Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs Everywhere

768 replies

SusanandMidge · 17/09/2023 20:36

I don't live in the UK but am just back from a holiday in Cornwall. We were shocked at the amount of dogs allowed everywhere. They were in every restaurant, cafe, pub and hotel. Two or three people with dogs would all go into a small shop, blocking the aisles for everyone else. In Port Isaac on a lovely sunny Sunday afternoon the whole harbour and uphill area was disrupted by loud and continuous barking. Dogs were running around off leash on every beach. People were clogging the narrow pavements with two or three dogs on leads, wheeling dogs around in prams and buggies, stopping outside holiday cottages for ages chatting while their dogs barked, yapped and howled and ruined the peace for the people inside.

We were genuinely wondering if the next time we came back there would be dog and owner spaces in supermarket carparks and an expectation that you should stand up on public transport to let people with dogs sit down.

AIBU to think England has gone a bit mad when it comes to dogs?

OP posts:
Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 09:46

Mercurial123 · 18/09/2023 09:44

Another anti dog thread. There should be a special board for the dog/cat haters.

Here's another view - another reason for someone to start a thread about entitled dog owners.

Willyoujustbequiet · 18/09/2023 09:45

Dogs aren't allowed on our local beaches. There are patrols and heavy fines.

But I was in a new restaurant yesterday and was appalled to see a dog do it's business inside and the owners saw and just walked off. Absolutely disgusting. The restaurant owner came over and apologised. He said they were going to change their policy and dogs would be banned. Don't blame him tbh.

MsRosley · 18/09/2023 09:45

Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 09:44

Dogs are better company to some people, but if you want something more than a potential hot water bottle, potential cuddles, and a one way conversation then they are not really that great tbh. Don't get me wrong, I've loved dogs I owned in the past but none of them were great conversationalists!

To be fair, most husbands aren't great conversationalists either.

Mercurial123 · 18/09/2023 09:44

Another anti dog thread. There should be a special board for the dog/cat haters.

SusanandMidge · 18/09/2023 09:44

drinkuptheezider · 18/09/2023 09:41

I wouldn't take her in a restaurant. At most, a cafe if seating is very spaced out, I prefer outside seating and would choose that everytime! To the other poster quoting me. I watch for others very carefully, precisely because I don't want to be perceived badly. She is a big dog, and I accept not everyone wants her near them.
She is trained and will continue training all her life but still relatively young and can be bouncy, so I assess every situation/ location. I want us to be good ambassadors for her breed combo of dog.

But would you agree that many dog owners do not behave with any consideration for others, including the ones who announce that Cornwall is dog friendly so they can do what they want there.

OP posts:
Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 09:44

MsRosley · 18/09/2023 09:39

Probably from having to be around them. Dogs are better company and tend to talk about themselves less.

Dogs are better company to some people, but if you want something more than a potential hot water bottle, potential cuddles, and a one way conversation then they are not really that great tbh. Don't get me wrong, I've loved dogs I owned in the past but none of them were great conversationalists!

drinkuptheezider · 18/09/2023 09:41

SusanandMidge · 18/09/2023 09:19

But you do realise that for every one of those people there were probably 10 more wishing you'd move the dog out of the way, not sit beside them in a restaurant etc etc I didn't go around complaining to owners about their dogs when on holiday, but that didn't mean it wasn't bothering me.

I wouldn't take her in a restaurant. At most, a cafe if seating is very spaced out, I prefer outside seating and would choose that everytime! To the other poster quoting me. I watch for others very carefully, precisely because I don't want to be perceived badly. She is a big dog, and I accept not everyone wants her near them.
She is trained and will continue training all her life but still relatively young and can be bouncy, so I assess every situation/ location. I want us to be good ambassadors for her breed combo of dog.

Anewnamea · 18/09/2023 09:39

YANBU. Interestingly a friend of mine is holidaying there right now with her family and they have their parents very beautiful but large and energetic dog with them. From what I understand they’re taking it everywhere when they go out .

The thing is Cornwall is known well known as a dog friendly holiday destination unfortunately, so they are going to be everywhere. It has actually put me off visiting tbh but I might still one day.

I’ve said before in another thread every restaurant or pub should display clearly if they are dog friendly or not with some kind of symbol on their website/window, and there needs to be a range of dog free and dog friendly places for people to choose from in the UK because it’s all going one way now. I don’t know any coffee shop in my whole town that is dog free. I seen a dog in the library too recently. I was walking downs. Steep narrow park and two dog walkers who had congregated on the corner with their 3 dogs between them didn’t bother to move so i had to cross over or step out onto the road to get past them. I’ll get told I didn’t have to but had I squeezed past and if it’d been a nervous dog that had bitten me no doubt I’d have been blamed for coming to close round a corner and startling a dog.

I can’t drive and it really annoys me that I’ll be on a train and bus and a dog owner can just come sit next to me and I have no idea of the dogs temperament and they have no idea if I’m allergic or not . It’s an enclosed space that I can’t easily escape from.

MsRosley · 18/09/2023 09:39

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 04:51

Where do you think this inability to be around other people comes from?

Probably from having to be around them. Dogs are better company and tend to talk about themselves less.

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 09:37

Afterrain · 18/09/2023 09:33

On Friday I was in John Lewis shopping.
I witnessed a 'yorkie' dog on a lead poop in the aisle. I said 'Oh excuse me you dog has just done the toilet'
She gave me the finger!
On Sunday outside a local coffee shop a woman had her dog on the chair. It peed.
She didn't attempt to wipe it.

I have always had dogs.

This is so disgusting. Yet the shit dog-owners deny this stuff happens.

Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 09:37

Alstroemeria123 · 18/09/2023 09:29

I don’t know, some people on here get even more upset if you say you don’t like cats.

Are you indirectly suggesting we start a 'dogs are better than cats' (or vice versa) thread, and get some popcorn?
(I am not being serious, but that might be entertaining).

Afterrain · 18/09/2023 09:33

On Friday I was in John Lewis shopping.
I witnessed a 'yorkie' dog on a lead poop in the aisle. I said 'Oh excuse me you dog has just done the toilet'
She gave me the finger!
On Sunday outside a local coffee shop a woman had her dog on the chair. It peed.
She didn't attempt to wipe it.

I have always had dogs.

Alstroemeria123 · 18/09/2023 09:29

Womencanlift · 18/09/2023 09:00

Because it apparently makes you a vile and untrustworthy person apparently 🙄

Funny how this vitriol about not liking something is only for dogs and not other animals

I don’t know, some people on here get even more upset if you say you don’t like cats.

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 09:29

Redlarge · 18/09/2023 09:24

I haven't done yet, worth a punt, though. Im telling you something always comes out in the wash at a later date about people who hate animals.

I would never date someone who didn't like animals, and i would be cautious about people i do meet who dont eg a new mum at the school, i would think oh, worth remembering ha

My mum was scared of big dogs because she was bitten as a child which is completely understable, but she didnt hate them, she ended up with a little old lady dog as company in her later years.

what you don’t seem to understand is that it’s not as simple as hating all animals.

I abhor cruelty to animals. I recognise that dogs bring comfort to many and of course there are incredible working and service dogs.

What people dislike is the increase in dogs being allowed in restaurants, standing with their paws up at a cafe counter, owners letting their dogs jump up at strangers, walk up and down tube carriages off-lead, ruin picnics and nuzzle through their property. All stuff which has happened to me in the last year.

Can you not see there is a difference?

Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 09:28

Redlarge · 18/09/2023 09:24

I haven't done yet, worth a punt, though. Im telling you something always comes out in the wash at a later date about people who hate animals.

I would never date someone who didn't like animals, and i would be cautious about people i do meet who dont eg a new mum at the school, i would think oh, worth remembering ha

My mum was scared of big dogs because she was bitten as a child which is completely understable, but she didnt hate them, she ended up with a little old lady dog as company in her later years.

Your second statement is simply untrue - people can 'hate' animals for a whole host of reasons. If you were choosing any other one feature, other than them having committed murder or something equally bad, then I'd call you out for your assuming superiority and judgemental attitude.

SusanandMidge · 18/09/2023 09:27

Redlarge · 18/09/2023 09:24

I haven't done yet, worth a punt, though. Im telling you something always comes out in the wash at a later date about people who hate animals.

I would never date someone who didn't like animals, and i would be cautious about people i do meet who dont eg a new mum at the school, i would think oh, worth remembering ha

My mum was scared of big dogs because she was bitten as a child which is completely understable, but she didnt hate them, she ended up with a little old lady dog as company in her later years.

I'm sorry, but that's just ridiculous and incredibly narrow minded.

OP posts:
Redlarge · 18/09/2023 09:24

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 09:12

So how do you do your checks when you have to trust someone? Do you email the school to check on teachers? Call the GP to review their stance on animals before booking an appointment?

I haven't done yet, worth a punt, though. Im telling you something always comes out in the wash at a later date about people who hate animals.

I would never date someone who didn't like animals, and i would be cautious about people i do meet who dont eg a new mum at the school, i would think oh, worth remembering ha

My mum was scared of big dogs because she was bitten as a child which is completely understable, but she didnt hate them, she ended up with a little old lady dog as company in her later years.

Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 09:21

drinkuptheezider · 18/09/2023 09:14

We holiday in this country, so we take our dog with us.
Far more people will say hello and comment 'what a beautiful dog' than ever cross the road to avoid. It's only on MN that I read about all the posters who detest dogs.

She is happy being with us and if anything behaves better for it.
We rarely get negative responses to her. If someone is clearly uncomfortable, I would remove her. It's not a problem. We visit lots of dog friendly places, on one occasion someone ran across the road to say hello because they had seen us the previous day at another place and wanted to pet her again. Our most recent holiday, a little lad asked to say hello, all his siblings/ cousins appeared to pet her too. The mother took pictures and thanked me for letting the children pet her, saying they don't have dogs in their homes culturally but the children love dogs so they were getting their 'fix'.
If children ask to pet her, I always thank them for asking, too, as respect and responsibility go both ways.

You do sound like a responsible owner, two things though - you might not be aware of the number of people who cross the road to avoid your dog. I often do this, but try to do it in a subtle way (mostly) because it's not that the dog/owner is always doing something wrong and more that I just don't want to risk the dog potentially sniffing me/jumping at me etc (if it's an unknown dog/owner I have no idea how they might behave). Also, just because you don't perceive this to be happening with your dog it doesn't mean it isn't happening. As for only hearing negative things on MN, that's not been my experience at all, and I know many people who are frustrated by the selfish dog owners (not all dog owners) in our community. I have just seen one this morning letting her dog use part of the school grounds to do a poo - granted she picked it up, but she should not be encouraging it to poo there to start with because picking up often still leaves small traces and school pupils routinely sit there at lunchtime/break! This lady looks after her dogs much better than many people, from what I have seen, but in the past a grassy area at a school would not have been seen as an acceptable toileting location!

SusanandMidge · 18/09/2023 09:19

drinkuptheezider · 18/09/2023 09:14

We holiday in this country, so we take our dog with us.
Far more people will say hello and comment 'what a beautiful dog' than ever cross the road to avoid. It's only on MN that I read about all the posters who detest dogs.

She is happy being with us and if anything behaves better for it.
We rarely get negative responses to her. If someone is clearly uncomfortable, I would remove her. It's not a problem. We visit lots of dog friendly places, on one occasion someone ran across the road to say hello because they had seen us the previous day at another place and wanted to pet her again. Our most recent holiday, a little lad asked to say hello, all his siblings/ cousins appeared to pet her too. The mother took pictures and thanked me for letting the children pet her, saying they don't have dogs in their homes culturally but the children love dogs so they were getting their 'fix'.
If children ask to pet her, I always thank them for asking, too, as respect and responsibility go both ways.

But you do realise that for every one of those people there were probably 10 more wishing you'd move the dog out of the way, not sit beside them in a restaurant etc etc I didn't go around complaining to owners about their dogs when on holiday, but that didn't mean it wasn't bothering me.

OP posts:
drinkuptheezider · 18/09/2023 09:14

We holiday in this country, so we take our dog with us.
Far more people will say hello and comment 'what a beautiful dog' than ever cross the road to avoid. It's only on MN that I read about all the posters who detest dogs.

She is happy being with us and if anything behaves better for it.
We rarely get negative responses to her. If someone is clearly uncomfortable, I would remove her. It's not a problem. We visit lots of dog friendly places, on one occasion someone ran across the road to say hello because they had seen us the previous day at another place and wanted to pet her again. Our most recent holiday, a little lad asked to say hello, all his siblings/ cousins appeared to pet her too. The mother took pictures and thanked me for letting the children pet her, saying they don't have dogs in their homes culturally but the children love dogs so they were getting their 'fix'.
If children ask to pet her, I always thank them for asking, too, as respect and responsibility go both ways.

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 09:12

Redlarge · 18/09/2023 09:11

I do take this as a bit of a red flag in life generally. Always have, always will. Not just dogs. All animals.

So how do you do your checks when you have to trust someone? Do you email the school to check on teachers? Call the GP to review their stance on animals before booking an appointment?

Redlarge · 18/09/2023 09:11

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 08:21

Do you check with your GP, dentist, kids’ teachers, new colleagues etc whether or not they like dogs before you interact with them and trust them? Because if that’s the reductive way you classify people, you can’t be too careful.

I do take this as a bit of a red flag in life generally. Always have, always will. Not just dogs. All animals.

MatchyM · 18/09/2023 09:11

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/09/2023 09:01

Some dog-related problems are the owner's fault - not picking up after them, letting them off their leads, allowing them to cause a nuisance barking incessantly or at inappropriate times in built up areas, not training them properly etc.

Others are a problem just because of the sheer unprecedented numbers of dogs there are now in England and the current fashion of bringing them everywhere with you (although you could also say the latter is an owner problem too). Some of it, the dangerous dogs aspect, is at least partly the fault of government not enforcing any of the laws there are, let alone passing better ones.

Most people on the thread are acknowledging there are good and bad dog owners.

It’s pretty clear even from this thread that there is a huge difference between the good and the bad owners. Unfortunately for the former, it’s the shit entitled group that screech most loudly these days.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/09/2023 09:01

vivainsomnia · 18/09/2023 08:55

So why for dog-lovers like you is your only desperate defence, ‘but but human people are worse’? Why not criticise the crap owners?
That's absolutely right. The issue is bad dog owners.

The problem is that the majority of posters here don't like any dog around them and put all owners in the same category. Good dog owners are a problem just the same.

After all, the initial posters moaned about dogs on pavements, good or bad.

Some dog-related problems are the owner's fault - not picking up after them, letting them off their leads, allowing them to cause a nuisance barking incessantly or at inappropriate times in built up areas, not training them properly etc.

Others are a problem just because of the sheer unprecedented numbers of dogs there are now in England and the current fashion of bringing them everywhere with you (although you could also say the latter is an owner problem too). Some of it, the dangerous dogs aspect, is at least partly the fault of government not enforcing any of the laws there are, let alone passing better ones.

Most people on the thread are acknowledging there are good and bad dog owners.

Womencanlift · 18/09/2023 09:00

Nevermind202020 · 18/09/2023 08:58

Why is it 'the problem' that some people don't like dogs and don't want them around them? It's personal choice.

Edited

Because it apparently makes you a vile and untrustworthy person apparently 🙄

Funny how this vitriol about not liking something is only for dogs and not other animals