Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP wants more money

464 replies

Itsnotbeeneasy · 18/02/2024 01:01

Trying to keep this as concise without losing the detail or drip feeding!!

4 kids in total - blended family. 2 each. I moved into DPs house 2.5 years ago

When I moved in I asked how much he would want in contribution each month - he was unsure so I asked for vague bill amounts (utilities and mortgage) each month and then added extra for me and my 2 kids being here, halved the total and that’s what I pay. This was half to mortgage and all utilities/bills. He was v.happy with the initial figure

Obvs as we all know bills have increased since so I have increased my payment each month slightly without him asking. Then - he let slip that I was paying more than he was per month. Bear in mind I’m paying half his mortgage.

DP is now asking for a higher contribution again but is flatly refusing to let me see bills for utilities to work out the fair figures stating that if I have any record of these then I would have a claim to his property - which as said is in his name - and instead wants me to pluck a figure out of the air that I would ‘be happy with’

I will add I own nothing - I’ve only just got myself out of debt, no property etc. If we split I’d be homeless and renting - no savings. He has told me time and time again that he has £150k+ of equity in his property and keeps throwing in that he could buy a small property and be mortgage free

I think this conversation is a knee jerk reaction to this months salary I revived which has been a lot higher than ‘normal’ - and I quote he said ‘if I was paid that salary I wouldn’t have any issues’ - I have just received £4.5k after tax this month - a lot higher than usual as I’m on commission. I earn between £2.5k-4k usually after tax each month and until now had been paying off debts - finally clear now (mortgage shortfall on my house and debts my ex husband put in my name - it’s been really shit)

Its all felt very grabby tonight - I told him when I moved in that I wanted to save enough to buy a rental property so my kids have an asset it at least have a decent savings account - at the point I can do that he is now asking for more money.

Please help. I dont want to use gaslit as a throwaway phrase but I need some opinions

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 18/02/2024 14:02

@Itsnotbeeneasy

I will also add DP drinks more than I would desire which is where much of his financial issue comes from. But right now - please help that this is not me

This is a dealbreaker for me, maybe it should be for you? If he 'drinks more than you desire' chances are that's because there is some effect of his drinking you don't like. Loses his temper? Passes out so you end up 'doing it all' for his kids as well as yours? Leaves you with all the kids so he can go drinking with his mate? If he drinks to excess in front of the kids, the optics aren't so great, either.

For anyone who has any knowledge of this - DP is emergency services and has said if he dies tomorrow I would have control of everything. He has no Will to state this. I’m so sick of feeling like I’m being gaslit

Unless your name is on 'everything' or you have Power of Attorney, then that's bullshit. As others have said, if he dies without a will everything goes to his minor children and probably with their mother as trustee. That'd be nice, wouldn't it? Having his ex-wife in charge of whether or not you can stay in the house?

As far as pulling some random figure out of thin air for your monthly contribution, you know he's hoping that you'll continue to 'overcompensate' your share. I'd offer something ridiculously low and tell him you're 'happy with that' because you need to save for your and your DCs future needs. Then when he balks at it, tell him that if he wants you to pay more, he'll need to show you proof of why you should pay more than you're 'happy with'.

What a wanker. BTW, do you feel the 'home duties' are split fairly? Do you find yourself being unpaid childcare for his children so he or his exW don't have to arrange paid childcare? Or so he can sit back and do nothing for his own children?

You need to think about what you're really getting out of this relationship.

nauticant · 18/02/2024 13:43

The law hasn't changed Barney60. An unmarried partner whose name isn't on the mortgage might be able to build up an equitable interest in the house for at least some share. However, there are certain things that must be in place to enable this and even if this means that someone is able to file a legal claim with a court, the claim might not succeed leaving them nothing and on the hook for legal costs, or the amount eventually secured could be lower than the legal costs.

https://www.silkfamilylaw.co.uk/blog/weve-just-separated-and-are-not-married-but-our-house-is-in-my-ex-partners-name-do-i-have-any-rights/

Notgood101 · 18/02/2024 13:42

Leave op

lookwhatyoudidthere · 18/02/2024 13:42

Itsnotbeeneasy · 18/02/2024 01:01

Trying to keep this as concise without losing the detail or drip feeding!!

4 kids in total - blended family. 2 each. I moved into DPs house 2.5 years ago

When I moved in I asked how much he would want in contribution each month - he was unsure so I asked for vague bill amounts (utilities and mortgage) each month and then added extra for me and my 2 kids being here, halved the total and that’s what I pay. This was half to mortgage and all utilities/bills. He was v.happy with the initial figure

Obvs as we all know bills have increased since so I have increased my payment each month slightly without him asking. Then - he let slip that I was paying more than he was per month. Bear in mind I’m paying half his mortgage.

DP is now asking for a higher contribution again but is flatly refusing to let me see bills for utilities to work out the fair figures stating that if I have any record of these then I would have a claim to his property - which as said is in his name - and instead wants me to pluck a figure out of the air that I would ‘be happy with’

I will add I own nothing - I’ve only just got myself out of debt, no property etc. If we split I’d be homeless and renting - no savings. He has told me time and time again that he has £150k+ of equity in his property and keeps throwing in that he could buy a small property and be mortgage free

I think this conversation is a knee jerk reaction to this months salary I revived which has been a lot higher than ‘normal’ - and I quote he said ‘if I was paid that salary I wouldn’t have any issues’ - I have just received £4.5k after tax this month - a lot higher than usual as I’m on commission. I earn between £2.5k-4k usually after tax each month and until now had been paying off debts - finally clear now (mortgage shortfall on my house and debts my ex husband put in my name - it’s been really shit)

Its all felt very grabby tonight - I told him when I moved in that I wanted to save enough to buy a rental property so my kids have an asset it at least have a decent savings account - at the point I can do that he is now asking for more money.

Please help. I dont want to use gaslit as a throwaway phrase but I need some opinions

You can probably find out things like: council tax (this is banded depending on house value), approx gas/water and electricity - just by knowing what supplier etc and then googling for averages based on the property size? 150k equity is not much in my view- so assuming the property is mortgaged up to the balls - is your partner trying to indicate that he'd ideally like to buy something cheaper? Also you haven't said when the mortgage renewal has/will take place, if for example that happened last year, you guys might be paying 6% interest- or some other daft figure? I'd say to him that I want to see paper copies of everything - not for you to keep obviously- to work out an equitable split. You don't have any claim to his property unless you are married.

QueenCamilla · 18/02/2024 13:25

Like FUCK would I be shagging someone and paying them "rent" for the privilege whilst having less say and rights over my living situation than any random tenant.
I have been thrown out by a partner with just a bin bag of clothes and my child as a result of him going into a rage of unfounded jealousy. I ended up in a refuge. At least he had politely refused my offers of financial contribution otherwise he'd be even more of a cunt.

I have my own house now and I would never charge any "rent" if I was to co-habit with someone. Halving the utilities and food would do (that's the only legally and morally correct way to go about it).

OP, give him the new figure - your usual payment minus the mortgage contribution.

Barney60 · 18/02/2024 13:25

Movinghouseatlast.
This isn't true in any way. Unless you are married or on the deeds or mortgage you have no interest in a property at all. Many women have been caught out believing this. Even after many years of cohabitation they can be out on their ear.

Oh have the laws changed then do you know?
Someone i know moved into his girlfriends house after 3.5 years they split he left went to a solicitor she had to pay him off as he proved he'd paid towards her mortgage and household bills, it was about 25 years ago though.
She told me this herself had to re-mortgage to pay him £8,000. Although i suspect the lawyers will of fought to take a hefty fee, no one ever gets rich bar solicitors in these situations.

C00k · 18/02/2024 13:24

@Barney16 no need to pay a solicitor for that. She'd be out.she has as many right to the boyfriends property as you or I do.

BuddyBuddyBumBum · 18/02/2024 13:21

Itsnotbeeneasy · 18/02/2024 01:29

The faulty sofa btw - all in my name!!! Was £4.5k. I paid the deposit and all subsequent payments despite him saying he would pay half. So now I’m currently waiting for the refund.

You’re being taken for an absolute mug.

Barney16 · 18/02/2024 13:18

He is taking advantage of you and will continue to do so until you stop him. You need a copy of each bill including the mortgage to work out what is half of the bills. I'm not legal but would suggest you ring a family solicitor for advice about the house and what would happen if he dies. The first 15 minutes is free. Stop buying big stuff and put every penny you can into a high interest saving account. And don't tell him how much you get paid. If he isn't open about finances why should you be.

Milkandnosugarplease · 18/02/2024 13:17

Oh joy, yet another woman subsidising and supporting a man with household chores and child support without any protection!

He has been ripping you off. You have zilch at the end of the relationship or if he dies. Great for him that he had enough money to buy another property.

I guess all the bills are solely in his name.

Time to get your ducks in row ….. ASAP

Movinghouseatlast · 18/02/2024 13:16

Notsandwiches · 18/02/2024 10:33

If you are contributing to his mortgage that entitles you to an equitable interest in the property. However, you'd have to go to court to quantify it. Don't just pay the bills and don't let him know you know. Try and get something in a text exchange to confirm the money you're paying is half the mortgage and bills.

This isn't true in any way. Unless you are married or on the deeds or mortgage you have no interest in a property at all. Many women have been caught out believing this. Even after many years of cohabitation they can be out on their ear.

Movinghouseatlast · 18/02/2024 13:13

Barney60 · 18/02/2024 11:56

Sorry to say this, if your partner dies you will be homeless his property will go to his nxt of kin, which will be unless hes stated otherwise will be his children.
Maybe go into trust until they are of age via his solicitors.

If you can PROVE you pay half of everything you do have a claim on his property if you split up.

Think i would be very concerned why hes checking up on all this legal stuff.
Stop telling him how much you are earning.

I also think get your savings whacked up save every penny you can, tell him youve had a few bad months, get your self sorted ASAP.

What would he say if you said ive had a really bad month and can not afford to pay what i usually pay only half?
His reply should tell you all you need to know!

This is a fallacy- she is not entitled to any share of the house unless she is named on the mortgage or on the deeds or married. Unmarried women in relationships have no rights over property they don't legally own.

ChangeAgain2 · 18/02/2024 13:12

You aren't entitled to anything. You don't even have lodgers rights. If he dies you'll get nothing. If he decided to throw you out then you have no rights.

I think he's being entirely unreasonable if you ate paying more monthly to the mortgage and utilities than him. He's not being transparent about the costs for a reason yet your being transparent about your earning.

Personally, I'd be looking at finding alternative accommodation and taking my sofa with me.

upthehills1 · 18/02/2024 13:06

My perspective is that all bills plus the interest payment of the mortgage should be split based on a fair agreement such as a percentage share dependent on take home salary.

The repayment of the mortgage is essentially his savings, and if you split he will keep it all and you’ll be high and dry.

I would suggest he pays the repayment part while you pay an equal amount into a savings account. Then you can either save for your own rental place if you wish, or with a view to eventually buying together or paying it into his mortgage if your name goes on the house.

This way, if you stay together.. great, you both have savings/equity to pursue your life together. If you split.. you both have paid fair living expenses while both having the opportunity to save

NotARealWookiie · 18/02/2024 13:04

HarrietStyles · 18/02/2024 11:35

“Hey partner, I’d really like for us to sit down and have a bit of a financial plan for the future. When I first moved in I was happy temporarily to pay half of the mortgage/bills etc so that we could all live together. Now that this is a permanent long-term relationship we need to have a chat about how to make this relationship mutually fair. Right now we are both paying into the living costs, but whilst you are building asset/equity, I am building nothing. You know this is obviously unfair for the long-term and leaves me very vulnerable. So let’s have a chat about what we can do going forwards - maybe you could rent out your house and we could buy a new house to live in together in both our names. Or maybe we could continue living in this house (with me paying less) and I buy a small property in my name as a BLT? What do you suggest?”

I think this is a steady and reasonable approach. There are already red flags but how he responds to this will tell you all you need to know about the future of your relationship.

Quitelikeit · 18/02/2024 13:04

How much are you paying him?

I would be paying around £500 a month to him and going half’s on the food costs.

Promise not to go after his house and definitely get on with saving for a deposit. He is clearly feeling hard done by even though you pay half of his mortgage!

Surely he shouldn’t profit from
you and nor you him.

FiresideDreamer · 18/02/2024 12:55

4.5k on a new sofa ?

Do you have any savings ?

Your partner may actually be mortgage free ?

You may be paying more than 100% of the bills ?

DO NOT PAY ANY EXTRA than you are already paying

Any further upgrades or repairs to the property, he needs to pay himself. This includes painting & decorating, gardening, electrical, white goods etc
This is his property, so these are his responsibility !

momonpurpose · 18/02/2024 12:50

Containerhome · 18/02/2024 01:16

I don't normally say this.... but I would start getting my ducks in a row. That's not a life OP. You have found out early enough what he is like.

This op. You have no claim. If something goes wrong you and your children are left with nothing. Get out and rent at least you will be in charge or the roof over your head. If you like continue to date him although this would be the end for me

Rainbow1901 · 18/02/2024 12:45

Itsnotbeeneasy · 18/02/2024 01:29

The faulty sofa btw - all in my name!!! Was £4.5k. I paid the deposit and all subsequent payments despite him saying he would pay half. So now I’m currently waiting for the refund.

So you deduct his share from your monthly payments until all is settled!! Or if further down the road you do split - you do own a sofa!!

Workhardcryharder · 18/02/2024 12:44

He isn’t being fair and treating you like a partner.

However you are paying his mortgage the same way I’m paying my landlords mortgage. You are paying to live there as you should. I don’t agree that this means you are morally entitled to a share of the property.

You shouldn’t be paying more than half of utilities though unless you have your children there more.

Movinghouseatlast · 18/02/2024 12:44

You absolutely have no claim on his house because you are not on the mortgage or deeds and you are not married. It doesn't matter if you pay half the mortgage. This is the shocking truth about being unmarried.

I would explain this to him and maybe show him something that proves this ( lots on internet) to make him understand.

However, if someone directly said to me, someone who is supposed to love me, that they don't want me to have any claim on their asset I would be off I'm afraid. Its such a bald statement, not qualified by anything.

If uou stay together you should draw up a legal agreement of who pays what.

FiresideDreamer · 18/02/2024 12:37

You paid for the sofa
Deduct that off your rent for the next few months
Why didn't he pay half of the sofa ?

Save up & move out

LetusandLoveit · 18/02/2024 12:35

If we split I’d be homeless and renting - no savings.

These two things aren't compatible @Itsnotbeeneasy

If you were to rent, you'd not be homeless.

Cherrysoup · 18/02/2024 12:35

You need to be married to get anything because currently his kids inherit if he dies. He needs to show you the bills, refusing but asking you to pay a random amount is obviously ridiculous. Any money you transfer needs to be referenced‘mortgage’, but that means nothing except for your records.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/02/2024 12:34

justasking111 · 18/02/2024 09:19

If @Itsnotbeeneasy was renting from him. She wouldn't have to cook, clean, wash, care for his two children. What's that worth?

Excellent point OP.

Give him a bill for childcare and housekeeping services.