Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will DH ever change? How can I get through to him?

260 replies

NewMomma21 · 23/07/2023 20:14

Looking for advice.

Married to DH for 4 years. We have an 18 month old and I’m almost 30 weeks pregnant. DH has a stressful job; he earns a very good salary and works long hours and travels abroad frequently. He is a good provider and great fun socially.

I would have considered myself happily married but recently I am becoming increasingly resentful of DH. Although he provides financially he does nothing to keep the house running. He doesn’t ever put a wash on. He lets the bins run to overflowing. He does absolutely no cleaning or cooking and frequently will leave a mess behind him whenever he is in the house. Often leaves clothes/towels on the floor. I have to ask multiple, multiple times over the course of days to do things I am physically unable to do (for example lifting heavy loads of washing, emptying bins, quick tidy of the garden). I am left to do everything around the house. Although I work FT I am off for the summer, it doesn’t matter if I’m in work or not he still contributes nothing. On the weekends he often plays golf for one day. On the days he is home and off when LO naps he more or often than not gets into bed for two hours for a nap or scroll on his phone. This is time during the day I use to do a tidy, load of washing, hoover etc.

Recently he was away for over a week (longest trip since covid) and it was just me and LO. Life was much easier. There was no mess to clean up. The house was clean and tidy. No picking up his clothes and litter. I found the extent to which it was easier shocking.

I have tried so many times to ask him for help. Begged. Nagged. Gotten angry, gotten upset. Nothing ever gets through to him. He just doesn’t seem to care. I feel increasingly like I am mother to a toddler and messy, selfish teenager.

Has anyone any advice? I don’t know how else to get through to him

YABU- he contributes financially and he is unlikely to ever change
YANBU- he needs to start pulling his weight

OP posts:
NewMomma21 · 25/07/2023 23:58

Thank you for the supportive replies. I really do appreciate them.

A lot of the replies on the thread really helped me describe my feelings to him. I said if it mattered to me then it should matter to both of us. He shrugged that off as quite ridiculous that housework should mean so much to a person. He categorically refused to apologise for the sleeping when DC does, he works hard and is tired. He said I was just nagging and repeating myself and there was no point engaging.

I am very shocked at his response. DH is from a separated family and he seemed unmoved by the suggestion of it. I suspect he thinks I’m just pregnant and hysterical.

I decided to sleep in the spare room . His very presence is just too upsetting. I can’t sleep thinking about where to from here.

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 25/07/2023 23:57

NewMomma21 · 23/07/2023 20:37

Sorry I should clarify I have explained numerous times to him I am not his cleaner or mother and I am not asking him for help and I am asking him to do his fair share. It just all seems to fall on deaf ears. He doesn’t care about mess or untidiness

And he clearly doesn't give a shit that it bothers you.

This is what people like this fail to understand. Sure, there's some people who are complete neat freaks (my mum is one) who expect their unrealistic expectations to be upheld by everyone. But it's not unrealistic to wipe up spills or replace used toilet rolls. It's not unrealistic that daily chores are shared equally between able persons in the household. And it's disrespectful and thoughtless to just not do it with the explanation that you 'don't see/don't care' about mess.

I don't think he'll change. But that doesn't mean you can't.

Pixiedust1234 · 25/07/2023 23:30

He said he couldn’t change my mind if separation was my preference
Good grief! He has now said it out loud hasn't he. He doesn't care enough to fight for you.

and that marriages don’t end over things like hoovering.
Yes they do. Time and time again as it's usually the last straw. Do you have the link to the dishwasher/divorce link handy, if so send it him. But honestly, i think it's over as he won't change and I don't think you can unsee what is happening.

I am so sorry OP, it really is a horrible feeling Flowers

monsteramunch · 25/07/2023 23:29

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/she-divorced-me-i-left-dishes-by-the-sinkbb_9055288/amp

I would usually suggest asking him to read this but fuck me, he really is an arrogant prick isn't he? What a disappointing reaction from him, I'm gutted for you OP.

He's telling you he's not going to change, he will mitigate using the absolute minimum effort he can possibly give, and resent you for doing so.

I couldn't spend the rest of my life with someone like that.

Flowers
cheddercherry · 25/07/2023 23:26

I’m frustrated just reading your update. Im so sorry that even when you’ve spoken he’s still doubled down. Surely once you’ve stated that these things matter so much to you then it should matter to him, regardless of how trivial it is to him?

In response to “marriages don’t end over hoovering” I’d probably have clapped back, well this one does. If it’s a simple as picking up a hoover in his eyes then why can he not even do that - saying divorce is your preference seems mightily unfair by someone who acknowledges they basically aren’t willing to fight for the relationship or make any compromises anyway? I really don’t know how you move forward if he won’t take on any responsibility or acknowledge any issue between you. Not simply outsourcing the work, I mean the lack of understanding and respect.

Mirabai · 25/07/2023 23:23

He’s just on a different planet. The idea that contributing to his marriage can only be happen on annual leave.

I wish I could be more encouraging but I really don’t see any way forward with this level of casual, clueless entitlement.

Hibiscrubbed · 25/07/2023 23:19

He really is an arrogant shit, isn’t he? 😔

NewMomma21 · 25/07/2023 23:09

An update. I spoke to DH tonight. Told him how his behaviour has made me feel. The bad example for DC. The physical toll it has all taken on me. How I have reached breaking point.

He predictably told me to outsource everything. He said it was over the top to get so upset over a bit of food on the floor or a towel left on the ground. He said he would do more once on annual leave and to provide him with a list of things that that he can do.

I said our marriage was in real jeopardy if things didn’t change and I was upset he wasn’t more concerned at my obvious distress. He said he couldn’t change my mind if separation was my preference and that marriages don’t end over things like hoovering.

Feeling just bereft.

OP posts:
rockpoolingtogether · 25/07/2023 20:38

If he doesn't have any personality disorder then I suggest marriage counselling as a safe space to raise this

pikkumyy77 · 25/07/2023 20:23

OP take heart—even though nobody can give you any magic words to open his eyes you have learned a lot on this thread. Your eyes have been opened and you can see that you have choices to make. One of those choices is no longer begging/pleading/nagging so thats actually a big saving of time and effort. You can decide to keep him like an expensive pet or a valued paying customer at a fancy hotel. Or you can dump him. But at least you no longer have to doubt yourself.

NewMomma21 · 25/07/2023 18:16

MillWood85 · 25/07/2023 17:49

The OP has already stated that she's asked repeatedly for him to help. His response is to tell her to pay for someone to pick up his slack. No counselling, no shouting or arguing is going to make this guy change. This is who he is.

OP either lumps it for the rest of her life, or she kicks him into the ether and takes on raising 2 kids by herself. Neither of which are remotely what she signed up for. She just wanted an equal, a partner. And he's anything but. Given she's heavily pregnant, I'd imagine that this all feels a bit shit Flowers

Thank you for your kind reply. I am grateful for all the support and replies.

I’ll be honest, is does feel a bit shit. I was naively hoping some replies might have been in the vein of DH was like this and x was the thing that changed things for us. I just feel sad and tired at this point

OP posts:
Tiqtaq · 25/07/2023 18:08

Is he on your team?
Does he care about your well being?
Does he respect you?
If the answer is no then I don't think you really have a relationship to build on.

If you want to stay with him, I would insist on separate bedrooms and bathrooms for the two of you.

I would stop doing his laundry, he can do it himself or make the arrangements to contract it out.

I would buy in support for as much of the housework as possible, daily help I think, and also buy in childcare so that you can have a decent amount of you time.

I'd also ask him to fetch and carry for you whilst you are pregnant and then continue with this.
Eg do not make your own cups of tea, do not go and get things from another room, ask for foot rubs, and generally offload mini tasks onto him as often as possible. Act like a Princess with staff and not like his mother.

Go out and have fun together then have a lie in the next morning, put a loud alarm outside his room. If he doesn't get up take your child into his bed. If that still doesn't work then you need to go out yourself and leave him in charge of your child. Book a series of regular nights and weekends at a spa with a friend or relative and leave him in charge.

Cultivate a fun out of the house hobby and do it weekly.

Good luck OP.

Daffodilwoman · 25/07/2023 18:07

Hell
I would tell him one more time that you find all this unattractive.
Either leave him or start paying for more help. Pay someone to do YOUR ironing- not his. Up the amount of times the cleaner comes, pay for on line shopping and make sure it comes out of joint funds.
Personally, I could not live with anyone like this, I’d rather be a single parent. It’s just so disrespectful.It sets a terrible example to your dc.
I am of the opinion that living with someone only works if you both have very similar values and outlook in life. Tidy people should only live with other tidy people. If you always make a drink for your partner then you really need someone who makes drinks for you. If you make a fuss about your partners birthday then you are better with someone who makes a fuss about your birthday.

RandomMess · 25/07/2023 18:00

I am incredibly untidy (DH is not). The levels of mess and contempt your H shows are awful.

MillWood85 · 25/07/2023 17:49

The OP has already stated that she's asked repeatedly for him to help. His response is to tell her to pay for someone to pick up his slack. No counselling, no shouting or arguing is going to make this guy change. This is who he is.

OP either lumps it for the rest of her life, or she kicks him into the ether and takes on raising 2 kids by herself. Neither of which are remotely what she signed up for. She just wanted an equal, a partner. And he's anything but. Given she's heavily pregnant, I'd imagine that this all feels a bit shit Flowers

AgnesX · 25/07/2023 17:36

NoSquirrels · 23/07/2023 20:19

No one here will tell you you’re unreasonable.

Why doesn’t he care? What does he say?

7% seem to think so....🙄

Pixiedust1234 · 25/07/2023 17:33

NewMomma21 · 25/07/2023 08:42

I’ve had this conversation so many times. I sat him down last week and said I don’t want to argue, I’m not going to raise my voice but you need to listen to what I’m saying, you need to do more. I’m doing x,y,z. I’m 7 months pregnant and my workload has not changed. I am up during the night with DC while you get a full nights sleep every night and I have to continue to entertain DC and do every single domestic task the next day. He said he would do better and “help” while on annual leave.

He came home on Friday night, helped himself to all the bread and cheese in the house leaving nothing for DC lunch the following day. I then came home to find him sound asleep on Saturday afternoon, having done absolutely nothing around the house.

Nothing I say makes a difference

I am up during the night with DC while you get a full nights sleep every night .
Tell him, not ask, that one day every weekend is when he does night duty AND you have a lie in. He needs to feel what you feel as he won't understand how bone achingly tiredness this is.

He came home on Friday night, helped himself to all the bread and cheese in the house leaving nothing for DC lunch the following day.
Tell him he can not do this again. Tell him he is taking food out of his child's mouth.

I then came home to find him sound asleep on Saturday afternoon, having done absolutely nothing around the house.
So despite saying he would help more...this was his answer?

Yep. Actions are louder than words and his actions are screaming FUCK YOU!!! My DH has been the same for the past thirty years, its soul destroying.

LucyLongbody · 25/07/2023 16:48

My Dad was like this and as a child and teen I watched my mum run herself into the ground cleaning. She worked FT too.

As soon as I was old enough I mucked in while my brother sat about and did nothing.

My parents divorced years ago and my dad lives in squalor now, he doesn't even have hot water or central heating. The house is a disgrace with dirt and damp. It needs professional cleaners.

When my Mum left I took over his laundry (had to bring it home as the washing machine broke) and shopping plus a bit of cleaning, changing bedding etc.
Then I moved abroad.

Now his sister does it all and she's 80 odd!

When I go back to visit I can't stay there as it's so cold, damp and dirty. I can't even have a cup tea without scrubbing the cup and spoon first.

I love my dad very much but he just doesn't see mess and doesn't care.

PollyPut · 25/07/2023 16:19

NewMomma21 · 24/07/2023 12:11

Thank you for your helpful suggestion. I have tried a communicative approach numerous times. I have explained how hurtful it is to come home from a trip out to find soiled nappies and wipes piled up on the changing table rather than in the nappy bin next to it and how it makes me feel like I am a glorified maid. I have explained at length with no raised voices that we have to be in partnership and that I feel like I am increasingly taking on a mother like role. I’m at the point of dreading having alone time or time with friends because I know when I return the house will be upside down while he lies back on the couch relaxing.

I realise now that he will probably never change and I feel sad for my future as it dawns on me that this is going to be my life. For today, I am not washing anymore of his clothes, I won’t be cooking his dinner and will do enough that the house is clean and tidy for DC and I to enjoy.

Just joined thread. He doesn't need to be perfect but if he's creating extra work instead of at least cleaning up after himself then that is really unreasonable.

Dirty nappies left out? That is just unacceptably unhygenic. Flies can come in and land on them, and spread the germs around the place. There is no excuse for that.

The filled bath sounds like a drowning risk and a way to make the place mouldy.

I have found that it's much easier to wash and dry DH's clothes in a separate wash from the rest of the family. He has loads so they can build up in wash basket without him running out and I can focus on the rest of the family (DC tend to have fewer as they grow out of clothes so quickly, so theirs need washing more often too). It makes putting it away simpler. I would definitely separate DH's and either explain they're separate from now on or that he can do them and you'll show him how. It's heavy lifting which you just don't need.

I'd be tempted to tell him to go and live at his Mum's if he can't keep the place clean, to stop creating work. Tell him you want him here, but without the trail of mess behind him.

NeedToChangeName · 25/07/2023 15:25

He won't change unless he wants to

And he currently doesn't want to. Actions speak louder than words

So, you have a difficult decision to make. As I see it, your choices are stark - (1) carry on as you are or (2) consider moving on from thus relationship

Don't give ultimatums eg "tidy up X or I'll leave" unless you mean it

But, a conversation along these lines might be helpful "I have been very happy with you in the past, but I'm finding this way of life hard. I feel like a maid. It's making me miserable. I'm starting to wonder if this is the beginning of the end. Perhaps we're not as well suited as we thought. I'm not sure I want to carry on like this. I am thinking we might be better apart". And then see what happens. If he continues as he is, then you know he won't ever change. If he really doesn't want to lose you, he may up his game, but you'd need to be vigilant it's not just temporary to pacify you

Whattodonut · 25/07/2023 15:13

But if he won't go to counselling I would definitely do what @StopMindlesslyScrolling says. Genius.

Whattodonut · 25/07/2023 15:12

We did couples counselling. Was the best idea for us because we had reached a point where we had said things to each other so many times we just weren't hearing it anymore.

Having a third party (together and separately) talk to us about how we communicate and the no1 thing- what we value most of all (answer: each other! ) made us make changes. Because my husband matters to me. I matter to him. His happiness matters to me and mine matters to him. Much more than (insert petty thing like not putting dishwasher in machine). It doesn't matter than we are not bothered by the same things. Our marriage was salvageable because we matter to each other more than being lazy. Our feelings are valid.

But we definitely needed reminding. And we probably will again some day.

jeaux90 · 25/07/2023 15:02

He is modelling really bad relationships and behaviour to your children

balzamico · 25/07/2023 14:59

I have no idea whether you can persuade him to change and I totally agree that he is showing you little respect or consideration,
I am not tidy by nature but I have learnt to be - its part and parcel of growing up into a fully formed adult.
The eye opener for me was when DH went away for a few days and when I came to tidy round before he came home there was something of mine that I'd left lying around in every single room (or on every surface), before that I'd thought he was as bad as me but it did make me realise just how much mess I can create just by not picking up after myself or putting things in the right place to start with.
It might be worth you staying with your parents for a week for a break, some sleep and for him to realise what you do but realistically it might no make any difference, good luck OP

jannier · 25/07/2023 14:04

NewMomma21 · 23/07/2023 20:37

Sorry I should clarify I have explained numerous times to him I am not his cleaner or mother and I am not asking him for help and I am asking him to do his fair share. It just all seems to fall on deaf ears. He doesn’t care about mess or untidiness

Does he care about food or clean clothes because he wouldn't have either if I were you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread