Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be having horrendous mum guilt 12 years later

36 replies

SolarLightsDoNotWork · 27/11/2023 08:15

Oh help,
I'm feeling horrendous about myself.
My darling boy, as a newborn baby, cried and cried and cried all through the nights. Every night, non stop, for 12 months.
I had him in his moses basket next to my bed. I would cuddle him and try to comfort him until he fell back asleep. Sometimes he'd feed from me, sometimes not. Then I'd place him back in his moses basket, he'd sleep for an absolute maximum of 15 - 20 mins and then he'd wake up crying/screaming again and wouldn’t stop for 2 or 3 hours despite me comforting him. Eventually he'd fall asleep for 15 - 20 mins and then wake up and re-start crying/screaming for hours again. This would go on all night long. Every night.
DH moved into spare room and left me to get on with it because he was working but I had a year off work for mat leave.
My next door neighbour banged on my front door one night at 3am and started arguing at me about how cruel I was to let my baby cry all night. I answered the door to her with my baby in my arms, he was crying loudly as I was holding him.
I talked to Midwives, Health Visitors and was referred to a sleeping clinic, and I tried all the different interventions suggested, but nothing helped.
At the time, I kept on thinking that my baby needed to co-sleep with me. It felt to me that he was settled and happy whilst physically in contact with me at night, and distressed when he was separated by being in his moses basket.
But I was a first time mum, I was exhausted, I'd had a very traumatic emergency birth with him where doctors and midwives were running round the room shouting out that we were going to lose him if we didn't get him out of me within 2 minutes, he wasn't breathing when he came out, I couldn't hold him because he was taken away for emergency intervention for his breathing, and I carried the trauma and stress from his birth for months afterwards, if I'm being honest it's still there a bit all this time later. No-one at the hospital or afterwards ever talked to me about the trauma I'd been through. So anyway I was terrified of having him in my bed next to me as a little baby. I had a big, deep, squashy, heavy mattress and I was scared of him rolling over in case his tiny nose and mouth went into the mattress and stopped his air entry. I'm a really, really heavy sleeper at the best of times, and the more tired I was getting, the more heavily I was sleeping in those 15 - 20 mins sections in between him waking up crying for another 2 hours. So I was scared that I wouldn't wake up if he rolled over, or that I wouldn't hear if his breathing pattern changed. And I was scared that I might roll into him if he was on the mattress next to me. So I kept him in his basket.
As he grew bigger, we set up a big wooden cot right next to my bed, one of those cots that converts to a toddler bed later on. It was physically touching the side of my bed, and I dropped the side guard so that I could put my arm across and put my hand on him to settle him when needed. But the crying and screaming all night carried on, doing the same cycles as I've described above. Looking back, my health visitor kind of gave up on me. I remember requesting another visit from her and I showed her a log I'd been keeping of how many times he was waking and crying every night, by now he was 10 months old and not sleeping for more than 15 mins at a time before another 3 hours of screaming.
I still didn't co-sleep.
I thought about it a lot, but my HV advised against it and my best friend, a mid-wife, lectured me long and hard against it multiple times.
So I kept him in his cot next to my bed.
And spent a year without sleeping through the night.
I was exhausted each and every day.
I should add at this point that during the day times he was a happy, smiling, laughing baby who brought me so much joy and love and happiness that this carried me through the exhaustion. He literally never cried in the day, he was so happy and content every day, so many people would comment all the time on what a contented and happy baby he was! He only cried and screamed at night.
At 12 months old, I said to my DH "I'm going back to work in a few weeks and if I can't sleep before a day at work I won't be able to function ".
DH said "OK I'll sleep with him then, you sleep in the spare room".
Next morning, DH said "He slept all night long. He started crying in his cot at 9pm so I put him in bed with me, we laid next to each other and both slept soundly all night! He didn't wake up once all night, and woke up smiling!".
And he co-slept every night after that and slept through whilst sleeping next to us.
Fast forward 10 years and he's been diagnosed with Sensory Processing Disorder.
I'm on a constant learning journey with him about this.
But now he's old enough to articulate himself, he has told me that he physically needs to sleep right next to me or DH, that it helps him regulate his senses, that he cant sleep if he sleeps on his own.
He's such a lovely boy, who struggles with SPD.
Why did I force him through a gruelling year of intense distress and upset every night for the first 12 months of his life? Why? Why didn't I listen to my instinct which was telling me he needed to co-sleep? Which he himself can now tell me? Why did I insist on having him in his basket and cot, when actually all that crying and screaming was telling me that he hated it?
He suffers from anxiety now. I've been told it's part of his SPD. But I think it stems from 12 months of being made to feel anxious every night time by being placed in a different sleeping space from where he actually wanted to be.
But I was so tired, I couldn't think clearly, and I had so many people around me telling me not to co-sleep.....and I listened to them all.
I am carrying this guilt like a heavy burden in my chest, and it's horrible 😞.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Helar · 24/05/2024 09:33

You made the best decision you could with the information you had at the time.

dogmama · 24/05/2024 08:10

That guilt sounds intense but remember he was happy during the day so you didn't traumatised him.. little kids brains are plastic and heal quickly so even if he was stressed he would have 'healed' so to speak soon after. We have no idea what we are doing as ftm. I bet this experience made you trust your instincts since, so you have learnt to trust yourself from this I'm sure! Forgiving yourself (even though there is NOTHING to forgive from an outsiders perspective) is an active practice but you can do this! You can live a guilt free life and be in the here and now.. good luck

MsCactus · 20/05/2024 22:48

I don't understand why you feel guilty? I'm also a deep sleeper and no way would I cosleep with my DC. It's too dangerous.

You absolutely did the right thing here. Nothing to feel guilty about

SolarLightsDoNotWork · 27/11/2023 18:50

Thank you to all of you......you've all been so lovely with your replies, thank you😌.
I'm just sitting with a cup of tea reading through, and taking all of your advice on board.
It's been very comforting, thank you.🙏

OP posts:
DodoNest · 27/11/2023 16:17

All the official advice I got (baby 9 months old now) was so so against co-sleeping and the increased risks of SIDs. I have never co-slept because of this as if anything did happen I would never forgive myself given all the advice despite wanting to occasionally on a bad night. Don't be too hard on yourself OP, you followed the advice of medical professionals which is all you can do really ❤️

UnbeatenMum · 27/11/2023 13:04

You did your best for him at the time with the information you had available and there is a chance that that may have saved his life. His anxiety could be due to lots of factors. With a diagnosis of SPD has he been assessed for autism too? As if he does have any autistic traits there could be other factors contributing to his anxiety as well as sensory issues.

Goldbar · 27/11/2023 12:59

I don't want to minimise what you went through, it sound horrendous. But some babies cry a lot for lots of different reasons and are very difficult to comfort. You got through it and, most importantly, you kept your baby safe.

There are a lot of babies who have less than optimal starts in life. For example, all those little ones who spend weeks/months in NICU with limited touch and contact compared to other babies. That is unfortunately what is best for them and all those caring for them try their best to give them the touch/contact they need, within the confines of what is safe for them. You did the same for your baby. In your case, there were very strong reasons why co-sleeping was not safe with a tiny baby. With a 1 year old, the risk is clearly much less and you could give him that closeness and comfort without risking his safety to the same degree.

pikkumyy77 · 27/11/2023 12:48

F

DoAWheelie · 27/11/2023 12:45

You kept him alive that first year. Once he was old enough that co-sleeping wasn't as big a risk you did it and helped him. But the risk-reward ratio was skewed way too far into the risk side of things that first year.

myotherkidisacassowary · 27/11/2023 12:43

You made the best decision you could at the time, in incredibly difficult circumstances.

I also don’t think you made the wrong decision - sleeping with a small baby on a squashy mattress when you were a heavy sleeper wouldn’t have been safe. Co-sleeping can be done in a way which reduces the risk but in the situation you were in you did what you needed to to keep your baby safe.

You are a good mum. Your son is safe and well looked after. You have nothing to feel guilty about.

LuluBlakey1 · 27/11/2023 12:40

You sound like a lovely mum who did everything you could to safely help your baby.

I could be completely wrong here - I don't understand what SPD is- but could what your son says about needing to sleep right next to you and DH not be because he did co-sleep eventually, for however long, and then, presumably, slept alone as he grew up, rather than because he didn't for the first year?

It isn't your fault. We are all complex beings who suffer different things and who react differently to what happens to us. You were next to him, holding him for hours and he was still crying- it wasn't because you weren't there.

StopStartStop · 27/11/2023 12:40

Why did I force him through a gruelling year of intense distress and upset every night for the first 12 months of his life?

Because you were conned by Western society to thinking not sleeping with your baby was the healthy and righteous thing to do. You know better now. it's not just neurodivergents like my family and your SPD ds who need to sleep close, it's everyone.

The con (and I don't know who it benefits, really. Manufacturers of sleep aids for babies. Fathers who want mothers available for sex constantly. I don't know) is at societal level and you really mustn't blame yourself for not seeing through it.

Thank you for sharing your experience. I hope young/new mums read it and understand.

wingardiumleviosar · 27/11/2023 12:33

OP how lovely that he can explain what he needs to you now and you are accommodating this - some parents would say that they need their own space at night and he'd just have to get on with it! I would say forgive yourself but there is nothing to forgive here- you were scared that you would hurt him or worse and he loves and trusts you

Waxdrip · 27/11/2023 12:30

You did the right thing and protected his safety even though it was hard. That's what good parents do. If you are a deep sleeper and exhausted it would not have been safe.

SorenLorensonsInvisibleFriend · 27/11/2023 12:24

Echoing the posts before me, to be very blunt, if you'd coslept it may have killed him. That would be mum guilt you truly wouldn't be able to recover from and a life that would never have the chance to progress and improve.

You made the best choices you could in the situation you were in with as much advice and help as you could get. You did do and are doing your absolute best. It's clear. Let go of the past and keep doing your absolute best with what's happening now. You can't change the past but you can feel stronger facing the future without weighing yourself down. All best wishes to you and please be gentle with yourself.

Nineteendays · 27/11/2023 12:21

I still think you did the right thing. You were absolutely exhausted and he was a tiny baby- it could well have been dangerous. You made your choice because you wanted to keep him safe- you have nothing at all to feel guilty for. You sound like a wonderful mum

MissHavershamReturns · 27/11/2023 12:21

Dearest op, I’m sending you love and understanding and I would invite you to send this to yourself, from you too. I have a VERY similar son. He’s still very very anxious even though I co slept with him every night until he was almost 4.

You did NOT let him down. He was there with you, could hear you and knew you loved him.

Olika · 27/11/2023 12:18

You did your best at the time with the knowledge and information you had.

DuploTrain · 27/11/2023 12:06

I think you still sound traumatised from a difficult birth and difficult first year.
Even though it was a long time ago I think it would be worth trying to have some counselling, as it hasn’t resolved itself over the years.

You didn’t do anything wrong though.

Velvian · 27/11/2023 11:59

You poor thing. Be kinder to yourself. You were desperately trying to keep your son alive and safe. I had a similar thing with my DD and baby led weaning. I just knew it was wrong for her, but allowed myself to be swayed by the insistence of the HV. She choked and it was utterly terrifying. Luckily I managed to clear the blockage, but it was awful.

My DD also has some sensory issues and ASD.

Dogsitterwoes · 27/11/2023 11:35

I'm sorry you were left with no support at the time.

In your circumstances, heavy sleeper, soft mattress, his life would have been in danger if you'd co slept with him as a baby.

Quickquestion10 · 27/11/2023 11:11

You're clearly an exceptional mum and you wouldn't be worrying about this if you weren't such a devoted mum.

I think you need to be kind to yourself and let this go. It will be in your son's interests as well because it doesn't help him for you to carry inappropriate guilt.

You did absolutely everything you could.

I think counselling is in order to help you process what has happened.

I do not for one moment think your son's anxiety is caused by the experience you describe.

Just for the record, we all have things we would have done differently and sometimes they bother us. You're not alone. It's part of being a diligent parent.

DisappearingGirl · 27/11/2023 11:11

You know OP some of the "research" on attachment, letting babies cry etc really makes me angry. For a lot of it they have taken research on poor babies/children in Romanian orphanages etc where they genuinely have been neglected, and then applied it to babies in loving homes who sometimes cried. Leading to immense mum guilt and absolutely knackered parents.

Loads of babies cry a lot. Some have reflux, some just can't get themselves to sleep. My DD as a baby would not nap and at bedtime would cry and cry, whether you held her or not, as she was beyond tired. Eventually we had to do some controlled crying at nap time and bedtime. She was just a baby that found it hard to settle. But she learned eventually.

You said yourself your boy was a happy baby and obviously loved and has a good attachment with you. I think it's very unlikely he has been traumatised from being a baby that happened to cry a lot.

geordio · 27/11/2023 11:00

He would have had SPD whatever you did when he was a newborn. You didn't cause it, you have no need to feel responsible or guilty. You have done, and continue to do, the very best you can - in fact I would say you went above and beyond by keeping him by your bed for a whole year. You are a great Mum, well done.

NewAgain123 · 27/11/2023 10:56

❤