Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found out man am dating was previously arrested

133 replies

wishingyouwell · 01/02/2024 19:32

He told me he was arrested due to false allegation of violence from ex partner. Said was released without charge. No way of finding out other side of story.
Would you continue relationship and hope for best or pull out? Early in relationship.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RavenSurvivor · 26/05/2024 20:33

There is a huge amount that needs doing re arrests for allegations.

A friend took his own life 2 years ago because of blatant false allegations.
A LARGE number of us KNEW he was innocent and even his own children from a previous marriage and their Mother contacted the investigating officer.

his most recent ex and her family hounded him to the grave.

yes we know a lot of men DO sexually assault but there is still that small percentage who don’t

we also discovered via extensive research that false accusers practically NEVER have any comeback and zero consequences.

for the benefit of EVERYONE the system needs an urgent review .

Theunamedcat · 26/05/2024 20:20

RavenSurvivor · 26/05/2024 10:58

if the man voluntarily told you and didn’t attempt to hide it then surely he thinks enough of you to trust you with this devastating allegation early on

all too often we’re quick to judge

he could simply have said nothing and that WOULD HAVE been very sad

talk to him, his friends and family.
unfortunately people DO make false allegations

to get get at someone, for attention or even financial compensation

it’s a slap in the face for real victims

Not at all my ex tells people all about his arrests but the embellishments are the key so he was arrested for SA on a minor (true) because her mom forced her to say it and I was found innocent (untrue) he was arrested for rape of his then fiance (true) she made it up because I was getting back with my ex wife and she was jealous about it and the charges were proved false (REALLY untrue) now it IS true that those arrests were NFA but he was never found innocent in fact in both cases he should have been found guilty for witness intimidation (or whatever its called) basically he is fucking scary dangerous person who gets away with a lot the only people to have success in court against him is the DVLA can't intimate them

Curiously the one where he told everyone including the police he was getting back with his ex wife no-one (including the police) actually thought to ask her if it was true they just proceed as if he is being truthful and don't check his story at all the one who made the allegations was a known alcoholic and a criminal though so not what you call a sympathetic victim in the eyes of the law basically they didn't care

RavenSurvivor · 26/05/2024 10:58

if the man voluntarily told you and didn’t attempt to hide it then surely he thinks enough of you to trust you with this devastating allegation early on

all too often we’re quick to judge

he could simply have said nothing and that WOULD HAVE been very sad

talk to him, his friends and family.
unfortunately people DO make false allegations

to get get at someone, for attention or even financial compensation

it’s a slap in the face for real victims

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/02/2024 23:04

Run

My ex got away with a serious SA. Violence in front of witnesses too.

There is a reason 96% of defendants in dv cases are male. Lack of a conviction does not mean innocent.

jannier · 02/02/2024 22:47

wishingyouwell · 01/02/2024 20:09

Everyone that knows him including colleagues sing his praises however I am aware no-one has the insight like a partner.
He doesn't trash talk his partner says he made mistakes etc and would do things differently going forward but was just looking for more insight about this arrest as v serious

The everyone thinks he's amazing is pretty common later on it turns to we couldn't believe he hit her until.....

Orangejuggler · 02/02/2024 20:56

wishingyouwell · 01/02/2024 20:09

Everyone that knows him including colleagues sing his praises however I am aware no-one has the insight like a partner.
He doesn't trash talk his partner says he made mistakes etc and would do things differently going forward but was just looking for more insight about this arrest as v serious

My ex was abusive ( still is). He was arrested and charges dropped.

He is the most nasty, vindictive person I’ve ever met.

Told everyone I made false allegations and his fan club believe him. 🙄

When we attended mediation the mediator suggested that he thought he was still in love with me- my nasty ex went on about what an amazing person I was ( though immediately before said I was unfit to parent, was questioning my sanity, threatening to take my kids away etc etc)

And I know some pps say that some women are just as bad. Yes- it is possible that she is lying and he is telling the truth.

But I’d say there was a 90% chance he was abusive.

I’d never take that risk having been through what I’ve been through.

Chimpandcheese · 02/02/2024 20:54

In the interests of balance, maybe he is innocent but he’s worried you might find out somehow so is being upfront with you? Do you trust your gut instinct and what it is saying to you? It’s right to be cautious, but maybe explore it more with him, and why he told you. If he has made you feel uncomfortable at all, lost his temper, belittled you etc then it might be best to ditch him.

wishingyouwell · 02/02/2024 20:42

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 02/02/2024 00:38

Please tell me that you are only dating, and that neither of you has moved in with the other ?
Please tell me that he does not have a key to your home ?!

Then just dump him politely by text, and delete / block. do not engage with any further communication.

Yes just dating, he was keen to move the relationship forward, I haven't been.

I will do the text thing when he has time off work. Today has been a slow fade I guess I haven't reached out at all etc.

As for the mental health I know what you all mean about manipulation but I can tell he has been depressed especially and have seen his medication.
Nevertheless as many of you say as sad as it is I'm not the one to help with this. I have tried to help him while dating but it isn't my profession either so I am not the best person to support with this anyhow.

OP posts:
wishingyouwell · 02/02/2024 20:32

ReadingSoManyThreads · 02/02/2024 00:51

Released without charge doesn't mean they didn't do it/were innocent.

My ex husband was extremely violent to me (I almost died), he was arrested. The DV support team were preparing me mentally for going to court but CPS dropped it for "not being in the public interest" to proceed, despite him admitting his violence towards me. I was his wife, I didn't matter, the public were safe, it was only his wife that he beat and strangled. Yes, I'm still bitter, having been left battling PTSD, whilst he remarried. No idea what his wife knows or doesn't know.

OP, I'd tread extremely carefully here. Would be better to end it now though, before you find out for sure he's lying/delusional.

Thank you and I'm very sorry to read that happened to you. Awful. I wish you strength in your recovery.

OP posts:
Littlegoth · 02/02/2024 11:41

PonyPatter44 · 01/02/2024 21:39

I don't know how I find them quite honestly

you don't find them. They are finding you. A wrong 'un can look at 10 women in a room and straightaway pick out the one giving off the "vulnerable " vibes. It's not victim-blaming to say this, although I know it could sound like it.

I would throw this one back. He's already lied to you and his story is changing subtly.

This is true. They prey on the vulnerable, and they’ve got an innate ability to spot vulnerability a mile away. It’s not victim blaming to say this. They start by showering you with affection, making you feel safe. Until they don’t.

PhoenixStarbeamer · 02/02/2024 02:31

Pull out. 100%%%%%%%

Lwrenn · 02/02/2024 01:04

Funny how most of the innocent men with unhinged crazy exes go on to beat their new partners within the first year.

Even if he's the exception to the rule don't wait around to find out. You're too important to be a statistic.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 02/02/2024 00:51

Released without charge doesn't mean they didn't do it/were innocent.

My ex husband was extremely violent to me (I almost died), he was arrested. The DV support team were preparing me mentally for going to court but CPS dropped it for "not being in the public interest" to proceed, despite him admitting his violence towards me. I was his wife, I didn't matter, the public were safe, it was only his wife that he beat and strangled. Yes, I'm still bitter, having been left battling PTSD, whilst he remarried. No idea what his wife knows or doesn't know.

OP, I'd tread extremely carefully here. Would be better to end it now though, before you find out for sure he's lying/delusional.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 02/02/2024 00:38

Please tell me that you are only dating, and that neither of you has moved in with the other ?
Please tell me that he does not have a key to your home ?!

Then just dump him politely by text, and delete / block. do not engage with any further communication.

NoOrdinaryMorning · 02/02/2024 00:29

Whilst I do think it's wise to walk away and I probably would myself, I do still wonder how awful it must be for the small amount of men out there who have been^^ falsely accused.
Forever doubted.
Meeting & falling in love with new partners, only to have them always dump him to be on the safe side because so many men lie......

JMSA · 02/02/2024 00:22

Ok, so just to play devil's advocate ...
A few years back, my best friend was arrested. She is a gentle, meek and lovely person who was married to a narcissistic abuser. Long story short, the police were called one night. He managed to convince them that she attacked him. Complete nonsense.
She spent a night in the cells but no charges were brought.
I've always respected the police, but this was a terrifying lesson in how they can still get it wrong.

Yep, chances are I wouldn't take the risk and dump him too. In fact, I know I would. But you just never truly know.

Aquamarine1029 · 02/02/2024 00:21

Please be smart enough to end this right now. Send a text saying you're no longer interested and block. Don't be yet another woman who ignored all the advice and red flags and then ends up a victim.

MCOut · 02/02/2024 00:14

Nope. There are many men in this world, this is not necessary. His mental health is not your problem for all you know he’s fine. Why would he tell you this especially if it was a non-issue if not to minimise?

Fionaville · 02/02/2024 00:14

In that case, I'd say that there's no smoke without fire.
I wouldn't continue the relationship.

manipulatrice · 02/02/2024 00:10

Right to ask, Claire's law. Do it. Most forces have an online submission form for it.

Missgemini · 01/02/2024 23:42

Please do not take the mental health thing into account. As everyone else has said, it’s ringing manipulation bells. Text him to end it and block. No room for negotiations.
Please be safe.

RosaMoline · 01/02/2024 23:25

@wishingyouwell

I could write the book on this.
Abusive alcoholic violent ex.
I had the stories on how he was the victim and his ex GFs were all psychos that attacked HIM.
His ex stopped him from seeing his kids when they were about 10. He was never able to give me a reasonable explanation for this. AFAIK, as adults they are not in contact with him still.
He also used depression/MH to manipulate me and use as an excuse for bad behaviour.
I hope you get out now. While you can.

Lysianthus · 01/02/2024 23:19

PeskyPotato · 01/02/2024 21:22

The way I see it, if you trust him not to hurt you, tell him you're doing Clare's law and see his reaction. If he has nothing to hide he won't care about you hearing all the details.

OP this is a really good idea. I get you want to give him the benefit of the doubt. This sorts it for you.

bombastix · 01/02/2024 23:15

I wouldn't give him the time of day. A text to say it was over, neutral and block.

Most men are very reluctant to reveal vulnerability. At the start of a relationship it can appear to be opening up, but it's actually a diversion so that your focus on helping not thinking; it engages you emotionally so you forget about the cold fact of arrest.

Such men are dangerous; this sort of mind game is part of the fun for them.

Al Wilson sang about the tender hearted woman with the snake half dead; she revives him with her care, he recovers and gleefully bites her, telling her she knew already what he was. Don't be fooled.

wishingyouwell · 01/02/2024 23:07

TheShellBeach · 01/02/2024 22:50

One of my daughters had a boyfriend who gave her the crazy ex story. She believed him.

Right up to the time he beat her black and blue.

I'm very sorry to read that.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread