Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Council opposed our planning application

30 replies

AlbatrosStrike · 12/12/2023 20:21

We submitted a planning application and received permission for a small single storey rear extension (standard extension on a 90s housing estate, would fall under permitted development but we’re making some other small changes so put the whole lot on one application). One of the neighbours objected (as is their right) but with no real basis in terms of planning.

My issue is that when I checked the planning department website I saw two more comments from the parish council and a local society affiliated with the council. The language used was very similar to the neighbour’s and the two comments were almost identical. It is highly unusual for the council to object to minor householder applications, and the society was not even consulted in the planning process. So someone went out of their way to find our application and comment on it. I suspect this is due to the neighbour.

I was very upset when I saw that the council comments. For the parish council to go after us in this way seems to me completely outrageous. Even the planning officer noted in the decision report that their objection had no basis in planning law.

I want to write to our local councillor (politely) to find out why the council had opposed our extension. However, my dh is completely against it as he thinks it would put a target on our backs. He says we got planning permission so I should just forget about it. It ended with a row as dh thinks I’m stirring the pot unnecessarily.

However, it doesn’t sit right with me that someone used their position on the parish council to try to help their mate against us. Obviously I wouldn’t make any accusations without proof, but AIBU to write to the council about this?

OP posts:
moaningstoatpoacher · 12/12/2023 20:38

No you would absolutely not be unreasonable to write and ask about this - they're your parish council too. Maybe the person who objected wrote to them, and that was the only voice they heard about the application. Maybe the objector turned up at a meeting and spoke about why they were against your application.

Its a good idea to go to a parish council meeting if your application is being discussed there - your council will hold public meetings where they discuss all applications. Then you can have your voice heard too. As for listening to their mates - your parish council is made up of volunteers, people just like you in your community, and they should make decisions based on proper planning law, but they're also allowed to have views about things, which might also be those of their mates. The best way to deal with this kind of nepotism... join the council yourself!

CalpolOnToast · 12/12/2023 20:38

What does it say in the parish council minutes?
No one councillor is supposed to make decisions on what the PC will support or not on their own.

If they've put in comments with no material basis all they've done is make themselves look foolish to the planning authority who will take less notice of them next time.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 12/12/2023 20:34

Just forget about it. You got the permission. I could have written and objected to your permission, anyone has that right, they don't have to live right next to you.

LIZS · 12/12/2023 20:32

Parish Council comments carry no more weight than any individuals and it is entirely possible that a parish councillor is on the other body. You don't have to be a consultee to comment. Has the planning authority determined it yet?

Soontobe60 · 12/12/2023 20:30

Honestly, why does it matter? Everyone is entitled to oppose a planning application and many do so as a group so their objections may look the same. Maybe your neighbours sister in law is shagging someone on the parish council so they asked them to do a favour and object.

Swipe left for the next trending thread