Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my name said correctly?

112 replies

WhereDoesItAllGo · 02/11/2023 23:49

My name is unusual, but follows English phonics rules. The same spelling is sometimes used by people shortening a different name with a zed sound, so their nickname is the same as my name, but with zed where I have ess. Unfortunately, some famous people have had this nickname, so the name with zed is known but my name with ess is unfamiliar.

For years I just tolerated my name being mauled. I can be quite shy and I was embarrassed to make a fuss. But I recently started in a new job, and felt it was an opportunity to establish my name correctly. It has been such an effort to stop people and remind them that my name is actually Xysss, not Xyzzz.

Six weeks on, some people are still zedding me. WIBU to start calling them Tom instead of Tim, or Ninny instead of Nina?

Just to add to the discomfort, my nearest more senior colleague, with whom I spend a lot of time and work very closely, has a slight lisp. I think this person may genuinely be unable to pronounce my name correctly. They certainly try, and they pronounce my name with a slight, blurry zed. Unfortunately the coworker who zeds my name the worst also works closely with us. How can I correct the one without humiliating the other?

OP posts:
BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 04/11/2023 10:03

@PumkinPorridge , I find it a bit precious to be offended about someone mispronouncing your name.
You probably find me precious then. I would probably be shocked if someone said my name correctly. It's a lovely name but nobody other than speakers of my language can say.

Many of the mispronunciations sound horrible. Some are just about tolerable.
The misspellings are either someone trying to make it into something they recognise, or rather funny.
The worst comments are ones like 'Why do you say/spell it like that when it's (something vaguely similar)' or 'What a stupid name'

WhereDoesItAllGo · 04/11/2023 09:38

I don't call myself pissy. That's just for an example of how I use the same sounds with the same spellings.

OP posts:
WhereDoesItAllGo · 04/11/2023 09:37

The only offensiveness is the attitude that they can choose my name.

Some manglers do try to get my name right, and I appreciate that. But some genuinely cannot be bothered, and get arsey with me for wanting to be called by my own name.

Which of you would accept a teacher having the attitude "I can't be bothered trying to learn your child's name, so I'll call her a vague approximation of it"?

Posters saying I should spell my name phonetically - it is spelled phonetically! How would you spell Issy phonetically?

All the sounds in my name are standard English sounds, in standard English order. All the name-manglers are standard English people, speaking standard English.

Posters saying I should demonstrate the sound using other words - I do! I even do it humorously so that it sticks. "Issy - like in pissy Missy Issy, who gets pissed off when her soft esses are missed off."

OP posts:
PumkinPorridge · 03/11/2023 23:48

@BestKitten

PumkinPorridge
My name is nearly always said wrong and spelt wrong. It's a foreign name and not common. I really love my name. It's pretty and I feel lucky to have such a nice name
^It literally never bothers me if people call me the wrong name. I occasionally correct people but the fact somebody has said my name wrongs means absolutely nothing. Why should it? Even if it's because they are being lazy what difference does it make to me?
Lots of people have flaws, I'm not sure saying 'zz' instead of 'ss' is that bad.*

"Wow I really do not agree nor can I understand this outlook. Good on you but I can't say I know anyone , even the least sensitive people, who wouldn't be bothered by people alway mispronouncing their name. Good on you for being thick skinned. Your name is how you interface with the world, if it causes an issue each times, it's awkward! Do you have a middle name or another shortening of your name op?"

Not minding if people mispronounce my name isn't being'thick-skinned'. I simply don't mind. I'll get offended when people are trying to offend me but I find it a bit precious to be offended about someone mispronouncing your name.

Redvelvet24 · 03/11/2023 21:56

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:05

@Redvelvet24 , do you have a regional accent or do you say it as Joe Lee? I've only heard Joely said to rhyme with Roly, but Joel will get said as Joe-(u)l, Jole and Joe El.

Tongue position can be really helpful for sorting pronunciation issue's that you can't hear
Definitely if it's sounds not in your own language.

I think you might be right with the Joe-Lee vs Roly. The problem is that I can’t hear the difference still. At the very back of my mind I can see how they might sound different but saying them both sounds the same and imagining someone else saying them they are still the same.

I'm going to discuss your thoughts with her and see if I can work it out.

Choux · 03/11/2023 21:34

BirthdayQuestions · 03/11/2023 19:49

'Tin hat time. If I saw it written, and didn't know the person, I'd say it like in the Beethoven (German) music title Für Elise, that is Eleezuh'

@Manadou Yes Eleezuh is what we were actually aiming at and is how I say it, but we thought in Britain it would be Eleeze. Didn't realise it was actually Eleece which is even further away.

Edited

Maybe you are in the wrong part of Britain? I went to primary school (many years ago) with an Elise and it was always Eleezuh. We were up in the northwest and not at all familiar with Beethoven.

hadrianswallsycamore · 03/11/2023 21:28

Issy Suttie is a famous Issssy rather than Izzzzy. It's a different name. It would annoy me too if my name was mispronounced

CarolinaInTheMorning · 03/11/2023 21:00

The "Elise" dilemma is interesting to me. I know two women named Denise. One pronounces her name De-neeze and the other is De-neese. I don't see either of them often, and then I struggle to remember which is which.

Manadou · 03/11/2023 20:57

@Herecomesdehotstepper

I know a female Lesley but she spells it Leslie which is the male version

This is mainly a UK thing, I think.

Of the top of my head, I can think of Leslie Caron, French actor, and Leslie Van Houten, American murderer and member of the Manson Family. There are loads more famous female Leslies outside the UK

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 03/11/2023 20:50

There are people who truly can't hear the same nuances in pronunciation.

This is very true. And what someone else said about some people being able to hear and understand them, but not pronounce them, and being aware of that to a greater or lesser extent.

There are also many people with some level of hearing loss who either aren't aware that they have it yet, or might not want to say so and draw attention to it, but they are doing their best. This can make it harder to learn to pronounce, and also remember, names. I don't say #BeKind very often but in this case, I do.

I would just leave it, and secretly smile to yourself about the people who manage to pronounce it correctly including your colleague who you suspect is trying very hard to. If you have a colleague who you think is just taking the piss, because it's part of their general attitude, feel free to secretly judge them on it too.

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:48

Thought so, like Siobhán is Shiv-AUN (not Shivvonne)

MissBeevor · 03/11/2023 20:38

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:35

I was a bit surprised to see Storm Kee Ron was actually Storm Ciarán. I thought Ciarán was Keerun or Keeraun

Ciarán is Kee-RAUN.

CharlotteStreetW1 · 03/11/2023 20:37

Herecomesdehotstepper · 03/11/2023 20:27

I have a name that was quite common up to the 1950s, with the standard spelling, which breaks one of the best known rules. There are several variants, but they are pretty uncommon, especially now that the name has pretty much died out.

Saying it is not too bad, although I did have one colleague who always called me by a completely different name with the same first two letters. I'm not sure what that was about.

Writing however is a completely different matter. My work e mail is a first name dot last name format. If I give that to people 9/10 of them will spell my first name wrong and I won't get the e mail. Luckily, I have a numerical alias, which works much better.

I know a female Lesley but she spells it Leslie which is the male version but it looks right for a female (I've always thought they should be the other way round).

BestKitten · 03/11/2023 20:35

PumkinPorridge · 03/11/2023 10:44

My name is nearly always said wrong and spelt wrong. It's a foreign name and not common. I really love my name. It's pretty and I feel lucky to have such a nice name.
It literally never bothers me if people call me the wrong name. I occasionally correct people but the fact somebody has said my name wrongs means absolutely nothing. Why should it? Even if it's because they are being lazy what difference does it make to me?
Lots of people have flaws, I'm not sure saying 'zz' instead of 'ss' is that bad.

Wow I really do not agree nor can I understand this outlook. Good on you but I can't say I know anyone , even the least sensitive people, who wouldn't be bothered by people alway mispronouncing their name. Good on you for being thick skinned. Your name is how you interface with the world, if it causes an issue each times, it's awkward! Do you have a middle name or another shortening of your name op?

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:35

I was a bit surprised to see Storm Kee Ron was actually Storm Ciarán. I thought Ciarán was Keerun or Keeraun

Herecomesdehotstepper · 03/11/2023 20:27

I have a name that was quite common up to the 1950s, with the standard spelling, which breaks one of the best known rules. There are several variants, but they are pretty uncommon, especially now that the name has pretty much died out.

Saying it is not too bad, although I did have one colleague who always called me by a completely different name with the same first two letters. I'm not sure what that was about.

Writing however is a completely different matter. My work e mail is a first name dot last name format. If I give that to people 9/10 of them will spell my first name wrong and I won't get the e mail. Luckily, I have a numerical alias, which works much better.

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:27

@Manadou , I think you mean monolglot brits, not all brits. Quite a few brits speak more than one language.

CharlotteStreetW1 · 03/11/2023 20:25

BirthdayQuestions · 03/11/2023 19:49

'Tin hat time. If I saw it written, and didn't know the person, I'd say it like in the Beethoven (German) music title Für Elise, that is Eleezuh'

@Manadou Yes Eleezuh is what we were actually aiming at and is how I say it, but we thought in Britain it would be Eleeze. Didn't realise it was actually Eleece which is even further away.

Edited

There's an Elise in our family who rhymes with Police which won't help your cause. She was named after the car.

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:23

Coral and Carol
Vowels tend to get transposed especially if there are several next to each other.
Leylah and Laylah are different vowel sounds. Are they?
I'd say both as Layla
Leila and Laila I'd say as Layla and Lie-la respectively but would be prepared to be corrected.

I don’t understand people who get themselves into a pickle at people who struggle with their name. I have people who still spell my name incorrectly despite it being on lots or paperwork etc
Some people mind, some don't. There may be cultural reasons why someone not getting a name right might seem like 'othering'. Dismissing it as 'get themselves into a pickle at people who struggle with their name' is a bit insulting IMO.

Manadou · 03/11/2023 20:17

BirthdayQuestions · 03/11/2023 19:49

'Tin hat time. If I saw it written, and didn't know the person, I'd say it like in the Beethoven (German) music title Für Elise, that is Eleezuh'

@Manadou Yes Eleezuh is what we were actually aiming at and is how I say it, but we thought in Britain it would be Eleeze. Didn't realise it was actually Eleece which is even further away.

Edited

Do not expect many Brits to know to pronounce German names.

CharlotteStreetW1 · 03/11/2023 20:12

Redvelvet24 · 03/11/2023 18:27

That’s how I say it … like the name Joe with ly on the end. Joely! Then she says ‘no, it’s not Joely, it’s Joely’ and it sounds exactly the same to me. Sometimes someone else steps in to demonstrate how I’m saying it wrong but I can’t hear a difference at all!

I’ve tried practising on my own… I expect it’s a subtly difference between the ‘oh’ sound and ‘ow’ sound, particularly the slight ‘w’ sound. I can only just hear the difference when I say those two phonemes separately and can’t hear them at all in the name.

Could t be that she wants the extra syllable? So Joe-a-ly?**

BridgeOverTheRiverWye · 03/11/2023 20:05

@Redvelvet24 , do you have a regional accent or do you say it as Joe Lee? I've only heard Joely said to rhyme with Roly, but Joel will get said as Joe-(u)l, Jole and Joe El.

Tongue position can be really helpful for sorting pronunciation issue's that you can't hear
Definitely if it's sounds not in your own language.

Delphinium20 · 03/11/2023 20:01

For the native English speaking people who think others' mispronunciations are micro aggressions, I'd love to hear them try to perfectly speak words in a tonal language, like Vietnamese. However, people from Viet Nam are probably too polite to correct you.

BirthdayQuestions · 03/11/2023 19:49

'Tin hat time. If I saw it written, and didn't know the person, I'd say it like in the Beethoven (German) music title Für Elise, that is Eleezuh'

@Manadou Yes Eleezuh is what we were actually aiming at and is how I say it, but we thought in Britain it would be Eleeze. Didn't realise it was actually Eleece which is even further away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread