Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
17
Thistlewoman · 23/08/2024 16:29

oOiluvfriendsOo · 08/01/2024 15:51

So sad what has happened to this poor dog......is it the first consequence of the ban, it certainly won't be the last .

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/man-targeted-vigilantes-after-dead-31822636

What's sad is that these flipping dogs even exist. The only good XLBully is a dead XLBully. I feel sorry for the neighbours of the vile person who rehomed the creature from England.

GrandTheftWalrus · 11/01/2024 15:56

Scotland are banning them now too

HoneyNuts · 11/01/2024 13:34

I would happily live in a world without dogs. I have had enough of bad owners not managing their dogs properly.

But goodness the cruelty shown towards these pets is just sickening. Breeding dogs who cannot walk or breathe 😫 Poisoning, stabbing and burning them. It make me sick.

There should be instant on the spot fines for these monstrous humans. Or throw them immediately in a cell for the night. These poor animals don’t deserve this.

SD1978 · 11/01/2024 11:44

@LaurieStrode - you had to have read down many comments, before your comment.....the title and opening post gave a pretty good indication of what the discussion was going to be. Maybe just hide posts with titles/ opening posts that you think you're going to be upset and offended over? Probably will make your day go a wee bit easier.

SomeCatFromJapan · 11/01/2024 11:21

Border collies haven't been responsible for any human fatalities from dog bites.
There is one case from 2014 when an Alaskan Malamute killed an unattended baby, a colle cross was present in the room and also euthanised.
So a very different picture to the growing list of fatalities from XL Bullies.

justaboutdonenow · 11/01/2024 10:16

The main differences I'm noticing between the border collies in the posted articles & XL bullies is that yes, they are injuring young children & not acceptable, but XLs are killing children, other peoples' pets & even grown men.
They're even killing the people who should be the ones a dog should love & trust the most- their owners.
Bully people need to stop pretending their dogs (collectively, as a 'breed') have some long, rich & wonderful history that needs preserving.
They are a newly created breed, bred by literally the dregs of the dog breeding world, marketed as a 'companion' but repeatedly demonstrating that they are pretty much the opposite of this.
Compare their 'work' to that of other emergent breeds such as silken windhounds, a project started in the 1980s which has resulted in a 'mini borzoi' that makes a lovely pet or sport dog, & they aren't making the papers.
If they truly wished to create a more biddable companion breed descending from the APBT the traits they'd select for would decreased dog aggression, general temperament & health.
Not size, muscle mass & fancy colours.
They'd not be outcrossing with molossers, literally the worst type if the goal is a friendly companion suitable for the average pet home.
Even then, the results would depend on a lot of time (most likely decades) & financial investment, thorough record keeping, networking with other breeders who share a common goal, health testing, temperament testing, maintaining contact with puppy buyers, & most importantly good dogs with excellent health, temperament & conformation for both foundation & infusion stock.
American bullies in any size have none of this care from their breeders so the result is an inbred, unhealthy, volatile breed that's no use as a pet, has no value as a working or sport dog so really has no reason to be continued.
And love them or loathe them, even actual APBTs (as opposed to generic bull breed mixes) have found a niche outside of their original purpose in their COO- as catch dogs, hog dogs & they excel at sports like weight pull.

SD1978 · 11/01/2024 03:42

The dog ate cannabis, and then was found dead. There is nothing in the article to say that a 'vigilante mob' took out the dog. Probably don't sell the dog you can't be fecked registering and insuring to someone for £400 who will then feed it drugs.....

Frequency · 11/01/2024 03:20

They want them for hare coursing and rabbiting, btw, coz hunting smaller animals with bigger animals is well 'ard Hmm

Frequency · 11/01/2024 03:16

@oakleaffy Those dogs aren't mine and the guy they do belong to is not the type of man anyone would snatch a dog from plus the child is usually with him and she bites

I do know people have offered him money for the sandy lurcher and his whippet. I assume the bull lurcher looked as daft as he actually was to the type of people who would stop someone in the street and offer them money for their pet.

The small black one below was mine and I was frequently offered money for her because she was small and agile. No one appeared off put by the fact she was scared of small furries including cats, rabbits and hares. Luckily no one tried to snatch her. We were followed home once. They only stopped following me after I called H to come and meet me after telling him what was going on.

Rehomed XL Bully, found dead in Glasgow......
Rehomed XL Bully, found dead in Glasgow......
oakleaffy · 11/01/2024 03:02

Frequency · 11/01/2024 02:14

@oakleaffy I can say with some degree of expertise that anyone who buys a lurcher or bull lurcher (the brindle one) for protection has clearly never met a lurcher.

The child is the only one of those animals I own and the only one who has ever shown any aggression

Lurchers are hopeless as guards. Good as hot water bottles though.
I had men throughout my Lurcher's life try to physically take her from me - she was like ''😟'' -for some reason they really wanted her, over many years- {she was spayed so zero use for breeding} ..even in the least couple of weeks of her life a lorry pulled up ''How much for the dog, love?'...I said she was ill {about 12, osteosarcoma} but he said ''I'll get a litter out of her first'' {pic as a younger dog}

{...at TWELVE?..just shows how they don't give a shit about the dogs}

Even now, the sound of a Toyota Pickup truck turns my stomach.

My friend has a Bull Lurcher from Dog's trust..

Rehomed XL Bully, found dead in Glasgow......
oakleaffy · 11/01/2024 02:39

SomeCatFromJapan · 10/01/2024 22:09

@oakleaffy I think it was you who recommended that Panorama episode to me? Just watched it and the Jack Lis case is heartbreaking. His poor, poor mother. I can't even imagine what she went through and still goes through.

It was Jack Lis's savage death that made me 'wake up' to the brutality of these large Pit Bull crosses, and in UK especially how hideously inbred they are.

Mia Derouen's death was so traumatic that hardened American coppers needed counselling.
That dog was related to the one that slaughtered Jack Lis.

Once these XL's turn, they are just too powerful for anyone to stop them.

Other, smaller dog breeds have killed babies and toddlers, but Pits and Pit crosses far outweigh the deaths and serious injuries to children and adults worldwide .

Here is the link again, if people haven't seen the programme.
So cruel to the dogs as well {appalling conformation in some of them}.

BBC1 Panorama, Dogs, Dealers & Organised Crime 23Jan23

BBC1_ Panorama, Dogs, Dealers & Organised Crime 23Jan23Vanessa Waddon: Founder & Senior Head of Operations at Hope Rescue, Llanharan, Waleshttps://www.hopere...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1g1v_WfsyMc

Frequency · 11/01/2024 02:14

@oakleaffy I can say with some degree of expertise that anyone who buys a lurcher or bull lurcher (the brindle one) for protection has clearly never met a lurcher.

The child is the only one of those animals I own and the only one who has ever shown any aggression

LuvSmallDogs · 11/01/2024 01:00

No animal should be abused, but I don't find that view and the view that the ban is good incompatible.

Assuming the original owners couldn't keep the rehomed-and-abused dogs due to not being able to afford housing that would allow them etc, then they could have rehomed the dogs as soon as the ban was warned of months ago. They could have had the dogs euthanised, which would have been a kinder end.

People who are scared of these dogs and want them banned, are not the ones shipping them off to unknown circumstances at the last minute. They're not the ones trading them around, breeding and beating them.

These animals have been irresponsibly bred from the start over here and almost all I've seen have had their ears illegally mutilated - who has funded those practises? The people who apparently "love" them. Just like the people who "loved" french and british bulldogs when they were en vogue were funding the extremely contorted bodies that made their "beloved" pets struggle to function and sometimes require surgery to breathe.

I don't like frenchies or XLs, but I've never harmed one the way the people who "love" them do.

oakleaffy · 11/01/2024 00:33

YeOldeGreyhound · 11/01/2024 00:07

Yes, this!
Long dogs (lurchers, greyhounds etc), are well known amongst the owners that know them that "bitey face" is a thing.... as is the sight hound "smile"..... they lift their lips up and give a big grin.... no aggression at all.

@Frequency Lurchers were very popular amongst beggars/ Squatters/ homeless and bus dwellers - many of whom were drug users
1990's.

Lurchers for some reason seemed to be the 'Dog of choice' at least in the South West.

@YeOldeGreyhound First time I witnessed 'Bitey Face' I was surprised- {no internet back then} - I didn't even know it was a 'thing!'..I heard a commotion and clashing teeth, but the hounds seemed to be liking it..so I let them carry on.

It was called 'Mouth sparring' by some people{How did we manage without the internet!?}
Also grabbing mouthfuls of cheek and ear- and mock ''going for the neck''
But no one gets hurt, it's just posturing with a very loose body language, and no more than a few grammes of pressure behind the 'bite'

Some Greyhounds collect for a dog charity locally, and they are very peaceful boys.

YeOldeGreyhound · 11/01/2024 00:07

oakleaffy · 11/01/2024 00:03

Re fashion for 'Lurchers'...they could {and do} do a thing called 'Bitey face'..it looks menacing, sounds menacing, but is entirely harmless.
Kind of like ''Mouth wrestling '' , often accompanied by an EEEeeeeeeEEEEEEEiiiiiiiEEEEEEEEiiiiiiieeee sound.
Whippets do it too.

Pic from online of 'Bitey face' Edit...dog on left looks like a Staffie X

Edited

Yes, this!
Long dogs (lurchers, greyhounds etc), are well known amongst the owners that know them that "bitey face" is a thing.... as is the sight hound "smile"..... they lift their lips up and give a big grin.... no aggression at all.

oakleaffy · 11/01/2024 00:03

Re fashion for 'Lurchers'...they could {and do} do a thing called 'Bitey face'..it looks menacing, sounds menacing, but is entirely harmless.
Kind of like ''Mouth wrestling '' , often accompanied by an EEEeeeeeeEEEEEEEiiiiiiiEEEEEEEEiiiiiiieeee sound.
Whippets do it too.

Pic from online of 'Bitey face' Edit...dog on left looks like a Staffie X

Rehomed XL Bully, found dead in Glasgow......
oakleaffy · 10/01/2024 23:55

mapleriver · 10/01/2024 22:04

Increase in attacks, but not in deaths. There are no wolf hybrid/husky death increases apart from infants and it does not reflect the increase in ownership as it should. Likewise for lurchers, lurchers got very popular among a type around a decade ago, there are no deaths by them. It's 100% the breed.

I remember amongst the homeless and Bus dweller populations, 1990's especially, Lurchers 'dogs on a string' were massively popular.
There was some nonsense around that the government paid the owners £7 a week per dog to keep them.. that was enough to keep a single Lurcher in food back then, but I don't think the dole paid for people's dogs.

They were almost always gentle shy dogs as well.

Then the 'Bull' type became popular. {Staffies}..and then the really large mauler types.
Dogs definitely seem to come in 'Fashions'.

Frequency · 10/01/2024 23:24

Lurchers became popular with drug dealers and criminals? Really?

I've known them have a rise in popularity in hare coursing but not as protection/status dogs.

Either way, if the aim of BSL was to reduce the number of people killed by dogs, then it has failed. It failed in 1993 in the UK, it has failed in every other country which has tried it and there is no evidence to suggest that ammending it again will have different result.

@LessonsLearnedInLife A lot of the sources I use I'm getting from essays I wrote for Uni. I no longer have access to the Uni's scientific library but the source for education reducing dog bites I have down as When dogs bite: what you don't know can kill dogs. DVM Newsmagazine 1998, Overall, K.

Maybe one of the vets on here still has access to this article?

I believe the article focused on educating children in dog behaviour rather than breeders but I do agree we need tighter controls around the breeding of all domestic/companion animals.

I also, personally believe that tighter controls on breeding would reduce dog attacks but my interest when I was studying was more focused on BSL and the impact breed has on aggression so most of my sources relate to that rather than breeding.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 10/01/2024 23:02

mapleriver · 10/01/2024 21:22

@Frequency They're not bull breeds but molossers that haven't been crippled into not being able to move, which makes them dangerous. All you have to do is look at the list of fatality by dog to see it IS the breed that makes a dog dangerous. From 1993 onwards, they are all molosser or bull breeds excluding a man who died of infection from a spaniel bite, one doberman, two gsds and 3 babies killed by 3 varying breeds. Excluding the infant deaths which are tragic MOST dog fatalities in the UK are caused by dogs who are known man work breeds, molossers or bull breeds. There are no poodles, no herding dogs, no sighthounds, no companion breeds. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1288786/Familys-border-collie-leaps-car-mauls-baby.html

Just one of many incidents of border collie attacks.

Family's border collie leaps into car and mauls baby, 7 months, who nearly loses a leg

William Jaundrell's leg was almost torn off when border collie Bill attacked him on the driveway of his grandparents' farm.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1288786/Familys-border-collie-leaps-car-mauls-baby.html

LessonsLearnedInLife · 10/01/2024 22:15

SomeCatFromJapan · 10/01/2024 22:09

@oakleaffy I think it was you who recommended that Panorama episode to me? Just watched it and the Jack Lis case is heartbreaking. His poor, poor mother. I can't even imagine what she went through and still goes through.

I mentioned it earlier in the thread. It’s an awful watch.

SomeCatFromJapan · 10/01/2024 22:09

@oakleaffy I think it was you who recommended that Panorama episode to me? Just watched it and the Jack Lis case is heartbreaking. His poor, poor mother. I can't even imagine what she went through and still goes through.

mapleriver · 10/01/2024 22:04

Frequency · 10/01/2024 21:31

Is it breed or is it the type of owner those large breeds attract?

There is a pattern, if you look closely enough. In the early 80's it was Rotts, GSDs and Dobermans, in the late 80's/early 90's it moved to bull breeds, in the 2010's there was a brief spike in attacks by northern/spitz type breeds as people attempted to create "direwolves" as seen in GoT, lockdown saw a move towards XL bully types.

Increase in attacks, but not in deaths. There are no wolf hybrid/husky death increases apart from infants and it does not reflect the increase in ownership as it should. Likewise for lurchers, lurchers got very popular among a type around a decade ago, there are no deaths by them. It's 100% the breed.

LessonsLearnedInLife · 10/01/2024 21:50

Some countries, counties and states have managed to put measures in place which have reduced the number of bites/fatalities. All of these sucessful measures have a greater emphasis on responsible ownerhsip than on breed. Studies have shown that education can reduce dog bites by 80%, whereas banning breeds has been shown to reduce dog bites by precisely fuckall.

Could you link these studies please? I’d be interested to see what measures counties in the UK have put in place that have managed to reduce the number of fatalities and dog bites and what agencies were involved in these initiatives. If you could also link the studies in how to educate hapless breeders I’d appreciate it.

Given the number of XL bullies recently transported to Scotland without home checks I think the Scottish Government should take note of these studies already carried out of they’re effective.

Frequency · 10/01/2024 21:31

Is it breed or is it the type of owner those large breeds attract?

There is a pattern, if you look closely enough. In the early 80's it was Rotts, GSDs and Dobermans, in the late 80's/early 90's it moved to bull breeds, in the 2010's there was a brief spike in attacks by northern/spitz type breeds as people attempted to create "direwolves" as seen in GoT, lockdown saw a move towards XL bully types.

Swipe left for the next trending thread