Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like I've let my kids down..

132 replies

sunkmybattleship · 13/03/2024 16:39

My house feels so cramped. It's probably worth around £200k ish, it just has a tiny entrance hall which won't even be 6x6ft, a small living room with stairs for upstairs in it, small kitchen and conservatory. Upstairs tiny bathroom and 3 rooms, my daughter's barely having room for a dinky bed and wardrobe. Useless garden.

My friend has moved into her old family home which is bought and paid for.. it's huge. So much room for the kids, acres of land. My daughter loved having all the toys there was that we just don't have room for. We have no room for toys really, or any space.

We can't afford anything better, we both work full time as it is. I just feel like I've let them down for only being able to afford such a small house.

OP posts:
Grapewrath · 14/03/2024 14:13

I had my own bedroom etc but my house was so miserable I spent more of it round my friends 2 bed flat. My bigger house was also filthy compared to my friends lovely clean and cosy flat
Even a box room can be adapted for study etc- ikea do a good fold down desk. It’s honestly not a big deal to kids.

5128gap · 14/03/2024 14:07

The size of your house is a fairly insignificant part of your life, unless you're so overcrowded you suffer discomfort or loss of privacy. Most of us spend the best part of our lives somewhere else, school, work, hobbies, parks, woods, towns, and when we are at home we can only sit in one room at a time, so why do we need surrounding by extra ones? You have all you need to give your children the basics - a safe, comfortable and adequate home. What you do from that foundation to enhance their childhood is entirely up to you, and nothing to do with the size of your house.

ItsallIeverwanted · 14/03/2024 14:06

Your house sounds the same as mine, average!

Arthur64 · 14/03/2024 14:05

We had a lovely big 4 bed semi and stupidly got too deep in debt. We moved to a terrace with no hall and two rooms on each floor in a state , had to gut it while we loved in it . 2 older teens still at home loved it . Family loved it ....I was ashamed at first but I did love that house 🏠 and miss it now we've moved areas .
My point is we were no happier in the big house and neither was anyone else . Let people judge but find your happiness by making your space as nice as you can .

stayathomer · 14/03/2024 14:04

We have a huge old bungalow, live very rural. Was in my friend’s house the other day and was thinking how much I hate the huge amount of cleaning here (her house sounds like yours and while it is full it’s very very clean(!) how messy ours can be, our kitchen floor takes forever to clean, then the fact that we can’t walk anywhere, that the kids can’t just go to a park like my friends’ can etc etc. but it’s our home and we’re so lucky to own, we got this by chance and it was vin an awful state and we wouldn’t have afforded anything else. I’m sorry to say this but work with what you have and try to enjoy!

PSEnny · 14/03/2024 13:56

I live in a flat with my DD. It is a large maisonette with more than enough space for us but I still feel guilty that it isn’t a house.
My DD has never made a comment about us having a flat and not a house, I just don’t think she notices. There are loads of kids in our street (which is all lower flats and upper maisonettes). I agree with others, feeling loved and secure is much more important.

AboutYouTalk · 14/03/2024 13:53

Hmm… your house is bigger than mine. Grass is always greener on the other side. Be grateful, it could be worse.

rustlerwaiter · 14/03/2024 13:47

We grew up moving around different council estates. DM always felt like she'd let us down when she got low and we always had to tell her that she did a great job. I doubt your kids see things the same way you do @sunkmybattleship, and they definitely won't when they're older and look back.

Chipsweep · 14/03/2024 13:45

6x6ft sounds massive for a hallway? My house is 12ft at its widest point and it’s a very standard house, not like a tiny shack

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 14/03/2024 13:42

There are always going to be people better off than you and there are always going to be people worse off than you. If your kids are clean, well and healthily fed, safe, you are meeting all of their needs like and you are emotionally available to them I don't think you can say you are letting them down.

areyoutheregod · 14/03/2024 13:41

sunkmybattleship · 13/03/2024 17:01

@SleepingStandingUp her parents are still alive and well but have just moved to a smaller house, giving her this house in her name mortgage free. All she had to do was move her stuff in and do it up as she liked her. Her partner isn't doing bad himself, she's never had to work a full time job in her life where as I have to kiss my 18 month old goodbye every morning so I can go to work Sad

yes you're comparing and I suspect if you didn't think about what your friend has so much you wouldn't actually think you're letting your children down at all. If you compare, you'll always find someone you think is doing better. Focus on your own life.

Avatartar · 14/03/2024 13:31

OP you are letting yourself down, not your DCs by allowing wishing and daydreaming which we all do, to affect you negatively. Think of how to improve your space inside and out and perhaps moving to a cheaper area to get more for your money. Redcar in the north is starting to boom as WFHs are buying then commuting when needed in the office. £150k for big space and beach on doorstep. There are lots of areas like this. There are usually options, aspire to, don’t envy. Security and love are the most important things for your DCs and it sounds like you’ve smashed those

SpidersAreShitheads · 14/03/2024 13:30

ohtobeinenglandinthespring · 14/03/2024 12:15

Your small house almost certainly will have a smaller carbon footprint than a much larger house, so you are actively helping the environment. Now that spring is here, if you want to work on the garden I would definitely work with what you've got - big slope? how about putting a giant slide in (set onto the ground? Your daughter and all her frineds will love you for it.

This is such a fun idea!!! And wouldn’t be possible with a flat garden so will make yours really unique. I love this!! I would want this and I’m a 48 year old woman 😂😂

I hope you’re feeling a bit better OP. We all have our moments of navel-gazing but you’re doing just fine.

Thedance · 14/03/2024 12:44

MrWilyFoxIsBack · 13/03/2024 17:03

You can say this because you grew up in a huge house. I grew up in a smallish house, I had a tiny room - I could only study sitting on my bed as there was only room for a bed and a wardrobe in my room. It was too noisy to study downstairs. Try doing ten GCSEs and then four A levels in that tiny space and believe me: you notice how small your house is. I did absolutely fine but it would have been amazing if I had had a big desk. I told myself I was lucky I had my own room (small yes, but all mine).

Yes I adored my parents and yes being in a loving family was important. But many kids have space to learn and play AND a loving family.

Oh it also wasn’t fun being bullied for living in a council house by my richer so-called friends, and being sneered at for being poor, and my best friend’s parents very clearly looking down on me when I went round to their house . Children do compare, they do play one-upmanship, and they are cruel. So there’s that in the mix too.

I still don’t think the Op has “let her children down” but let’s not pretend money doesn’t matter in giving kids an equal chance in life. It does.

I did GCEs and A levels without having a desk or anywhere private to study. I shared a room, had four siblings and we lived in a three bedroomed house. . It didn't bother me it seemed normal to me. So much so that when I went to university and had my own room I found it almost impossible to concentrate it was too quiet.
What I mainly remember from my childhood is how loving my parents were, how much they wanted the best for us and the good times we had together and I have very fond memories of that smallish house.

mrgrimblesgerbil · 14/03/2024 12:41

I suppose I do compare, I just felt so sad seeing her happily running around playing with all these toys that we don't have room for, prams, play kitchens, dressing tables etc. we have a few dolls or a jigsaw out and the room is so tiny it looks a mess.

Kids love playing with their friends' toys, that's part of the joy of going to someone else's house. If you really want her to have some of these toys though, there is usually a way. Our toy kitchen (a fiver second hand!) was just a small stove with oven underneath (not one of the bigger ones with sink, cupboards etc) so a small footprint, but it was used constantly and much loved. Most toy prams fold away for storage. Mess is just part of play - as long as it can all be easily thrown back into toy boxes before bedtime, I don't see it as a big deal.

Most kids have way too many unnecessary toys anyway. They don't need endless "stuff" but they do need versatile toys (things like building blocks, some generic dressing up items like cloaks, crowns, magic wands etc, a toy teaset etc) which are flexible and allow themselves to be incorporated into lots of different games. Mine will raid the house and turn the cupboards upside down to find things to use in their games - more temporary chaos but less permanent clutter and plastic tat! Some additional toys and accessories can be cheaply made at home and discarded without guilt after they're finished with. Also, have a ruthless declutter and invest in clever bedroom furniture. IKEA is full of furniture with clever storage solutions that will maximize vertical space and free up floor space for play. Does your daughter really need a wardrobe in her room at this age, or could her clothes live in yours leaving her more floor space for bigger toys? Etc.

Thedance · 14/03/2024 12:35

You haven't failed your children. Many people grow up in small houses. Your children have a warm home and a garden however small that is a lot more than many people have.
Don't focus on what you don't have just on what you have and try and give your children a happy secure childhood.
When they grow up they will remember and valve more the time they spend with you and the things you all do together more than how big their house was.

Caspianberg · 14/03/2024 12:26

Can you work on the garden?
Our garden is sloped, so the only flat flat area is the small terrace area near house. Ds plays out there all the time.

Most used things are the sandpit, a mud kitchen, and water play in summer. They all take up little space compared to a climbing frame. Also have chalkboard on wall

We also built some raised beds into the slopes which are great for kids to grow strawberries and other things. You can grow basics in regular pots.

Thedogsbeanbag · 14/03/2024 12:26

The faux 'I've let my kids down' is silly and untruthful. What you mean is you are jealous you have to work and that nobody handed you life on a plate like they did to this woman. Well, that's just life.

Quite right. Another of these 'I've let my kids down' posts from people living perfectly normal lives so that they sound unselfish rather than envious.

usernother · 14/03/2024 12:22

You haven't let them down, there are families living in bed and breakfasts for months who'd love to have what you have. Count your blessings.

ZingyShaker · 14/03/2024 12:18

Comparison is the thief of joy and all that. Can you tweak the layout so that you feel more in love with it?

I've gone from a 4 bed detached to a 3 bed terrace post divorce, and I do have days where I yearn for my log burner and bigger plot, but that's not practical for me now and I try to keep that in mind.

CharlotteBog · 14/03/2024 12:18

I have raised 2 sons with a 10 year age gap in a 2 bed house.
DS2 stayed in my room until DS1 left for uni (and still then had to move back in with me when DS1 came home).
It is what it is. We are financially secure, happy and healthy.
Looking at what you don't have rather what you do is never helpful (unless you are a lazy arse and need outside motivation).
As I've got older, things like health and peace of mind become way more important than material wealth.

ohtobeinenglandinthespring · 14/03/2024 12:15

Your small house almost certainly will have a smaller carbon footprint than a much larger house, so you are actively helping the environment. Now that spring is here, if you want to work on the garden I would definitely work with what you've got - big slope? how about putting a giant slide in (set onto the ground? Your daughter and all her frineds will love you for it.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 14/03/2024 12:14

Sorry - am I misreading the original post? IIRC

  1. First, OP is in the privileged minority (40%) of the UK population that actually own their home
  2. Secondly - unless I misunderstand -it's a three bedroomed house. So all separate bedrooms (and one to spare?)
  3. Thirdly, OP has a conservatory
  4. Fourthly, OP has a garden - which even without anything dong to it, will hold a trampoline/whatever.

The only way she will be failing her child will be if the envy she has of her 'friend' (the friend she's not happy for) and general resentment is an attitude that permeates the household and is picket up by her child

RecycleMePlease · 14/03/2024 12:14

My kids have lived in everything from 3 story houses with multiple rooms we never even went in, to tiny flats where you had to pull a divider to get a bedroom out of view of the living room (we've moved around a lot)

We were happy in all of them. It's me that goes stir crazy not being able to have some peace, they just adapt to wherever we're living now - they're far more affected by everything else in their lives - friends, school, whether the local swimming pool/playground is decent etc.