to know their pupils and can build positive relationships. Very mutually respectful culture throughout the school with staff at all levels. Kids and teachers are friendly and polite towards each other so none of the Us V Them combative relationships you read about on many posts.
SEN kids have 1-2-1 support in all lessons.

Simmy76349 · 19/03/2024 19:54

izimbra · 19/03/2024 19:45

Oh come on Foxesandsquirrels - 'better behaviour' and 'smaller class sizes are the reasons most commonly stated by parents who choose fee paying schools. It's not a stereotype when it's true!

Yep absolutely 2 of the reasons we opted for the school we did (amongst others). I loved the behaviour and values I witnessed. It seems we can't admit we opted for private for any reason on here! The reality is if we didn't think there was something we preferred, we wouldn't do it would we?!

I'm not saying private schools have better behaviour (clearly not given that OP is at a private school) but the values and behaviours at the particular school we choose are great. I can't say if that's the parents or the school but something is causing it.

Oh and most of the parents work...absolutely crazy talk I know!

karriecreamer · 19/03/2024 19:52

waterrat · 18/03/2024 20:08

Someone mentioned a year 4 boy - so - a boy of 8 or 9. A child that age should be spending HOURS running around - how much is he getting really? May be arriving at school sitting down most of the day and going home and sitting in front of screens - of course he is behaving appallingly - this is no way to bring kids up. We have a mental and physical health crisis in our children.

And sad as it is for teachers, the first question should be to look at how children are feeling and how we are failing them - especially when they are this young.

When I was 8 or 9, we all spent most of the day sat in classrooms and certainly weren't spending hours running around. We weren't disruptive, aggressive etc! We need to stop making excuses. The fact is that parents aren't "parenting" and are far too keen/happy to abdicate responsibility to schools. That wasn't the case a few decades ago. But hardly surprising when todays' kids are being brought up by parents who weren't "properly" brought up back 20/30 years ago. It's just self perpetuating and getting worse with each generation.

izimbra · 19/03/2024 19:45

Oh come on Foxesandsquirrels - 'better behaviour' and 'smaller class sizes are the reasons most commonly stated by parents who choose fee paying schools. It's not a stereotype when it's true!

bobotothegogo · 19/03/2024 19:41

VeneziaJ · 19/03/2024 19:36

I do not think it is common at all! My eldest DGS is in year 9 and has never seen any violence towards staff in any school he has attended. His young brother is in reception at school and there are no issues like this in his year either.

So, the experience of two children?

Foxesandsquirrels · 19/03/2024 19:36

izimbra · 19/03/2024 19:26

GoodnightAdeline - so we'd expect to see this in all countries across the EU unless we have evidence of lower phone use in those places?

And the reason you don't see this in private schools is because well off people are better, less neglectful parents?

You're actually showing your own stereotypes here. The thread was started by someone working in a private school and many teachers on here comment on the middle class and wealthier parents being a bigger problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread