Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child hitting my child at school

220 replies

ShepherdMoons · 16/11/2023 19:49

Youngest dd has two new children in her class. Both have ASD and should be in specialist provision but the school has a new unit and is part of a new programme to help children with special needs be in a mainstream classroom. They spend an hour in the unit each day and then they are in the classroom for the day.

I totally appreciate that both children have many challenges and it must be very hard for them too but my child is coming home each day saying that X has hit her hard on her back, been kicked, pushed. Each day I have been to the teacher as my child is getting more distressed and frightened. The teacher has been putting more measures in place to help the boys but I have also a meeting with the Head tomorrow to voice my concerns.

Today one of the boys kicked the dinner lady and will spend time in the unit for this but then he will inevitably be back in the classroom next week. This is also disruptive to the children learning as there is more noise and general disruption due to them struggling to concentrate. AIBU to consider moving my dd out of this school?

OP posts:
ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 16/11/2023 20:55

ShepherdMoons · 16/11/2023 20:13

@Neodymium we have also considered a private school as it seems to be more common in state schools to have little support and more children will needs. It's hard on everyone as the teachers are clearly struggling to cope, the poor dinnerladies are scared too. The dinner lady at dd's school was really (understandably) upset by what happened in the playground.

Could you maybe try sounding less insulting towards kids with SEN?

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:55

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:46

OP said The dinner lady at dd's school was really (understandably) upset by what happened in the playground. the OP also seems to know the child’s disability, that his support involves an absent TA and a unit, and when he is “punished” and how often he is in and out of class. Disabled people have a right to privacy, he presumably can’t attend school without this support and it definitely shouldn’t be common knowledge in the playground.

All that said repeatedly insisting on your child’s safety will help him get more support and help her have a more peaceful school experience.

Not sure why you would presume the staff member would be talking about it and not the OPs child? Or the child’s mother who was openly laughing about his violence in public…

x2boys · 16/11/2023 20:54

Pixiedust49 · 16/11/2023 19:56

I’m in Wales so could be different but inclusion policy means that all children are in mainstream education here. Therefore all schools will be similar.

All children???
Thankfully no it's not the same in England I have a severely autistic non verbal.13 year old
Who.has always Been a special school I can't imagine how it would benefit him.at all.to.be in mainstream , Op, you need to ask the school.what they are doing to safeguard your child concentrate on how she us being let down.

Conkersinautumn · 16/11/2023 20:52

I work as a midday supervisor and no, it's not at all.appropriate to discuss incidents that happen at school outside school staff. As for being kicked etc, it's a very regular occurrence, not just by students, parents can be very violent too.

greengreengrass25 · 16/11/2023 20:51

Lucky schools

Pixiedust49 · 16/11/2023 20:51

Ladychatterly86 · 16/11/2023 20:47

It isn’t right that your daughter is in this position. I would write to your MP outlining your concerns. There is a reason that there is an Education crisis. The crisis is real and the government are aware and should be held accountable . Schools and school staff are trying their best in very difficult contexts. Unfortunately, change will not happen unless parents and communities rally behind schools. As a mother to a child about to start school and as a teacher, it breaks my heart to know that this situation is not isolated and is very much the norm.

Absolutely! Completely agree

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:48

Private school have a lot of neurodiverse children especially in early primary.

Ladychatterly86 · 16/11/2023 20:47

It isn’t right that your daughter is in this position. I would write to your MP outlining your concerns. There is a reason that there is an Education crisis. The crisis is real and the government are aware and should be held accountable . Schools and school staff are trying their best in very difficult contexts. Unfortunately, change will not happen unless parents and communities rally behind schools. As a mother to a child about to start school and as a teacher, it breaks my heart to know that this situation is not isolated and is very much the norm.

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:46

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:38

I think you want to try reading that again

It’s the boys mother who’s ‘gossiping’ about the attack, laughing and joking about it to the OP, not the poor dinner lady who’s been attacked by a violent child!

OP said The dinner lady at dd's school was really (understandably) upset by what happened in the playground. the OP also seems to know the child’s disability, that his support involves an absent TA and a unit, and when he is “punished” and how often he is in and out of class. Disabled people have a right to privacy, he presumably can’t attend school without this support and it definitely shouldn’t be common knowledge in the playground.

All that said repeatedly insisting on your child’s safety will help him get more support and help her have a more peaceful school experience.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 16/11/2023 20:44

Lavinia56 · 16/11/2023 20:38

If you can afford private then please move her. You will be a paying customer there, and private schools can't afford to tolerate that sort of behaviour for fear of losing pupils.
Any really badly behaved children are managed out. (This happened in my granddaughter's school).

Lovely. All of us poor people will just have to suck up having those kids in our schools.

Fantasyanswer · 16/11/2023 20:39

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:29

Are you the boys mother? The poor woman was attacked at work and you’re trying to victim blame her, disgusting.

That’s not victim blaming. She’s not saying she is responsible for being attacked.

Lavinia56 · 16/11/2023 20:38

If you can afford private then please move her. You will be a paying customer there, and private schools can't afford to tolerate that sort of behaviour for fear of losing pupils.
Any really badly behaved children are managed out. (This happened in my granddaughter's school).

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:38

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:34

Because she shouldn’t be naming children and gossiping about them to other parents.

I think you want to try reading that again

It’s the boys mother who’s ‘gossiping’ about the attack, laughing and joking about it to the OP, not the poor dinner lady who’s been attacked by a violent child!

ginandtonicwithlimes · 16/11/2023 20:38

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:26

Disabled children ARE mainstream children, part of society, part of life.

Many can't cope with mainstream school though. Cruel to put them in mainstream school.

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:34

Because she shouldn’t be naming children and gossiping about them to other parents.

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:33

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:31

No I’m not but I do understand confidentiality as does ANYONE working in school

Sure….and how exactly do you think she’s broken confidentiality in this scenario?

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:31

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:29

Are you the boys mother? The poor woman was attacked at work and you’re trying to victim blame her, disgusting.

No I’m not but I do understand confidentiality as does ANYONE working in school

Fantasyanswer · 16/11/2023 20:30

I d think this is a real gap in education. It works for no one. The kids who can’t cope in mainstream are forced to be there. They may disrupt or hurt the other kids. Teachers time gets taken from teaching.

The only specialist provision now is for kids with severe disabilities or really severe behavioural problems.

I presume the only reason it’s like this as the government doesn’t want to spend money to address this gap and can hide behind the ridiculously simplistic and demonstrable wrong idea that ‘inclusion’ ( by which they mean bunging everyone in together with no real thought and analysis of the benefits and harms of this ) is always a good thing.

SparkyBlue · 16/11/2023 20:30

My son has asd and attends an autism class (I hate the word unit) anyway he attends mainstream for a small part of the day and spends most of his time in the smaller calmer class setting. It looks like these children are not having their needs met so you need to constantly complain as their behavior is not acceptable. Unfortunately sometimes schools open up special classes without fully taking on board the commitment and the work involved. It's not simply a case of opening a class and it will all work out great.

greengreengrass25 · 16/11/2023 20:29

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:25

The dinner lady shouldn’t have been gossiping about a school child especially a disabled school child

Why shouldn't she.

Who would want to be hurt in their job

Prinnny · 16/11/2023 20:29

TomeTome · 16/11/2023 20:25

The dinner lady shouldn’t have been gossiping about a school child especially a disabled school child

Are you the boys mother? The poor woman was attacked at work and you’re trying to victim blame her, disgusting.

Neodymium · 16/11/2023 20:29

ShepherdMoons · 16/11/2023 20:13

@Neodymium we have also considered a private school as it seems to be more common in state schools to have little support and more children will needs. It's hard on everyone as the teachers are clearly struggling to cope, the poor dinnerladies are scared too. The dinner lady at dd's school was really (understandably) upset by what happened in the playground.

I teach in a private school and it’s worlds away from the state schools. I have friends who teach in state schools and the stuff they deal with I just couldn’t even imagine. One friend has a boy in her class who regularly goes on a rampage destroying the class ripping posters down upturning desks, throwing stuff. She just has to evacuate the rest of the kids from the class and leave him to it. (This is year 3). Can’t make him stop or talk to him. His mum just blames the school and demands to know why he doesn’t learn anything or get a report card with grades like the other kids.

FoxSticks · 16/11/2023 20:29

It's not true to say private schools have better provisions, most of them just kick the children out. We've had children turn up in our state primary who've been told with very little notice that they are not welcome anymore. Private schools can just decide to exclude the child without any support given or any of the long processes that state schools will have to go through. Losing one childs fees is far more preferable to risking losing many more if they allow the child to stay and try to manage the situation.

The sad truth is that specialist settings are incredibly hard to find and obtain and children who really need this environment are left in mainstream with inadequate funding to help them and all the other children in their class.

I would second a previous poster and say you should request a meeting with the safeguarding lead to ask about thesafeguarding provisions for your child.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 16/11/2023 20:27

ShepherdMoons · 16/11/2023 20:17

The boy's mum (the boy who kicked the dinnerlady) said he'd done this because he was frustrated that she wouldn't get some equipment out of the shed for him. She said he can't control his behaviour and sort of justified it by saying his needs aren't being met. My dd's 'needs' are not being met but she's not entitled to hit or kick others. The boy's mother even jokingly said 'he should have kicked her harder' which I find appalling.

I'd actually written something similar about meeting needs then deleted it before posting. She's partly right (and partly wrong). Autistic children do lash out when their needs are not being met. It is the school's job to manage that effectively. But not getting some equipment out for him isn't "unmet needs" that's "giving him whatever he wants."

Two key ways they can meet his needs are: 1. Ensuring the class's work is differentiated adequately so that all students can access the learning and simultaneously don't finish it too quickly and get bored, and 2. Ensuring the boy's transitions and dead time are managed appropriately so he is always occupied in some way and not left hanging. It sounds like he was trying to find something to do. He should have as part of his management plan somewhere to go and something to do at his breaks/lunches/any time he's out of lessons, and a member of staff should guide him there to ensure he goes to the right place. There will be other interventions needed at various times but these two things underpin everything else.

But you are completely right, these are not yours or your daughter's problems. I'm trying to make it clear that the school's management is the issue here and there's a lot they could do better that would head off this sort of behaviour before it starts, better schools are doing these things, and moving your daughter to a school where the SEN kids are properly cared for and managed would benefit your daughter massively.

ShepherdMoons · 16/11/2023 20:26

@modgepodge his regular support has been off ill for a while, she is really good. The school have struggled a lot with absence of the teaching assistants and other support staff.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread